Da Silva Moura (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Da Silva Moura (Migration) [2021] AATA 238 (29 January 2021)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Maria Helena Da Silva Moura

CASE NUMBER:  1921296

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          BCC2019/2343323

MEMBER:T. Quinn

DATE:29 January 2021

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the application for a Student (Temporary) (Class TU) visa for reconsideration, with the direction that the applicant meets the following criteria for a Subclass 500 (Student) visa:

·clause 500.212(a) of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.

Statement made on 29 January 2021 at 1:34pm

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Student (Temporary) (Class TU) – Subclass 500 (Student) – genuine temporary entrant – applied for student visa after arriving on tourist visa – lack of academic progress – harassment by fellow student and non-completion of course – enrolment in new course, close to finishing – incentives to remain or return – partner visa application in progress – mother and her business in home country – uncertain future plans because of COVID-19 pandemic – closely balanced factors – decision under review remitted

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 65, 338(2), 347, 359(2)
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2, cl 500.212(a)

CASES
Baker v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCAFC 145
Chen v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 46
Cockrell v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2008) 171 FCR 345
FKP18 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1555
Jagroop v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 225 FCR 482
Kaur v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCCA 1372
Khan v Minister for Immigration [2019] FCCA 565
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Obele (2010) 119 ALD 358
Saini v MIBP [2016] FCA 858
Tshering v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCCA 2667
Williams v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 226 FCR 112

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs (‘the delegate’) on 12 July 2019 to refuse to grant the applicant a Student (Temporary) (Class TU) visa (‘the visa’) under section 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (‘the Act’).

  2. The applicant applied for the visa on 1 May 2019 (‘the application’).   At the time of application, Class TU contained two subclasses: Subclass 500 (Student) and Subclass 590 (Student Guardian).  The applicant applied for the visa (being a Subclass 500 (Student) visa) to undertake study in Australia and does not claim to meet the criteria for a Subclass 590 (Student Guardian) visa.

  3. On 12 July 2019, the delegate refused to grant the visa on the basis that the applicant did not satisfy the requirements of clause 500.212 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (‘the Regulations’), namely that the applicant was not considered to be a genuine applicant for entry and stay as a student. A copy of the delegate’s decision was provided to the Tribunal with the applicant’s review application.

  4. On 2 August 2019, the applicant applied for a review…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Da Silva Moura (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 238
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) reviewed a decision concerning a Brazilian citizen, Ms. Da Silva Moura, who applied for a Subclass 500 (Student) visa. Ms. Da Silva Moura had arrived in Australia on a tourist visa and subsequently applied for the student visa to undertake an English course. The delegate had refused her application, finding she was not a genuine temporary entrant.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Ms. Da Silva Moura met the genuine temporary entrant criterion under clause 500.212(a) of the Migration Regulations 1994. This involved assessing her circumstances in her home country and in Australia, her immigration history, and any other relevant matters, in accordance with Direction No. 69 issued by the Minister. The Tribunal was required to consider these factors holistically and independently, not as a mere checklist.

The Tribunal noted several factors that presented a complex picture. While Ms. Da Silva Moura had a history of employment in Brazil and had provided plausible reasons for studying English in Australia rather than her home country, the Tribunal expressed concern about her arrival on a tourist visa and subsequent application for a student visa shortly thereafter, finding it difficult to accept the level of planning involved. However, the Tribunal also acknowledged that her circumstances were closely balanced, that she was enrolled in a course and nearing completion, and that her previous study history was plausible.

