CSR Building Products Limited v James Hardie Technology Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

CSR Building Products Limited v James Hardie Technology Limited [2017] APO 28

Patent Applications:                 2006241323 & 2010246457

Title:Fiber Cement Building Materials with Low Density Additives

Patent Applicant:  James Hardie Technology Limited

Opponent:  CSR Building Products Limited

Delegate:  M. G. Kraefft

Decision Date:  8 June 2017

Hearing Date:  Written submissions completed on 26 May 2017

Catchwords:  PATENTS – section 59 - final determination – amendments overcame defects identified in previous decision – whether amendments introduced new deficiencies - amendments have not introduced new deficiencies – both applications proceed to grant.

Representation:  Patent attorney for the applicant:  Shelston IP.

Patent attorney for the opponent:  Griffith Hack.

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                   2006241323 & 2010246457

Title:Fiber Cement Building Materials with Low Density Additives

Patent Applicant:  James Hardie Technology Limited

Date of Decision:  8 June 2017

DECISION

The amendments to the specifications of applications 2006241323 and 2010246457 have overcome the previously successful ground of opposition of lack of inventive step.

Moreover the amended claims of both specifications are clear and fairly based.  The amendments have not introduced new deficiencies.

Subject to appeal, I direct that both applications proceed to grant.

Costs in accordance with Schedule 8 awarded against the opponent, CSR Building Products Limited.

REASONS FOR DECISION

BACKGROUND

  1. Patent applications 2006241323 and 2010246457 are in the name of James Hardie Technology Limited (“the applicant”).  After examination and acceptance of the applications, BGC (Australia) Pty Ltd and CSR Building Products Limited jointly filed notices of opposition against each of the applications.

  2. In a decision dated 30 May 2016, BGC (Australia) Pty Ltd & CSR Building Products Limited v James Hardie Technology Limited, [2016] APO 31 (“the previous decision”), a delegate found the oppositions against each application were successful on the ground of lack of inventive step. The delegate allowed the applicant an opportunity to amend to overcome the successful ground of opposition.

  3. On 29 July 2016, the applicant filed requests under Section 104 to amend the specifications of each application.  Those requests were both subsequently allowed.

  4. Prior to final determination, the applicant and the second opponent, CSR Building Products Limited (“the opponent”), requested to be heard.  BGC (Australia) Pty Ltd did not wish to be heard.  The hearing was conducted by way of written submissions.

    APPLICABLE LAW

  5. It is well established that the decision of a delegate in opposition proceedings determines the matter finally, subject to appeal (R v Smith (Commissioner of Patents); Ex parte Mole Engineering Pty Ltd, [1981] HCA 25; (1981) 147 CLR 340 at 348-349). There is no scope for the Commissioner to re-open or re-hear matters that had already been determined in the previous decision. Thus, in a final determination the only questions are whether the amendments to the specification overcome the deficiencies identified in the previous decision and whether the amendments introduce any new deficiencies. New deficiencies are grounds of opposition that arise solely from the amendment of the specification. That is, pre-existing deficiencies are excluded (Iluka Midwest Ltd…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CSR Building Products Limited v James Hardie Technology Limi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] APO 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

CSR Building Products Limited opposed patent applications 2006241323 and 2010246457 filed by James Hardie Technology Limited. The applications, relating to fiber cement building materials with low density additives, were opposed on the ground of lack of inventive step. In a previous decision, the delegate found the oppositions against each application were successful on that ground and allowed the applicant to amend the specifications. After the applicant amended the specifications, the delegate conducted a final determination to decide whether the amendments overcame the deficiencies identified in the previous decision and whether the amendments introduced any new deficiencies. The delegate found the amendments overcame the previously successful ground of opposition of lack of inventive step and that the amended claims of both specifications were clear and fairly based. The amendments had not introduced new deficiencies. Subject to appeal, the delegate directed that both applications proceed to grant and awarded costs against the opponent.

The delegate found the amendments overcame the previously successful ground of opposition of lack of inventive step. The composition of the cenospheres in the amended claims was part of the scope of all claims of both applications, and the applicant had overcome this ground of opposition. The opponent submitted the amendments introduced new deficiencies, such that lack of clarity and lack of fair basis arose from the amendments to the specifications. The opponent argued that the use of the term “cenospheres” in the independent claims, while using the broader terms “hollow ceramic microspheres” or “microspheres”, or similar, in the dependent claims, resulted in a variety of terms that did not have a clear, plain and consistent meaning. The delegate found that all the claims of both applications were clear when read in context and as a whole. The opponent's fair basis arguments were also found to be moot. The delegate concluded the claims of both applications were fairly based.

The delegate concluded the applicant’s amendments to both specifications had overcome the previously successful ground of opposition of lack of inventive step. Moreover, the amended claims of both specifications were clear and fairly based, and the amendments had not introduced new deficiencies. Subject to appeal, the delegate directed that both applications proceed to grant and awarded costs against the opponent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established