Dates v Minister for Environment, Heritage and the Arts (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dates v Minister for Environment, Heritage and the Arts (No 2) [2010] FCA 256

Citation: Dates v Minister for Environment, Heritage and the Arts (No 2) [2010] FCA 256
Parties: WORIMI DATES v MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT, HERITAGE AND THE ARTS
File number: NSD 635 of 2009
Judge: BENNETT J
Date of judgment: 24 March 2010
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – review of Minister’s decision not to make declarations under ss 9,10 and 12 of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act – Minister only satisfied that part of the specified area is a significant Aboriginal area – not satisfied that the part of the area affected by roadworks is significant – utility of challenging s 9 decision when s 10 decision made – error of law – whether the Minister asked the correct question – whether conclusions supported by any probative material or made on logical grounds – relevant considerations – irrelevant considerations – procedural fairness
Words and phrases: “Aboriginal tradition”
Legislation: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984 (Cth) ss 9, 10, 12
Cases cited: Anderson v Minister for Environment, Heritage and the Arts [2010] FCA 57 followed/applied
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu (1999) 197 CLR 611 applied
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24 applied
Williams v Minister for Environment and Heritage (2003) 74 ALD 124 distinguished
Date of hearing: 2 and 3 March 2010
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 80
Mr A Oshlack of Indigenous Justice Advocacy Network appeared on behalf of the Applicant by leave
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr S Free
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 635 of 2009

BETWEEN:

WORIMI DATES
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT, HERITAGE AND THE ARTS
Respondent

JUDGE:

BENNETT J

DATE OF ORDER:

24 MARCH 2010

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.Costs be reserved.

3.The parties file and serve any submissions on costs within 7 days.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 635 of 2009

BETWEEN:

WORIMI DATES
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT, HERITAGE AND THE ARTS
Respondent

JUDGE:

BENNETT J

DATE:

24 MARCH 2010

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 10 December 2008, Mr Malcolm Carrall on behalf of Mr Worimi Dates, applied pursuant to ss 9 and 10 of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984 (Cth) (the Act) for emergency and longer term protection of Alum Mountain at Bulahdelah, New South Wales (also referred to as Bulahdelah Mountain) (the specified area). On 21 January 2009, Mr Carrall, on behalf of Mr Dates, sought protection under s 12 of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dates v Minister for Environment, Heritage and the Arts (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 256
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Dates v Minister for Environment, Heritage and the Arts (No 2), the Federal Court examined whether the Minister for the Environment erred in his decision regarding the significance of Alum Mountain to Aboriginal tradition. The applicant, Mr Dates, sought to challenge the Minister's conclusion that the lower part of Alum Mountain was not significant in Aboriginal tradition, whereas the upper part was. The Court was tasked with determining whether the Minister made any errors of law, acted irrationally, or failed to give genuine consideration to the evidence presented.

The primary legal issue was whether the Minister's decision was flawed due to an alleged error of law in drawing an inference that the lower part of the Mountain was not significant, despite evidence to the contrary. Mr Dates argued that the Minister failed to properly consider the Umwelt Report and did not provide logical reasons for distinguishing between the significance of the upper and lower parts of the Mountain. The Court examined the Minister's reasoning and whether it was based on probative evidence and logical grounds.

The Court found that the Minister's decision was not flawed. The Minister's reasons detailed the evidence considered, including reports and statements from Aboriginal persons. The Court held that the Minister was entitled to draw an inference from the evidence before him and that there was no error in concluding that there was insufficient evidence to support the claim that the lower part of the Mountain had significance according to Aboriginal tradition. The Minister did not act perversely or make findings unsupported by evidence or logic. The Court also dismissed the claim that the Minister asked the wrong question or failed to consider the significance of the area properly.

