Details
- Case
- [2013] AATA 307
- Decision Date
-
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In the case of David Bose against Swire Pacific Ship Management (Australia) Pty Ltd, the applicant, David Bose, sought compensation for a Major Depressive Disorder he claimed to have suffered due to work-related stress and events that occurred while he was employed as a Chief Engineer on the Pacific Valkyrie. The respondent, Swire Pacific Ship Management (Australia) Pty Ltd, opposed the claim. The dispute was heard and determined by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).
The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant had suffered a Major Depressive Disorder due to work-related stress, entitling him to compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act). Specifically, the Tribunal needed to determine if the stress experienced by the applicant was attributable to his employment and if the Major Depressive Disorder was a result of that stress.
The Tribunal found that the applicant had indeed suffered a Major Depressive Disorder on 5 June 2012. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant's employment as a Chief Engineer was a significant contributing factor to the stress he experienced, particularly in light of his long service with the company and the events that transpired, including disagreements with his superior, Eric Duck, and the breakdown of the vessel. The Tribunal accepted that the applicant's refusal to immediately install exhaust valves in a spare cylinder head, despite his belief that it was not urgent, was a catalyst for his removal from the vessel and subsequent stress.
The Tribunal set aside the original decision and substituted it with a decision that compensation is payable to the applicant for the Major Depressive Disorder suffered on 5 June 2012, pursuant to section 26(1) of the SRC Act.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·the “T Documents” (T1–T11, pp 1–38) lodged by the respondent pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth);·exhibits A1–A14 tendered by the applicant;·exhibits R1–R8 tendered by the respondent; and·the oral evidence of the applicant and of the following witnesses:-Dr M Mustapha and Dr A Banerjee (who were called by the applicant);-Dr V Cheng, Mr E Duck and Mr M Hearnden (who were called by the respondent).The Applicant’s Evidence The applicant said that he had been employed by the respondent for the last 20 years – for the first 3 years as a First Engineer and for the last 17 years as a Chief Engineer. He tendered his witness statement, dated 9 January 2013, and he confirmed that its contents are true and correct. That statement is as follows:“1. I was born in India. I attended university there and obtained a Marine Engineering Degree which I completed in 1977. From 1978 to 1991 I worked as a marine engineer for the Shipping Corporation of India. I migrated to Australia in 1991. From 1991 to 1993 I worked for Total Marine Services as a Marine Engineer on board offshore vessels including three Swires vessels. In 1993 I commenced employment with Swire Pacific Offshore. I was employed on a permanent basis. I have worked on a number of vessels for the company which are engaged in the offshore oil and gas industry. 2.In November 2010 I joined the Pacific Valkyrie, an anchor handling offshore supply vessel. This vessel has a crew of 12 consisting of 3 deck officers, 3 engineers, 5 integrated ratings and 1 cook. I was employed as Chief Engineer on the vessel. I hold an AUS Engineer Class 1 (Motor) Certificate of Competency and as such I am an AMSA Certified Engineer/Manager. I am the second most senior engineer in the company’s fleet. I am junior to Peter Isted but only by a brief period. 3.In June 2007 I consulted Dr Mustapha, my general practitioner, in relation to some stress I was undergoing at that stage. There were a number of issues weighing on me at that stage including:(a)I was depressed about my relationship with my ex-wife. We had separated briefly in 2001 and were divorced and then subsequently we got back together. Our relationship over the years has been difficult and we have experienced a number of ups and downs.(b) I was frustrated that the company had not appointed me to serve on other vessels in the fleet. I did offer to resign at this stage but decided to take a leave of absence of about 5 to 6 months. I used my sick leave and accrued leave and some of my long service leave. The company paid for me to see a counsellor in Osborne Park who I saw on 5 occasions at its expense. I also saw this person on 3 occasions at my own expense. Dr Mustapha placed me on Efexor medication during this period. By the about [sic] the end of 2007 I returned to work with the company. I ceased taking the Efexor medication. I felt much better psychologically. 