Ultimately, the Tribunal was satisfied that Ms. Da Silva Moura met the genuine temporary entrant criterion. Consequently, the Tribunal remitted the application for the Subclass 500 (Student) visa to the Minister for reconsideration, with a direction that the applicant satisfied clause 500.212(a) of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Direction is a lawful direction of the Minister made in accordance with section 499 of the Act. The Tribunal is therefore bound to consider and, to the extent that its terms are relevant, apply it to the applicant’s case.[1] Accordingly, the terms of the Direction and their application to the applicant’s case have been considered in relation to material before the Tribunal. The Tribunal, however, recognises that it is an independent statutory body. It must therefore reach its own conclusions as to the merits of the applicant’s case, which includes an assessment of how and to what extent each factor in the Direction is relevant and applicable, independently of any conclusions reached by the delegate. In this regard, the Tribunal also notes the decision of Judge McNab in Tshering v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCCA 2667 (at [44]-[47]), wherein his Honour referred to the decisions of Kaur v Minister for Home Affairs & Anor [2019] FCCA 1372 (at [49] and [51]) and Khan v Minister for Immigration & Another [2019] FCCA 565 (at [35]) in relation to the proper approach to the consideration of guidelines such as the Direction. Most pertinently, his Honour endorses the view espoused in those cases, that such guidelines may not be relevant where the matters raised by an applicant, either upon the application or at merits review, do not raise facts which engage particular matters identified by those guidelines. [1]FKP18 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1555, [10], [34]; Chen v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 46, [29]; Williams v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 226 FCR 112, [60]-[73]; Jagroop v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 225 FCR 482, [8]; Baker v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCAFC 145, [10]; Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Obele (2010) 119 ALD 358, [53] Cockrell v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2008) 171 FCR 345, [27]-[28].CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The applicant in this case is a 42-year-old female Brazilian citizen who first arrived in Australia on 4 April 2019 as the holder of a tourist visa.[2] She has not returned to her home country since that time.[3] The applicant commenced studying shortly after her arrival and sought the student visa which is the subject of this review to undertake a General English course with a proposed completion date of 15 March 2020.[4][2] See delegate’s decision and applicant’s response to the s359(2) letter.[3] See applicant’s response to the s359(2) letter.[4] See applicant’s response to the s359(2) letter and evidence at hearing. Prior to coming to Australia, the applicant completed a twelve month Business Administration Technology course in 2007 and a six month course for entrepreneurial women in 2015 in Brazil.[5] The applicant worked as a Manager for three different employers: from 1999-2004 earning AUD12,000 equivalent per annum; from 2004-2017 earning AUD24,000 equivalent per annum and from 2017-2019 earning AUD30,000 equivalent per annum in Brazil.[6][5] See delegate’s decision and applicant’s response to the s359(2) letter.[6] See applicant’s response to the s359(2) letter.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant is not working onshore and has expenses of AUD3,000 per annum.[15] She owns a car worth AUD8,000 in her home country.[16] The Tribunal notes that the United Nations Human Development Index, which is a statistical comparison of life expectancy, education and per capita income indicators by country, ranks Brazil as 79th in the world as compared to Australia’s ranking of 6th in the world.[17] The Tribunal does not consider it can form any firm conclusions as to whether the applicant’s economic circumstances onshore are acting as a significant incentive for her to remain onshore.[15] See applicant’s response to the s359(2) letter and evidence at hearing.[16] See applicant’s response to the s359(2) letter and evidence at hearing.[17]See Table 1 of United Nations’ Human Development Report 2019 commencing at page 300 <>The applicant states that English courses in Brazil will not provide skills to a level of proficiency that those in Australia can and studying English in an English speaking country will further develop her skills.[18] The Tribunal considers the applicant has provided reasonable reasons for not undertaking the study in her home country or region.[18] See applicant’s response to the s359(2) letter.The applicant’s response to the s359(2) letter stated she has had no travel, visa or immigration issues in the past. The applicant stated she does not have any potential military service obligations or civil unrest concerns in Brazil.[19][19] See applicant’s response to the s359(2) letter.The Tribunal is concerned about the way in which the applicant arrived onshore (being on a tourist visa and only then, once onshore, applying for a student visa). It is difficult for the Tribunal to accept that the applicant, in such a short space of time after their arrival onshore as a tourist, could have then promptly researched all study and living options and decided to remain onshore for a further extended period. The Tribunal accepts that it is possible that an applicant may seek a change in plans or to further their skills for employment reasons and remuneration opportunities, but the Tribunal is puzzled when an applicant arrives on a visitor visa and then makes sudden changes to their plans within a short period of time. It seems unlikely to the Tribunal that a person travelling as a tourist would make such a significant change from their initial intentions to visit. Such a significant change would necessarily include a greater level of planning and preparation before arriving in Australia considering the length of time that the applicant proposed to spend in Australia.The Tribunal considers the factors for and against the applicant being a genuine temporary entrant for study in Australia are closely balanced in this case. However, the applicant has provided a plausible explanation in relation to her study history and is currently enrolled, studying and only months away from completion. Should the applicant make a further student visa application on the basis of an intention to undertake further study after this, her submissions and evidence in connection with this case will clearly be relevant