Croghan v Hawkesbury City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales

          CITATION:
Croghan -V- Hawkesbury City Council [1999] NSWLEC 134
          PARTIES
APPLICANT:
Croghan
RESPONDENT:
Hawkesbury City Council
          NUMBER:
30199 of 1995
          CORAM:
Bignold J
          KEY ISSUES:
Costs :- whether the Applicant should be regarded as being substantially successful in the litigation—effect of certain agreements made between parties in course of litigation
          LEGISLATION CITED:
Land Acquisition (Just Terms) Compensation Act 1991
          DATES OF HEARING:
04/21/1999
          EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE:

04/21/1999
          LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


APPLICANT:
Mr P. Tomasetti, Barrister
SOLICITORS;
Mervyn J Cathers & Co.

RESPONDENT:
Mr D. Miller, Barrister
SOLICITORS:
Abbott Tout


    JUDGMENT:

IN THE LAND AND Matter No. 30199 of 1995


ENVIRONMENT COURT OF Coram: Bignold J.


NEW SOUTH WALES 21 April 1999

ALAN FRANCIS CROGHAN

Applicant

v.

HAWKESBURY CITY COUNCIL

Respondent

JUDGMENT



Bignold J:

1. By its Motion filed on 4 March 1999 the Applicant seeks an order for costs in proceedings involving an objection pursuant to the Land Acquisition (Just Terms) Compensation Act 1991 (Just Terms Act) in respect of the compulsory acquisition by the Council of land previously owned by the Applicant, by Compulsory Acquisition Notice published in the Government Gazette No.86 of 14 July 1995.

2. In my judgment delivered on 5 June 1998, I upheld the objection and determined the amount of compensation in the sum of $621,027 plus interest, in accordance with Just Terms Act (s 49) to be paid. I reserved the question of costs. In my reasons for judgment, I had indicated that prima facie, the Applicant, having been substantially successful in the proceedings, enjoyed a presumptive entitlement to a costs order but since the Council had expressly asked me to reserve the question of costs, I did so, having made that initial observation to assist the parties on this issue.

3. On the hearing of the Motion today, effectively the Council urged me to depart from my earlier observations concerning the success of the Applicant and advanced an attractive argument, skilfully put together, that I should regard the Applicant as not having been substantially successful and that in consequence, I should depart from the ordinary rule which reflects costs following the event. Instead, Council submitted that it would be appropriate, if any costs order were to be made in favour of the Applicant to make a limited order, something like 50 per cent of the assessed costs of the hearing. The hearing was effectively completed in one day, although the hearing was supplemented by additional written submissions received from both parties subsequent to the hearing date

4. In my reasons for judgment, I indicated that the parties at the commencement of the hearing had notified the Court that they had reached agreement on a number of matters, chiefly upon the market value (at a per hectare rate) of the land compulsorily acquired. Other agreements concerning the existence of a footpath traversing part of the acquired land which had been constructed before the date of compulsory acquisition is referred to, together with an agreement as to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Croghan v Hawkesbury City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWLEC 134
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Croghan v Hawkesbury City Council before the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales involved a dispute over the compensation payable for the compulsory acquisition of land by the Hawkesbury City Council. The Applicant, Croghan, contested the adequacy of the compensation offered under the Land Acquisition (Just Terms) Compensation Act 1991. Following a hearing, Justice Bignold determined that the compensation offered was inadequate and ordered a higher amount of compensation, reserving the question of costs.

The key legal issues the court had to decide were whether the Applicant was substantially successful in the litigation and, consequently, entitled to an order for costs. The Hawkesbury City Council argued that the Applicant should not be regarded as substantially successful because the litigation had resulted in a significant reduction of the issues requiring adjudication due to agreements reached between the parties. Additionally, the Council argued that certain offers of compromise during the litigation should influence the court's discretion on costs.

Justice Bignold concluded that the Applicant was substantially successful in the litigation. The court found that the Applicant was successful on two of the three main issues, including the significant issue of adjoining owner influence, which dominated the proceedings. The judge rejected the Council's argument that the agreements reached between the parties should reduce the Applicant's entitlement to costs, reasoning that such an approach would be unreasonable and unfair. The court further held that the litigation history and offers of compromise did not alter the Applicant's status as the successful party in the proceedings.

Accordingly, the court ordered the Hawkesbury City Council to pay the Applicant's costs of the proceedings, either as agreed between the parties or, if no agreement could be reached, as assessed by the court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established