FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| CSO15 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR | [2017] FCCA 1812 |
| Catchwords: MIGRATION – Application for review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal – protection (Class XA) visa – where Applicant claims the Tribunal erred in its statutory task because it did not deal with the psychologist report – where reference to the psychologist’s report would not have led to a different result – no jurisdictional error – application dismissed. |
| Applicant: | CSO15 |
| First Respondent: | MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION |
| Second Respondent: | ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL |
| File Number: | MLG 2797 of 2015 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Hartnett |
| Hearing date: | 21 April 2017 |
| Delivered at: | Melbourne |
| Delivered on: | 4 August 2017 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicant: | Mr Albert |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | Victoria Legal Aid |
| Counsel for the Respondents: | Mr Hosking |
| Solicitors for the Respondents: | Sparke Helmore Lawyers |
ORDERS
The application is dismissed.
The Applicant is to pay the costs of the First Respondent fixed in the sum of $7,206.00.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT MELBOURNE |
MLG 2797 of 2015
| CSO15 |
Applicant
And
| MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION |
First Respondent
| ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL |
Second Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
By amended application filed 21 April 2017 the Applicant seeks judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) dated 27 November 2015 in which the Tribunal affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant the Applicant a protection (Class XA) visa (‘the visa’).
The grounds of application are as follows:-
“1. The Tribunal erred by failing to consider:
a. the Applicant's claims in respect of the area to which he would return, namely Usterzai Bala, Khyber Paktunkhwa; and/ or
b. an integer of the Applicant's claim, namely that he was at real risk of relevant harm on return to Usterzai Bala, Khyber Paktunkhwa.
2. The Tribunal erred in its statutory task in that it did not 'deal with' the psychologist's report dated 23 June 2015, in particular in respect of the general negative credibility assessment arising from the dates the Applicant said he lived in the Federally Administered Tribal Area as compared with Khyber Paktunkhwa, Pakistan.”
The First Respondent seeks dismissal of the Application and costs.
History
The Applicant is a citizen of Pakistan. He arrived on Christmas Island by boat on 9 June 2012. On 4 January 2013, he applied for a protection visa.
A delegate of the Minister refused that application on 31 March 2014 and on 7 April 2014 he applied to the then Refugee Review Tribunal for review.
The Applicant appeared before the Tribunal to give evidence and present arguments with the assistance of an interpreter in the Pashto and English languages on 10 July 2015. He was represented by a registered migration agent.
The Applicant presented his claims in his protection visa application on 4 January 2013; in a Departmental interview he attended on 25 June 2013; in a detailed submission from his adviser received by the Tribunal on 3 July 2015 to which…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CSO15 v Minister for Immigration and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FCCA 1812
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the Tribunal had erred in law in its assessment of the applicant's claims regarding membership of a particular social group and the risk of persecution. Specifically, the Court was required to consider whether the Tribunal had properly applied the relevant legal principles in determining whether the applicant's asserted social group met the criteria for a "particular social group" as defined under international refugee law and Australian domestic law, and whether the Tribunal had adequately considered the evidence presented by the applicant concerning the real chance of harm.
Judge Hartnett found that the Tribunal had made a jurisdictional error in its assessment of the applicant's claim. The Court reasoned that the Tribunal had failed to adequately engage with the evidence concerning the specific characteristics of the asserted social group and had applied an overly restrictive interpretation of the "particular social group" definition. This failure meant that the Tribunal had not properly considered whether the applicant's fear of persecution was well-founded, thereby vitiating the decision.
Consequently, the Court quashed the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal and remitted the matter to the Tribunal to be heard and determined according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
At the Tribunal hearing, the applicant presented his claims with the assistance of an interpreter in Pashto and English. He was represented by a registered migration agent. The Tribunal accepted that the applicant was a citizen of Pakistan, born in Kalaya in Orakzai Agency. It found, on the basis of independent country information, that Orakzai Agency was in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas and not in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa as claimed by the applicant. The Tribunal found inconsistencies in the applicant’s evidence about his residence in Pakistan which raised concerns about his credibility. The Tribunal accepted that there may have been suicide bombings in the villages where the applicant was living or visiting, but there was no evidence to suggest that he or his family were specifically targeted by the bombings or that he was personally caught up in these events or was affected by them. The Tribunal did not accept the applicant’s evidence that armed and masked Taliban members stopped a bus he was travelling in and threatened to kill him. The Tribunal found that the applicant did not face a real chance of serious harm if he returned to his home area in Kalaya in Orakzai Agency. The Tribunal did not consider whether the applicant was at real risk of harm in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
The Tribunal considered the psychologist’s report dated 23 June 2015. It found that the applicant may have been depressed since he arrived in Australia due to separation from his family and his fiancée, as discussed in the psychologist’s report. However, it was not satisfied that this or the applicant’s intellectual development adequately explained the applicant’s failure to raise significant and personal claims at an earlier stage in the process. The Tribunal did not find many of the claims made by the applicant to be credible. The Tribunal’s reasons are detailed and comprehensive, and it canvassed and carefully weighed and considered a wide range of independent country information.
