Cutbush v Scenic Rim Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Cutbush v Scenic Rim Regional Council [2019] QCAT 80

PARTIES:

PAUL CUTBUSH
(applicant)

v

SCENIC RIM REGIONAL COUNCIL

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR325-17

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

28 March 2019

HEARING DATE:

8 October 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Gordon

ORDERS:

1.   All outstanding applications of a procedural nature are refused.

2.   In the application for a review of the decision about the dog, the decision made by Scenic Rim Regional Council on internal review on 27 November 2017 to confirm the concurrent regulated dog declaration and destruction order and combined information notice made on 6 November 2017, is confirmed.

3. There shall be a stay of the destruction order for 28 days from the date of this final decision. The stay is conditional upon the owner of the dog and a responsible person for the dog ensuring that the requirements under schedule 1, section 3, of the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 (Qld) are complied with for the dog the subject of the declaration.

4.   The non-publication order made by the tribunal on 11 May 2018 as varied by the order of
10 September 2018 is continued for a period of 3 years from the date of this final decision except that the non-publication order is varied to permit the publication of details of documents and evidence before the tribunal and identification of persons in so far as recited in the published reasons for the decision, and* information which enables the identification of Paul Cutbush and Scenic Rim Regional Council.

* corrected on 27 May 2019 pursuant to s 135 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009

5.    

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – concurrent regulated dog declaration and destruction order following seizure of the dog  – where dog attacked and bit people on three different occasions – where owner shows no acceptance of the events, remorse or insight – where owner shows disrespect for the processes of animal management – whether further risk of noncompliance identified – whether ‘last resort’ test is the correct one to apply – whether right to confirm destruction order

ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – concurrent regulated dog declaration and destruction order following seizure of the dog – where entry to premises not by warrant or with consent but using additional powers of entry under section 112 of the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 (Qld) and in compliance with section 122 of that Act – meaning of ‘place’ in those sections – whether entry and seizure was lawful

ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – provision of evidence to parties and to the tribunal – whether such evidence needs to be ‘sealed’

Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 (Qld) s 3, s 4, s 59, s 89, s 94, s 95, s 107, s 112, s 122,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cutbush v Scenic Rim Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCAT 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Cutbush v Scenic Rim Regional Council was heard in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The central dispute involved a regulated dog declaration and destruction order issued by the Scenic Rim Regional Council against Mr. Cutbush, following incidents where his dog attacked and bit people. The legal issues before the court were whether the seizure of the dog was lawful, the applicability of the 'last resort' test, and whether the right to confirm the destruction order existed. Additionally, procedural issues were raised concerning the provision of evidence to the parties and the tribunal, including whether such evidence needed to be 'sealed'.

The tribunal addressed the procedural matters first, noting that Mr. Cutbush had repeatedly complained about not receiving sealed evidence, which he believed meant he had not received it at all. The tribunal clarified that there was no requirement for evidentiary material to be sealed under the QCAT Rules. Instead, section 21 of the QCAT Act mandates that decision-makers provide relevant documents to the tribunal within a reasonable period, but there is no requirement for these documents to be filed or sealed. Despite this, as a matter of procedural fairness, the tribunal should provide such material to the applicant.

The tribunal also considered Mr. Cutbush's numerous applications throughout the proceedings, both formal and informal, and managed them according to the tribunal's rules and aims of conducting proceedings in an informal manner and acting with minimal formality and technicality. Given the volume and frequency of Mr. Cutbush's correspondence, the tribunal reserved many matters for final decision to manage the case efficiently.

The tribunal confirmed the decision of the Scenic Rim Regional Council to issue the concurrent regulated dog declaration and destruction order, subject to a 28-day stay conditional on compliance with specific requirements. The non-publication order was also continued for three years with certain variations.

In summary, the tribunal confirmed the original decision of the Scenic Rim Regional Council while addressing the procedural concerns raised by Mr. Cutbush. The final orders confirmed the destruction order with a conditional stay, continued the non-publication order with specified variations, and refused all outstanding procedural applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. All outstanding applications of a procedural nature are refused.

2. In the application for a review of the decision about the dog, the decision made by Scenic Rim Regional Council on internal review on 27 November 2017 to confirm the concurrent regulated dog declaration and destruction order and combined information notice made on 6 November 2017, is confirmed.

3. There shall be a stay of the destruction order for 28 days from the date of this final decision. The stay is conditional upon the owner of the dog and a responsible person for the dog ensuring that the requirements under schedule 1, section 3, of the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 (Qld) are complied with for the dog the subject of the declaration.

4. The non-publication order made by the tribunal on 11 May 2018 as varied by the order of

10 September 2018 is continued for a period of 3 years from the date of this final decision except that the non-publication order is varied to permit the publication of details of documents and evidence before the tribunal and identification of persons in so far as recited in the published reasons for the decision, and* information which enables the identification of Paul Cutbush and Scenic Rim Regional Council.

