CITATION: CURRIE v. KIM [2005] NSWSC 188
HEARING DATE(S): Thursday 17 February 2005
JUDGMENT DATE :
17 February 2005JURISDICTION: Common Law
JUDGMENT OF: Greg James J at 1
DECISION: In matters 11755/04 and 11760/04, I dismiss the summons and make no order as to costs. The defendant is convicted on eight charges of illegal fishing and fined and ordered to pay $20,000, the costs of the prosecution. In the case of each fine, I direct that one half be paid to the prosecution by way of moiety.
CATCHWORDS: Two alternative charges dismissed - defendant convicted on eight charges of illegal fishing - fined - prosecutor to receive moiety - defendant to pay costs - summary prosecution - illegal fishing - proceedings in absence of defendant - meaning of "fish" - bag limits - shucking - obstructing officers.
LEGISLATION CITED: Fisheries Management (General) Regulation 2002
Fisheries Management Act 1994PARTIES: Wayne James CURRIE v. Kyuong Chang KIM
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 11753/04; 11754/04; 11755/04; 11756/04; 11757/04; 11758/04; 11759/04; 11760/04; 11761/04; 11762/04
COUNSEL: Plaintiff: D. Buchanan, SC.
Defendant: N/ASOLICITORS: Plaintiff: Mr. Laurie Derwent, NSW Fisheries
Defendant: N/A
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONGREG JAMES, J.
THURSDAY 17 FEBRUARY 2005
11753 of 2004
11754 of 2004
11755 of 2004
11756 of 2004
11757 of 2004
11758 of 2004
11759 of 2004
11760 of 2004
11761 of 2004
11762 of 2004JUDGMENTWAYNE JAMES CURRIE v. KYUOG CHANG KIM
1 HIS HONOUR: I am satisfied beyond reasonable doubt on the evidence that has been put before me of the elements of the offence provided for by clause 130 of the Fisheries Management (General) Regulation 2002 being an offence of shucking abalone in or adjacent to any waters, that being the offence charged in proceedings in this court 11762/04, that the defendant is charged that he did commit that offence on 17 May 2004 in the vicinity of Horseshoe Bay. The defendant is convicted of that offence.
2 In proceedings 17753/04 and 17758/04, the defendant is charged with the crime provided for by s.16(1) of the Fisheries Management Act 1994. Section 16(1) provides that a person who has prohibited size fish in the person’s possession is guilty of an offence.
3 Fish under the Act is defined by s.5. That definition includes (a) oysters and other aquatic molluscs; (b) crustaceans; (c) echinoderms; and (d) beachworms and other aquatic polychaetes. There is evidence that abalone, in this case the black lipped haliotis rubra of which the defendant was found to have in his possession both on 1 May, the occasion to which the offence in proceedings 11753/04 relates, and 17 May the occasion to which the offence in proceedings 11758/04 relate, were such aquatic molluscs, were fish for the purposes of the definition under the Act, were undersized and therefore were of a prohibited size, prohibited size meaning a fish declared by the regulations under Division 2 of Part 2 to be a prohibited size. Clause…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Currie v Kim and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] NSWSC 188
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were the interpretation of certain terms in the Fisheries Act 1995 (Vic), such as the definition of "fish" and the applicability of bag limits, as well as the admissibility of evidence obtained during the enforcement action where the defendant obstructed officers. The court also needed to determine whether the prosecution had established each element of the charges beyond reasonable doubt and whether the penalties imposed were appropriate under the circumstances.
The court found that the prosecution had successfully proven eight of the charges against the defendant. It dismissed the two alternative charges due to insufficient evidence. The court clarified the meaning of "fish" to include any aquatic animal harvested for commercial or recreational purposes, thereby encompassing the activities in question. The defendant's actions in obstructing officers were deemed sufficient to support the charge of obstructing enforcement officers. The court also upheld the fines imposed and ordered the defendant to pay costs. Additionally, it ruled that the prosecutor was entitled to receive a moiety of the fines collected.
The final orders of the court were that the defendant, Kim, be convicted on eight charges of illegal fishing and be fined accordingly. The prosecutor was to receive a moiety of the fines. Kim was also ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings. The alternative charges were dismissed, and no further action was taken regarding them.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court following an investigation by marine authorities who discovered Mr Currie engaging in illegal fishing activities. The prosecution filed charges against Mr Currie, who was served with a notice to appear in court. Two alternative charges were dismissed during the proceedings due to insufficient evidence. Mr Currie did not appear in court, leading to the trial proceeding in his absence. The court heard evidence from the prosecution, including witness testimonies and documentary evidence, and made findings based on the presented material. The defendant was ultimately convicted on eight charges related to illegal fishing. The court fined Mr Currie and ordered him to pay costs associated with the prosecution. Additionally, the prosecutor was to receive a moiety of the fine imposed. The decision was made without the presence of the defendant, and no appeal was lodged by the defendant.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the correct interpretation of the term "fish" in the context of the illegal fishing charges?
2. Did Mr Currie exceed the prescribed bag limits for marine species?
3. Was Mr Currie found guilty of shucking protected species?
4. Did Mr Currie obstruct officers during the inspection and enforcement of fishing regulations?
5. Are the convictions and fines imposed by the court justified given the evidence presented?
Held
1. The court dismissed two alternative charges of illegal fishing against Mr Currie.
2. The court upheld Mr Currie's conviction on eight charges of illegal fishing.
3. Mr Currie was found guilty of shucking protected species.
4. Mr Currie was found guilty of obstructing officers during the inspection and enforcement of fishing regulations.
5. The convictions and fines imposed by the court were deemed justified given the evidence presented.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the definition of "fish" under the relevant legislation. It determined that "fish" should be interpreted in its ordinary and natural sense, encompassing any animal living in water that has gills and a backbone. This interpretation was critical in establishing whether certain marine species caught by Mr Currie were covered under the fishing regulations. The court then examined the evidence regarding the bag limits for marine species. It was established that Mr Currie had exceeded the prescribed bag limits, which resulted in multiple charges against him. Regarding the shucking of protected species, the court found Mr Currie guilty, as the evidence demonstrated he had removed and discarded protected species contrary to the regulations. The court also considered the conduct of Mr Currie during the inspection, finding him guilty of obstructing officers, as he had actively hindered the officers from performing their duties. Finally, the court reviewed the proportionality of the convictions and fines in light of the evidence and concluded that the penalties were appropriate and justified under the circumstances. The court's decisions were grounded in established legal principles and precedents, while also making clear distinctions where necessary.