Cumaiyi v Jones

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Cumaiyi v Jones [2014] NTSC 36

PARTIES:CUMAIYI, Paul

v

JONES, Timothy

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY EXERCISING APPELLATE JURISDICTION

FILE NO:JA 25 of 2014 (21350609)

DELIVERED:  14 August 2014

HEARING DATES:  12 August 2014

JUDGMENT OF:  RILEY CJ

APPEAL FROM:  J NEILL SM

CATCHWORDS:

Domican v The Queen (1992) 173 CLR 555; Winmar v Western Australia (2007) 35 WAR 159, referred to.

Weapons Control Act 2001 (NT), ss 3, 8.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant:T Moses

Respondent:  D Jones

Solicitors:

Appellant:North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency

Respondent:  Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions

Judgment category classification:    C

Judgment ID Number:  Ril1413

Number of pages:  10

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Cumaiyi v Jones [2014] NTSC 36

No. JA 25 of 2014 (21350609)

BETWEEN:

PAUL CUMAIYI

Appellant

AND:

TIMOTHY JONES

Respondent

CORAM:     RILEY CJ

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 14 August 2014)

  1. On 13 March 2014, in the Court of Summary Jurisdiction, the appellant was found guilty of an offence arising out of events that took place at Wadeye on 9 October 2013. He was initially charged with having taken part in a riot and with having carried an offensive weapon, an axe, with the circumstance of aggravation that the offence occurred at night time. The hearing in relation to the alleged riot did not proceed. There was a hearing in relation to the allegation of carrying an offensive weapon.

  2. The prosecution case relied upon the evidence of Constable Damien Clarke. No other witness was called. At the conclusion of the evidence, the magistrate found the appellant guilty. The appellant was convicted and sentenced to a term of imprisonment of three months.

  3. The appellant has appealed the conviction on two grounds:

    (a)that the magistrate could not be satisfied as to the identification of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt; and

    (b)that the magistrate erred in finding that the axe was an offensive weapon.

    The evidence

  4. The evidence of Constable Clarke was that at about 9pm on 9 October 2013 he was stationed at Wadeye and was off duty. He heard a large disturbance in the community and he contacted Sergeant Rose. The two officers resumed duty to deal with the situation. Over some hours they drove their police vehicle around the community responding to various disturbances. At about 11pm, they drove to the Middle Camp area. Sergeant Rose drove the vehicle and Constable Clarke operated a spotlight from the front passenger seat.

  5. At Middle Camp, Constable Clarke said he saw “30 or 40 young males all armed with what looked like steel bars, axes, rocks. As we have come up to that – that area, the Middle Camp area, they’ve all run away”. He said the people were “running away from the police truck”. The only person Constable Clarke was able to identify was the appellant. He said the appellant ran in front of the police vehicle and was carrying an axe which was described…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cumaiyi v Jones and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NTSC 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Cumaiyi v Jones, Paul Stanley Cumaiyi, the appellant, appealed his conviction on two grounds: first, that the magistrate could not be satisfied as to the identification of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt, and second, that the magistrate erred in finding that the axe was an offensive weapon. The appeal was heard in the Northern Territory Court of Appeal. The central issue was the reliability of the identification made by Constable Clarke and whether the weapon in question constituted an offensive weapon under the Weapons Control Act 2001 (NT).

Constable Clarke testified that he recognised the appellant, who was running away during a disturbance, based on their prior interactions over two and a half years, during which they played football and went crabbing together. Clarke identified the appellant by his distinctive blonde Mohawk haircut, his red football shorts, his shirt hanging over his shoulders, and his large build. Despite the appellant being in motion and the identification occurring at night, Clarke maintained that the lighting conditions were adequate, with the high beam of the police vehicle and a handheld spotlight directed at the appellant. The appellant contested the identification, arguing that the conditions were not conducive to a reliable identification, but the court found that Constable Clarke's familiarity with the appellant over an extended period lent credibility to his identification.

