Dalton v Lawson Hill Estate Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dalton v Lawson Hill Estate Pty Ltd  [2005] FCAFC 169

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading conduct – sale of vineyard and winery – misrepresentation by vendors of area occupied by vines – whether misrepresentation also made by selling agent – whether selling agent merely passing on information supplied, and known to purchaser to have been supplied, by vendors.

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading conduct – sale of vineyard and winery – misrepresentation by vendors of volume of available bore water as 1800 gallons per hour – in support, vendors handed to purchaser an ‘invoice’ given to them more than two years previously by water drilling contractor referring to ‘1800 GPH’ (1800 gallons per hour) – contractor had in fact orally informed vendors water flow from bore was 400 gallons per hour – 400 gallons per hour is approximately 1800 litres per hour – trial judge accepted that contractor had inadvertently written ‘1800 GPH’ rather than ‘1800 LPH’ and that if vendors had read the invoice at the time, they would have appreciated the error – whether contractor liable to purchaser as a result of vendors having handed over the invoice to them more than two years later – whether chain of causation broken.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 52
Partnership Act 1892 (NSW) ss 6(1), 10(1), 12

Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661 cited
Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Limited (2004) 212 ALR 357 applied
John G. Glass Real Estate Pty Ltd v Karawi Constructions Pty Limited [1993] ATPR
41-249 distinguished
Re La Rosa;  Ex parte Norgard v Rodpat Nominees Pty Ltd (1991) 31 FCR 83 cited

JOHN MICHAEL DALTON v LAWSON HILL ESTATE PTY LTD
as trustee of the LAWSON HILL ESTATE TRUST
NSD 1928 of 2004

TOVEGOLD PTY LTD as trustee for O’BRIEN McGREGOR TRUST FUND v LAWSON HILL ESTATE PTY LTD as trustee of the LAWSON HILL ESTATE TRUST
NSD 56 of 2005

LAWSON HILL ESTATE PTY LTD as trustee of the LAWSON HILL ESTATE TRUST v JUNE MARGARET GRACE
NSD197 of 2005

LINDGREN, FINN & EMMETT JJ
22 AUGUST 2005
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1928 of 2004

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

JOHN MICHAEL DALTON
APPELLANT

AND:

LAWSON HILL ESTATE PTY LTD
As trustee of the LAWSON HILL ESTATE TRUST
(ACN 096 523 241)
FIRST RESPONDENT

JUNE MARGARET GRACE
SECOND RESPONDENT

JOSE JOHN HAROLD GRACE
THIRD RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

LINDGREN FINN & EMMETT JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

22 AUGUST 2005

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The appeal be allowed.

2.        The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.

3.Orders 1, 2, 5, 6 and 7 made on 10 December 2004 in proceeding NSD 1303 of 2003, in so far as they relate to the appellant, be set aside.

4.In lieu of those orders in so far as they relate to the appellant:

(a)The application as against the appellant be dismissed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dalton v Lawson Hill Estate Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCAFC 169
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Dalton v Lawson Hill Estate Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the Purchaser and the Vendor concerning the sale of a property. The Purchaser claimed that the Vendor had made misrepresentations regarding the property, including the number of fruiting vines and the output of the bore. The primary judge had found in favour of the Purchaser, awarding damages of $705,589. The Vendor appealed the decision. The key legal issues in the appeal were whether the Vendor had made misleading or deceptive representations and whether the disclaimer in the brochure exempted the Vendor from liability. The court examined the conduct of the agent in relation to the particular purchaser, considering the nature of their dealings and conversations. The court found that the disclaimer in the brochure did not exempt the Vendor from liability as the agent had not brought home to the Purchaser that it was not in a position to take responsibility for the statement and was acting as a mere messenger. The appeal was allowed, and the orders made by the primary judge were set aside. The court dismissed the Purchaser's application and cross-claim, and ordered the Vendor to pay the Purchaser's costs. The decision highlights the importance of considering the particular circumstances of each case when determining liability for misleading or deceptive conduct.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.

3. Orders 1, 2, 5, 6 and 7 made on 10 December 2004 in proceeding NSD 1303 of 2003, in so far as they relate to the appellant, be set aside.

4. In lieu of those orders in so far as they relate to the appellant:

(a) The application as against the appellant be dismissed and there be judgment for the appellant against the first respondent accordingly.

(b) The cross-claim brought by the third respondent against the appellant be dismissed and there be judgment for the appellant against the third respondent on that cross-claim accordingly.

(c) The appellant’s cross-claim against the second and third respondents be dismissed.

(d) The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of its application as against the appellant.

(e) The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appellant’s cross-claim against the second and third respondents.

(f) The third respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the third respondent’s cross-claim against the appellant.

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The first respondent pay the appellants’ costs of the appeal.

3. Orders 1, 2, 5, 6 and 7 made on 10 December 2004 in proceeding NSD 1303 of 2003, in so far as they relate to the appellants, be set aside.

4. In lieu of those orders in so far as they relate to the appellants:

(a) The application as against the appellants be dismissed and there be judgment for the appellants against the first respondent accordingly.

(b) The appellants’ cross-claim brought against the second and third respondents be dismissed.

(c) The first respondent pay the appellants’ costs of the application as against the appellants.

(d) The first respondent pay the appellants’ costs of the appellants’ cross-claim against the second and third respondents.

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The respondent pay the first appellant’s costs of the appeal.

