Croll v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

 Croll v Commissioner of Police [2023] QDC 69

PARTIES:

TREVOR HENRY CROLL

(appellant)

v
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

2506/2022

DIVISION:

Criminal

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court at Cleveland

DELIVERED ON:

24 March 2023 (ex tempore)

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

24 March 2023

JUDGES:

Allen KC DCJ

ORDER:

1.   The appeal is allowed. 

2.   The orders made by the Magistrates Court on 21 September 2022 are set aside. 

3.   The verdict and judgment record be amended so as to record that the plea was one of “Not guilty” and the verdict/result is “Found guilty”. 

4.    

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE – where the appellant pleaded not guilty to one charge of unlawful stalking in the Magistrates Court – where the appellant was self-represented – where the presiding Magistrate failed to inform the appellant of his right to trial by jury – where the presiding Magistrate cross-examined the appellant so as to elicit an admission of guilt – where the presiding Magistrate proceeded to sentence the appellant in the absence of a plea of guilty or a verdict of guilty and reasons for that verdict – where the presiding Magistrate disregarded the appellant’s claimed defence of unsoundness of mind – whether there was a miscarriage of justice –     inaccurate Verdict and Judgment Record

Legislation

Criminal Code 1899 (Qld), s 359E, s 359F, s 552B, s 552I,
s 631A

Justices Act 1886 (Qld), s 146, s 148, s 222, s 225

Cases

Forrest v Commissioner of Police [2017] QCA 132
Ralph v Commissioner of Police [2015] QDC 206

Stapleton v Queensland Police Service [2019] QDC 190

APPEARANCES:

The appellant appeared on his own behalf
S Whitfield, sol, Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld) for the respondent

Background

  1. The appellant was in a relationship with the ex-wife of the complainant, a serving police officer residing at relevant times on Russell Island.  The complainant and his ex-wife were embroiled in a bitter dispute as to the custody of their daughter.  The appellant chose to involve himself in that dispute. 

  2. On 31 December 2021, the appellant travelled to Russell Island with copies of a two-page leaflet he had prepared.  The florid contents railed against decisions of the Commonwealth and State government, various public agencies and judges and lawyers. Had the contents stopped there, they would have been easily disregarded as the incoherent rantings of a conspiracy theorist.  Unfortunately, two paragraphs of the document identified the complainant by name, date of birth, police station and residential address, and defamed the complainant with imputations as to his integrity and allegations of domestic violence and poor parenting.  The appellant was observed to place copies of the leaflet in at least four letterboxes of houses in the street where the complainant resided.

  3. The fact and content of the leaflet swiftly came to the attention of residents of the houses and then to a Member of Parliament, the officer in charge…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Croll v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QDC 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Croll v Commissioner of Police, the appellant, Croll, appealed against his conviction for unlawful stalking in the Magistrates Court. The appellant was self-represented and pleaded not guilty. The respondent, the Commissioner of Police, argued that the trial was procedurally fair despite several issues that arose during the proceedings. These issues included the presiding Magistrate’s failure to inform the appellant of his right to trial by jury, the Magistrate cross-examining the appellant to elicit admissions of guilt, and sentencing the appellant without a plea of guilty or a verdict of guilty. The court had to determine whether there was a miscarriage of justice due to the procedural errors made by the presiding Magistrate.

The court found that the trial was indeed marred by significant procedural errors, leading to a miscarriage of justice. The presiding Magistrate did not comply with the requirements of section 552I of the Criminal Code (Qld) by failing to inform the appellant of his right to be tried by jury. Furthermore, the Magistrate disregarded the appellant’s defence of unsoundness of mind, which is a serious breach of procedural fairness. The court held that these errors warranted the appeal to be allowed and the conviction to be quashed. The presiding Magistrate’s conduct, including asking leading questions and not allowing proper cross-examination, compounded the miscarriage of justice. The Verdict and Judgment Record was also found to be problematic, as it was created after the events it purported to record and inaccurately stated that the appellant had pleaded guilty.

The appeal was allowed, and the conviction was quashed. The orders made by the Magistrates Court on 21 September 2022 were set aside. The Verdict and Judgment Record was to be amended to accurately reflect that the plea was “Not guilty” and the verdict/result was “Found guilty.” This decision underscores the importance of procedural fairness in criminal trials and the necessity for presiding Magistrates to adhere to statutory requirements to avoid miscarriages of justice.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The orders made by the Magistrates Court on 21 September 2022 are set aside.

