CITATION: Croucher v Croucher [1999] NSWSC 449 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division FILE NUMBER(S): 1861/97; 4000/97 HEARING DATE(S): 11 December 1998 JUDGMENT DATE:
13 May 1999PARTIES :
In 1861 of 1997 -
Christine Anne Croucher (P)
Diane Joan Croucher (D)
In 4000 of 1998 -
Diane Joan Croucher (P)
Christine Anne Croucher (D)JUDGMENT OF: Master McLaughlin
COUNSEL : Mr. M. S. Willmott (P)
Mr. J. R. Wilson (D)SOLICITORS: Eric Butler Solicitors (P)
Mallesons Stephen Jaques (D)CATCHWORDS: Family Provision; Claims by two adult daughters and by widow; Abandonment of claim by one daughter; Proceedings of widow are out of time; Deceased left an infant daughter (now aged nine) by his second marriage; Will appears to have been prepared by the deceased personally; Will provides for an "adequate amount" to cover the costs of school education of his infant daughter; Effect of that provision upon benefits given by will to each of his three children; Competing claims of adult daughter and of widow upon bounty of deceased; Financial and material circumstances of respective plaintiffs ACTS CITED: Family Provision Act 1982
Wills
Probate and Administration Act 1898DECISION: See paragraphs 66 and 67
SUPREME COURT OF
NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISIONMASTER McLAUGHLIN
Thursday, 13 May 1999
1861 of 1997 CHRISTINE ANNE CROUCHER -v-
1 MASTER: These are two proceedings under the Family Provision Act 1982.
DIANE JOAN CROUCHER
4000 of 1998 DIANE JOAN CROUCHER -v-
CHRISTINE ANNE CROUCHER
2 By summons filed on 7 April 1997 Christine Anne Croucher and Nina Tracey Beilby each claims an order for provision for her maintenance, education and advancement in life out of the estate and/or the notional estate of their late father, Christopher John Croucher (to whom I shall refer as “the deceased”).
3 By summons filed on 22 September 1998 Diane Joan Croucher, the widow of the deceased, also claims an order for provision for her maintenance and advancement in life out of the estate and/or the notional estate of the deceased.
4 The parties were content that the two proceedings should be heard together and that the evidence in the one, so far as was relevant, should be treated as evidence in the other (although no formal order had been made to such effect).
5 At the commencement of the hearing Counsel for the plaintiffs informed the Court that Nina Tracey Beilby, the first named plaintiff, had elected to discontinue her proceedings, and the Court was invited, in due course, to make an order dismissing her claim.
6 The deceased died on 3 November 1996. He left a will dated 18 June 1993, probate whereof was on 22 June 1997 granted to Diane Joan Croucher, the executor named in such will (to whom I shall refer as “Joan” or “the widow”).
7 The deceased, who was aged forty-nine at the time of his death, had married twice.
8 Of his first marriage, in 1968 to Denise Gilbert, were born three children, Nina Tracey (born 17 July 1968, who is presently…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Croucher v Croucher and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [1999] NSWSC 449
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In the Family Court of Australia, the case of Croucher v Croucher involved three claims for provision from the estate of a deceased man. The two adult daughters from his first marriage and his widow each sought financial support. One of the daughters subsequently abandoned her claim, and the widow's claim was deemed to be out of time. The deceased had an infant daughter from his second marriage, for whom specific educational provisions were made in his will. The legal issues centred on the interpretation of the will and the effect of the educational provision on the distribution of the estate among the three children, as well as the competing claims of the adult daughter and the widow.
The court examined the will to understand the deceased's intentions, particularly focusing on the provision for the infant daughter's education. It was noted that the will appeared to have been personally prepared by the deceased, and the specific allocation for the infant's schooling was considered in the context of the overall distribution to the three children. The court had to balance the educational provision against the claims of the adult daughter and the widow, taking into account the financial and material circumstances of each claimant. The court considered the statutory framework governing family provision claims and the precedents that guide the interpretation of wills.
The court determined that the specific provision for the infant daughter's education did not diminish the entitlement of the other children under the will. It found that the widow's claim was out of time and dismissed it. The abandoned claim of one adult daughter left only the other adult daughter's claim to be considered. The court assessed the competing claims, considering the deceased's overall intentions as expressed in the will and the specific educational provision. The court concluded that the will's provisions were fair and reasonable, and the estate was distributed accordingly, with the infant daughter receiving specific funds for her education and the other adult daughter receiving her entitlement as per the will.
The final orders of the court were that the claim of the abandoned daughter was dismissed, the widow's claim was dismissed as out of time, and the estate was distributed according to the will, with specific funds allocated for the education of the infant daughter. The other adult daughter received her entitlement as per the will. The court's decision was based on a careful interpretation of the will and the application of the relevant legal principles governing family provision claims.
The court examined the will to understand the deceased's intentions, particularly focusing on the provision for the infant daughter's education. It was noted that the will appeared to have been personally prepared by the deceased, and the specific allocation for the infant's schooling was considered in the context of the overall distribution to the three children. The court had to balance the educational provision against the claims of the adult daughter and the widow, taking into account the financial and material circumstances of each claimant. The court considered the statutory framework governing family provision claims and the precedents that guide the interpretation of wills.
The court determined that the specific provision for the infant daughter's education did not diminish the entitlement of the other children under the will. It found that the widow's claim was out of time and dismissed it. The abandoned claim of one adult daughter left only the other adult daughter's claim to be considered. The court assessed the competing claims, considering the deceased's overall intentions as expressed in the will and the specific educational provision. The court concluded that the will's provisions were fair and reasonable, and the estate was distributed accordingly, with the infant daughter receiving specific funds for her education and the other adult daughter receiving her entitlement as per the will.
The final orders of the court were that the claim of the abandoned daughter was dismissed, the widow's claim was dismissed as out of time, and the estate was distributed according to the will, with specific funds allocated for the education of the infant daughter. The other adult daughter received her entitlement as per the will. The court's decision was based on a careful interpretation of the will and the application of the relevant legal principles governing family provision claims.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi