Set aside by Appeal:
CITATION: Cromwell's Auctioneers & Appraisers Pty Ltd v Commissioner for Fair Trading [2004] NSWADT 281 DIVISION: General Division PARTIES: APPLICANT
Cromwell's Auctioneers & Appraisers Pty Ltd
RESPONDENT
Commissioner for Fair TradingFILE NUMBER: 043008 HEARING DATES: 10/08/2004, 19/08/2004 SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 08/19/2004 DATE OF DECISION:
12/03/2004BEFORE: Montgomery S - Judicial Member APPLICATION: Motor Dealer - grant of licence - Motor Dealers Act - motor dealer - grant of licence MATTER FOR DECISION: Principal matter LEGISLATION CITED: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997
Motor Dealers Act 1974CASES CITED: Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321
Clearihan v Registrar of Motor Vehicle Dealers in the Australian Capital Territory (1994) 122 ACTR 25
Haining v Commissioner of Police, NSW Police Service (1999) NSWADT 6
Hughes and Vale Pty Ltd v New South Wales (No. 2) (1955) 93 CLR 127
McEvoy v Director-General, Department of Fair Trading [2000] NSWLEC 183
Pickles Auctions Pty Ltd v Registrar Consumer Claims Tribunal and Ors, Supreme Court of NSW 9 September 1994 unreported
Raymond Robbins v Business Licensing Authority (2000) VCAT 457
Sobey v Commercial and Private Agents Board 20 SASR 70
Trlin v Commissioner of Fair Trading [2003] NSWADT 222
Young Taek Chong v Tomazin (1994) ASC 56-283REPRESENTATION: APPLICANT
P Glissan, barrister
RESPONDENT
A Wilson, solicitorORDERS: 1. The decision of the Commissioner for Fair Trading to refuse the application by Cromwell’s Auctioneers & Appraisers Pty Ltd for a dealer licence under the Motor Dealers Act 1974 is set aside; 2. The matter is remitted for reconsideration by the Commissioner for Fair Trading with the recommendation that Cromwell’s Auctioneers & Appraisers Pty Ltd be granted the licence sought if it satisfies the other requirements provided for in s.12 of the Motor Dealers Act 1974.
Introduction
1 On 23 September 2003, Cromwell’s Auctioneers & Appraisers Pty Ltd (“the Applicant”) applied for a dealer licence under the Motor Dealers Act 1974 (“the Act”). The Applicant is a corporation of which Mr. James Warren Byrnes is the sole director. The Commissioner for Fair Trading (“the Commissioner”) administers the Act. The functions currently performed by the Commissioner were previously performed by the Director-General of the Department of Fair Trading (“the Department”). Any reference to the Director-General in the Act is to be taken to be a reference to the Commissioner.
2 On 26 November 2003 Mr. Robert Guthrie, as delegate of the Commissioner issued a Notice of Refusal to Grant a Motor Dealers Licence. The refusal was based upon section 12(4)(h) of the Act on the ground that it appeared to the Commissioner that a director of the Applicant company was "not of good reputation or character or in any other way would not be a fit and proper person to be the holder of a licence if the director ... were to apply for the licence personally".
3 On 28 November 2003 Mr. Byrnes, on behalf of the Applicant, sought an internal review of the decision and that review was conducted…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cromwell's Auctioneers & Appraisers Pty Ltd v Commissioner f... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWADT 281
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the Commissioner had failed to properly consider the applicant’s suitability for a dealer licence and had instead relied on a generalised policy statement that did not take into account the applicant’s individual circumstances. The court held that the Commissioner’s decision was flawed because it did not properly apply the criteria set out in the Act. The court found that the Commissioner had not considered all relevant factors and had not provided adequate reasons for his decision. The court further found that the Commissioner's reliance on a blanket policy was inconsistent with the requirements of the Act, which mandated a case-by-case assessment.
As a result, the court set aside the Commissioner’s decision and remitted the matter back to him for reconsideration. The court recommended that the Commissioner grant the licence if the applicant satisfied the other requirements provided for in section 12 of the Act. The court also ordered that the Commissioner’s decision be reviewed in light of the court's findings and that the applicant’s application be reconsidered on its merits. The court's orders were clear and directed the Commissioner to take specific steps to ensure that the applicant's application was assessed fairly and in accordance with the law.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The decision of the Commissioner for Fair Trading to refuse the application by Cromwell’s Auctioneers & Appraisers Pty Ltd for a dealer licence under the Motor Dealers Act 1974 is set aside; 2. The matter is remitted for reconsideration by the Commissioner for Fair Trading with the recommendation that Cromwell’s Auctioneers & Appraisers Pty Ltd be granted the licence sought if it satisfies the other requirements provided for in s.12 of the Motor Dealers Act 1974.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi