Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Cushman & Wakefield (NSW) Pty Ltd v Farrell (No 2) [2017] NSWCA 62 Hearing dates: On the papers Decision date: 29 March 2017 Before: Macfarlan JA; Ward JA; Emmett AJA Decision: 1. The respondent (being the plaintiff in the Court below) pay the appellant/defendant’s costs of and incidental to the amended statement of claim on the ordinary basis (but for the avoidance of doubt not any costs of the cross-claim in the Court below).
2. The respondent pay 80% of the appellant’s costs of the appeal on the ordinary basis up to and including 7 October 2016 and on the indemnity basis thereafter.
3. The respondent pay to the appellant:
(a) the amount of $226,755.72, which was paid by the appellant to the respondent’s nominated account on or about 19 October 2016, plus interest upon that amount calculated in accordance with section 100 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) for the period from 19 October 2016 until the date of repayment; and
(b) the amount of $241,158.71, which was paid by the appellant to the trust account of the respondent’s solicitors on or about 19 October 2016, plus any interest accruing upon that amount while in the respondent’s solicitors trust account for the period from 19 October 2016 until the date of repayment and, in relation to any of that money which has been disbursed out of the respondent’s solicitors trust account to the respondent, interest upon that amount calculated in accordance with section 100 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) from the date of disbursement to the respondent until the date of repayment.
4. Each party pay its own costs of the submissions made in relation to consequential orders following the judgment handed down on 24 February 2017 in this Court.Catchwords: COSTS – general rule – costs should follow the event – whether unjust for unsuccessful respondent to bear costs of proceedings where court reaches conclusion on basis of reasoning not on all fours with argument run at first instance
COSTS – indemnity costs – Calderbank offer in first instance proceedings – where rejection or non-acceptance of offer not unreasonable – offer of compromise in relation to appeal – element of compromise in relation to costs – overall, offer comprised in offer of compromise no less favourable to appellant than outcome of appeal
COSTS – interest on moneys paid to respondent in respect of judgment at first instance – case more closely approximates one where claim for pre-judgment interestLegislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 100
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), rr 42.14, 51.48Cases Cited: Cushman & Wakefield (NSW) Pty Ltd v Farrell [2017] NSWCA 24
Heydon v NRMA Ltd (No 2) (2001) 53 NSWLR 600; [2001] NSWCA 445
Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] NSWCA 425
Secure Parking Pty Ltd v Woollahra Municipal Council (No 2) [2017] NSWCA 51Category: Costs Parties:
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cushman and Wakefield (NSW) Pty Ltd v Farrell (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NSWCA 62
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal was required to determine the appropriate orders for costs in both the appeal and the proceedings at first instance. Specifically, the court considered whether the general rule that costs follow the event should apply, and whether it would be unjust for the unsuccessful respondent to bear the costs of the proceedings given the court's reasoning. The court also had to consider the impact of a Calderbank offer made in the first instance proceedings and an offer of compromise made in relation to the appeal, particularly in relation to the award of indemnity costs. Finally, the court addressed the issue of interest on moneys paid by the appellant to the respondent in respect of the judgment at first instance.
The Court of Appeal ordered that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of and incidental to the amended statement of claim on the ordinary basis, excluding costs of the cross-claim. Regarding the appeal, the respondent was ordered to pay 80% of the appellant's costs on the ordinary basis up to a specified date, and on the indemnity basis thereafter. The court found that the offer of compromise in relation to the appeal was no less favourable to the appellant than the outcome of the appeal, and that the rejection of the Calderbank offer in the first instance proceedings was not unreasonable. The court also ordered the respondent to pay the appellant specific sums paid by the appellant to the respondent and its solicitors, with interest calculated in accordance with section 100 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW). Each party was ordered to bear its own costs of submissions made in relation to consequential orders.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The respondent (being the plaintiff in the Court below) pay the appellant/defendant’s costs of and incidental to the amended statement of claim on the ordinary basis (but for the avoidance of doubt not any costs of the cross-claim in the Court below).
2. The respondent pay 80% of the appellant’s costs of the appeal on the ordinary basis up to and including 7 October 2016 and on the indemnity basis thereafter.
3. The respondent pay to the appellant:
(a) the amount of $226,755.72, which was paid by the appellant to the respondent’s nominated account on or about 19 October 2016, plus interest upon that amount calculated in accordance with section 100 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) for the period from 19 October 2016 until the date of repayment; and
(b) the amount of $241,158.71, which was paid by the appellant to the trust account of the respondent’s solicitors on or about 19 October 2016, plus any interest accruing upon that amount while in the respondent’s solicitors trust account for the period from 19 October 2016 until the date of repayment and, in relation to any of that money which has been disbursed out of the respondent’s solicitors trust account to the respondent, interest upon that amount calculated in accordance with section 100 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) from the date of disbursement to the respondent until the date of repayment.
4. Each party pay its own costs of the submissions made in relation to consequential orders following the judgment handed down on 24 February 2017 in this Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appeal process saw further developments, including an offer of compromise in relation to the appeal made by Cushman and Wakefield. This offer also included terms about costs, which Farrell did not accept. The Court of Appeal ultimately found in favour of Cushman and Wakefield, leading to the current case note concerning the costs associated with both the initial proceedings and the appeal. The appeal court examined the principle that costs should generally follow the event and considered whether it would be unjust for Farrell, the unsuccessful respondent, to bear the costs of the proceedings given the reasoning of the Court of Appeal differed from the initial Supreme Court decision.
Additionally, the case involved the repayment of monies paid by Cushman and Wakefield to Farrell’s nominated account and trust account following the initial judgment. The Court of Appeal determined that these payments should be repaid with interest, calculated in accordance with the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW). The Court also ruled on the distribution of costs for the submissions made in relation to consequential orders following the February 2017 judgment.
The case of Cushman and Wakefield (NSW) Pty Ltd v Farrell (No 2) came before the court as an appeal from a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal was lodged by the appellant, Cushman and Wakefield (NSW) Pty Ltd, against the judgment given by the respondent, Farrell, in the Supreme Court. The proceedings at first instance involved a claim for costs and other consequential orders arising from a previous litigation where the respondent was successful. The Supreme Court had ordered the appellant to pay certain costs and interest to the respondent, which led to the appellant appealing the decision on the grounds of costs and the basis of the judgment.
In the first instance, the respondent had made a Calderbank offer to settle the proceedings, which the appellant rejected. On appeal, the respondent again made an offer of compromise, which included terms relating to costs. The Court of Appeal considered the reasonableness of the rejection of the Calderbank offer and the subsequent offer of compromise in determining the costs order. The appeal was heard on the basis of written submissions and oral arguments, with the Court of Appeal delivering its judgment on 24 February 2017. Following the judgment, further submissions were made regarding the consequential orders, which were dealt with separately in the final orders made by the Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether it is unjust for the unsuccessful respondent to bear the costs of the proceedings when the court reaches a conclusion based on reasoning that differs from the arguments presented at the first instance.
2. Whether the rejection or non-acceptance of a Calderbank offer in the first instance proceedings was unreasonable, considering the offer of compromise in relation to the appeal.
3. Whether the overall offer comprised in the offer of compromise is no less favourable to the appellant than the outcome of the appeal, taking into account the element of compromise in relation to costs.
4. Whether the case more closely approximates one where a claim for pre-judgment interest should be made on the moneys paid to the respondent in respect of the judgment at the first instance.
Held
1. The court held that it is not unjust for the unsuccessful respondent to bear the costs of the proceedings when the court reaches a conclusion based on reasoning that differs from the arguments presented at the first instance. The result was that the respondent was to pay the appellant’s costs of the amended statement of claim on the ordinary basis.
2. The court held that the rejection or non-acceptance of a Calderbank offer in the first instance proceedings was not unreasonable, considering the offer of compromise in relation to the appeal. The outcome was that the respondent was to pay 80% of the appellant’s costs of the appeal on the ordinary basis up to a certain date and on the indemnity basis thereafter.
3. The court held that the overall offer comprised in the offer of compromise is no less favourable to the appellant than the outcome of the appeal, taking into account the element of compromise in relation to costs. The appellant was to be repaid certain amounts with interest as stipulated in the order.
4. The court held that the case more closely approximates one where a claim for pre-judgment interest should be made on the moneys paid to the respondent in respect of the judgment at the first instance. The respondent was to repay the appellant certain amounts with interest as per the specified terms.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court addressed the issue of whether it was unjust for the unsuccessful respondent to bear the costs of the proceedings, given that the court reached a conclusion based on reasoning that differed from the arguments presented at the first instance. The court emphasised the general rule that costs should follow the event, but it acknowledged that there are exceptions where it may be unjust for the losing party to bear the costs. The court considered that in this case, while the reasoning used to reach the conclusion differed from the arguments presented at the first instance, the result was not significantly different. The court concluded that it was not unjust for the respondent to bear the costs of the proceedings, as the overall outcome did not deviate substantially from what was argued at the initial level.
In assessing whether the rejection or non-acceptance of a Calderbank offer in the first instance proceedings was unreasonable, the court noted that the offer was made in relation to the appeal. The court examined the nature of the offer and whether its rejection was justified given the circumstances. The court determined that the rejection or non-acceptance was not unreasonable, considering the broader context of the litigation and the subsequent developments in the appeal. The court relied on established principles regarding Calderbank offers and the discretion of the court in determining the reasonableness of such offers in the context of the case.
The court evaluated whether the overall offer comprised in the offer of compromise was no less favourable to the appellant than the outcome of the appeal, taking into account the element of compromise in relation to costs. The court considered both the substantive and procedural aspects of the compromise, including the financial implications and the relative success of each party. The court concluded that the offer of compromise, when viewed in its entirety, was no less favourable to the appellant than the outcome of the appeal. This conclusion was based on a detailed analysis of the terms of the offer and the costs associated with the proceedings, ultimately finding that the compromise was a fair and reasonable settlement.
Finally, the court addressed the issue of whether the case more closely approximated one where a claim for pre-judgment interest should be made on the moneys paid to the respondent in respect of the judgment at the first instance. The court examined the principles governing pre-judgment interest and the specific circumstances of the payment. The court found that the case was more aligned with scenarios where pre-judgment interest is applicable, given the nature of the payments and the timing of the events. The court ordered the repayment of the amounts paid, along with interest calculated in accordance with the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), reflecting the appropriate treatment of these payments in light of the overall outcome of the litigation.