Davies Coop and Company Pty Ltd v Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read
54 CLR 155

of its obtaining leave to appeal, the order for a new trial should H. C. OF be set aside and a verdict entered for the defendant.

Pursuant to the order giving leave to appeal

the order for a new trial discharged and in lieu thereof judgment of nonsuit entered. Appeal dismissed with costs. Solicitors for the appellant, Sly &Russell. Solicitors for the respondent, Campbell, Campbell &Campbell.

[HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA.]

DAVIES COOP AND COMPANY PROPRIETARY

THE COMMONWEALTH Bounty-Cotton yarn-Computation of bounty-Power to withhold bounty where net

profits' exceed ten per cent of capital employed in manufacture-Cotton Industries Bounty Act 1930-1932 (No. 13 of 1930-No. 17 of 1932), sec. 13.

In ascertaining, for the purposes of sec. 13 of the Cotton Industries Bounty Act 1930-1932, whether the " net profits" of any person, firm or company claiming bounty under the Act exceed ten per cent of the capital employed in the manufacture of cotton yarn the amount payable as Federal and State income tax in respect of the profits of manufacture cannot be deducted from the profits.

CASE STATED.

In an action in the High Court by Davies Coop &Co. Pty. Ltd. against the Commonwealth of Australia for a declaration that in the computation of its net profits for the purposes of the

54 CLR 156

Cotton Industries Bounty Act 1930-1932 in respect of its business as

a manufacturer of cotton yarn for the year ending 30th June 1932 there should be deducted as outgoings of such business all sums payable by it by way of income tax, both Federal and State, in respect of its income for such year from such business, the parties agreed in stating for the opinion of the Full Court a case which was substantially as follows :-

1. The plaintiff is a company duly incorporated in Victoria under the Companies Act 1928.

2. The plaintiff has continuously since the month of January 1931 down to the commencement of this action carried on in Melbourne the business of manufacturing or spinning cotton yarn and of manufacturing or knitting cotton and other textile goods.

3. The plaintiff claims from the defendant payment of bounty under the provisions of the Cotton Industries Bounty Act 1930-1932 of the Commonwealth of Australia in respect of the manufacture by it of cotton yarn during the year ending 30th June 1932. The defendant does not dispute that the plaintiff became entitled to payment of a certain amount as bounty as aforesaid and has in fact paid to the plaintiff the sum of £10,298 2s. lld. as such bounty.

4. Sec. 13 of the said Act is as follows: "If the net profits of any person, firm or company claiming bounty under this Act on cotton yarn exceed, in any year, ten per centum of the capital employed in the manufacture of cotton yarn, the Minister may, after inquiry and report by the Tariff Board, withhold the whole of the bounty for that year, and, where the payment of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Davies Coop and Company Pty Ltd v Commonwealth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1935] HCA 74
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Davies Coop & Company Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) brought an action against the Commonwealth of Australia (the defendant) seeking a declaration regarding the computation of "net profits" for the purposes of the *Cotton Industries Bounty Act 1930-1932*. The dispute centred on whether Federal and State income tax should be deducted as an outgoing when calculating these net profits. The matter was presented to the High Court of Australia by way of a special case stated by the parties.

The legal issue before the court was whether, in ascertaining the net profits of the plaintiff company for the year ending 30 June 1932 for the purposes of section 13 of the *Cotton Industries Bounty Act 1930-1932*, a sum of £2,054 19s. 1d., representing the estimated Federal and State income tax payable on the profits derived from the manufacture of cotton yarn, should be deducted as an outgoing of that business. Section 13 of the Act empowered the Minister to withhold bounty if the net profits of a claimant exceeded ten per cent of the capital employed in the manufacture of cotton yarn.

The High Court, in answering the question posed by the special case, determined that income tax should not be deducted in the computation of net profits for the purposes of section 13 of the Act. The Court reasoned that the Act was designed to encourage the manufacture of cotton yarn by providing a bounty, and the calculation of net profits under section 13 was intended to reflect the commercial profitability of that specific manufacturing activity before any government imposts. While acknowledging that income tax is a liability of a company, the Court distinguished it from other business expenses or taxes like excess profits duty, which might be deductible. The Court noted that income tax is levied on the overall taxable income of a taxpayer, which can encompass profits from various sources, and that attempting to apportion it to a specific business segment for the purpose of this Act could lead to complex and potentially inequitable outcomes, particularly given the Act's broad application to persons, firms, and companies. Furthermore, the Court considered that deducting income tax before calculating profits would create a circularity problem with the provision in section 13 that allows for withholding bounty if its payment would cause net profits to exceed the ten per cent threshold, as bounty payments are themselves part of the profits.

The Court answered the question in the negative, ruling that the sum of £2,054 19s. 1d. should not be deducted in the computation of the net profits of the company for the purposes of the Act. Consequently, judgment was entered for the defendant, the Commonwealth of Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.