Dale and BIS Industries Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL                  )

)No: 2015/0567 and 2015/2391

General Division  )

Re: Steven Dale

Applicant

And: BIS Industries Limited

Respondent

CORRIGENDUM

TRIBUNAL:              Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

DATE:   12 December 2016

PLACE:                    Brisbane

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the text of the decision in this application as follows:

Sentence 2 of the decision should read:

“For the purpose of s 7(4) of the Act, the applicant should have been taken to have sustained the injury on 25 October 2013.”

In paragraph 71 of the decision the second sentence should read:

“For the purpose of s 7(4) of the Act, the applicant should have been taken to have sustained the injury on 25 October 2013.”

..................................[sgd]..............................

Deputy President

Dale and BIS Industries Limited (Compensation) [2016] AATA 862 (31 October 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers

2015/0567 and 2015/2391

Re

Steven Dale

APPLICANT

And

BIS Industries Limited

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

Date 31 October 2016
Place Brisbane

I set aside the reviewable decision of 24 September 2014 in application no 0567 of 2015 and substitute a decision that from and including 23 September 2014 until the date of this decision the applicant is entitled to compensation for incapacity for work under s 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). For the purpose of s 7(4) of the Act, the applicant should have been taken to have sustained the injury on 19 July 2013. The application is remitted to the respondent to calculate incapacity payments in accordance with paragraph 70 of these reasons for decision. The respondent is to pay the reasonable costs and expenses of the applicant incurred in relation to application no 0567 of 2015.

In application no 2391 of 2015 I affirm the decision of 18 April 2015 under review.

..............................[sgd]..........................................

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – compensation for injuries resulting in incapacity – injury suffered by employee – rehabilitation program not suitable employment – decision set aside and remitted

COMPENSATION – compensation in respect of medical expenses – applicant does not require further medical treatment – decision affirmed under review

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4, 8, 16, 19, 40

CASES

Lyons and Telstra Corporation (2001) 66 ALD 159
Telstra Corporation v Lyons (2003) 132 FCR 548
Saag and Comcare (2006) 89 ALD 710
Simmons v Comcare (2013) 134 ALD 522
Australian Postal Commission v Oudyn (2003) 73 ALD 659

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

31 October 2016

introduction

  1. On 28 June 2011, Steven Dale (“the applicant”) commenced employment with BIS Industries Limited (“the respondent”) as an Operator (Level 2) with road train driver duties.[1] On 25 October 2013, the applicant was injured in the course of his employment.[2] The applicant received compensation after the injury was sustained until his employment with the respondent was terminated on or about 22 September…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dale and BIS Industries Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 862
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by an employee against a decision by QBE, affirming a previous determination that the employee was not entitled to further compensation. The dispute centred on the employee's capacity to earn income in suitable employment following an injury. The case was heard by Deputy P McDermott Rfd P.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the applicant's ability to earn income in suitable employment, as contemplated by section 19 of the relevant Act. This involved assessing whether the applicant's earning capacity was correctly calculated by the respondent and whether the respondent had a present liability to pay compensation from a specific date. A secondary issue concerned the applicant's entitlement to compensation for medical expenses.