to any assessment her intention to stay in Australia temporarily only to study.Having had regard to the applicant’s circumstances, her immigration history and all other relevant matters, the Tribunal is satisfied that the applicant is a genuine applicant for entry and stay as a student temporarily as required by clause 500.212. Accordingly, the applicant meets clause 500.212(a) of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.Given the above findings, the appropriate course is to remit the application for the visa to the Minister to consider the remaining criteria for a Subclass 500 (Student) visa.DECISIONThe Tribunal remits the application for a Student (Temporary) (Class TU) visa for reconsideration, with the direction that the applicant meets the following criteria for a Subclass 500 (Student) visa:·Clause 500.212(a) of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.MemberT. QuinnAttachment – Direction No.69DIRECTION NUMBER 69 – ASSESSING THE GENUINE TEMPORARY ENTRANT CRITERION FOR STUDENT VISA AND STUDENT GUARDIAN VISA APPLICATIONS(Section 499)I, PETER DUTTON, Minister for Immigration and Border Protection give this Direction under section 499 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).Dated: 18 April 2016Peter DuttonMinister for Immigration and Border ProtectionNote: Section 499(1) of the Act empowers the Minister to give a written direction to a person or body having functions or powers under the Act if the directions are about the performance of those functions; or the exercise of those powers. Under section 499(2) of the Act, the direction must not be inconsistent with the Act or the Migration Regulations 1994. Under section 499(2A) of the Act, the person or body must comply with the Direction.Part 1 of Direction No. 69 - PreliminaryName of DirectionThis Direction is Direction No. 69 - Assessing the genuine temporary entrant criterion for Student visa and Student Guardian visa applications.It may be cited as Direction No. 69.CommencementThis Direction commences on 1 July 2016.InterpretationAct means the Migration Act 1958.Genuine temporary entrant means a person who satisfies the genuine temporary entrant criterion for Student visa or Student Guardian visa applications.Genuine temporary entrant criterion refers to clause 500.212(a), 500.312(a) and 590.215(a) at Schedule 2 to the Regulations.Home country has the same meaning as the definition of that term in regulation 1.03 in Part 1 of the Regulations.Regulations mean the Migration Regulations 1994.Relative has the same meaning as the definition of that term in regulation 1.03 in Part 1 of the Regulations.Spouse has the same meaning as the definition of the term in section 5F of the Act.Student visa means a Subclass 500 (Student) visaStudent Guardian visa means a Subclass 590 (Student Guardian) visa.ApplicationThis Direction applies to delegates performing functions or exercising powers under section 65 of the Act in relation to assessing an applicant’s temporary entrant criterion for Student visa applications in Schedule 2 to the Regulations.This Direction also applies to members of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal who review the decisions of primary decision-makers in relation to a Student visa or a Student Guardian visa application.The genuine temporary entrant criterion must be satisfied by all applicants who make an application for either a Student visa seeking to satisfy the primary criteria for a Student Guardian visa.PreambleThe Australian Government operates a student visa programme that enables people who are not Australian citizens or Australian permanent residents to undertake study in Australia. A person who wants to undertake a course of study under the student visa programme must obtain a student visa before they can commence a course of study in Australia. A successful applicant must be both a genuine temporary entrant and a genuine student.An applicant who is a genuine temporary entrant will have circumstances that support a genuine intention to temporarily enter and remain in Australia, notwithstanding the potential for this intention to change over time to an intention to utilise lawful means to remain in Australia for an extended period of time or permanently.The genuine temporary entrant criterion for Student visa applications requires the Minister to be satisfied that the applicant intends genuinely to stay in Australia temporarily, having regard to:a.the applicant’s circumstances; andb.the applicant’s immigration history; andc.if the applicant is a minor — the intentions of a parent, legal guardian or spouse of the applicant; andd.any other relevant matter.This Direction provides guidance to decision makers on what factors require consideration when assessing the above paragraphs a to d, to determine whether the applicant genuinely intends to stay in Australia temporarily.Decision makers must take a reasonable and balanced approach between the need to make a timely decision on a Student visa or Student Guardian visa application and the need to identify those applicants who, at time of decision, do not genuinely intend to stay in Australia temporarilyPart 2 of Direction No. 69 - DirectionsAssessing the genuine temporary entrant criterion1.Decision makers should not use the factors specified in this Direction as a checklist. The listed factors are intended only to guide decision makers when considering the applicant’s circumstances as a whole, in reaching a finding about whether the applicant satisfies the genuine temporary entrant criterion.2.Decision makers should assess whether, on balance, the genuine temporary entrant criterion is satisfied, by:a.considering the applicant against all factors specified in this Direction; andb.considering any other relevant information provided by the applicant (or information otherwise available to the decision maker).3.Decision makers may request additional information and/or further evidence from the applicant to demonstrate that they are a genuine temporary entrant, where closer scrutiny of the applicant's circumstances is considered appropriate.4.Circumstances where further scrutiny may be appropriate include but are not limited to:a.information in statistical, intelligence and analysis reports on migration fraud and immigration compliance compiled by the department indicates the need for further scrutiny;b.the applicant or a relative of the applicant has an immigration history of reasonable concern;c.the applicant intends to study in a field unrelated to their previous studies or employment; andd.apparent inconsistencies in information provided by the applicant in their Student visa application.5.An application for a Student visa or a Student Guardian visa should be refused if, after weighing up the applicant’s