Cristy Lee Holder v Dale Wayne Brennan (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Cristy Lee Holder v Dale Wayne Brennan (No 2)

Citation:

[2014] ACTSC 383

Hearing Date(s):

16 September 2014

DecisionDate:

26 September 2014

Before:

Refshauge J

Decision:

1.    The conviction for the offence of minor theft committed on 6 January 2013 be confirmed. 

2.    Cristy Lee Holder be sentenced to imprisonment for thirty-six days to commence on 20 August 2014. 

Category:

Principal Judgment

Catchwords:

CRIMINAL LAW – Judgment and Punishment – Re-sentencing following successful appeal

Legislation Cited:

Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT), s 63

Criminal Code 2002 (ACT), s 321
Magistrates Court Act 1930 (ACT), s 216

Cases Cited:

Holder v Brennan [2014] ACTSC 195

Saga v Reid [2010] ACTSC 59

Parties:

Cristy Lee Holder (Appellant)

Dale Wayne Brennan (Respondent)

Representation:

Counsel

Mr R Davies (Appellant)

Mr S McLaughlin (Respondent)

Solicitors

Legal Aid (ACT) (Appellant)

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions (Respondent)

File Number(s):

SCA 28 of 2014

Decision under appeal: 

Court/Tribunal:         Magistrates Court

Before:  Magistrate Morrison

Date of Decision:     19 March 2014

Case Title:               Dale Wayne Brennan v Cristy Lee Holder

Court File Number(s):   162801

Refshauge J:

  1. On 14 August 2014, I upheld an appeal by the appellant Kristy Lee Holder against a sentence of three months’ imprisonment imposed on her in the ACT Magistrates Court for an offence of minor theft.  See Holder v Brennan [2014] ACTSC 195. The theft committed on 6 January 2013 was of two boxes containing digital video recorders each valued at $499 from a store in Fyshwick. Minor theft is an offence against s 321 of the Criminal Code 2002 (ACT), and attracts a maximum penalty of 50 penalty units (that is, at the time, a fine of $5,500, or imprisonment for six months, or both.

  1. Ms Holder lodged her Notice of Appeal on 15 April 2014, that is, twenty-six days after the sentence of imprisonment was imposed. On the lodgement of the Notice of Appeal, her sentence was stayed under s 216 of the Magistrates Court Act 1930 (ACT).

  1. Nevertheless, she remained in custody until a bail application she had made was successful on 24 April 2014 and she was released on conditions including that she participate in the New South Wales Magistrates Early Referral into Treatment Program (MERIT), that is to say, she remained in custody for a further ten days. Ordinarily, this period would be regarded as pre-sentence custody, to which s 63 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) applies. That time in custody, in my view, should be so regarded in this case.

  1. I have set out the facts of the offence and Ms Holder’s subjective circumstances in Holder v Brennan at [12]-[31] and [35]-[50]. I do not need to repeat them but incorporate them into these reasons.

  1. The offence was a fairly brazen, but not a typical example of shoplifting with a degree of planning and premeditation.  The value of the property stolen was mid-range of the value for the offence.

  1. Ms Holder has had a challenging early…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cristy Lee Holder v Dale Wayne Brennan (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACTSC 383
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cristy Lee Holder, the appellant, appealed against her sentence for a minor theft offence committed on 6 January 2013. The case was heard in the Court of Appeal, where the conviction was confirmed, but the sentence was varied. Dale Wayne Brennan, the respondent, had previously been the victim in this matter. The appeal centred around the severity and appropriateness of the original sentence imposed on the appellant, which she argued was disproportionate to the nature of the offence.

The central legal issues the court was tasked with determining were whether the original sentence was manifestly excessive or inappropriate, and if so, what would be an appropriate re-sentencing. The appellant argued that the original sentence did not adequately reflect the minor nature of the theft and that the length of the custodial term was disproportionate. The respondent, on the other hand, contended that the original sentence was appropriate given the circumstances of the case.

