Crummer v Jenkinson

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

[2010] QDC 310

DISTRICT COURT
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
JUDGE KOPPENOL
No 165 of 2010

BRADLEY MICHAEL CRUMMER Appellant
and
LEE JAMES JENKINSON Respondent
BRISBANE
..DATE 07/06/2010
ORDER

1-1
HIS HONOUR: This is an appeal against orders made by a

1

Magistrate on 6 January 2010.

On that occasion the appellant was charged with driving without due care and attention, committing a public nuisance and failing to keep a safe distance from the front vehicle.

10

The appellant pleaded not guilty. He was 23 years of age at the time. He conducted his own defence at a summary trial. Ultimately, the Magistrate found that the three offences were proven.

20

The appellant had one prior criminal offence; it was for
entering or being in premises with the intent to commit an
indictable offence and was committed when he was 17. The
appellant also had committed a number of traffic offences, 30
including some low level speeding offences.
The Magistrate found that on the day concerned the appellant's
vehicle and the complainant's vehicle had stopped on a road at
Cannon Hill on their way to the Exhibition. The appellant 40

gave evidence that he was being tailgated by the complainant; the Magistrate did not accept that evidence. There was an off-duty police officer in the complainant's vehicle in addition to an eight year old child and the driver of the vehicle.

50

The Magistrate, having heard all of the evidence, found that the appellant approached the complainant's vehicle in a threatening way, yelled obscenities at the driver of that car

1-2

ORDER

60

1

and there was no justification for his having acted in the way

that he did.

The appellant was ordered to serve four months' imprisonment

with parole after two months. That was for the public 10

nuisance offence, the maximum penalty for which was six months' imprisonment. For the other two charges the appellant was convicted and not further punished.

The appellant served a total of 17 days in actual custody. He 20
was then released on bail pending this appeal. The bail
pending appeal hearing occurred some 19 or 20 weeks ago.
I think that the learned Magistrate regarded this incident as
a road rage incident and acted correctly in that regard. I 30

also have the distinct impression that the Magistrate sentenced the appellant on the basis that these offences were of the nature of an offence of violence.

The Magistrate also noted, correctly in my view, that the 40

appellant had shown no remorse or cooperation with the authorities. It seems that the appellant also had alcohol and anger management issues at the time he committed these offences.

50

Whilst I regard the sentence of four months' imprisonment with parole after two months as quite high, I can perfectly understand the Magistrate's concern to ensure that appropriate

1-3

ORDER

60

1

penalties are imposed to deter road rage incidents.

I'm also of the view that a period of imprisonment could not be said to be outside the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crummer v Jenkinson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QDC 310
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Crummer v Jenkinson, the appellant, Bradley Michael Crummer, appealed against the sentence imposed by the Magistrate. Crummer was charged with driving without due care and attention, committing a public nuisance, and failing to keep a safe distance from the front vehicle. He pleaded not guilty and conducted his own defence at a summary trial, but the Magistrate found him guilty on all counts. The Magistrate sentenced Crummer to four months' imprisonment with parole after two months for the public nuisance offence, and no further punishment for the other two charges. The appeal was heard by Judge Koppenol, who considered whether the sentence was excessive and whether the Magistrate's decision to impose imprisonment was appropriate.

The court had to determine if the sentence was appropriate and if the Magistrate's decision to impose imprisonment was justified. The Magistrate considered the incident as a road rage incident and sentenced Crummer to imprisonment as a deterrent for such offences. The court acknowledged that a period of imprisonment could be an appropriate sentence for this type of offending but found that the four-month sentence with parole after two months was excessive in the circumstances. The court also noted that Crummer had already served 17 days in custody and had been on bail pending appeal for approximately five months.

Judge Koppenol allowed the appeal, revoked the original sentence, and substituted a sentence of 17 days' imprisonment. The court deemed the 17 days already served by Crummer to be time served in respect of the substituted sentence, meaning no further period of actual imprisonment or penalty would be imposed. The court found that while the Magistrate's decision to impose imprisonment was not inappropriate, the four-month sentence was excessive. The court considered a fine to be an appropriate sentence in this case, but ultimately upheld the Magistrate's decision to impose imprisonment. There was no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established