CTA v Queensland Police Service

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

CTA v Queensland Police Service [2018] QCAT 440

PARTIES:

CTA
(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR205-14

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review

DELIVERED ON:

13 December 2018

HEARING DATE:

27 November 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Dr Collier

ORDERS:

The Application is refused.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – when evidence may be excluded – evidence that may be considered under the Weapons Act 1990 (Qld) – evidence that may be considered under the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)

EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – illegally obtained evidence – rules under Bunning v Cross (1978) 141 CLR 54 – rules concerning admissibility in civil matters – whether evidence should be excluded

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 20, s 28, s 28(3), Chapter 2 Part 1 Division 3

Weapons Act 2009 (Qld), s 3, s 10B, s 10B(1), s 29,
s 29(1), s 29(1)(b), s 29(1)(d), s 153, Schedule 2

Bunning v Cross (1978) 141 CLR 54
Polycarpou v Australian Wire Industries Pty Ltd (1995) 36 NSWLR 49
R v Borg [2012] VSC 26
R v Hammond (2016) 258 A Crim R 323

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

M White, instructed by Butler McDermott Lawyers

Respondent:

R Paz Landim, Senior Constable

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Noting that orders were made by the Tribunal on 11 April 2017 in matter APL302-15 prohibiting the publication of the identity of the applicant in certain matters, the Applicant in this decision has been de-identified.

  2. The Applicant’s weapons licence was revoked by the Queensland Police on


    22 May 2014. Following various hearings and appeals dating back to 2015, the Applicant is now waiting for this Tribunal to conduct a review of the original decision of the Respondent to revoke his weapons licence.

  3. The substantive matter has yet to be decided by this Tribunal. The instant issue before the Tribunal is an application by the Applicant for certain material to be excluded from consideration by the Tribunal in its review of the Respondent’s decision. In particular, the Applicant seeks:

    That pages 3 to 43 (inclusive) of the Respondent’s material filed in this proceeding on 5 March 2018 be excluded from consideration by the Tribunal

  4. The Applicant seeks to have the material identified (hereafter, the ‘impugned evidence’) excluded on the basis that it pertains to evidence obtained as a consequence of an unlawful search carried out on his property on 13 July 2017.

  5. Briefly stated, the Queensland Police conducted a search of the Applicant’s property on 13 July 2017 according to the terms of a warrant in the belief that weapons offences were occurring at this property. For reasons to do with carelessness, the warrant relied upon to perform this search, on its face, expired on 12 July 2017.

  6. Notwithstanding the fact that illegal weapons were seized by police during the search, the Applicant was not prosecuted for the apparent offences because of the error…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CTA v Queensland Police Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 440
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of CTA v Queensland Police Service, the dispute arose from the admissibility of evidence obtained through potentially unlawful means under both the Weapons Act 1990 (Qld) and the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld). The applicant, CTA, sought to exclude certain evidence presented by the respondent, Queensland Police Service, on the grounds that it was obtained in an illegal manner. The case was heard by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal, which had to determine whether the evidence should be excluded based on its admissibility under the relevant statutes and legal principles.

The primary legal issues before the tribunal were whether the evidence obtained by the respondent was illegally procured and, if so, whether it should be excluded from consideration. The tribunal had to examine the circumstances under which the evidence was obtained and apply the principles established in Bunning v Cross to determine the admissibility of the evidence. The Bunning v Cross case provided the framework for assessing the admissibility of illegally obtained evidence, taking into account factors such as the nature of the illegality, the cogency of the evidence, and the ease with which the law could have been complied with.

The tribunal considered the principles from Bunning v Cross, which outlined that evidence should generally not be admitted if its procurement involved deliberate or reckless disregard of the law. However, if the illegality arose from a mistake rather than deliberate or reckless conduct, other factors such as the cogency of the evidence and the ease of complying with the law could be taken into account. In this case, the tribunal found that while the respondent argued that the evidence was legally obtained, there was a sufficient basis for the applicant to seek its exclusion. The tribunal concluded that the application should be adjudicated, and no costs order should be made against the applicant.

In summary, the tribunal ruled that the application to exclude the impugned evidence was refused. The tribunal found that there was a sufficient basis for the applicant to seek the exclusion of the evidence, and it was appropriate to adjudicate on the matter without imposing costs on the applicant.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Application is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Based on this survey of the law, the case against admitting the impugned evidence would have to be very strong for this Tribunal to make an interlocutory decision against material being admitted into evidence for consideration by the Tribunal.The curial rules of evidence The principal Australian rules concerning the admissibility of improperly or illegally obtained evidence are expounded in the High Court case of Bunning v Cross (1978) 141 CLR 54. Bunning v Cross involved a question of whether evidence comprising a breath sample for the presence of alcohol, where that evidence had been illegally obtained, should have been excluded by the magistrate in making a decision as to conviction. The judgment of Mason and Aickin JJ, with whom Barwick CJ concurred as to the formulation of the rules, stated them as being:[7]36. If the unlawfulness was merely the result of a perhaps understandably mistaken assessment by the police of the inferences to be drawn from what they observed of the appellant's conduct this must be of significance in any exercise of discretion. Although such errors are not to be encouraged by the courts they are relatively remote from the real evil, a deliberate or reckless disregard of the law by those whose duty it is to enforce it.37. The second matter to be noted is that the nature of the illegality does not in this case affect the cogency of the evidence so obtained. Indeed the situation is unusual in that the evidence, if admitted, is conclusive not of what it demonstrates itself but of guilt of the statutory offence of driving while under the influence of alcohol to an extent rendering him incapable of having proper control of his vehicle.38. To treat cogency of evidence as a factor favouring admission, where the illegality in obtaining it has been either deliberate or reckless, may serve to foster the quite erroneous view that if such evidence be but damning enough that will of itself suffice to atone for the illegality involved in procuring it. For this reason cogency should, generally, be allowed to play no part in the exercise of discretion where the illegality involved in procuring it is intentional or reckless. To this there will no doubt be exceptions: for example where the evidence is both vital to conviction and is of a perishable or evanescent nature, so that if there be any delay in securing it, it will have ceased to exist.39. Where, as here, the illegality arises only from mistake, and is neither deliberate nor reckless, cogency is one of the factors to which regard should be had. It bears upon one of the competing policy considerations, the desirability of bringing wrongdoers to conviction. If other equally cogent evidence, untainted by any illegality, is available to the prosecution at the trial the case for the admission of evidence illegally obtained will be the weaker. This is not such a case, due to the mistaken reliance of the police, when they first intercepted the applicant, upon what they thought to be their powers founded upon …40. A third consideration may in some cases arise, namely the ease with which the law might have been complied with in procuring the evidence in question. A deliberate "cutting of corners" would tend against the admissibility of evidence illegally obtained. However, in the circumstances of the present case, the fact that the appellant was unlawfully required to do what the police could easily have lawfully required him to do, had they troubled to administer an "alcotest" at the roadside, has little significance. There seems no doubt that such a test would have proved positive, thus entitling them to take the appellant to a police station and there undergo a "breathalyzer" test. Although ease of compliance with the law may sometimes be a point against admission of evidence obtained in disregard of the law, the foregoing, together with the fact that the course taken by the police may well have been the result of their understandably mistaken assessment of the condition of the applicant, leads us to conclude that it is here a wholly equivocal factor.41. A fourth and important factor is the nature of the offence charged. While it is not one of the most serious crimes it is one with which Australian legislatures have been much concerned in recent years and the commission of which may place in jeopardy the lives of other users of the highway who quite innocently use it for their lawful purposes. Some examination of the comparative seriousness of the offence and of the unlawful conduct of the law enforcement authority is an element in the process required by Ireland's Case [1970] HCA 21; (1970) 126 CLR 321.42. Finally it is no doubt a consideration that an examination of the legislation suggests that there was a quite deliberate intent on the part of the legislature narrowly to restrict the police in their power to require a motorist to attend a police station and there undergo a "breathalyzer" test. This last factor is, of course, one favouring rejection of the evidence. However it is to be noted that by the terms of s. 66 (1) the legislation places relatively little restraint upon "on the spot" breath testing of motorists by means of an "alcotest" machine. It is essentially the interference with personal liberty involved in being required to attend a police station for breath testing, rather than the breath testing itself (albeit by means of a more sophisticated appliance), that must here enter into the discretionary scales.[7]pp 79, 80; Jacobs J not deciding the point, and Murphy J dissenting.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the Respondent expressed the view that the Applicant had little or no sound basis on which to seek to have the impugned evidence excluded, there is a sufficient basis to accept that the Applicant was entitled to ask that this matter be considered. While I have contemplated reserving the costs in this Application for consideration by the decision-maker of the substantive issue, I conclude that, on balance, the Applicant was entitled to have this matter adjudicated and to make no costs order.Decision The Tribunal makes the following decision in this matter:(a)The Application is refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.