| [2025] FWC 899 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.739 - Application to deal with a dispute
David Mathieson
v
Mornisupa Pty Ltd
(C2025/2019)
| COMMISSIONER REDFORD | MELBOURNE, 4 APRIL 2025 |
Alleged dispute about any matters arising under the modern award and the NES; failure to file material in accordance with directions; dismissal of application pursuant to s 587 of the Act
On 18 March 2025 Mr David Mathieson made an application pursuant to s 739 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) seeking that the Commission deal with a dispute concerning the National Employment Standards (NES). The alleged dispute concerns Mornisupa Pty Ltd (Mornisupa).
The application was allocated to my chambers on 19 March 2025.
I conducted a conference in relation to the matter on 31 March 2025. Mr Mathieson attended on his own behalf, and Mr Dawson attended for Mornisupa.
The application
The application descries the clause of the industrial instrument or other written agreement the dispute relates to as “NES section 88.2”. I take this to be a reference to s 88(2) of the Act which provides:
“88 Taking paid annual leave
(1) Paid annual leave may be taken for a period agreed between an employee and his or her employer.
(2) The employer must not unreasonably refuse to agree to a request by the employee to take paid annual leave.”
Under the heading “What is the dispute about” the application states as follows:
“Applied for Long service leave on 28/2, for the period 10/6 to 11/7 inclusive.
Application approved for all dates except for 23/6 to 30/6
Reason given for declining leave (23/6 to 30/6) cited as business grounds.”
Under the heading “What relief are you seeking by making this application to the Commission” the application stated, “Long service leave approved in full”.
Under the heading “What kind of industrial instrument (e.g. an award or agreement) or other written agreement covers the employment relationship and contains the dispute resolution procedure relevant to this application” the application states “General retail industry award” which I take to be a reference to the General Retail Industry Award 2020 (the GRIA Award).
Concerns about the application
Based on the materials filed by the parties, I formed a provisional concern that Mr Mathieson’s application may be without merit, because he was seeking to agitate a dispute about long service leave of a kind which is not a matter dealt with by s 88(2) of the Act, or any other part of the NES, or any part of the GRIA Award.
In particular, the clause of the relevant industrial instrument referred to – s 88(2) of the Act (part of the NES) deals with annual leave, not long service leave.
Nothing said during the conference by Mr Mathieson diminished my concerns.
I made Directions in relation to the proposition that the application be dismissed pursuant to s 587 of the Act. Those Directions stated, among other things:
“[4] During the conference, I…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read David Mathieson v Mornisupa Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] FWC 899
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Commissioner issued directions for Mr Mathieson to provide submissions on why his application should not be dismissed. A typographical error in the directions led to confusion about the filing deadline, but after further clarifications, Mr Mathieson failed to file any submissions by the revised deadline. Mornisupa filed its submissions on 3 April 2025, which largely reiterated previous arguments that the application was misdirected because it concerned long service leave, not annual leave as referenced in the application.
The Commissioner considered the application under section 587 of the Act, which allows the Commission to dismiss an application if it has no reasonable prospects of success or if it is not made in accordance with the Act. The Commissioner concluded that the application did not relate to a matter covered by the General Retail Industry Award or the National Employment Standards, and therefore, the Commission did not have jurisdiction to deal with the dispute. Given Mr Mathieson's failure to comply with the directions and provide submissions, the Commissioner decided to dismiss the application. An order will be issued to this effect.
Background
Background to the litigation
On 18 March 2025, Mr Mathieson filed an application with the FWC. The matter was allocated to Commissioner Redford on 19 March 2025. A conference was conducted on 31 March 2025, with Mr Mathieson representing himself and Mr Dawson representing Mornisupa. The Commissioner formed a provisional concern that Mr Mathieson's application might be without merit, as it pertained to long service leave, which is not covered by the referenced NES clause or the GRIA Award. Directions were issued on the possibility of dismissing the application under section 587 of the Act. Mr Mathieson was given several opportunities to file submissions and other material in response to the Directions, but he failed to do so by the specified deadlines. Consequently, Mornisupa filed its submissions on 3 April 2025.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the FWC have jurisdiction to deal with the dispute about long service leave under the GRIA Award or the NES?
2. Does Mr Mathieson’s application have reasonable prospects of success?
3. Should Mr Mathieson’s application be dismissed for failing to comply with the Commission’s Directions?
Held
1. The Fair Work Commission (FWC) does not have jurisdiction to deal with the dispute about long service leave under the General Retail Industry Award (GRIA Award) or the National Employment Standards (NES). The court concluded that the dispute about long service leave is not covered by either the GRIA Award or the NES, and thus the Commission lacks jurisdiction to hear the matter.
2. Mr Mathieson’s application does not have reasonable prospects of success. The court determined that based on the materials before it, the application has no reasonable chance of succeeding because it concerns an issue not covered by the GRIA Award or the NES.
3. Mr Mathieson’s application should be dismissed for failing to comply with the Commission’s Directions. The court found that Mr Mathieson did not follow the directions to submit relevant material by the specified deadlines, despite being given additional opportunities to do so. Consequently, his application was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Commissioner examined the application to determine whether the FWC has jurisdiction to deal with the dispute about long service leave under the GRIA Award or the NES. The application referred to section 88(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009, which deals with paid annual leave, not long service leave. The Commissioner noted that the GRIA Award does not cover long service leave, and while the NES addresses long service leave, it does not cover an employer’s refusal to agree to an employee’s request to take such leave in the circumstances presented. Therefore, the FWC lacks jurisdiction to deal with this dispute under section 739 of the Act.
The Commissioner also considered whether Mr Mathieson’s application had reasonable prospects of success. Given the jurisdictional issue, the Commissioner concluded that the application had no reasonable chance of succeeding. This conclusion was based on the materials before the Commission, which showed that the dispute did not fall within the scope of the GRIA Award or the NES.
Furthermore, the Commissioner addressed whether Mr Mathieson’s application should be dismissed for failing to comply with the Commission’s Directions. Despite being given opportunities to submit relevant material, Mr Mathieson did not comply with the deadlines. The Commissioner noted that Mr Mathieson had been made aware of the potential consequences of non-compliance and had been afforded procedural fairness. The Commissioner decided that dismissing the application was warranted to balance the prejudice to each party, ultimately finding that justice demanded the dismissal of the application.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this decision is that the FWC lacks jurisdiction to deal with disputes about long service leave not covered by the relevant industrial instruments, and that failure to comply with the Commission’s Directions can result in the dismissal of an application.