4.In December 2008 I suffered a fall at my home and punctured a lung. I ended up being hospitalised at Joondalup Hospital from around 6 December 2008. I recovered completely from the punctured lung but did see Dr Mustapha in early January 2009 in connection with some residual chest symptoms. I was also feeling a little stressed at that stage and I note that he described the condition as post traumatic stress disorder. I thought that was a very long name for what was a fairly minor problem. He gave me a referral to see Ashley Frew, a clinical psychologist; however I recovered from the minor stress problems I was then experiencing. I returned to work in about February 2009. 5.Since about November 2010 I had been experiencing some minor episodes of stress which were basically related to my work. I was working very lengthy hours and was bringing my work home with me. That caused some problems at home with my wife. I saw Dr Mustapha in February 2012 and mentioned this to him and he gave me a referral to see Dr Banergee [sic], the Psychiatrist but the appointment was not until April 2012. 6.Eric Duck was promoted to the position of Technical Manager for the company in about late 2010. Prior to that time I had not had much to do with him and was mainly dealing with the previous technical manager.7.Up until May 2012 my personal relationship with Mr Duck was okay but I had experienced some problems with him on technical matters. He appeared to be unfamiliar with the requirements of the Pacific Valkyrie and its sister ships which were a new generation of vessels in the Australian offshore area. They had different electronics and automation systems and engine set ups. My general work roster was 4 weeks on, 4 weeks off. The Pacific Valkyrie was working in the oil and gas fields in Bass Strait.8.In January 2012 we experienced problems with the cylinder head on the starboard main engine. We removed the head on 30 January 2012 and fitted a spare cylinder head which we had obtained from our sister ship, the Pacific Vulcan. The broken head was sent ashore to be forwarded to MAN Diesel in Sydney for repair. I emailed Eric Duck about this issue on 29 and 30 January 2012. 9.This left the Pacific Valkyrie without a spare cylinder head. I was keen to get the original head back as quickly as follows [sic]. Eric Duck, as the Technical Manager, was primarily responsible in following this through and I wrote to him about the matter on 5 February 2012 and 15 March 2012. By 15 March 2012 the matter was becoming somewhat urgent as we needed to remove the cylinder head from the port main engine to undergo overhaul ashore. The original cylinder head which we had removed in January was eventually returned direct to the Pacific Vulcan in about mid March 2012. 10.Our spare cylinder head was fitted to replace the port main engine cylinder head which went ashore on 19 March 2012. I emailed again to the company on 19 March 2012 seeking advice as to the earliest possible return of that head as we were once again without a spare. I received no response to that email. On 3 April 2012 I emailed Robert Wackett at MAN Diesel in order to chase him up about this. I also wrote to Steffi Harkins, the Swires Fleet Support Coordinator about the matter. She responded on 10 May 2012 by an email indicating that they were chasing MAN up. 11.By May 2012 we had effectively been without a spare cylinder head since January of that year.12.On 10 May 2012 the vessel broke down at sea near Barry’s Beach off the southern coast of Victoria. This occurred because the exhaust valves in the starboard cylinder head had become corroded. This had been an ongoing problem. I emailed Eric Duck at 10:08 am on 11 May 2012 and requested that arrangements be made for the Pacific Vulcan to come alongside so that we could borrow its spare cylinder head. 13.Mr Duck replied to my email and advised that he had located the spare head at MAN Diesel in Sydney. He said that he intended to make arrangements to get the cylinder head shipped back to Melbourne. He hoped that I had the spare exhaust valves to be fitted to the cylinder head when it was on board. I replied on the same day and said that I thought there was no point in doing this and that the work was best left to MAN. Several further emails passed between us on 11 May 2012 concerning the technical issues in relation to fitting valves to a cylinder head. I disagreed with his plan for the following reasons:(a)The quickest way to get the Pacific Valkyrie back in operation was to replace the leaking starboard main engine cylinder head with the spare off the Pacific Vulcan, which was nearby, rather than wait for the head to arrive from Sydney. Even when dockside at Melbourne another vessel would still have to be diverted to pick it up and run it out to the Pacific Valkyrie. All of that would take time. (b)I was concerned that the head which was coming from Sydney still needed to have its exhaust valves put back into it. That is normally not a major task but if there was a problem and the valves needed grinding or calibration, that was a job better done ashore. (c)The best course was for the head to be left on shore in Melbourne for it to be checked and the work completed, so that we could pick it up at the end of the swing.14.The spare cylinder head from the Pacific Vulcan was delivered on board the Pacific Valkyrie on 12 May 2012. We worked all night to install it and we got the Pacific Valkyrie back into unrestricted service at about midnight on 12 May 2012. I emailed Mr Duck and informed him of this early on 13 May 2012. I note that there is a typographical error in that email in that the reference to ‘April’ should read ‘May’. The Master congratulated me for getting the starboard main engine back in operation.15.At about 10:00 pm on 14 May 2012 Mr Duck rang me and we spoke about some other general matters and he then said to me words to the effect: ‘When the cylinder head comes back on board I want you to put the valves in right away.’ I said to Mr Duck that I couldn’t see the urgency in putting the exhaust valves in straight away. It takes 6 hours to remove and replace a cylinder head. The work involved in putting two exhaust valves in the new cylinder head would take between 15 to 30 minutes. Accordingly if we did need to replace a cylinder head again the amount of time involved in fitting the two exhaust valves would be insignificant. It was this that I tried to explain to Mr Duck. I said to him words to the effect that ‘When the spare cylinder head comes back on board, and we need to use it, I will install the two exhaust valves. If we did not need to use the cylinder head then the next crew could do it when the swing changes in early June.’ I said to him that we had our hands full with plenty of other more essential work than fitting exhaust valves into a spare cylinder head and I did not see that it was an urgent job.Mr Duck then said in an aggressive tone: ‘The urgency is that I’m telling you it’s urgent.’ He then hung up.16.I could not understand Mr Duck’s logic. At this stage we were in the middle of Bass Strait and were working and the ship was once more fully operational and we were not planning to come back into port till the end of May 2012. The spare cylinder head was not even on board and Mr Duck was telling me that I had to fit the two exhaust valves to it as a matter of urgency. I assume that Mr Duck was upset that I had been able to get the Pacific Valkyrie back up and running without having to wait for him to get the spare cylinder head back from Sydney. I also assume that he was embarrassed about the length of time it took him to get the cylinder head fixed, a fact which I have raised with him in a number of my emails.17.At 10:36 pm and following the above telephone conversation I forwarded an email to Mr Duck to confirm what had been discussed. He responded by email at 11:19 pm informing me that I had been removed as Chief Engineer from the vessel and that when ashore he would arrange for a meeting in order to address my refusal to carry out his lawful commands.18.I felt devastated about Mr Duck’s response. I was in a state of shock. I felt humiliated, I couldn’t believe it. I discussed with some of the other officers on board and they agreed with me.19.Over the next 16 days the ship continued to work in Bass Strait. It didn’t come into port. We came into an anchorage close to Barry’s Beach on a couple of occasions to run from bad weather. The company could have taken me off the vessel then but it didn’t. They could have used that opportunity to get the cylinder head back on board then, but they didn’t. The head did not come back on board until sometime after we docked at South Wharf in Port Melbourne on 30 May 2012. I find this somewhat surprising given Mr Duck’s stated position that it was ‘urgent’.20.During the 16 days that I remained on the vessel I attempted to do my work to the best of my ability. It was difficult because I felt emotionally shattered by Mr Duck’s decision to have me removed from the vessel. I felt that decision was completely unwarranted, particularly in view of my many years service for Swires. I became very stressed, anxious and worried. I could not sleep and was continually ruminating about what had occurred. I felt that for a Chief Engineer to be removed summarily from a vessel, was a tremendous humiliation. 