circumstances, immigration history and any other relevant matter, the decision maker is not satisfied that the applicant genuinely intends a temporary stay in Australia.The applicant’s circumstances6.Decision makers should have regard to the applicant’s circumstances in their home country and the applicant’s potential circumstances in Australia.7.For primary applicants of Subclass 500 Student visas, decision makers should have regard to the value of the course to the applicant’s future.8.Weight should be placed on an applicant’s circumstances that indicate that the Student visa or Student Guardian visa is intended primarily for maintaining residence in Australia.The applicant’s circumstances in their home country9.When considering the applicant’s circumstances in their home country, decision makers should have regard to the following factors:a.whether the applicant has reasonable reasons for not undertaking the study in their home country or region if a similar course is already available there. Decision makers should allow for any reasonable motives established by the applicant;b.the extent of the applicant’s personal ties to their home country (for example family, community and employment) and whether those circumstances would serve as a significant incentive to return to their home country;c.economic circumstances of the applicant that would present as a significant incentive for the applicant not to return to their home country. These circumstances may include consideration of the applicant’s circumstances relative to the home country and to Australia;d.military service commitments that would present as a significant incentive for the applicant not to return to their home country; ande.political and civil unrest in the applicant’s home country. This includes situations of a nature that may induce the applicant to apply for a Student visa or Student Guardian visa as means of obtaining entry to Australia for the purpose of remaining indefinitely. Decision makers should be aware of the changing circumstances in the applicant’s home country and the influence these may have on an applicant’s motivations for applying for a Student visa or a Student Guardian visa.10.Decision makers may have regard to the applicant’s circumstances in their home country relative to the circumstances of others in that country.The applicant’s potential circumstances in Australia11.In considering the applicant’s potential circumstances in Australia, decision makers should have regard to the following factors:a.The applicant’s ties with Australia which would present as a strong incentive to remain in Australia. This may include family and community ties;b.evidence that the student visa programme is being used to circumvent the intentions of the migration programme;c.whether the Student visa or Student Guardian visa is being used to maintain ongoing residence;dwhether the primary and secondary applicant(s) have entered into a relationship of concern for a successful Student visa outcome. Where a decision maker determines that an applicant and dependant have contrived their relationship for a successful Student visa outcomes, the decision maker may find that both applicants do not satisfy the genuine temporary entrant criterion; ande.the applicant’s knowledge of living in Australia and their intended course of study and the associated education provider; including previous study and qualifications, what is a realistic level of knowledge an applicant is expected to know and the level of research the applicant has undertaken into their proposed course of study and living arrangements.Value of the course to the applicant’s future12.Decision makers should have regard to the following factors when considering the value of the course to the applicant’s future:a.whether the student is seeking to undertake a course that is consistent with their current level of education and whether the course will assist the applicant to obtain employment or improve employment prospects in their home country. Decision makers should allow for reasonable changes to career or study pathways; andb.relevance of the course to the student’s past or proposed future employment either in their home country or a third country; andc.remuneration the applicant could expect to receive in the home country or a third country, compared with Australia, using the qualifications to be gained from the proposed course of study.The applicant's immigration history13.An applicant’s immigration history refers both to their visa and travel history.14.When considering the applicant’s immigration history, decision makers should have regard to the following factors:a.Previous visa applications for Australia or other countries, including:i.if the applicant previously applied for an Australian temporary or permanent visa, whether those visa applications are yet to be finally determined (within the meaning of subsection 5(9) of the Act), were granted, or grounds on which the application(s) were refused; andii.if the applicant has previously applied for visa(s) to other countries, whether the applicant was refused a visa and the circumstances that led to visa refusal.b.Previous travels to Australia or other countries, including:i.if the applicant previously travelled to Australia, whether they complied with the conditions of their visa and left before their visa ceased, and if not, were there circumstances beyond their control;ii.whether the applicant previously held a visa that was cancelled or considered for cancellation, and the associated circumstances;iii.the amount of time the applicant has spent in Australia and whether the Student visa or Student Guardian visa may be used primarily for maintaining ongoing residence, including whether the applicant has undertaken a series of short, inexpensive courses, or has been onshore for some time without successfully completing a qualification; andiv.if the applicant has travelled to countries other than Australia, whether they complied with the migration laws of that country and the circumstances around any non-complianceIf the applicant is a minor— the intentions of a parent, legal guardian or spouse of the applicant15.If the primary or secondary applicant for a Subclass 500 Student visa is a minor, decision makers should have regard to the intentions of a parent, legal guardian or spouse of the applicant.Any other relevant matters16.Decision makers should also have regard to any other relevant information provided by the applicant (or information otherwise available to the decision maker) when assessing the applicant’s intention to temporarily stay in Australia. This includes information that may be either beneficial or unfavourable to the applicant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established