3. The verdict and judgment record be amended so as to record that the plea was one of “Not guilty” and the verdict/result is “Found guilty”.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondent contended that other aspects of the trial amounted to procedural unfairness, including: (a)the prosecution were required by the presiding Magistrate to tender body-worn camera footage of the police officer which they repeatedly submitted was hearsay evidence and the prosecution was not relying upon it;(b)the prosecution were denied the right to cross-examine the appellant;(c)the presiding Magistrate indicated throughout the proceedings his view of the case and the appellant’s guilt; (d)the presiding Magistrate gave the appellant the option of deciding whether he needed to hear from the sixth prosecution witness instead of allowing the witness to be called, and the appellant making the decision not to cross-examine the witness, the police prosecutor was not consulted as to what was apparently the Magistrate’s decision:No. All right. Well, we won’t call him.(e)the Magistrate asked the appellant leading questions during evidence-in-chief which encompassed his guilt and why he committed the acts, which ultimately led to further admissions on his behalf to elements of the offence; (f)the presiding Magistrate asked the prosecution what penalty they would be seeking while the appellant was still in evidence-in-chief; (g)the Magistrate did not afford the appellant the opportunity to call further evidence and proceeded to converse with the prosecutor about what penalty they were seeking and subsequently excused the appellant from the witness box and sent him back to the bar table; (h)the Magistrate did not invite closing addresses from either party; (i)the Magistrate did not re-arraign the appellant, or make it an option, and have him enter a plea of guilty after admissions had been made. In the absence of that taking place, the Magistrate should have given formal reasons by way of a judgment and stated how he had found the appellant guilty of unlawful stalking beyond reasonable doubt in the absence of a plea of guilty.Verdict and Judgment Record The written submissions of both parties were made without the benefit of having considered the Verdict and Judgment Record. The Verdict and Judgment Record is problematic. It was apparently only made on 7 December 2022, well after the events which it purports to record, and only after the defendant had filed a notice of appeal. It records the “plea” as “guilty” and the “verdict/result” as “pleaded guilty”.Consideration It is clear that the appeal should, as conceded by the respondent, be allowed. The hearing of the charge against the defendant entirely miscarried due to errors by the presiding Magistrate. In addition to those conceded by the respondent in written submissions, the respondent conceded in oral submissions that during the hearing the presiding Magistrate also erred in failing to comply with the requirements of section 552I of the Criminal Code (Qld). The charge of stalking, contrary to section 359E of the Criminal Code (Qld), is one which must be heard and decided summarily unless the defendant informs the Magistrates Court that he or she wants to be tried by jury (section 552B of the Criminal Code (Qld)). Section 552I of the Criminal Code (Qld) provides relevantly as follows:(a) This section applies to any charge for an offence to which section 552B applies.(b) If the defendant is not legally represented, the Magistrates Court is required –(a) to state the substance of the charge to the defendant; and(b) to explain to the defendant that he or she is entitled to be tried by jury and is not obliged to make any defence; and(c) to ask the defendant whether he or she wants the charge to be dealt with summarily.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The written submissions of both parties were made without the benefit of having considered the Verdict and Judgment Record. The Verdict and Judgment Record is problematic. It was apparently only made on 7 December 2022, well after the events which it purports to record, and only after the defendant had filed a notice of appeal. It records the “plea” as “guilty” and the “verdict/result” as “pleaded guilty”.Consideration It is clear that the appeal should, as conceded by the respondent, be allowed. The hearing of the charge against the defendant entirely miscarried due to errors by the presiding Magistrate. In addition to those conceded by the respondent in written submissions, the respondent conceded in oral submissions that during the hearing the presiding Magistrate also erred in failing to comply with the requirements of section 552I of the Criminal Code (Qld). The charge of stalking, contrary to section 359E of the Criminal Code (Qld), is one which must be heard and decided summarily unless the defendant informs the Magistrates Court that he or she wants to be tried by jury (section 552B of the Criminal Code (Qld)). Section 552I of the Criminal Code (Qld) provides relevantly as follows:(a) This section applies to any charge for an offence to which section 552B applies.(b) If the defendant is not legally represented, the Magistrates Court is required –(a) to state the substance of the charge to the defendant; and(b) to explain to the defendant that he or she is entitled to be tried by jury and is not obliged to make any defence; and(c) to ask the defendant whether he or she wants the charge to be dealt with summarily. The defendant was not legally represented at the hearing on 21 September 2022 and it was necessary that the procedure mandated by section 552I(2) of the Criminal Code (Qld) be undertaken. It was not. Even if, during prior mentions of the matter, there had been an understanding between the parties and the Court that the matter would proceed by way of summary trial, any prior intimation as to pleas and elections of summary jurisdiction would have been merely administrative. It was necessary at the commencement of the hearing for the presiding Magistrate to comply with the requirements in section 552I(2) and the failure to do so was both an error on the part of the presiding Magistrate and productive of a miscarriage of justice: Stapleton v Queensland Police Service [2019] QDC 190 at [19]. The presiding Magistrate further erred and caused a miscarriage of justice by his disregard of the defendant’s claimed defence of insanity. There are established procedures available in the Magistrates Court to investigate issues of unsoundness of mind at the time of the alleged offence; see the detailed discussion of the applicable legislation and practice directions by Morzone QC DCJ in Stapleton v Queensland Police [2019] QDC 190. At the very least, the presiding Magistrate should have inquired of the defendant whether he was seeking an adjournment to undertake the investigations he had deposed to in his affidavit. The presiding Magistrate’s failure to do so denied the defendant procedural fairness and resulted in a miscarriage of justice.