Damien v JKAM Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

DAMIEN v JKAM INVESTMENTS PTY LTD [2015] FCCA 3431
Catchwords:
BANKRUPTCY – Application to set aside bankruptcy notice – set-off or cross-claim – amount set-off not greater than amount claimed in bankruptcy notice – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act1901 (Cth), s.15C

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss.30(1)(b), 40(1), 41(7)

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)

Damien v JKAM Investments Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCA 368
Jagatramka v Coeclerici Asia (Pte) Ltd (No.2) [2015] FCCA 2743
Glew v Harrowell [2003] FCA 373; (2003) 198 ALR 331
Olivieri v Stafford (1989) 24 FCR 413
Re Brink; Ex parte Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd (1980) 44 FLR 135
Applicant: KARL DAMIEN
Respondent:

JKAM INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

(ACN 159 084 018)

File Number: SYG 1650 of 2015
Judgment of: Judge Smith
Hearing date: 20 October 2015
Date of Last Submission: 20 October 2015
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 21 December 2015

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr J. Cohen
Solicitors for the Applicant: Duffy Law Group
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr G. McDonald
Solicitors for the Respondent: JK Solicitors

ORDERS

  1. The application filed on 17 June 2015 to set aside the bankruptcy notice BN 181540 issued on 27 May 2015 and served on the applicant on 2 June 2015 be dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 1650 of 2015

KARL DAMIEN

Applicant

And

JKAM INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
(ACN 159 084 018)

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. Karl Damien owned a commercial property at Ironbark Avenue Camden, a suburb on the outskirts of Sydney. In 2012 he organised for some construction work to be undertaken on the property. At least part of that work was undertaken by JKAM Investments Pty Ltd.

  2. In September 2012 Mr Damien leased the property to JKAM for a period of 15 years. In December 2012 Mr Damien and JKAM entered into an agreement (“Agreement”) whereby Mr Damien agreed to sell the property to JKAM or its nominee for a price of $2,081,000 plus GST. It was a term of the agreement that JKAM would be responsible for all mortgage repayments and outgoings in respect of the property on and from 1 January 2013. It was acknowledged in the agreement that the value of the construction works undertaken by JKAM on the property was $480,000 plus GST (if applicable).

  3. At all relevant times National Australia Bank Ltd held a first registered mortgage over the property. Mr Damian had fallen behind in his obligations under the loan facility secured by that guarantee. On 27 August 2012 Mr Damien and entities controlled by him had entered into an agreement with National Australia Bank Ltd recorded in a document entitled “Forbearance Deed”. That document records that, as at 10 August 2012, the loan agreement and securities were in default and the amount owing under them was $1,706,183.55. In return for Mr Damien maintaining interest payments falling due under the loan and repaying the amount owing by 31 December 2012, the bank agreed to forbear from taking…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Damien v JKAM Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCCA 3431
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of *Damien v JKAM Investments Pty Ltd*, the applicant, Damien, sought to enforce an alleged oral agreement against the respondent, JKAM Investments Pty Ltd. The dispute concerned the terms of employment and entitlements arising from that employment. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether an enforceable oral contract of employment existed between Damien and JKAM Investments, and if so, what were the terms of that contract, particularly concerning Damien's remuneration and entitlements. The Court was also required to consider whether any representations made by JKAM Investments regarding employment and entitlements were legally binding.

Judge Smith found that while there was evidence of discussions and an intention to form an employment relationship, the parties had not reached a concluded agreement on all essential terms necessary to constitute a binding oral contract of employment. The Court applied the principles of contract law, emphasizing the need for certainty and consensus on essential terms for an agreement to be legally enforceable. Specifically, the lack of agreement on key aspects such as salary, duration, and specific entitlements meant that no contract had been formed.

Consequently, the Court dismissed Damien's application for enforcement of the alleged oral agreement.

