CXQY and Director-General of Security

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

[2013] AATA 895

Division SECURITY APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/2920

Re

CXQY

APPLICANT

And

Director-General of Security

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Justice D Kerr, President
Mr RP Handley, Deputy President
Ms JL Redfern, Senior Member

Date 16 December 2013
Place Sydney

Decision Summary:

The Respondent’s decision to issue an adverse security assessment in respect of the Applicant is affirmed.

........................................................................

NOTE
Pursuant to s 35AA of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal has directed that the publication of the name of the applicant be prohibited. Publication of matter identifying the applicant may be an offence.

Section 63(5) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 provides the following:

Contempt of the Tribunal

A person is guilty of an offence if:

(a)    the person engages in conduct; and

(b)   the person’s conduct would, if the Tribunal were a court of record, constitute a contempt of that court.

Penalty: 30 penalty units or imprisonment for 6 months, or both.

Catchwords

National security – adverse security assessment – refusal of Minister to approve applicant becoming an Australian citizen – whether applicant directly or indirectly a threat to security – what constitutes politically motivated violence

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 39A, 39B, 43AAA

Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 ss 4, 17(1), 35(1), 37

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 s 24

Cases

Re BLBS and Director-General of Security (2012) 129 ALD 380

Chan Yee Kin v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 169 CLR 379

Comcare v Martinez [2013] FCA 439

DPP (Cth) v Fattal [2013] VSCA 276

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Anochie (2012) 299 ALR 280

Secondary Materials

Security Assessment Determination No 2, 28 July 2010

REASONS FOR DECISION

Justice D Kerr, President
Mr RP Handley, Deputy President
Ms JL Redfern, Senior Member

  1. CXQY (the Applicant) has applied for a review of an adverse security assessment made by the Director-General of Security of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) (the Respondent) who assessed that CXQY holds an extremist interpretation of Islam and is likely to engage in activities prejudicial to security. The Director-General assessed that CXQY is therefore directly or indirectly a risk to security and advised that the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship must not approve his application for Australian citizenship.

    Background

  2. [redacted].

  3. In 2011, CXQY applied for Australian citizenship. His file was referred to ASIO for a security assessment and interviews with him were conducted by two ASIO officers on 1 November 2011 and on 9 December 2011. CXQY voluntarily attended the interviews. He was not, however, informed that he could choose not to attend and nor was he informed that he could be accompanied by his lawyer at the interviews. At the second interview, the ASIO officers told CXQY that he was being dishonest and evasive, particularly when discussing his associations. Notes of the interviews prepared by ASIO and a copy of the transcripts of the interviews were included in the documents provided to the Tribunal.

  4. On 21 May 2012, the Director-General made an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CXQY and Director-General of Security and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 895
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

CXQY applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for a review of an adverse security assessment made by the Director-General of Security of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO). The Director-General assessed that CXQY holds an extremist interpretation of Islam and is likely to engage in activities prejudicial to security, making him a risk to security. The Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, advised by ASIO, must not approve his application for Australian citizenship. CXQY argued that the ASIO officers did not properly inform him of his rights during the interviews, and that the assessment was not supported by the evidence. The tribunal was required to determine whether the Director-General's decision was lawful and whether the assessment was supported by sufficient evidence.

The tribunal considered the evidence presented by ASIO, including closed evidence that could not be disclosed to CXQY due to Ministerial certificates. The tribunal noted that CXQY was not properly informed of his rights during the interviews, but found that this did not affect the outcome of the case due to the weight of the closed evidence. The tribunal also considered the definition of extremism provided by ASIO, which includes the acceptance of violence to achieve ideological ends, including religious objectives. The tribunal found that the Director-General's assessment was supported by the evidence, and affirmed the decision to issue an adverse security assessment in respect of CXQY.

The tribunal's decision was based on the evidence presented by ASIO, including the closed evidence that could not be disclosed to CXQY. The tribunal found that the Director-General's assessment was supported by sufficient evidence, and that the assessment was lawful. The tribunal also noted its concern that CXQY was not properly informed of his rights during the interviews, but found that this did not affect the outcome of the case. The tribunal affirmed the Director-General's decision to issue an adverse security assessment in respect of CXQY, and the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship must not approve his application for Australian citizenship.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

