Daleport Holdings Pty Ltd v Brooks

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Land and Valuation Division)

DALEPORT HOLDINGS PTY LTD v BROOKS & ORS

[2007] SASC 260

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Debelle

11 July 2007

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - CONSENTS, APPROVALS AND PERMITS

Application for development consent – construction of single storey dwelling with associated earthworks – whether excavation and earthworks consistent with Development Plan – whether proposal complied with Development Plan – relevant criteria – appeal dismissed.

Ampol Road Pantry Pty Ltd v City of Brighton (1993) 62 SASR 165; Jim Stojan Pty Ltd v Jenny & Daughters Pty Ltd (1994) 179 LSJS 164; Leimal Pty Ltd v Adelaide City Council (2007) 246 LSJS 467; Ventura v Sustek (1976) 14 SASR 395, applied.
City of Mitcham v Freckmann (1999) 74 SASR 56; Hennig & Co Pty Limited v South Australian Planning Commission (PAT No 405 of 1992, delivered 1 March 1993); Moyes v J & L Developments Pty Ltd (2004) 236 LSJS 211; South Australia Housing Trust v Development Assessment Commission (1994) 63 SASR 35, considered.

DALEPORT HOLDINGS PTY LTD v BROOKS & ORS
[2007] SASC 260

Land and Valuation Division

  1. DEBELLE J.        This is an appeal from a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources and Development Court.

  2. The appeal concerns a proposal to erect a large dwelling on a parcel of land at 33 Birch Road, Stirling.  The land is within the area of the Adelaide Hills Council (“the Council”).  The Council categorised the application as a Category 3 development.  It gave notice of the proposal to neighbours as well as giving public notice.  Representations objecting to the development were made by a number of neighbours.  They were made by Professor and Mrs Moyes, who reside on the allotment immediately south at 35 Birch Road; by Mr and Mrs Brooks, who reside at 41 Birch Road; by Mr and Mrs Sands, who reside at 29 Birch Road; and by Mrs Josephian of 25 Birch Road.  These objections were essentially concerned that the proposed dwelling was too large for the site.  Mr Lillie who resides on 31 Birch Road, the land adjoining the subject land to the north, also objected.  He was concerned with the stability of his land given the earthworks and excavation proposed by Daleport.  For convenience, I will call those who made representations “the objectors”. 

  3. The Council granted provisional development plan consent subject to a number of conditions.  All of the objectors save Mrs Josephian appealed to the Environment, Resources and Development Court (“the Environment Court”), which upheld the appeal and set aside the decision of the Council.  From that decision Daleport appeals to this Court.

  4. This is the second appeal to this Court concerning the construction of a dwelling on this land.  The first appeal was Moyes v J & L Developments Pty Ltd (2004) 236 LSJS 211. The facts in that appeal were that the Council had refused provisional development plan consent to a proposal to construct a dwelling on the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Daleport Holdings Pty Ltd v Brooks and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 260
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Daleport Holdings Pty Ltd v Brooks, the appellant, Daleport, sought to construct a single-storey dwelling with associated earthworks. The respondent, Brooks, objected to the proposal, and the matter was heard in the Environment Court, which dismissed the application for development consent. The appeal against this decision was brought before the Court. The key issue before the Court was whether the excavation and earthworks proposed by Daleport were consistent with the Development Plan and whether the proposal complied with the relevant criteria. Another matter considered by the Court was an application by Daleport to lead new evidence in support of its appeal.

The Court found that the Commissioner had correctly applied the Development Plan and had considered all relevant issues in making the decision. The Court also found that the evidence that Daleport sought to lead could have been presented at the hearing in the Environment Court and that it would not have had an important influence on the outcome of the appeal. Therefore, the application to lead new evidence was dismissed. The appeal was ultimately dismissed, and the decision of the Environment Court was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the hearing of the appeal the argument advanced by Mr Sallis on behalf of Daleport essentially consisted of three grounds, namely, 1that the Commissioner had focussed on one issue, namely, excavation and had ignored other relevant issues;2that the Commissioner had misunderstood the effect of the evidence as to the extent of excavation; and3that the Commissioner had concentrated on a quantitative approach to the question of excavation and had failed to adopt a qualitative approach to that question and in doing so have failed correctly to apply the provisions of the Development Plan.In the course of his submissions on these issues, Mr Sallis submitted that the Commissioner had failed correctly to apply the decisions of this Court in South Australia Housing Trust v Development Assessment Commission (1994) 63 SASR 35 and City of Mitcham v Freckmann (1999) 74 SASR 56. For the reasons which follow, these submissions must fail. Application to Lead New Evidence The amended notice of appeal also contained an application to lead new evidence. The application sought to adduce evidence of a surveyor for the purpose of proving that the existing platform was too small to permit construction of the proposed dwelling. A further application to lead evidence to prove that the character and amenity of the locality is characterised by large dwellings with extensive excavation and filling was not pressed. Daleport sought to lead the survey evidence in answer to the following finding made by the Commissioner:As Ms Bell observed in her evidence (which I accept) a range of design options was available for the construction, on the subject land, of a dwelling of the floor area proposed, without necessitating substantial new excavation. Indeed, no evidence was led to suggest that a substantial dwelling could not be contemplated wholly on the existing platform. I dismissed the application. The reasons follow. In order to be able to lead new evidence on an appeal three conditions must be satisfied. First, it must be shown that the evidence could not have been obtained without reasonable diligence for use at the trial; secondly, the evidence must be such that, if given, it would probably have an important influence on the result of the case, though it need not be decisive; thirdly, the evidence must be apparently credible, although it need not be incontrovertible: Venturav Sustek (1976) 14 SASR 395, 399-400; Jim Stojan Pty Ltd v Jenny & Daughters Pty Ltd (1994) 179 LSJS 164 at 169. The particulars provided by the objectors some four weeks before the hearing of the appeal in the Environment Court directly raised the question of the extent to which the proposed dwelling covered the site, asserting that it was excessive. The particulars also referred to the proposed excavation. The particulars gave notice that one of the issues at the hearing was the suitability of the proposal on the site. The evidence which Daleport now seeks to lead could have been lead on the hearing of the appeal in the Environment Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

DEBELLE J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DEBELLE J