21.I left the vessel when it arrived alongside at South Wharf, Port Melbourne on 30 May 2012. My swing was due to finish on about 7 June 2012.22.I contacted Mr Philip Olsen from my union, the Australian Institute of Marine & Power Engineers for assistance in relation to the matter. He corresponded with the company’s Human Resources Manager, Mal Hearnden and requested that the company reconsider its decision, however he refused to do so. 23.When I got home I was feeling shattered. The whole issue seemed to consume me and I couldn’t think of anything else. I lost my appetite and had difficulty sleeping. 24.On 5 June 2012 I saw Dr Mustapha and he prescribed Lexapro and gave me a certificate off work. He also gave me a referral back to see Dr Banergee [sic] and the first appointment I could get with him was on 19 June 2012.25.Mal Hearnden sent me an email to arrange the meeting and that duly occurred in the Fremantle office on 7 June 2012. Present at that meeting was Mal Hearnden and Simone Osten, Mr Duck, Phil Olsen from the Union and myself. Mr Hearnden said that I had been rude to Mr Duck. I disputed that. I have never sworn at him. I admit that I call a spade a spade and I don’t necessarily appreciate being told how to do my job. I know how to do my job. I know that the company says in its email of 8 June 2012 that I had refused to obey other instructions from Mr Duck. I dispute this and I have never been given details of those alleged occurrences. Mr Olsen enquired as to what the company proposed to do in relation to the matter. Mr Hearnden said that they would let us know tomorrow.26.On 8 June 2012 I received an email from Mr Hearnden setting out his proposal, namely that I apologise for being rude and that I agree to a demotion to First Engineer for a minimum of 3 swings so that I take that opportunity to learn how other Chief Engineers react to directions from the Technical Manager.27.I replied to that proposal saying that I was not in a position to respond as I was not well and had been certified unfit for work. I have not made any formal response to that email since that time. I feel that the company was intent upon making me a scapegoat. I felt that I should have been congratulated, as I had been by the Master, for getting the Pacific Valkyrie back into operation so quickly. I felt that Mr Duck was deserving of criticism for failing to chase up the return of the spare cylinder head despite prompting by me on several occasions that he do so. I felt that Mr Duck decided to make an issue about installing the exhaust valves into the cylinder head as a matter of urgency, even when the head was not on board, in order to deflect criticism from his own handling of the matter.I found it completely objectionable that I was to be demoted and made to apologise in circumstances which I believe were totally unwarranted.28.I saw Dr Banergee [sic] on 19 June 2012. He continued to certify me unfit for work and he’s changed my medication. I am currently taking Pristique 150 mg once a day. ... I last saw him on 30 October 2012 and have an appointment for review on 20 November and 11 December 2012.29.My psychologist is Ms Liney [sic] Ford ... I first saw in [sic] early August 2012. Initially I was seeing her once a fortnight, now it’s about once every 3 to 4 weeks.30.Dr Mustapha has received reports from Dr Banerjee and Dr Ford and has continued to declare me unfit for duty. Dr Mustapha’s details are recorded in the workers compensation certificates that I have been forwarding to Swires on a regular basis ...31.Currently I’m having problems with my blood pressure. This developed in about September of this year. Dr Mustapha has put me on Micarardis medication which seems to be controlling it. I’m also suffering from recurrent headaches.32.I am very passionate about my work and I feel greatly distressed about what has occurred. Since my departure from the vessel the Pacific Valkyrie has left the Australian coast. I have a suspicion that the company all along decided to provoke this dispute in the hope or expectation that I would resign.” (Exhibit A1)
Decision
Reasons for decision
Pursuant to s 26(1) of the SRC Act, therefore, compensation is payable to the applicant for Major Depressive Disorder suffered by him on 5 June 2012.Decision For the above reasons the decision under review is set aside and in, substitution therefor, it is decided that, pursuant to s 26(1) of the SRC Act, compensation is payable to the applicant for Major Depressive Disorder suffered by him on 5 June 2012.