The Tribunal considered various medical reports detailing the applicant's left elbow injury, which included tears to the extensor tendon and collateral ligaments. Medical opinions varied regarding the applicant's fitness for duty and the necessity for further treatment, with some recommending surgery and others deeming the applicant fit for light or sedentary duties. The respondent argued that the applicant's ability to earn income in suitable employment was equal to his normal weekly earnings, thus resulting in nil compensation payable. However, the Tribunal found that the applicant was unable to earn any income in suitable employment.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the reviewable decision and substituted a new decision finding the applicant entitled to compensation for incapacity for work from a specified date. The matter was remitted to the respondent for the calculation of incapacity payments. The Tribunal also affirmed the decision regarding medical expenses.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 18 April 2015 QBE issued a reviewable decision affirming the determination of the respondent dated 9 March 2015.[11][11] Exhibit 1, T-Documents – 2015/2391, T7.medical evidence On 21 November 2013, Dr Darlow reported a tear of the extensor tendon insertion of the applicant’s left elbow. On 21 November 2013, an ultrasound revealed an almost complete tear of the common extensor tendon insertion.[12] On 4 December 2013, an MRI report confirmed a high grade partial or complete tear of the lateral collateral and lateral ulnar collateral ligaments. The MRI report also confirmed a high grade partial tear of the common extensor tendon insertion.[13] At this time Dr Darlow reported that the applicant was not fit for his normal duties and would require reassessment. Dr Darlow referred the applicant to a specialist.[12] Exhibit 2, T-Documents – 2015/0567, T7.[13] Exhibit 2, T-Documents – 2015/0567, T15. On 10 April 2014, Mr Adams, Exercise Physiologist, reported that the applicant had a left elbow common extensor tendon tear and a lateral collateral ligament tear and that he was fit for suitable duties.[14][14] Ibid. On 29 May 2014, Dr Bansi reported that the applicant could return to driving duties with breaks and recommended that he be provided a vehicle with power steering and automatic transmission.[15][15] Exhibit 2, T-Documents – 2015/0567, T28. On 1 August 2014, Konekt Australia issued a Return to Work Progress Report. It was reported that the applicant had returned to a seven day swing of twelve hour shifts with five to seven hours of driving per shift. The applicant then reported that he experienced an increased, but manageable, level of pain after driving for an extended period, but experienced no specific difficulties.[16][16] Exhibit 2, T-Documents – 2015/0567, T30. On 2 September 2014, Dr Bansi reported that the applicant was fit for suitable duties and did not require further specialist review. Dr Bansi recommended PRP injections and physiotherapy. Dr Bansi described the elbow as stable and stationary.[17] [17] Exhibit 2, T-Documents – 2015/0567, T32. On 3 October 2014, Dr Journeaux reported that the applicant had a traumatic onset of a lateral epicondylitis involving the common extensor mechanism with lateral collateral ligament damage.[18] Dr Journeaux noted that the PRP injections that were recommended by Dr Bansi did not provide any significant benefit.[19] Dr Journeaux recommended surgical exploration of the elbow followed by a splint and physiotherapy.[20] He considered the applicant was fit for light duties and noted that the applicant had been working full-time with modified duties prior to being stood down.[21].[18] Exhibit 2, T-Documents – 2015/0567, T39 at p. 117.[19] Ibid at p. 114.[20] Ibid at pp. 117-118.[21] Ibid at pp. 115, 118. On 15 December 2014, Dr van der Walt reported that the applicant had sustained a significant injury in the accident resulting in recalcitrant tennis elbow syndrome.[22] The pain experienced by the applicant since the accident gradually increased despite receiving PRP injections and undergoing physiotherapy.[23] Dr van der Walt reported that the applicant had some relief by using an elbow strap. However, he ceased using the elbow strap because it caused ulnar nerve symptoms.[24] In terms of his current symptoms, the applicant reported to Dr van der Walt that his pain was not “a problem” as long as he did not perform physical activity.[25] Dr van der Walt did not recommend surgery because he considered that there was a risk that surgery would worsen the applicant's condition.[26] Dr van de Walt considered the applicant was unfit for his pre-injury duties but fit for sedentary or light manual work.[27][22] Exhibit 10, Medical report prepared by Dr Van Der Walt dated 15 December 2014 at p. 7.[23] Ibid at pp. 3-4.[24] Ibid at p. 4.[25] Ibid.[26] Ibid at p. 7.[27] Ibid at p. 8.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant in the reply seeks an order that his entitlement to compensation under s 19 of the Act from 23 September 2014 to the date of determination of the proceedings is $2,190.33. The respondent had not made an objection to this form of order. However, the Act does not confer jurisdiction upon this Tribunal to make such an order. For the first 45 weeks from 23 September 2014 the amount of NWE is $2,190.33. However, after an employee has received the first 45 weeks of incapacity payments, the rate of incapacity payments is calculated under s 19(3) of the Act to be the applicable adjustment percentage which in this case would appear to be 75% of NWE. The amount of AE in the formula in s 19 of the Act is $0.00 as I do not consider that the applicant is able to earn any income in suitable employment.decision71. I set aside the reviewable decision of 24 September 2014 in application no 0567 of 2015 and substitute a decision that from and including 23 September 2014 until the date of this decision the applicant is entitled to compensation for incapacity for work under s 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). For the purpose of s 7(4) of the Act, the applicant should have been taken to have sustained the injury on 19 July 2013. The application is remitted to the respondent to calculate incapacity payments in accordance with paragraph 70 of these reasons for decision. The respondent is to pay the reasonable costs and expenses of the applicant incurred in relation to application no 0567 of 2015. 72. In application no 2391 of 2015 I affirm the decision of 18 April 2015 under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 19(4) of the Act provides the following criteria that must be considered in determining the amount per week that an employee is able to earn in suitable employment:a)where the employee is in employment (including self-employment)—the amount per week that the employee is earning in that employment;b)where, after becoming incapacitated for work, the employee received an offer of suitable employment and failed to accept that offer—the amount per week that the employee would be earning in that employment if he or she were engaged in that employment;c)where, after becoming incapacitated for work, the employee received an offer of suitable employment and, having accepted that offer, failed to engage, or to continue to engage, in that employment—the amount per week that the employee would be earning in that employment if he or she were engaged in that employment;d)where, after becoming incapacitated for work, the employee received an offer of suitable employment on condition that the employee completed a reasonable rehabilitation or vocational retraining program and the employee failed to fulfil that condition—the amount that the employee would be earning in that employment if he or she were engaged in that employment;e)where, after becoming incapacitated for work, the employee has failed to seek suitable employment—the amount per week that, having regard to the state of the labour-market at the relevant time, the employee could reasonably be expected to earn in such employment if he or she were engaged in such employment;f)where paragraph (b), (c), (d) or (e) applies to the employee— whether the employee’s failure to accept an offer of employment, to engage, or to continue to engage, in employment, to undertake, or to complete, a rehabilitation or vocational retraining program or to seek employment, as the case may be, was, in Comcare’s opinion, reasonable in all the circumstances; andg)any other matter that Comcare considers relevant.considerationApplication 0567 of 2015 The respondent contends that the applicant’s ability to earn income in suitable employment has been correctly calculated as the amount that he was earning prior to the termination of his employment. The respondent further contends that as of 23 September 2014 the respondent did not have a present liability to pay compensation to the applicant under s 19 of the Act. This submission was made on the basis that the amount per week that the applicant was able to earn in suitable employment was the same as his NWE so that the amount per week of compensation payable to the applicant under the formula in s 19(2) of the Act is as follows:$2,190.33 (NWE) - $2,190.33 (AE) = $0.00 Section 19(4) of the Act provides for matters to be considered in determining what an employee is able to earn in suitable employment. The respondent relies upon paras 19(4)(c) and (g) of the Act in support of its submission that as at 23 September 2014, it was not liable to pay compensation to the applicant under the Act.