DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: Dabron v. Houssaini & Anor [2000] QDC 244 PARTIES: NATASHA DABRON (Plaintiff)
v.
DR MANU HOUSSAINI (First Defendant)
And
THE ESTATE OF RICHARD GORZKI (Second Defendant)FILE NO/S: D1090 of 2000 DIVISION: PROCEEDING: ORIGINATING COURT: District Court Brisbane DELIVERED ON: 12 July 2000 DELIVERED AT: Brisbane HEARING DATE: 19 June 2000 JUDGE: Samios DCJ ORDER: CATCHWORDS: LIMITATIONS OF ACTIONS – postponement of the bar – extension of period – cause of action in respect of personal injuries - means of knowledge of applicant – has applicant taken all reasonable steps to find out the fact
Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v. Taylor (1996-7) 186 CLR 541
Dick v. University of Queensland (1999) QCA 474
Do Carmo v. Ford Excavations Pty Ltd (1984) 154 CLR 234
Healy v. Femdale Pty Ltd (unreported CA, Qld, 9 June 1993, 37/92)COUNSEL: Mr Boccabella for the plaintiff
Mr Diehm for the first defendantSOLICITORS: Damien Bourke & Associates for the plaintiff
Flower & Hart for the first defendant
By proceedings commenced in this court on 17 March 2000, the plaintiff claims against the first defendant damages for personal injuries, loss and damage.
The plaintiff alleges that she suffered personal injuries, loss and damage by reason of the negligence of the first defendant. The plaintiff was a patient of the first defendant. The first defendant carried on practise as a dentist in New Farm.
According to the plaintiff, in March and April 1996, the plaintiff consulted the first defendant to determine what could be done cosmetically to improve the appearance with regard to her upper teeth between and including the canines. The first defendant had treated her previously for routine dental check ups, and the plaintiff relied upon his assessment. It was during one of these routine consultations with the first defendant that the plaintiff inquired about having work carried out to improve the general appearance of her teeth.
Her teeth at that stage were straight and in good condition, however:
(a) her teeth had a yellow tinge due to childhood antibiotics and she wanted whiter teeth;
(b) her two canines were larger than the other teeth and she wanted them to be more consistent with the size of the other teeth.
The plaintiff was informed by the first defendant that he could fit crowns to both the top and bottom rows of teeth and he informed her that it would improve the cosmetic appearance of her teeth. When the plaintiff initially saw the first defendant to consult with him in or about March and April 1996, she discussed with him the result of the procedure he proposed (that is, the crown work) to carry out. The first defendant’s response to her queries was “Don’t worry, they will be perfect”. The plaintiff instructed the first defendant to carry out the work which was carried out over about four visits. The procedure involved in the fitting of crowns, involved the reduction of the existing teeth to what is known as a…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dabron v Houssaini and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] QDC 244
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the material facts relating to the plaintiff's cause of action were within her means of knowledge before the limitation period expired, and if the court should exercise its discretion to extend the limitation period under the Act. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff took all reasonable steps to ascertain the facts of her claim before the limitation period ended.
The court found that the plaintiff did not have any reason to doubt the work performed by Dr Houssaini until she consulted Dr Thompson in 1999. The court accepted the plaintiff's evidence that she remained unaware of the need to seek a second opinion earlier due to her lack of knowledge about the deficiencies in the work. The plaintiff's dissatisfaction with the cosmetic result did not suggest to her that there was any fault in Dr Houssaini's advice or work. The court concluded that the material facts were not within the plaintiff's means of knowledge until after the limitation period had commenced. The court exercised its discretion to extend the limitation period, ordering that the plaintiff's proceedings could commence by 18 March 2000.
The court ordered further hearings to address the defendant's application for judgment and the costs associated with the plaintiff's and defendant's applications.
Background
Background to the litigation
Throughout the proceedings, the plaintiff maintained that she had no reason to doubt the work done by Dr. Houssaini until her consultation with Dr. Thompson. She explained that while she was unhappy with the cosmetic result, she believed the functional issues with her teeth had been addressed. The plaintiff also mentioned that Dr. Houssaini provided options to improve the appearance, but she lacked the financial means to pursue them at the time. The court was tasked with determining whether the plaintiff took all reasonable steps to discover the alleged negligence before the limitation period expired. The plaintiff argued she remained unaware of the fault in Dr. Houssaini's work until Dr. Thompson's evaluation, and thus the facts were not within her means of knowledge earlier. Dr. Houssaini conceded that the facts were material and of a decisive character but argued the plaintiff could have discovered them earlier. The court found in favour of the plaintiff, concluding that she had not unreasonably delayed in obtaining the necessary advice and that extending the limitation period would not significantly prejudice the defendant.
