| [2020] FWC 4069 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
David Smythe
v
Noilly Pty Ltd T/A Westral Sunshades
(U2020/4081)
DEPUTY PRESIDENT BEAUMONT | PERTH, 28 AUGUST 2020 |
Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – whether applicant ‘employed’ – consideration of contract of service or contract for service – applicant an independent contractor – application dismissed.
[1] On 2 April 2020, Mr David Smythe made an application to the Fair Work Commission for a remedy in respect of his dismissal from Noilly Pty Ltd T/A Westral Sunshades (Westral).
[2] Westral raised several jurisdictional objections to the application. In essence, those objections can be distilled into three propositions. The first, Mr Smythe was not an employee because he was an independent contractor. The second, Mr Smythe earnt over the high income threshold and therefore the application was moot. And the third, Mr Smythe was not dismissed but left the business of his own accord.
[3] If the Commission upholds any of the objections, then Mr Smythe’s application will be beyond the jurisdiction of the Commission and will have to be dismissed.
[4] In French Accent v Do Rosario, 1 a Full Bench of the Commission’s predecessor stated that, in determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor, the ultimate question is ‘whether the worker is the servant of another in that other’s business, or whether the worker carries on a trade or business on his or her own behalf: that is, whether, viewed as a practical matter, the putative worker could be said to be conducting a business of his or her own of which the work in question forms part.’ The question is concerned with the objective character of the relationship and is to be answered by considering the terms of the contract and the totality of the relationship.2
[5] In short, I am satisfied the evidence establishes that Mr Smythe runs his own sales consultancy business. My conclusion, if one considers the objective character of the relationship - the arrangement between Mr Smythe and Westral was an independent contracting arrangement. The jurisdictional objection is therefore upheld, and the application dismissed. Given the conclusion reached, it has proved unnecessary to consider the other grounds raised by Westral. My reasons for the decision follow.
Background
[6] Westral has been in business in Western Australia for approximately 47 years. It manufactures doors, security screens and shutters, amongst other products. The business has 130 employees and some 30 contractors. The employees perform manufacturing work, marketing, management and administration. The contractors are engaged for the purpose of selling the product and installing the same. According to Westral, it is a model that has worked well for some 15 years.
[7] Mr Smythe is part of a 15 person sales force that takes home, according to Westral, approximately $2 - 3 million dollars per annum. Westral submitted that the business attracts people with a broad ability to interact with others, are able to understand the needs of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read David Smythe v Noilly Pty Ltd T/A Westral Sunshades and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FWC 4069
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined various factors to determine the nature of the relationship, including the level of control exercised by the respondent over the applicant, the manner in which the applicant performed his work, and the degree of financial risk borne by the applicant. The evidence suggested that the applicant operated as an independent contractor rather than an employee. He had significant control over how he performed his work, did not adhere to a set schedule, and was not subject to the respondent's operational policies or supervision. The applicant also assumed a substantial amount of financial risk, bearing his own expenses and operating as a sole trader.
In light of these findings, the court concluded that the applicant was not an employee but rather an independent contractor. As such, he was not eligible for an unfair dismissal remedy. The application was dismissed on the basis that the applicant did not meet the criteria for employment under the Fair Work Act 2009. No orders were made as the dismissal was found to be lawful.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi