Curtis v Hallett Cove Manager Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

CURTIS v HALLETT COVE MANAGER PTY LTD

[2016] SASC 47

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Doyle

6 April 2016

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

The respondent sued the appellant in the District Court. Those proceedings were resolved by entry into a heads of agreement which required that the appellant pay the respondent a number of weekly instalments, or in default of those payments being made, the sum of $40,000.

The appellant did not pay, and the respondent brought proceedings in the Magistrates Court seeking payment of the $40,000. A Magistrate entered summary judgment in favour of the respondent. The Magistrate gave no reasons for his decision.

The appellant appealed on the grounds that the Magistrate erred in finding that the heads of agreement was properly executed and erred in failing to find that the respondent had acted unconscionably.

Held (per Doyle J), dismissing the appeal:

1.       The appellant has not established any defence in fact or law which has reasonable prospects of success.

2.       Although the Magistrate erred in failing to give reasons, the order for summary judgment was appropriate.

Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules 2013 (SA) r 103(1), r 8, referred to.
Kadeh v Gill (2000) 211 LSJS 88; Papps v Police (2000) 77 SASR 210; R v Keyte (2000) 78 SASR 68; Ceneavenue Pty Ltd v Martin (2008) 106 SASR 1; Estate of the Late Sir Donald Bradman v Allens Arthur Robinson (2010) 107 SASR 1, considered.

CURTIS v HALLETT COVE MANAGER PTY LTD
[2016] SASC 47

Magistrates Appeal: Civil

DOYLE J:

  1. The respondent sued the appellant in the District Court.  Those proceedings were resolved by entry into a heads of agreement which required that the appellant pay the respondent a number of weekly instalments, or in default of those payments being made, the sum of $40,000.

  2. The appellant did not pay, and the respondent brought proceedings in the Magistrates Court seeking payment of the $40,000.  By orders made on 2 December 2015, a Magistrate entered summary judgment in favour of the respondent for $40,000 plus costs.

  3. This is an appeal from the Magistrate’s order.

    Background

  4. The respondent is the underlessor of the Hallett Cove Shopping Centre.  In February 2011 the respondent and Our Home Holdings Pty Ltd (the Lessee) entered into a lease (the Lease) in relation to premises located at the Shopping Centre (the Premises).  The appellant agreed to guarantee and indemnify the respondent in respect of the Lessee’s performance of its obligations under the Lease.

  5. The Lessee’s business was unsuccessful, and in early May 2012 the respondent re-entered the Premises and terminated the Lease as a result of the Lessee’s failure to pay rent.  The respondent issued proceedings against the Lessee and the appellant in the District Court, seeking recovery of a debt and damages resulting from the termination of the Lease.  The appellant filed a defence, and the matter…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Curtis v Hallett Cove Manager Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was brought by the appellant, Curtis, against the decision of the respondent, Hallett Cove Manager Pty Ltd, in the Magistrates Court of South Australia. The respondent had issued proceedings against the appellant seeking recovery of a debt of $40,000 under a heads of agreement executed in 2014. The appellant argued that he had been coerced into signing the agreement and that it was not legally binding. The Magistrate dismissed the appeal and granted summary judgment in favour of the respondent. The legal issues before the court were whether the appellant had established any defence which had reasonable prospects of success, and whether the Magistrate erred in not providing reasons for granting summary judgment.

The court held that the appellant had not established any defence which had reasonable prospects of success. The appellant's complaints related to the circumstances surrounding the Lease and guarantee, and not the heads of agreement. The only matters in the defence that directly responded to the claim for $40,000 under the heads of agreement were that the appellant was convinced (bullied) into signing the agreement and that it was signed illegally. The court found that the appellant had not established that he was misled by any particular statement by the respondent or its lawyers at the meeting when the heads of agreement was signed. The court also held that the Magistrate erred in not giving reasons for granting summary judgment, but found that there was little utility in remitting the matter for rehearing in the Magistrates Court.

The court determined that the Magistrates Court had power to enter summary judgment where there is no reasonable basis for the defence. The court found that the defences raised by the appellant were bound to fail and that the prospects of the defence succeeding were merely fanciful rather than realistic. The court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the decision of the Magistrate to grant summary judgment in favour of the respondent. The court granted the appellant permission to rely on the proposed amended grounds of appeal. The court ordered that the appeal be dismissed and that the appellant pay the respondent's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal from the Magistrate’s order.Background The respondent is the underlessor of the Hallett Cove Shopping Centre. In February 2011 the respondent and Our Home Holdings Pty Ltd (the Lessee) entered into a lease (the Lease) in relation to premises located at the Shopping Centre (the Premises). The appellant agreed to guarantee and indemnify the respondent in respect of the Lessee’s performance of its obligations under the Lease. The Lessee’s business was unsuccessful, and in early May 2012 the respondent re-entered the Premises and terminated the Lease as a result of the Lessee’s failure to pay rent. The respondent issued proceedings against the Lessee and the appellant in the District Court, seeking recovery of a debt and damages resulting from the termination of the Lease. The appellant filed a defence, and the matter was set down for a 5 day trial commencing 11 August 2014. In late July, the appellant met with representatives of the respondent at the offices of Cowell Clarke, the solicitors for the respondent. Mr Jamie Watts of Cowell Clarke was present at the meeting. The purpose of the meeting was to attempt to resolve the matters which were the subject of the District Court proceedings. A resolution was reached, taking the form of a document entitled ‘Heads of Agreement’. It was executed by both parties. The agreement required that the appellant pay the respondent $31,200 by way of $200 payments every week for a period of three years commencing 31 January 2015. The agreement provided that in default of those payments being made, the sum of $40,000 (less any sums already paid) would become immediately due and payable by the appellant to the respondent, and that the respondent may apply for summary judgment against the appellant in respect of this sum. On 19 January 2015 the respondent sent the appellant an invoice for the payments. A letter of demand followed on 26 February 2015, but the appellant did not make any of the weekly payments required by the agreement. On 18 March 2015 the respondent issued proceedings in the Magistrates Court seeking judgment for the amount of $40,000 owing under the agreement, plus interest and costs. The appellant filed a defence dated 2 April 2015. The defence raised several complaints relating to the circumstances surrounding the entry into the Lease, and the conduct of the Lessee’s business pursuant to that Lease. It made reference to the appellant being a bankrupt at the time he signed the guarantee, alleging that this was known to Cowell Clarke. It described Cowell Clarke as being his lawyers, as well as the lawyers for the respondent. The only matters in the defence that directly responded to the claim for $40,000 under the heads of agreement were in paragraphs 6 and 7 of the defence:I was convinced (bullied) into believing I had to sign a heads of agreement in 2014 to reduce a notional debt of over $100 thousand dollars and due to me trying to get back on my feet and the young business I was now running as a sole trader was struggling to survive I believed I had no option but to sign this agreement and buy myself time to get the business strong. This did not happen and the business was closed down by the landlord Coles in October 2014.I am now in a position where I would like to defend the original claim completely as it was not meant to be and it was signed illegally.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no other allegation of a relevant misapprehension by the appellant, let alone any allegation that he was misled by any particular statement by the respondent or its lawyers at the July 2014 meeting when the heads of agreement was signed.Conclusion It follows from the above that the appellant has not established any defence in fact or law which has reasonable prospects of success. The matters which he has raised either do not address the heads of agreement, or are bound to fail. While the Magistrate erred in not giving reasons for ordering summary judgment in the respondent’s favour, the order made was the appropriate one. I dismiss the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It emerged during the hearing of the appeal that the respondent had not been provided with a copy of the proposed amended grounds of appeal. However, as there was no formal opposition to the proposed amendments, and because there is significant overlap between the abandoned grounds and the second of the proposed amended grounds, I grant the appellant permission to rely upon these grounds.Consideration As the respondent accepts, and as the Full Court of this Court held in Kadeh v Gill,[1] reasons should ordinarily be given for granting summary judgment after a contested application. The reasons need not be extensive, but they ought to address the main contentions raised and the main grounds for the decision reached.[2] In the absence of reasons, the appeal court’s role becomes more difficult. In the case of the Magistrates Court, the obligation to give reasons for a final judgment after the conclusion of a contested hearing is enshrined in r 103(1) of the Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules 2013 (SA). A summary judgment is a final judgment under those Rules.[1] Kadeh v Gill (2000) 211 LSJS 88; [2000] SASC 367 at [26].[2] Papps v Police (2000) 77 SASR 210; R v Keyte (2000) 78 SASR 68. In my view, the failure to give reasons involved error on the part of the Magistrate. However, I consider there to be little utility in remitting the matter for rehearing in the Magistrates Court. This would be productive merely of delay and cost. As this appeal is by way of rehearing, and because the matter was determined on the papers, it is appropriate that I determine the appropriate outcome. The Magistrates Court has power to enter summary judgment under r 8 where there is “no reasonable basis for the action or defence”. The power to enter summary judgment is to be exercised sparingly. In the case of an application brought by a plaintiff, it requires that the court be satisfied that the defence is bound to fail, or that the prospects of the defence succeeding are merely fanciful rather than realistic.[3] [3] Kadeh v Gill (2000) 211 LSJS 88; [2000] SASC 367 at [29]; Ceneavenue Pty Ltd v Martin (2008) 106 SASR 1; Estate of the Late Sir Donald Bradman v Allens Arthur Robinson (2010) 107 SASR 1. Turning to the matters raised by the appellant as being defences potentially available to him, most of his complaints can be put to one side as being relevant only to the circumstances surrounding the Lease and guarantee, and not impugning the heads of agreement. The respondent’s claim for $40,000 in the Magistrates Court proceedings was for money owing under the heads of agreement, and so only matters responsive to that claim are capable of constituting defences which might stand in the way of summary judgment in favour of the respondent. The first matter raised by the appellant in his amended notice of appeal is his contention that the heads of agreement was not executed in accordance with the Corporations Act. On the hearing of the appeal the appellant explained that his challenge was on the basis that Mr Blunt, who executed the heads of agreement for the respondent, may not have been authorised to do so. This matter was not raised in the appellant’s defence, nor in his affidavits or submissions before the Magistrate. Even putting this problem to one side, I consider that this foreshadowed defence is bound to fail. Mr Blunt is the Chief Executive Officer of the group companies of which the respondent is a member. He attended the meeting in late July on behalf of the respondents. The appellant quite frankly conceded that he had no reason to believe that Mr Blunt was not authorised, and has not adduced any evidence to suggest that he was not authorised. Bearing in mind the seniority of Mr Blunt, and the authority which would usually come with his role, I do not think that this defence has reasonable prospects of success.