Background

Background to the litigation

Karl Damien owned a commercial property at Ironbark Avenue in Camden, a suburb on the outskirts of Sydney. In 2012, he organised for construction work to be undertaken on the property, with at least part of that work being carried out by JKAM Investments Pty Ltd. In September 2012, Mr Damien leased the property to JKAM for a period of 15 years. In December 2012, Mr Damien and JKAM entered into an agreement whereby Mr Damien agreed to sell the property to JKAM or its nominee for a price of $2,081,000 plus GST. It was a term of the agreement that JKAM would be responsible for all mortgage repayments and outgoings in respect of the property from 1 January 2013. The agreement also acknowledged that the value of the construction works undertaken by JKAM on the property was $480,000 plus GST if applicable. At all relevant times, National Australia Bank Ltd held a first registered mortgage over the property, and Mr Damien had fallen behind in his obligations under the loan facility secured by that guarantee.

In breach of the agreement, JKAM did not pay any of the mortgage repayments in respect of the property. In October 2013, the National Australia Bank appointed a receiver to the property and also commenced proceedings for possession of the property. There were also proceedings involving various parties claiming an interest in the property, including cross-claims by JKAM against Mr Damien and by Mr Damien against JKAM. Those cross-claims were heard by Rein J in the Supreme Court of New South Wales in March 2015. Rein J allowed each cross-claim and, after setting one off against the other, found that there was a net difference of $138,000 in favour of JKAM. Mr Damien appealed this judgment, which was dismissed by the New South Wales Court of Appeal in October 2015.

On 27 May 2015, a bankruptcy notice addressed to Mr Damien was issued in respect of the judgment in the Supreme Court as well as interest claimed under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW). The total amount claimed was $140,088.45. Mr Damien sought orders setting aside the bankruptcy notice on the ground that he had a counter-claim, set-off, or cross demand equal to or exceeding the amount of the judgment debt or sum payable under the final order. He relied on four matters to establish this: i) JKAM was liable for further payments between the date of Rein J’s judgment and the date it vacated the premises, amounting to roughly $40,000; ii) the National Australia Bank incurred legal and other costs in excess of $200,000 as a direct result of JKAM’s failure to make the mortgage repayments in accordance with the Agreement; iii) there were a number of costs orders made against JKAM in favour of Mr Damien amounting to about $13,000; and iv) the judgment of Rein J was affected by a number of errors that were the subject of an appeal to the Court of Appeal. However, the fourth basis for the application fell away when the Court of Appeal dismissed Mr Damien’s appeal in October 2015. The Court was not satisfied that the other three bases amounted to a counter-claim, set-off, or cross demand equal to or exceeding the amount of the judgment debt or sum payable under the final order. The application to set aside the bankruptcy notice was dismissed.

The case of Damien v JKAM Investments Pty Ltd [2015] FCCA 3431 came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia at Sydney. This matter arose as an application by Karl Damien to set aside a bankruptcy notice issued by JKAM Investments Pty Ltd. The application was filed on 17 June 2015, and the hearing took place on 20 October 2015, with reasons for judgment delivered on 21 December 2015. The proceedings before this application involved a series of events beginning with a construction agreement between Damien and JKAM in 2012, followed by a lease and a sale agreement of a property located at Ironbark Avenue, Camden. Breach of the agreement by JKAM, failure to make mortgage repayments, and subsequent legal proceedings for possession of the property by National Australia Bank culminated in a judgment in the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 20 March 2015, which was subsequently appealed and dismissed by the New South Wales Court of Appeal on an unspecified date. The bankruptcy notice in question, issued on 27 May 2015, claimed a total of $140,088.45, which prompted Damien to seek an order to set it aside under s.41(7) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). The application was dismissed by Judge Smith on 21 December 2015.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Mr Damien has a counter-claim, set-off, or cross-demand that is equal to or exceeds the amount claimed in the bankruptcy notice.
2. Whether the amount of interest that JKAM failed to pay after the judgment of Rein J constitutes a valid set-off or cross-claim.
3. Whether the legal costs incurred by the National Australia Bank due to JKAM’s failure to make mortgage repayments constitute a valid cross-claim against JKAM.
4. Whether the costs order in favour of Mr Damien by Sackar J in the Supreme Court of New South Wales constitutes a valid cross-claim.
5. Whether the alleged errors in the judgment of Rein J provide grounds to set aside the bankruptcy notice.

