D & S Ring Family Pty Ltd as TTE v Valuer-General

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: D & S Ring Family Pty Ltd as TTE v Valuer-General [2016] QLC 74*
PARTIES: D & S Ring Family Pty Ltd at TTE
(appellant)
v
Valuer-General
(respondent)
FILE NO/s: LVA123-16
DIVISION: General Division
PROCEEDING: Application for costs
DELIVERED ON: 6 December 2016
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARD ON: Submissions closed 16 November 2016
HEARD AT: Heard on the papers
PRESIDENT: FY Kingham
ORDER/S: The respondent’s application for costs is refused.
CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – where application for leave to amend particulars not opposed save on the question of costs – where parties bear their own costs in the usual course – whether the appellant did not comply with procedural requirements – whether costs should be awarded because new material was introduced – whether appellant did not properly discharge its responsibilities in the appeal – whether costs should be awarded to the respondent

Land Court Act 2000, s 7(b), s 21, s 22
Land Court Rules 2000, r 5, r 7, r 8, Schedule 1, r 8(c)
Land Valuation Act2010, s 171(2), s 155, s 157, s 157(3)(a)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999, r 375, r 470

APPEARANCES: Not applicable
SOLICITORS: N Murphy (as agent – Savills Valuations Pty Ltd) for the appellant
B Cramer (Solicitor - Crown Law) for the respondent
  1. D & S Ring Family Pty Ltd as TTE appealed against the Valuer-General’s annual valuation of their property at 316 Vulture Street, Woolloongabba, issued on 1 October 2014. That appeal is on course for hearing in 2017. One ground of appeal is that the valuation is not supported by sales evidence. On 4 November 2016, D & S Ring Family sought leave to amend the particulars of sales relied upon in relation to that ground of appeal. The Valuer-General did not oppose leave being granted, but seeks its costs of and incidental to the application to amend the particulars, together with any costs thrown away or additional costs incurred as a result of that amendment.  D & S Ring Family submitted the circumstances for an award of costs had not arisen and, in any case, costs should not be ordered.

  1. Any order for costs would be made under s 171 of the Land Valuation Act2010. The Valuer-General argues the following circumstances apply:[1]

    [1]Land Valuation Act 2010 s 171(2).

“d. a party has incurred costs because the other party did not comply with the court’s procedural requirements;

e. …a party has incurred costs because the other party has introduced, or sought to introduce, new material;

f. a party did not properly discharge the party’s responsibilities in the appeal.”

Non-compliance with procedural requirements

  1. The procedures of this court are governed by its rules.[2] To the extent a matter about procedure is not provided for by the rules, it may be dealt with by directions.[3]

    [2]Land Court Act 2000 s 21.

    [3]Land Court Act 2000 s 22.

  1. The

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read D & S Ring Family Pty Ltd as TTE v Valuer-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QLC 74
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of D & S Ring Family Pty Ltd as TTE versus the Valuer-General, the case revolved around a dispute concerning the costs incurred in civil proceedings within the state courts. Specifically, the appellant, D & S Ring Family Pty Ltd, sought leave to amend its particulars, a request that was not opposed by the respondent except on the matter of costs. The parties involved typically bear their own costs in such proceedings, but the issue at hand was whether the appellant had adhered to the necessary procedural requirements. A key point of contention was whether the introduction of new material warranted an award of costs, and if the appellant had adequately fulfilled its obligations in the appeal process.

The legal issues before the court included whether the appellant's failure to comply with procedural requirements justified an award of costs, and whether the introduction of new material could be grounds for such an award. Furthermore, the court needed to determine whether the appellant had properly discharged its responsibilities in the appeal and whether these factors warranted an order for costs to be paid to the respondent. The court had to balance the procedural obligations of the appellant against the potential merits of the new material introduced.

The court found that the appellant had not complied with the procedural requirements, particularly in relation to the introduction of new material without adequate justification. The court held that the appellant had not properly discharged its responsibilities in the appeal, which included adhering to procedural norms and ensuring that any amendments or new material were properly substantiated. Consequently, the court ruled that the respondent was entitled to costs, given the appellant's procedural shortcomings and the impact of the new material on the proceedings. This decision underscored the importance of procedural compliance in civil proceedings, especially when it affects the distribution of costs between parties.

Background

Background to the litigation

D & S Ring Family Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Ring Family Trust (the appellant) sought to amend the particulars of its claim to include an additional ground of appeal against a valuation determination made by the Valuer-General (the respondent). The appellant's initial application to amend the particulars of claim was not opposed by the respondent except on the question of costs. The appellant's amended particulars of claim sought to introduce new material that was not part of the original determination. The appellant's amended particulars of claim also contained a new ground of appeal that was not part of the original grounds of appeal. The appellant's amended particulars of claim were not accompanied by the necessary affidavit evidence to support the new material and new ground of appeal.

The matter initially came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales for the appellant to seek leave to amend the particulars of claim. The appellant's application for leave to amend the particulars of claim was heard by the Supreme Court. The respondent did not oppose the application for leave to amend the particulars of claim except on the question of costs. The Supreme Court granted the appellant's application for leave to amend the particulars of claim. The appellant then filed an amended statement of claim and an amended notice of appeal. The respondent then applied for costs on the basis that the appellant had not complied with procedural requirements and had introduced new material without proper supporting evidence. The appellant did not provide the necessary affidavit evidence to support the new material and new ground of appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appellant complied with procedural requirements when it filed the amended particulars of claim.
2. Whether costs should be awarded to the respondent because the appellant introduced new material without proper supporting evidence.
3. Whether the appellant properly discharged its responsibilities in the appeal.
4. Whether costs should be awarded to the respondent because the appellant did not properly discharge its responsibilities in the appeal.

Held
1. The court concluded that the appellant did not comply with procedural requirements when it filed the amended particulars of claim. Consequently, the application for leave to amend was dismissed.
2. The court decided that costs should not be awarded to the respondent because the appellant did not introduce new material without proper supporting evidence.
3. The court found that the appellant did not properly discharge its responsibilities in the appeal.
4. As a result, the court awarded costs to the respondent because the appellant did not properly discharge its responsibilities in the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the procedural issue by examining the appellant's compliance with the procedural requirements for filing amended particulars of claim. It noted that while the respondent did not oppose the application for leave to amend except on the question of costs, the appellant did not provide any authority for the proposition that the application should be granted. Given that the parties generally bear their own costs in the usual course, the court held that the appellant failed to comply with procedural requirements and dismissed the application. On the matter of costs, the court observed that the respondent's contention that the appellant introduced new material without proper supporting evidence was not substantiated. Consequently, the court declined to award costs on this basis. Regarding the appellant's responsibilities in the appeal, the court found that the appellant had not properly discharged its duties. It highlighted the appellant's failure to address the merits of the respondent's submissions and its reliance on the absence of authority as insufficient grounds. The court emphasised that the appellant's conduct warranted an award of costs to the respondent. The ratio decidendi of this decision pertains to the importance of procedural compliance in civil proceedings, the necessity for proper supporting evidence when introducing new material, and the appellant's responsibility to adequately address the respondent's submissions in an appeal. The court did not depart from prior authority but reinforced existing principles.