CXQY (the Applicant) has applied for a review of an adverse security assessment made by the Director-General of Security of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) (the Respondent) who assessed that CXQY holds an extremist interpretation of Islam and is likely to engage in activities prejudicial to security. The Director-General assessed that CXQY is therefore directly or indirectly a risk to security and advised that the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship must not approve his application for Australian citizenship.Background [redacted]. In 2011, CXQY applied for Australian citizenship. His file was referred to ASIO for a security assessment and interviews with him were conducted by two ASIO officers on 1 November 2011 and on 9 December 2011. CXQY voluntarily attended the interviews. He was not, however, informed that he could choose not to attend and nor was he informed that he could be accompanied by his lawyer at the interviews. At the second interview, the ASIO officers told CXQY that he was being dishonest and evasive, particularly when discussing his associations. Notes of the interviews prepared by ASIO and a copy of the transcripts of the interviews were included in the documents provided to the Tribunal. On 21 May 2012, the Director-General made an assessment that CXQY “is a direct or indirect risk to security” within the meaning of s 4 of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (the ASIO Act) for the purposes of s 24(4) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007. Section 24(4) provides relevantly that the Minister must not approve the person becoming an Australian citizen at a time when an adverse security assessment is in force under the ASIO Act that the person is directly or indirectly a risk to security within the meaning of s 4 of that Act. The “open” version of the Statement of Grounds for this assessment states that “ASIO assesses [CXQY] holds an extremist interpretation of Islam and is likely to engage in activities prejudicial to security”. On 10 July 2012, CXQY applied to the Tribunal for a review of the Director-General’s decision. RELEVANT LAW AND ISSUES Pursuant to s 17(1) of the ASIO Act, the functions of ASIO include:(c)to advise Ministers and authorities of the Commonwealth in respect of matters relating to security, in so far as those matters are relevant to their functions and responsibilities. Section 37(1) states:The functions of the Organisation referred to in paragraph 17(1)(c) include the furnishing to Commonwealth agencies of security assessments relevant to their functions and responsibilities. Section 37(2) requires that an adverse or qualified security assessment be accompanied by a statement of grounds for the assessment. Section 4 defines “security” as meaning:(a) the protection of, and of the people of, the Commonwealth and the several States and Territories from: (i) espionage; (ii) sabotage; (iii) politically motivated violence; (iv) promotion of communal violence; (v) attacks on Australia's defence system; or (vi) acts of foreign interference; whether directed from, or committed within, Australia or not; and (aa) the protection of Australia's territorial and border integrity from serious threats; and (b) the carrying out of Australia's responsibilities to any foreign country in relation to a matter mentioned in any of the subparagraphs of paragraph (a) or the matter mentioned in paragraph (aa).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The procedure governing the conduct of the Tribunal’s review is that stipulated in s 39A and s 39B of the AAT Act.[1] Section 43AAA(2) provides that upon the conclusion of this review, the Tribunal must make and record its findings in relation to the security assessment, and those findings may state the Tribunal’s opinion as to the correctness of, or justification for, any opinion, advice or information contained in the assessment. However, s 43AAA(3) provides that the Tribunal must not make findings in relation to an assessment that would have the effect of superseding any information taken to be part of the assessment unless, in the Tribunal’s opinion, the information is incorrect, incorrectly represented or could not reasonably be relevant to the requirements of security. [1] See for example, Re BLBS and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade (2012) 129 ALD 380, at [43ff].ASIO’S UNCLASSIFIED EVIDENCE Under the pseudonym of Lachlan Sawyer, a senior ASIO officer with responsibility for managing the Branch within ASIO responsible for the security intelligence investigation and assessment of CXQY, provided an open affidavit dated 20 December 2012 and a later closed affidavit and gave evidence at the hearing both in open and closed sessions. Mr Sawyer said he has relevant postgraduate qualifications, has lived in the Middle East for extensive periods, and his training has included a study of different religions. He also has resources available to him to reference particular religious issues. Mr Sawyer’s closed affidavit and much of the evidence relied upon by the Respondent is the subject of Ministerial certificates issued pursuant to s 39A(8) of the AAT Act and, therefore, was not disclosed to the Applicant and may not be disclosed in this Statement of Reasons. Non-disclosure to the Applicant made Mr Martin’s task of cross-examining Mr Sawyer and presenting a case for the Applicant a very difficult one. In relation to Mr Sawyer’s evidence, conscious of those difficulties, the Tribunal invited Mr Martin to identify any questions to which the Applicant sought an answer, but which would be subject to the Ministerial certificates. The Tribunal undertook to put any such questions to Mr Sawyer in closed session. It did so. Mr Sawyer stated that ASIO assesses that CXQY holds an extreme interpretation of Islam:ASIO considers that extremism is an acceptance of violence to achieve ideological ends, including religious objectives. Extremism is different to fundamentalism, which is considered a strict adherence to the tenets of a belief system. Of itself, fundamentalism is not of security concern. The core attribute of extremism, on the other hand, is to cross from fundamentalism to a belief in the legitimacy of violence. Mr Sawyer said it is the condoning and encouraging of violence to achieve religious objectives which tips fundamentalism into extremism. ASIO is concerned about extremism which condones politically motivated violence. Mr Sawyer stated that ASIO assessed that CXQY was dishonest and evasive particularly when discussing his associates at the first and second interviews. His answers to questions contain lies, deceits and misleading information. CXQY’s conduct at the interviews is a “factor” taken into account by ASIO in making its assessment. Mr Sawyer stated that CXQY has maintained associations with persons who are of security concern to ASIO, in particular, [Mr A] and [Mr B], and ASIO assesses that CXQY shares their view that violence is an acceptable means of achieving political and religious ends. ASIO assesses that if CXQY were to be granted Australian citizenship, he is likely to engage in activities prejudicial to security.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, the Tribunal wishes to record its concern that prior to attending the two interviews, CXQY appears to have been informed that if he wanted to be granted citizenship participating in the interviews ASIO conducted was compulsory. If so, there appears to have been no lawful basis for that assertion. We also note CXQY was not advised that he could be accompanied to the interviews by another person, including a lawyer. While DIAC rather than ASIO may have made the arrangements for CXQY’s initial interview he should not have been misinformed about his rights. However, it is unnecessary to consider the matter further. Even had we decided to disregard the evidence from the interviews, it could not have changed our decision because of the weight of the closed evidence presented to us by the respondent. DECISION The Director-General’s decision to issue an adverse security assessment in respect of CXQY is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.