* corrected on 27 May 2019 pursuant to s 135 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Some of the points made are about procedural matters including whether Mr Cutbush has had a fair hearing, which if valid could affect the way I should deal with this final decision. I ought to deal with those points now. Allegation about not having received any of the evidence This was one of the points made by Mr Cutbush in his email of 5 October 2018 and it has since been repeated in numerous emails, applications and submissions. What happened was that at some point Mr Cutbush discovered that under the QCAT Rules, applications and documents are filed in the tribunal when they are sealed. From that time he has complained that the Council’s evidential material submitted to him had not been sealed. Hence he says, they were not given to him at all. On 4 December 2018 Mr Cutbush brought contempt proceedings in the tribunal against the Council and its Mayor and against two of the solicitors who had been handling the case for the Council and also the barrister instructed in the review of the decision about the dog.[7] Those proceedings are still current. In those proceedings he claims (amongst other things) that they are in contempt by failing to serve him with the material as ordered by the tribunal and in proceeding to a hearing on 8 October 2018. [7]These contempt proceedings were also brought against two of the Council’s witnesses who gave evidence in the review of the decision about the dog and against two other lawyers. The truth of this matter is that none of the evidentiary material in this case needed to be sealed by the tribunal. The rules governing filing of documents in the tribunal are in Part 4 of the QCAT Rules.[8] It is clear from these rules and from the QCAT Act itself that the act of ‘filing’ is required only for applications and certain other formal documents. Section 33 requires that applications for the tribunal to deal with a matter are ‘filed’. Section 73 requires that objections to a person who has presided over a compulsory conference hearing the matter are filed. Sections 85 and 86 permit the filing of written terms of settlement in the tribunal. Section 143 requires filing of appeals and applications for leave to appeal. There is no provision requiring evidentiary material to be ‘filed’. It is clear from the Rules that filing in the tribunal is a formal act which entails the principal registrar recording the document and stamping it with the tribunal’s seal.[9] Since the principal registrar may refuse to do this on various grounds,[10] it has been held that it requires some consideration and processing of the document which is to be filed, rather than simply receiving it and placing it on the tribunal file.[11][8]Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 (Qld).[9]Rule 31.[10]As for which, see rule 32 and also section 35 of the Act.[11]Perryman v The Commissioner of State Revenue [2016] QCAT 26. In reviews of a reviewable decision like this matter, the decision-maker is required by section 21 of the QCAT Act to provide to the tribunal within a reasonable period of not more than 28 days after being given a copy of the application for the review, a written statement of the reasons for the decision and any document or thing in the decision-maker’s possession or control that may be relevant to the tribunal’s review of the decision.[12] Section 21 does not require that material to be ‘filed’ in the registry. Instead, section 21 requires such material to be ‘provided to’ the tribunal. There is nothing in the tribunal rules which requires section 21 material to be given to the applicant for a review, but as a matter of procedural fairness this of course should happen.[13][12]Section 21(2).[13]Rule 35 of the QCAT rules requires copies of filed documents to be given to the other parties but as explained above this does not apply to section 21 documents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

After a series of interlocutory orders and directions, the matter was listed before me for a two day hearing starting on Monday 8 October 2018. The hearing followed an unusual course. When considering the likelihood of compliance with the requirements of the dangerous dog provisions (as an alternative to the destruction order) I will need to explain this in more detail. For the moment, I need only to explain that despite being ordered by the tribunal to attend the hearing, Mr Cutbush did not do so. Instead, during the hearing he sent a number of emails to the tribunal containing his arguments and material. This largely duplicated material already before the tribunal but some of it was new. Since the hearing he has submitted more material. I confirm that I have accepted in evidence all the material given to the tribunal by Mr Cutbush at any time and in any form, and have taken it and all his submissions into account.Other matters before me for this final decision Quite apart from the central issue before me about the future of the dog, there are a number of other matters which I will be dealing with in this final decision. These have come about because Mr Cutbush made numerous applications throughout the proceedings both before and after the hearing – some formal (on approved forms) and some informal (in emails). The option of ignoring any application which is not on an approved form may not always be open to the tribunal. This is because the tribunal should ensure that proceedings are conducted in an informal way[1] and because the tribunal must act with as little formality and technicality and with as much speed as the requirements of the QCAT Act or the rules and a proper consideration of the matters before the tribunal permit.[2] In addition to these requirements, the tribunal may waive compliance with the procedural requirements of the QCAT Act or the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 (Qld) (Rules).[3] And in a case like this one, where a party has caused damage to his own case by not attending a hearing when he was ordered to do so, any way in which that damage can be reduced should as a matter of procedural fairness be considered.[1]Section 4(c) of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act).[2]Section 28(3)(d) of the QCAT Act.[3]Section 61(1)(c) of the QCAT Act. Although in the usual case the tribunal’s aims and rules referred to above generally work well, in the case of Mr Cutbush, due to the volume and frequency of correspondence from him, managing this matter in an efficient way became a problem for the tribunal. The tribunal’s resources were being used well beyond the norm for cases of this sort. In an attempt to minimise these difficulties, many matters have been reserved to this final decision. Only applications which warranted attention prior to this final decision about the dog have been dealt with. The applications from Mr Cutbush formally decided prior to this final decision can be divided into three categories: those dealt with before the hearing, those dealt with at the hearing, and those dealt with after the hearing.Applications dealt with before the hearing listed for 8 and 9 October 2018(a)Application dated 25 September 2018 to attend the hearing on 8 October 2018 by telephone. After receiving submissions from the parties on 4 October 2018 about this, on Friday 5 October 2018 (in the ‘first 5 October 2018 order’) Member Kanowski refused this application and required Mr Cutbush to attend in person. The directions did however, permit his witness Mrs Cutbush, and possibly another witness to give evidence at the hearing by telephone.(b)Application dated 27 September 2018 for the hearing to be postponed for 6 months. The grounds were relied on were various, but the main suggestion was that this would allow the dog in question to be assessed by an independent animal behavioural specialist. After receiving submissions from the parties on 4 October 2018 about this, in the first 5 October 2018 order Member Kanowski refused this application and directed that the hearing was to proceed as scheduled.(c)Application dated 2 October 2018 for the hearing to proceed as a hearing on the papers. After receiving submissions from the parties on 4 October 2018 about this, in the first 5 October 2018 order Member Kanowski refused this application and directed that the hearing was to proceed as scheduled. (d)In the first 5 October 2018 order, four applications made by Mr Cutbush were postponed to be dealt with at the hearing. They were an application that the hearing be conducted as a closed hearing, an application concerning non-publication, an order seeking production of certain items from the Council’s witnesses, and for the exclusion of the evidence of the Council’s expert Dr Day.(e)Mr Cutbush had made other formal and informal applications prior to 5 October 2018. All these were referred to Member Kanowski but none were successful and they were refused in the first 5 October 2018 order.(f)The tribunal emailed the first 5 October 2018 order to Mr Cutbush at 11.43am on Friday 5 October 2018.(g)After receiving the first 5 October 2018 order, in an email sent to the tribunal at 3.40pm Mr Cutbush sought again to get the hearing postponed. The grounds relied on appeared to be the same as before, with the possible addition that he wished to seek legal representation. That email was referred to Member Kanowski who made an order later that day confirming that the hearing on the following Monday would proceed (the ‘second 5 October 2018 order’). This order was sent to Mr Cutbush that day and received by him. The order also said that the applications made by Mr Cutbush in his email sent at 3.40pm on 5 October 2018 would be considered at the commencement of the hearing on 8 October 2018.(h)Mr Cutbush requested written reasons for the second 5 October 2018 order and these were provided by Member Kanowski and published at Cutbush v Scenic Rim Regional Council (No. 3) [2018] QCAT 350. In doing so, Member Kanowski also provided some reasoning for his order made earlier on 5 October 2018 in applications covering the same ground.Applications dealt with at the hearing(a)On the morning of 8 October 2018 when the hearing commenced before me, Mr Cutbush did not appear. Bearing in mind his applications to postpone the hearing, for the hearing to be conducted ‘on the papers’, and to attend by telephone had been refused, and that he had been directed to attend the hearing in person, it was inappropriate for the tribunal to telephone him. Instead, for reasons given orally at the hearing, I made a decision to proceed in his absence.(b)I also dealt with the matters listed in the first 5 October 2018 as reserved to me to be dealt with at the hearing, and various other matters arising from the emails from Mr Cutbush, giving oral reasons for my decision on those matters.The oral reasons given on that day are available to Mr Cutbush.Applications dealt with since the hearing(a)Applications for extension of time to provide written final submissions in the review of the decision about the dog, granted on 9 November 2018, 20 November 2018 and 11 February 2019. (b)Application to reopen the proceedings filed on 13 November 2018. This application was given file number RE019-18. Directions were given on 21 November 2018. Both parties filed submissions in respect of this application and a final decision refusing this application was made on 11 February 2019.(c)Application for an interim order seeking an order for daily family and pet visitation and exercise rights to the dog pursuant to ‘section 129 of the Animal Management Act 2008’ and ‘Chapter 3 p 1 s 17 of the Animal Protection Act 2001’. A final decision refusing this application was made on 11 February 2019. This was made on the grounds that the tribunal has no jurisdiction to make such an order.(d)Applications from both sides for contempt. These applications have been referred to the President.