Regarding the second issue, the court had to determine whether the prosecution established that the axe was an offensive weapon as defined in the Weapons Control Act 2001 (NT). The court found that the context of the night's events, which included riotous disturbances, supported the conclusion that the weapon was intended for causing injury or fear of injury. Given the presence of a large group armed with various weapons and the appellant's possession of an axe during these disturbances, the court held that the prosecution had sufficiently demonstrated the weapon's offensive nature. The court dismissed the appeal on both grounds, affirming the magistrate's findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The appellant has appealed the conviction on two grounds:(a)that the magistrate could not be satisfied as to the identification of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt; and(b)that the magistrate erred in finding that the axe was an offensive weapon.The evidence The evidence of Constable Clarke was that at about 9pm on 9 October 2013 he was stationed at Wadeye and was off duty. He heard a large disturbance in the community and he contacted Sergeant Rose. The two officers resumed duty to deal with the situation. Over some hours they drove their police vehicle around the community responding to various disturbances. At about 11pm, they drove to the Middle Camp area. Sergeant Rose drove the vehicle and Constable Clarke operated a spotlight from the front passenger seat. At Middle Camp, Constable Clarke said he saw “30 or 40 young males all armed with what looked like steel bars, axes, rocks. As we have come up to that – that area, the Middle Camp area, they’ve all run away”. He said the people were “running away from the police truck”. The only person Constable Clarke was able to identify was the appellant. He said the appellant ran in front of the police vehicle and was carrying an axe which was described as a “small tomahawk axe” a bit less than half a metre in length. The appellant ran behind one of the houses. The evidence of Constable Clarke was that the person he identified as the appellant:(a)had a bleached blonde Mohawk haircut;(b)was wearing red football shorts;(c)had a shirt hanging over his shoulders; and(d)was a “bigger fellow”. In cross-examination, Constable Clarke agreed that the identification of the appellant took place at about 11pm and when it was dark. However he said the lights of the police vehicle were on high beam and he also operated a hand-held spotlight which he shone on the appellant. The appellant was running and was in the light for “maybe 10 seconds”. The appellant was lifting his T-shirt up apparently seeking to hide his face. Constable Clarke was about 10 metres away from him and he was running away. When Constable Clarke first saw the appellant he noticed his face and then, as he was running away, his back was turned to the Constable. Constable Clarke agreed that he noticed the distinctive blonde haired Mohawk. He agreed that there were a number of people in Wadeye who had blonde hair cut in a similar style. He also noticed the large build of the person. In his evidence in chief, Constable Clarke said of the appellant “I know him, he is Paul Stanley Cumaiyi” and, a little later, “Yeah I have known him for the whole time I’ve been out here”. When challenged in cross-examination as to the identification of the appellant Constable Clarke responded, “No, I know Paul Stanley, he is the man I saw”. Paul Stanley is a name by which the appellant is known. The Constable later said in cross-examination “I know him, I’ve known him for the long time I have been out here”. In re-examination Constable Clarke gave evidence that he recognised the appellant. He said:I observed that it was him. I’ve known him for the last two and a half years I’ve been out here, I have played footy with him, gone out (inaudible) with him, crabbing, stuff like that. … I recognised him, yes.The findings – identity

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondent submitted that the magistrate was entitled to be satisfied as to the identification of the appellant to the requisite standard. Attention was drawn to the fact that Constable Clarke had been stationed at Wadeye for two and a half years and had known the appellant for that period. He had played football with him and gone crabbing with him “and stuff like that” during that period. He knew where the appellant lived. He had a long and familiar relationship with the appellant in a small community. On the night, he recognised the appellant who was wearing red football shorts, had a blonde Mohawk hairstyle which stood out and was carrying an axe. Contrary to the submission of the appellant the lighting was good, consisting of the police headlights which were on high beam assisted by a hand-held spotlight which Constable Clarke shone on the appellant. He provided a description of the movements of the appellant. He made appropriate concessions in cross-examination including that other people in Wadeye sported a similar hair colour and style. Nevertheless, he was firm in his identification of the appellant.Conclusions – identification In my opinion, error on the part of the magistrate has not been demonstrated. There was a sound basis for the conclusion of his Honour that the evidence regarding identification established beyond reasonable doubt the appellant as the alleged offender. Constable Clarke was able to recognise the appellant having interacted with him over a period of some two and a half years. He had played football with him, gone crabbing with him and had other connection with him over that period. Constable Clarke knew sufficient about the appellant to know where he lived. In addition, the appellant had a “distinctive” hairstyle, which his own counsel described as “his signature”, and he also had a particular build which was familiar to the Constable and which assisted in identification. I dismiss this ground of appeal.Offensive weapon The appellant was charged with possession of an offensive weapon. Section 8 of the Weapons Control Act 2001 (NT) provides:(1) A person must not, without lawful excuse, proof of which is on the person, possess, carry or use an offensive weapon. An offensive weapon is defined in s 3 of the Act in the following terms:offensive weapon means an article: (a) made or adapted to cause damage to property or to cause injury or fear of injury to a person; or (b) by which the person having it intends to cause damage to property or to cause injury or fear of injury to a person; but does not include a prohibited weapon, controlled weapon or body armour. It is necessary for the prosecution to establish that the item is an offensive weapon as defined and then the onus shifts to the accused to establish that he or she had a lawful excuse for possessing, carrying or using the weapon. The issue in the present proceedings was whether or not the prosecution had established that the axe was an offensive weapon by which the appellant intended to cause injury or fear of injury to a person. His Honour dealt with the issue in detail. His Honour found the following:(a)there was a series of “riotous disturbances” in Wadeye on that night;(b)Constable Clarke and Sergeant Rose travelled from point of disturbance to point of disturbance over a period of hours;(c)at the relevant point of disturbance at Middle Camp there were 30 to 40 young males armed with steel bars and axes, they dispersed when police arrived; and(d)Constable Clarke identified the appellant as one of the group and he was in possession of an axe.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established