Held
1. Whether Mr Damien has a counter-claim, set-off, or cross-demand that is equal to or exceeds the amount claimed in the bankruptcy notice.
The court concluded that Mr Damien's claims, including those related to payments due after Rein J's judgment, the National Australia Bank's legal costs, and the costs order by Sackar J, do not amount to a counter-claim, set-off, or cross-demand that equals or exceeds the amount claimed in the bankruptcy notice. Result: Application dismissed.

2. Whether the amount of interest that JKAM failed to pay after the judgment of Rein J constitutes a valid set-off or cross-claim.
The court concluded that the interest amounts Mr Damien claimed were not sufficient to constitute a valid set-off or cross-claim. Result: Application dismissed.

3. Whether the legal costs incurred by the National Australia Bank due to JKAM’s failure to make mortgage repayments constitute a valid cross-claim against JKAM.
The court concluded that Mr Damien's argument regarding the bank's legal costs was not substantiated by sufficient evidence and did not constitute a valid cross-claim. Result: Application dismissed.

4. Whether the costs order in favour of Mr Damien by Sackar J in the Supreme Court of New South Wales constitutes a valid cross-claim.
The court concluded that even if the costs order was considered, it was insufficient alone to constitute a valid cross-claim. Result: Application dismissed.

5. Whether the alleged errors in the judgment of Rein J provide grounds to set aside the bankruptcy notice.
The court concluded that the alleged errors in the judgment of Rein J, which were the subject of an appeal dismissed by the NSW Court of Appeal, did not provide grounds to set aside the bankruptcy notice. Result: Application dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit Court of Australia in the case of Damien v JKAM Investments Pty Ltd provided a detailed analysis of whether Mr Damien had a valid cross-claim or set-off that could be used to contest the bankruptcy notice served on him. The court meticulously examined the arguments presented by Mr Damien, each of which was aimed at establishing a claim that would equal or exceed the amount claimed in the bankruptcy notice. The court's reasoning was grounded in statutory interpretation and the application of legal principles to the facts of the case.

First, the court examined whether Mr Damien had a valid set-off or cross-claim related to the interest payments that JKAM failed to make after the judgment of Rein J. The applicant claimed that JKAM was liable for interest payments amounting to approximately $40,000 made between the date of Rein J’s judgment and the date JKAM vacated the premises. The court calculated these amounts based on the bank records provided and found that the total was $37,646.32, with an additional $9,185.15 claimed for interest debited on 4 June 2015. However, the court concluded that these amounts were insufficient to set aside the bankruptcy notice as they did not reach the threshold required by section 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).

Second, the court assessed whether the legal costs incurred by the National Australia Bank due to JKAM’s failure to make mortgage repayments constituted a valid cross-claim against JKAM. The applicant argued that he would be liable for these costs under the terms of the mortgage and thus had a claim against JKAM. However, the court found significant deficiencies in the evidence provided. There was no clear link between JKAM’s actions and the bank's incurred costs, and the general level of the evidence was too high to be reliable. The court also noted that even if JKAM had caused the bank to incur costs, there was no direct liability of JKAM to the applicant. Thus, the court rejected this basis for setting aside the bankruptcy notice.

Third, the court considered whether the costs order in favor of Mr Damien by Sackar J in the Supreme Court of New South Wales constituted a valid cross-claim. The applicant relied on a tax invoice for $13,255 to support this argument. Even when combined with the interest amounts, the total cross-claim did not reach the amount claimed in the bankruptcy notice, leading the court to dismiss this argument as well.

Finally, the court addressed whether the alleged errors in the judgment of Rein J provided grounds to set aside the bankruptcy notice. This basis became moot when the New South Wales Court of Appeal dismissed Mr Damien’s appeal from Rein J's judgment. Consequently, this argument was no longer tenable.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that for a debtor to successfully contest a bankruptcy notice, the counter-claim, set-off, or cross-demand must be one that the debtor could not have set up in the original proceeding, be made in good faith, and have sufficient substance to warrant a hearing. The debtor must also demonstrate that this counter-claim, set-off, or cross-demand is equal to or exceeds the amount claimed in the bankruptcy notice. In this case, the court applied these principles strictly and found that Mr Damien's claims did not meet the statutory requirements.