David Keith Grant v Ford Co-Operative Society Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

) )

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
1 No. VX 459 of 1991
)
BANKRUPTCY DIVISION 1
BETWEEN: 

DAVID KEITH GRANT

Debtor

Ex Parte: FORD CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY LIMITED

(Formerly Commercial Credit

JUDGE : Heerey J.

m: Melbourne

DATE : 11 December 1991
EX TEMPORE REASONS FOR JU~XENT -

This is an application brought under s.222(1) of the Bankru~tcv Act 1966 seeking an order that a composition be declared void and, consequentially upon that, a sequestration order; see s.222(7).

The case of the applicant turns on a series of meetings. A meeting of the creditors of the debtor was called for 29 August 1991. That meeting was adjourned to 9 September 1991. One of the issues in this case was whether that adjournment was valid, and in particular, whether there was a resolution for the adjournment as may be requ~red by s.197(1). This issue involved a dispute of fact as to whether a resolution for the adjournment was proposed and carried at the meeting or whether the chairman simply adjourned the meeting himself. The onus on the lssue is on the debtor. I prefer the evidence tendered on behalf of the applicant, and in particular a detailed memorandum compiled by a Mr Matthew Harrington, who was present at the meeting, and which noted

Mr Lloyd Felman, a solicitor, gave evidence before me to the

that a vote was taken. The chairman of the meeting,

effect that there was no resolution and produced minutes to that effect. However, the force of his evidence was substantially diminished by the fact that the minutes which the Act requires to be lodged within 14 days of the meeting (see s.203(3)) were not signed by him until four months later. He claims to have taken some notes of the meeting but did not bring them to court with him. I find that there was a resolution for adjournment and thus the point dependent on the adjournment of the meeting need no longer be considered.

At the adjourned meeting on 9 September, the composltion was put to the meeting. On its face it was not a very appealing one, since it involved payment by the debtor of only $25,000 over a period of four months in full satisfaction of unsecured debts of approximately $2.5 million. However, the proposal very nearly obtained the required statutory majority, being supported by 74.6% in value of the creditors present.

One of the creditors votlng against the composition was the present applicant who was admitted to vote for a debt of $527,516. However, it emerged subsequently, and this is now common ground, that the correct amount of the debt was $493,785. If that amount of debt had been known at the meeting there would have been a majority of 75.319% in favour

of the composition, thus satisfying the statutory requirement.

Following the rejection of the composltion, by letter dated 11 October 1991 a second meeting of creditors was called for 25 October and at that meeting the composition…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read David Keith Grant v Ford Co-Operative Society Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1991] FCA 865
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

David Keith Grant filed for bankruptcy and Ford Co-Operative Society Ltd applied to the Federal Court of Australia under s.222(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 to have a composition voided and a sequestration order made. The applicant's case hinged on whether a meeting of creditors was properly adjourned and if a composition was validly accepted at a subsequent meeting. The court found that the adjournment was valid and that the composition was nearly approved at the first meeting but for an error in the amount of debt owed by the debtor to the applicant.

The primary legal issue was whether the second meeting of creditors was valid to approve the composition. The court noted that while the Full Court had held that only one meeting is contemplated under Part X of the Act, the court has a discretion under s.52(2)(b) to refuse a sequestration order if it ought not to be made for other sufficient cause. The court considered the creditors' reliance on the debtor for financial advice and their opposition to sequestration despite the debtor's insolvency.

The court exercised its discretion not to make a sequestration order, primarily due to the near approval of the composition at the first meeting and the error made by the applicant itself. The court concluded that it would not be fair to allow the applicant to rely on its own error to prevent the policy of the Act from operating.

The court declared the composition accepted at the second meeting void, dismissed the application for a sequestration order, and made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.