D'Arcy v Caltex Australia Limited (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

D’Arcy v Caltex Australia Limited (No 3)

Citation:

[2018] ACTSC 307

Hearing Date:

30 August 2018

DecisionDate:

9 November 2018

Before:

Burns J

Decision:

See [22]

Catchwords:

COSTS – Application for special costs order – Calderbank offer made by defendant to plaintiff prior to trial proceedings – Rules Offer of Compromise made by defendant to plaintiff prior to trial proceedings – offers rejected by plaintiff – Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 1012 – whether first defendant is entitled to a special costs order

Legislation Cited:

Court Procedures Act 2004 (ACT) s 5A

Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) rr 1002(5)(b), 1012, 1701, 1721, 1752

Cases Cited:

D’Arcy v Caltex Australia Petroleum Pty Ltd [2016] ACTSC 270

D’Arcy v Caltex Australia Limited [2018] ACTSC 206
D’Arcy v Caltex Australia Limited (No 2) [2018] ACTSC 306

Forge v Rewers (No 2) [2017] ACTSC 273

Parties:

Phillip Raymond D’Arcy (Plaintiff)

Caltex Australia Limited (ACN 004 201 307) (First Defendant)

Representation:

Counsel

Mr L Grey (Plaintiff)

Mr J Gracie (First Defendant)

Solicitors

Sneddon Hall and Gallop Lawyers (Plaintiff)

Colin Biggers & Paisley Lawyers (First Defendant)

File Number:

SC 263 of 2014

BURNS J

  1. On 3 August 2018 I published reasons for entering judgment for the first defendant (Caltex) against the plaintiff (D’Arcy v Caltex Australia Limited [2018] ACTSC 206). It subsequently became necessary to revise my orders and reasons, chiefly in regard to the plaintiff’s case against the second defendant (Fuel-Sys). I have today, 9 November 2018, published my revised judgment, including final orders with regard to the plaintiff’s case against both Caltex and Fuel-Sys (D’Arcy v Caltex Australia Limited (No 2) [2018] ACTSC 306).

  1. Caltex seeks an order that the plaintiff is to pay its costs of the proceedings up to and including 21 February 2015 on a party and party basis, and thereafter on an indemnity basis (the primary submission). In the alternative, Caltex seeks an order that the plaintiff pay its costs of the proceedings up to and including 8 April 2017 on a party and party basis and thereafter on an indemnity basis.

  1. The basis of Caltex’s submissions is that on two occasions prior to the trial of the proceedings in April 2017 Caltex made compromise offers to the plaintiff. The first such offer it described as a Calderbank offer, and the second as a Rules Offer of Compromise. The plaintiff did not accept either of the offers, and the judgment for Caltex against the plaintiff, Caltex submitted, was a substantially better result for Caltex than was available in the event the plaintiff had compromised the proceedings by acceptance of either of the offers.

The Calderbank offer

  1. The offer described by Caltex as a Calderbank offer was contained in a letter dated 23 December 2014 from the lawyers for Caltex to the plaintiff’s lawyers. The letter was marked “Without prejudice, save as to costs”. The letter read, relevantly for present purposes:

We are instructed to inform…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read D'Arcy v Caltex Australia Limited (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ACTSC 307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of D'Arcy v Caltex Australia Limited (No 3) involved the plaintiff, D'Arcy, who brought proceedings against Caltex, the defendant, regarding certain contractual obligations and liability concerning a service station site. The dispute centred around whether Caltex was an occupier of the site and responsible for the maintenance of underground fuel tanks. A significant aspect of the case was the consideration of a Calderbank offer made by Caltex to D'Arcy prior to the trial, which was ultimately rejected by D'Arcy.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Caltex was entitled to a special costs order under the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 1012. This rule provides that if a defendant makes an offer that is not accepted by the plaintiff and the defendant subsequently obtains a judgment no less favourable than the terms of the offer, the defendant is entitled to an order for costs against the plaintiff. D'Arcy argued that the Calderbank offer was made too late and that there was insufficient evidence at the time to support Caltex's position. Additionally, D'Arcy contended that it only became aware of Caltex's specific allegations concerning Evangelista's role in appointing Fuel-Sys for the tank relining work in late 2015, which influenced its decision to apply to join Evangelista as a party.