The matter of Dabron v. Houssaini originated in the District Court of Queensland, Brisbane, where the plaintiff, Natasha Dabron, filed proceedings against Dr. Manu Houssaini on 17 March 2000. Dabron alleged that she suffered personal injuries, loss, and damage due to the negligence of Dr. Houssaini, who had performed dental work on her. The defendant responded by claiming that the plaintiff's cause of action was barred by the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 due to the three-year limitation period for personal injury claims. Consequently, Dabron applied to the court to extend the limitation period to 18 March 2000. The application was heard on 19 June 2000, and the presiding judge, Samios DCJ, considered various factors, including the plaintiff's means of knowledge and the material facts relevant to the case. After evaluating the evidence and arguments presented, the judge determined that the material facts were not within the plaintiff's means of knowledge until after the commencement of the year preceding the expiration of the limitation period. Therefore, the judge extended the limitation period, allowing the plaintiff's proceedings to continue. The court will subsequently address the orders related to the defendant's application and the costs associated with both applications.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the alleged negligence by the first defendant constitutes a material fact of a decisive character.
2. Whether the facts establishing the plaintiff's cause of action were within the plaintiff's means of knowledge before the limitation period expired.
3. Whether the plaintiff took all reasonable steps to ascertain the facts of the alleged negligence before the limitation period expired.
4. Whether the court should exercise its discretion to extend the limitation period under the Limitations of Actions Act 1974 (Qld).
Held
1. Whether the alleged negligence by the first defendant constitutes a material fact of a decisive character. The court concluded that the alleged negligence was a material fact of a decisive character.
2. Whether the facts establishing the plaintiff's cause of action were within the plaintiff's means of knowledge before the limitation period expired. The court concluded that the facts establishing the plaintiff's cause of action were not within the plaintiff's means of knowledge before the limitation period expired.
3. Whether the plaintiff took all reasonable steps to ascertain the facts of the alleged negligence before the limitation period expired. The court concluded that the plaintiff took all reasonable steps to ascertain the facts of the alleged negligence before the limitation period expired.
4. Whether the court should exercise its discretion to extend the limitation period under the Limitations of Actions Act 1974 (Qld). The court concluded that the court should exercise its discretion to extend the limitation period under the Limitations of Actions Act 1974 (Qld).
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The District Court of Queensland in Dabron v. Houssaini considered whether the plaintiff, Natasha Dabron, could have her limitation period extended for commencing her personal injury claim against Dr. Manu Houssaini. The court examined several issues to determine whether the extension should be granted.
First, the court considered whether the alleged negligence by Dr. Houssaini constituted a material fact of a decisive character. The court determined that the facts which the plaintiff discovered from another dentist, Dr. Thompson, were indeed material facts of a decisive character. These facts were crucial in establishing the negligent conduct upon which the plaintiff's cause of action in negligence was founded. The court found that the plaintiff would have needed to prove these facts to establish her claim.
Second, the court examined whether the facts establishing the plaintiff's cause of action were within the plaintiff's means of knowledge before the limitation period expired. The court found that until the plaintiff consulted Dr. Thompson in September 1999, she did not have any belief or reason to doubt that the work carried out by Dr. Houssaini had been done properly and with due skill and care. The court accepted the plaintiff's evidence that she remained in ignorance of the need to ascertain these facts until she saw Dr. Thompson. The court held that the plaintiff's conduct was consistent with her evidence that she was not so unhappy nor did she think the work was inadequate that she should seek a second opinion.
Third, the court considered whether the plaintiff took all reasonable steps to ascertain the facts of the alleged negligence before the limitation period expired. The court found that the plaintiff did not fail to take all reasonable steps to find out the facts. The court reasoned that the plaintiff could have sought a second opinion at any time, but there was no aspect of the work done that would have suggested to the plaintiff that she should seek a second opinion before she saw Dr. Thompson.
Lastly, the court examined whether it should exercise its discretion to extend the limitation period under the Limitations of Actions Act 1974 (Qld). The court found that extending the limitation period would not result in significant prejudice to the first defendant and that there were no features of the plaintiff's claim that might affect the availability or reliability of evidence relevant to the issues. Therefore, the court ordered that the period of limitation for the commencement of the plaintiff's proceedings be extended to 18 March 2000.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a plaintiff has not taken all reasonable steps to ascertain the facts of the alleged negligence before the limitation period expired, the court may still extend the limitation period if the facts were not within the plaintiff's means of knowledge and the extension would not result in significant prejudice to the defendant. The court in this case found that the plaintiff did not fail to take all reasonable steps to find out the facts and that extending the limitation period would not result in significant prejudice to the defendant. Therefore, the court exercised its discretion to extend the limitation period.