Ultimately, the Court found no merit in Mr Dates' arguments and dismissed his application. The Court's decision affirmed the Minister's conclusion that the lower part of Alum Mountain was not significant in Aboriginal tradition and that the decision was based on appropriate considerations of the evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Dates submits that the Minister was obliged to consider whether the lower area of Alum Mountain was of significance to any Aboriginal. As the Minister noted Aboriginal tradition is defined in terms of a body of traditions, observances, customs and beliefs of Aboriginals generally or of a particular community or group of Aboriginals. While it includes traditions, observances, customs or beliefs relating to particular persons, areas, objects or relationships, that refers to the persons, areas, objects or relationships about which the belief is held. It does not mean that the belief of a single Aboriginal person about a particular area constitutes Aboriginal tradition as defined. The Minister did not ask himself the wrong question under the Act as submitted by Mr Dates.Did the Minister make findings as to which there was no evidence? The Minister’s reasons set out the evidence upon which his conclusions were based. Mr Dates has not demonstrated that there was any finding or reason that did not have evidentiary support. Rather, his submission is that the evidence was not probative. The Minister’s reasons explained the basis for the evidence that he relied upon and the weight he gave that evidence. The evidence was either from Aboriginal persons or contained in reports that had been commissioned. Mr Dates has not demonstrated that any of the matters referred to, or the evidence cited in the reasons, was not probative.Was the Minister’s conclusion that the lower part of the Mountain was not of significance in Aboriginal tradition while the top part of the Mountain was significant, illogical? Mr Dates submits that it was not possible logically to hold that one part of the Mountain is of significance and another part is not. I do not accept that submission. The Minister accepted that the top part of the Mountain was of significance for men’s business. There is no illogicality in the Minister’s conclusion that there was insufficient evidence to support an assertion that the lower part of the Mountain had significance to Aboriginal persons in accordance with Aboriginal tradition, having found that there was insufficient evidence to support the Aboriginal traditions which Mr Dates relied upon to claim significance of the whole Mountain. At no time did the Minister accept that the whole of Alum Mountain was of significance. This is in contrast to Williams. There the Minister had accepted an assertion that the broader area had particular significance but found that part of an area within that broader area did not.Conclusion on the issues relating to the asserted error of law I am not satisfied that the Minister’s reasons indicate that he failed to give proper, genuine and realistic consideration to the significance of the specified area, or that his conclusion was illogical, or that he asked the wrong question. Mr Dates asserts in the amended application that the Minister made an error of law by drawing an inference with evidence to the contrary. It does not constitute an error of law for an administrative decision maker to draw an inference or to make a factual finding in circumstances where there is evidence for the contrary. It was for the Minister to determine, on the basis of the evidence before him, whether he was satisfied of the relevant factual matters going to the proposition that the specified area was significant in the relevant sense. Mr Dates has not demonstrated that the Minister acted perversely, or that his lack of satisfaction was based on findings or inferences of fact which were not supported by probative material or logical grounds (Eshetu at [145]; Anderson at [105]). Broad assertions that the Minister acted perversely do not demonstrate error. References to the evidence and an assertion that the Minister should not have accepted that evidence does not amount to relevant error.

Decision

Reasons for decision

By letter dated 10 December 2008 the RTA responded to Mr Dates’ s 9 application, particularly addressing the Umwelt Report. It asserted that, as at that date, the NSW Minister would soon consider the proposed declaration of the Aboriginal place in the area. A statement from the Director-General of Planning was to the effect that the RTA proposal was unlikely to diminish the integrity of the area as a potential Aboriginal place. The RTA’s letter also referred to the measures taken with respect to the Guardian Tree and the Healing Stream, namely to remove and re-position the former and to effect construction to protect the latter.The Minister’s reasons for the s 10 Decision The Minister’s statement of reasons for the s 10 decision (the Minister’s reasons) first set out the relevant legislation, including s 10(1), (2) and (3) of the Act. The Minister’s reasons acknowledged that s 10 requires him to be satisfied that the area is a “significant Aboriginal area” which is defined in subsection 3(1) of the Act relevantly as being an area of particular significance to Aboriginals in accordance with “Aboriginal tradition”. The reasons rehearsed the making of the application under s 9 and s 10 of the Act by Mr Carrall on behalf of Mr Dates and the fact that the Minister declined to make a declaration in relation to the s 9 application. The reason in respect of the s 9 decision was that the Minister was satisfied that the top of Alum Mountain (the upper slopes and ridge crest outcrops) is significant as part of Aboriginal tradition but could not be satisfied that the Bulahdelah Bypass is a serious and immediate threat of injury or desecration to this area. The Minister noted that Mr Carrall on behalf of Mr Dates sought protection under s 12 of the Act for the protection of objects within the specified area. The Minister’s reasons referred to the different evidence and material before him, being:·the Brennan Report with attachments that included the Umwelt Report, the Navin Report and the Great Lakes Study. The reasons note that the Navin Report was commissioned by the RTA for the purposes of an environmental impact statement and that the Great Lakes Study was an independent study which assessed the significance of both the Indigenous and non-Indigenous heritage of Alum Mountain;·two letters from the Honourable Carmel Tebbutt MP, NSW Minister for Climate Change and the Environment, dated 17 February 2009 and 23 April 2009;·the assessment of the Department for Environment, Heritage and the Arts (the Department) of the s 10 application; and·background information on the Act. The Minister noted that Mr Dates stated, inter alia, that the whole of the area of Alum Mountain is very significant to his culture and heritage and his specific reference in his statement to the Healing Stream, Ochre Ground, Bora (ceremonial ring), artefact scatters, the Guardian Healing Tree and numerous other Aboriginal scarred trees in the lower part of the Mountain. The Minister also commented that the Brennan Report had noted, in turn, that Mr Dates acknowledged that he alone holds some of the beliefs to which he referred and that other Worimi traditional owners challenged Mr Dates’ knowledge and authority to speak of Worimi traditions. Further, the Minister noted that Mr Dates’ claims in relation to the Mountain in its entirety were contrary to what has been the consistent view of the Karuah Land Council, which was that only the top of Alum Mountain may have particular significance because of men’s business.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As the top of the Mountain was not under threat of injury and desecration because of the road works, the Minister declined to make a declaration under s 10 of the Act. In that regard the Minister noted that under s 10 of the Act, he is able to make a declaration only if satisfied that the specified area is a significant Aboriginal area and that it is under threat of injury or desecration.CONSIDERATIONError of law Mr Oshlack put this issue in a number of different ways. First, he makes it clear that Mr Dates does not disagree with the Minister’s conclusion as to the upper part of Alum Mountain. That is, the upper area is a significant Aboriginal area, which is not the subject of likely injury by the proposed roadworks, being unaffected by the roadworks. Mr Dates challenges the conclusion that the lower part of the Mountain is not of Aboriginal significance and the finding that no areas of Aboriginal significance will be affected by the roadworks. Mr Dates says that there was no good reason given by the Minister as to how the upper slopes are a significant Aboriginal area and the lower slopes are not. He refers to evidence of sites on the lower slopes such as the artefacts scatter, the Guardian Tree, the Healing Stream and other scarred trees. He points to the Umwelt Report which, he says, recommended that the lower parts be recognised under the NSW Act. He asks rhetorically what differentiated the upper and lower parts of the Mountain? The evidence, he says, was either that the whole of the Mountain is of significance or was silent as to the lower parts of the Mountain. Mr Dates says that no Aboriginal witness had said that the lower slopes are not significant. Mr Dates submits that the Minister’s decision was unreasonable; that it manifested a failure properly to consider the Umwelt Report; and that insufficient reasons were given for the conclusion which, he seems to submit, defied logic. He submits that the decision was inherently illogical, as was the conclusion of the Brennan Report. Mr Oshlack repeatedly describes the Minister’s conclusion as a “perversion” and says that there was no probative evidence to support that conclusion. On the other hand, he says, there was before the Minister probative evidence that the whole of the Mountain, including the lower slopes, is of significance to Aboriginal people. The error of law identified in Mr Dates’ written submissions is that the Minister erred in reaching the s 10 decision ‘by drawing an inference with evidence to the contrary that the lower mountain slope of the Alum Mountain was not significant to Aboriginal people’. He says that there was no evidence to support the inference. To the extent that this aspect of Mr Dates’ case is separately dealt with by him in written and oral submissions, he seems to raise the further matter that the Minister’s conclusion as to the lower slopes was not supported by any probative material or by “logical grounds”. Mr Dates acknowledges that, as set out by Foster J in Anderson at [105], in order for him to succeed he must demonstrate either that the Minister has acted perversely or that his findings or inferences of fact were not supported by any probative material or made on logical grounds (Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu (1999) 197 CLR 611 at [145] per Gummow J). Mr Dates’ course of reasoning seems to be as follows:·The evidence demonstrated that there are a number of identified Aboriginal archaeological sites located on the lower slopes.·This established that Aboriginal people had occupied and utilised the area.·There was probative evidence that a number of Worimi traditional owners and other Aboriginal people believe that the whole top, ridges and slopes of the Mountain are significant in accordance with their traditions.·There was evidence from traditional owners that there are a number of cultural places on the lower slopes of the Mountain including scarred trees, healing places, burial and ceremonial areas that are significant to them.