This case involves an application for judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal). The Applicant, a citizen of Pakistan, originally applied for a protection (Class XA) visa on 4 January 2013 after arriving in Australia by boat. A delegate of the Minister for Immigration refused the application on 31 March 2014, and the Applicant sought a review by the then Refugee Review Tribunal (now known as the Administrative Appeals Tribunal). Following a hearing on 10 July 2015, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision on 27 November 2015. The Applicant filed an amended application for judicial review on 21 April 2017, contending that the Tribunal had erred in its statutory task by not considering certain aspects of his claims and the psychologist’s report. The Tribunal’s decision record shows that it considered the psychologist’s report but did not find it critical to the credibility of the Applicant’s claims. The Tribunal found that the Applicant did not face a real chance of serious harm if he returned to his home area in Kalaya in Orakzai Agency. The First Respondent, the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, seeks dismissal of the application along with costs. The application was heard on 21 April 2017 and the judgment dismissing the application was delivered on 4 August 2017.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Tribunal err by failing to consider whether the Applicant would return to live in Usterzai Bala, Khyber Paktunkhwa, and if so, whether he would face a real risk of harm there?
2. Did the Tribunal err in its statutory task by not adequately "dealing with" the psychologist's report dated 23 June 2015, particularly in respect of the general negative credibility assessment arising from the dates the Applicant said he lived in the Federally Administered Tribal Area as compared with Khyber Paktunkhwa, Pakistan?
Held
1. Did the Tribunal err by failing to consider whether the Applicant would return to live in Usterzai Bala, Khyber Paktunkhwa, and if so, whether he would face a real risk of harm there?
The court concluded that the Tribunal did not err in this regard as the Tribunal made a finding about where the Applicant would return, which was Kalaya village in the Orakzai Agency. The Tribunal's finding was both clearly open to it on the evidence before it, and consistent with the case put by the Applicant to the Tribunal. Therefore, the Tribunal committed no jurisdictional error in respect of this ground.
2. Did the Tribunal err in its statutory task by not adequately "dealing with" the psychologist's report dated 23 June 2015, particularly in respect of the general negative credibility assessment arising from the dates the Applicant said he lived in the Federally Administered Tribal Area as compared with Khyber Paktunkhwa, Pakistan?
The court concluded that the Tribunal did not err in this regard as it referred to the psychologist’s report on several occasions in the Decision Record. The proper inference to draw was that the Tribunal did properly have regard to the report and found it relevant to some issues and not others. There was nothing illogical in the conclusion drawn by the Tribunal on the totality of the evidence before it, which included the psychologist’s report. Therefore, no jurisdictional error was established on the basis of this ground.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court considered the two primary issues raised by the Applicant concerning the Tribunal's decision. The first issue was whether the Tribunal erred by not considering if the Applicant would return to Usterzai Bala, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and if so, whether he would face a real risk of harm there. The Court noted that the Tribunal had explicitly identified the Applicant's "home area" as Kalaya village in the Orakzai Agency, where his family resided. Since the Applicant did not specifically argue that he might return to Usterzai Bala, and this possibility did not emerge from the evidence before the Tribunal, the Court concluded that the Tribunal did not commit a jurisdictional error in this regard. The Tribunal's finding about the Applicant's "home area" was deemed both reasonable and consistent with the Applicant's claims.
The second issue was whether the Tribunal erred in its statutory task by not adequately considering the psychologist's report dated 23 June 2015, particularly regarding the negative credibility assessment arising from the dates the Applicant claimed he lived in the Federally Administered Tribal Area (FATA) compared to Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan. The Court found that the Tribunal had indeed referred to the psychologist's report multiple times in its decision, and it was reasonable to infer that the Tribunal had considered the report in assessing the Applicant's credibility. The psychologist's report was used to explain inconsistencies in the Applicant's evidence rather than to establish his claims. Given that the Tribunal had the benefit of observing the Applicant's demeanour during the hearing, the psychologist's report had limited probative weight. The Court concluded that the Tribunal did not err in its statutory task regarding the psychologist's report, and there was no jurisdictional error in this regard either.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a tribunal does not commit a jurisdictional error by not speculating on a return location not explicitly argued by the Applicant and by considering a psychologist’s report in the context of assessing credibility without it being the sole determinant of the outcome. The Court did not find any error in how the Tribunal approached these issues, and therefore dismissed the application with costs.