The court considered the timing and content of the Calderbank offer, as well as the subsequent evidence that became available. It was noted that the offer was made approximately six months after the commencement of the proceedings, and that D'Arcy had limited documentation regarding liability at that time. By the time the offer was extended, D'Arcy had obtained the sublease between Evangelista and Caltex, which clearly indicated Caltex's role as an occupier and its sole responsibility for the maintenance of the underground fuel tanks. Despite this, D'Arcy rejected the offer and maintained its stance that Caltex was not an occupier and that it was Evangelista who was responsible for the tank relining work. The court found that Caltex was entitled to a special costs order under r 1012 as it had obtained a judgment no less favourable than the terms of the offer.

ORDERS:
Caltex was granted a special costs order under Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 1012, with specific directions regarding the assessment of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [22]

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The relevant provisions of the Rules are:1012 Offer not accepted and judgment no less favourable to defendant (1) This rule applies if the offer is made by the defendant, but not accepted by the plaintiff, and the defendant obtains an order or judgment on the claim no less favourable to the defendant than the terms of the offer. (2) Unless the court orders otherwise— (a) the defendant is entitled to an order against the plaintiff for the defendant’s costs in relation to the claim, to be assessed on a party and party basis, up to the time when the defendant is entitled to costs under paragraph (b); and (b) the defendant is entitled to an order against the plaintiff for the defendant’s costs in relation to the claim, assessed on a solicitor and client basis— (i) if the offer was made before the first day of the trial—on and from the day after the offer was made; and(ii) if the offer was made on or after the first day of the trial— at and from 11 am on the day after the offer was made. …1701 Costs—general provisions (1) The costs that the court may award— (a) may be awarded at any stage of a proceeding or after the proceeding ends; and (b) must be assessed in accordance with this part. (2) If the court awards the costs of an application in a proceeding, it may order that the costs not be assessed until the proceeding ends. …1721 Costs—general rule (1) The costs of a proceeding or of an application in a proceeding are in the discretion of the court. (2) The costs of the proceeding include the costs of an application in the proceeding, unless the court otherwise orders. …1752 Costs—assessed on solicitor and client etc basis (1) The court may order costs to be assessed— (a) on a solicitor and client basis; or (b) on an indemnity basis; or (c) on any other basis it considers appropriate. The plaintiff submitted that no special costs order should be made in favour of Caltex, and that he should simply be required to pay its costs on a party and party basis. With regard to the Calderbank offer, the plaintiff noted that it was made approximately six months after the commencement of the proceedings, at which time documentation relating to liability in the possession of the plaintiff was rudimentary. I will observe at this point that this was accepted by counsel for Caltex. This offer was ultimately extended for acceptance until 21 February 2015. By approximately 15 January 2015 the plaintiff had access to the sublease between Evangelista and Caltex which demonstrated that Caltex was an occupier of the service station site, and showed that contractual responsibility for repairs and maintenance of the underground fuel tanks lay solely with Caltex. The sublease, the plaintiff said, clearly demonstrated that Caltex’s statement in its letter of 23 December 2014 that it was not an occupier of the service station site was incorrect. Subsequent perusal of the Star Franchise Agreement, which was obtained later in 2015, did not provide any basis for altering the plaintiff’s view that Caltex was an occupier of the service station premises. The plaintiff submitted that it only became aware in late 2015 that Caltex was alleging that Evangelista had been responsible for actually appointing Fuel-Sys to do the work on the underground fuel tanks. It was this allegation, the plaintiff said, that prompted an application to join Evangelista as a party. This application was heard by Mossop AsJ (as his Honour then was) and refused on 16 September 2016: D’Arcy v Caltex Australia Petroleum Pty Ltd [2016] ACTSC 270. In the course of his reasons Mossop AsJ said that WorkSafe documents produced to the plaintiff on 9 February 2015 provided a substantial amount of evidence that Evangelista was the party that contracted with Fuel-Sys for the tank relining work. His Honour set out a list of documents referred to in the WorkSafe report which provided an evidentiary basis for the proposition that Evangelista had contracted with Fuel‑Sys to undertake the relining work.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.