3. Orders 5, 6 and 7 made on 10 December 2004 in proceeding NSD 1303 of 2003 in so far as they relate to the respondent, be set aside, and Order 1 be varied by the insertion immediately after the words ‘Jose Harold Grace (third respondent) and’ the words ‘June Margaret Grace (fourth respondent)’.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Relevantly for the claim made by the Purchaser in the proceeding before the primary judge, the following further special conditions were also included:‘1.The purchasers acknowledge that they have inspected the subject property and are purchasing the same in its present situation, conditions and state of repair. The vendors have not and nor has anyone on the vendors behalf, made any representations in respect of the same and the purchasers will make no objection requisition or claim for compensation in respect of the property in its present situation, condition and state of repair or in respect of any inability to obtain or supply any Certificates in respect of the same.…4.The purchasers acknowledge that no warranties are given by the vendors or their agent as to the condition or state of repair of any structural improvement or any inclusion passing with the property or as to the carrying capacity of the land, its productivity or the uses to which it may be put and agree to accept delivery of the same on completion subject to all defects (if any) both latent and patent.…10.Prior to completion the vendors will furnish to the purchase written confirmation from the Department of Land and Water conversation that there is an appropriate licence in respect of the bore for 37 megalitres.’THE PURCHASER’S COMPLAINTS AND THE PRIMARY JUDGE’S JUDGMENT The Purchaser contended that Mr and Mrs Grace and the Agent each represented that the Property contained 20 acres of fruiting vines, whereas, in fact, the Property contained only some 14 to 16 acres of fruiting vines. The Purchaser also claimed that Mr and Mrs Grace represented that the Property contained a bore capable of supplying 1800 gallons of water per hour, whereas the output of the bore was only 400 gallons of water per hour, or less. In addition, the Purchaser claimed that Mr Dalton made misrepresentations concerning the Property, by creating, and not rectifying the mistake on, Invoice 0650. The proceeding was conducted on the basis that both representations were made by Mr and Mrs Grace and that they were false. It is somewhat extraordinary that the Purchaser should be entitled to recover damages of $705,589 in respect of a purchase for a total purchase price of $1,125,000, on the basis of informal statements made in the course of negotiations, which led to a formal written contract, where the Purchaser had been advised by a viticulturist, an accountant and solicitors. One might have expected that, if any reliance at all was to be placed upon such informal statements, some attempt would have been made to formalise them by including them as warranties in the contract. It is, therefore, curious that the Purchaser signed a contract containing special conditions (1) and (4), which refer expressly to the absence of representations and warranties concerning certain aspects of the Property. Specifically, the Purchaser acknowledged in special condition (1) that no representation had been made in respect of the situation, conditions and state of repair of the Property. The Purchaser expressly acknowledged that it had inspected the Property, that is to say, it had seen the extent of the vines. If the particular acreage of the vines was of any significance, it is curious that they did not themselves measure it, or ask for some express confirmation of the representations upon which they were intending to rely in signing the contract. The Purchaser also acknowledged in special condition (4) that no warranties had been given as to the carrying capacity of the Property, its productivity or the uses to which it might be put. It is just as curious that, having signed a contract containing such a provision, the Purchaser did not ask for express warranties concerning matters that it considered were of sufficient significance to induce it to enter into the contract.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Notwithstanding the disclaimer in the 2000 Brochure, his Honour found that the Agent made no disclaimer about its knowledge or belief in the correctness of the statements in the 2000 Brochure. His Honour found that the Agent had not brought home to the Purchaser that it was not in a position to take responsibility for the statement and was acting as a mere messenger. Mr O’Brien did not suggest that he said anything to that effect to Mr Houlihan or Mr Dunne. The primary judge concluded that that was not the effect of the disclaimer in the 2000 Brochure. His Honour concluded that Mr Houlihan’s belief that the Agent was taking responsibility for the statement about the vine area was not unfounded or unreasonable. Consideration on the appeal In considering the liability of an agent for sale for contravention of s 52 of the Trade Practices Act or s 42 of the Fair Trading Act, it is necessary to consider the character of the particular conduct of the particular agent in relation to the particular purchaser, bearing in mind what matters of fact each knew about the other as a result of the nature of their dealings and the conversations between them, of which each may be taken to have known. The mere fact that a person had engaged in the conduct of supplying a document containing information which is in fact misleading does not necessarily mean that that person had engaged in misleading conduct. It is crucial to examine the role of the person in question (see Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Limited (2004) 212 ALR 357 (‘Butcher’ – discussed further below) at [37]). Where a person purports to do no more than pass on information supplied by another, in circumstances that make it apparent that the person is not the source of the information and that the person expressly or impliedly disclaims any belief in its truth or falsity, merely passing it on, for what it is worth, does not involve conduct that is misleading or deceptive (see Yorke v Lucas at 666). The area planted with vines is not a matter discernible without measurement. Indeed, his Honour found that there was a question as to precisely what is to be measured when stating the area that is planted with vines. Thus, there is a question of whether or not access areas should be included. As the communications between Mr and Mrs Grace, on the one hand, and the Agent, on the other, which are summarised above, demonstrate, some care was taken by the Agent to obtain confirmation from Mr and Mrs Grace that the statements in the 2000 Brochure were accurate. To state that ‘every care has been taken in respect of the information’ contained in a brochure does not signify that independent steps have been taken to verify the information. More particularly, such a statement does not signify that an agent has independently measured or calculated an area to check whether the information given by its principal is correct, particularly when the statement goes on to say that ‘no warranty is given as to the accuracy’ of the information.