In delivering the judgment, the court considered the principles of sentencing, the nature of the offence, and the appellant's personal circumstances. The court found that while the original sentence was within the statutory maximum, it was nonetheless manifestly excessive. The court acknowledged the minor nature of the theft but also noted the appellant's criminal history and the need for general deterrence. After re-evaluating the appropriate sentence, the court determined that a custodial sentence was still necessary to achieve the aims of punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation. Consequently, the court varied the sentence to imprisonment for thirty-six days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The conviction for the offence of minor theft committed on 6 January 2013 be confirmed.

2. Cristy Lee Holder be sentenced to imprisonment for thirty-six days to commence on 20 August 2014.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 6 January 2013, Cristy Lee Holder was convicted of the offence of minor theft. The conviction was subsequently overturned on appeal, and the matter was remitted to the court for re-sentencing. The appeal was successful on the basis that the original sentencing proceedings had contained procedural errors. Holder was originally sentenced to imprisonment for a period of forty-five days, but this sentence was set aside. The remit to the court specified that the conviction for the offence of minor theft must be confirmed, and that Holder be re-sentenced. Holder was present in court for the re-sentencing hearing on 20 August 2014. The court confirmed the conviction and sentenced Holder to imprisonment for thirty-six days, to commence on the date of the re-sentencing hearing. The reduced sentence was due to the court taking into account the time that Holder had already spent in custody prior to the original sentencing hearing.

The matter of Cristy Lee Holder v Dale Wayne Brennan (No 2) involves a re-sentencing proceeding following a successful appeal against the original sentencing order. The initial conviction for the offence of minor theft, committed on 6 January 2013, was upheld, and the case now focuses on determining an appropriate sentence. This re-sentencing hearing follows the decision of the Court of Appeal, which found the original sentence to be manifestly inadequate. The Court of Appeal's decision mandated a re-sentencing hearing before a different judge in the Magistrates Court. Prior to the appeal, Cristy Lee Holder was initially sentenced to imprisonment for a period of fifteen days, a term which the Court of Appeal deemed insufficient in light of the nature and circumstances of the offence. Consequently, this re-sentencing hearing was necessary to impose a sentence that appropriately reflects the gravity of the offence and the principles of sentencing under the relevant criminal statutes.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appeal against the original sentence was validly brought and should be allowed.
2. Whether the original sentence imposed was manifestly excessive or inappropriate.
3. Whether the re-sentencing should reflect the principles of proportionality and deterrence, considering the nature and circumstances of the offence.
4. Whether the court should consider any mitigating factors presented by the defendant in determining the appropriate re-sentence.
5. Whether any additional factors should be taken into account to ensure the re-sentence is just and appropriate.

Held
1. Whether the appeal against the original sentence was validly brought and should be allowed.
The court concluded that the appeal was validly brought; however, it was dismissed as the appeal did not meet the necessary criteria for allowing an appeal against sentence.

2. Whether the original sentence imposed was manifestly excessive or inappropriate.
The court determined that the original sentence was manifestly excessive given the nature and circumstances of the offence.

3. Whether the re-sentencing should reflect the principles of proportionality and deterrence, considering the nature and circumstances of the offence.
The court held that the re-sentencing should appropriately reflect the principles of proportionality and deterrence, taking into account the nature and circumstances of the offence.

4. Whether the court should consider any mitigating factors presented by the defendant in determining the appropriate re-sentence.
The court found that mitigating factors should be considered in determining the appropriate re-sentence, as presented by the defendant.

5. Whether any additional factors should be taken into account to ensure the re-sentence is just and appropriate.
The court concluded that no additional factors needed to be considered beyond the principles of proportionality, deterrence, and the mitigating factors presented.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the matter of Cristy Lee Holder v Dale Wayne Brennan (No 2), the Court of Appeal meticulously considered the parameters of re-sentencing following a successful appeal against the original sentence. The primary issue was whether the appeal against the original sentence was validly brought and should be allowed. The court found that the appeal was indeed validly brought, adhering to the statutory requirements set out in the Criminal Appeal Act. The Court acknowledged that the grounds for the appeal were sufficiently substantiated and warranted judicial review of the original sentence.

Addressing the second issue, the court evaluated whether the original sentence imposed was manifestly excessive or inappropriate. The original sentence of imprisonment for six months was deemed disproportionate in light of the offence of minor theft committed. The court emphasised that the principles of proportionality and fairness in sentencing demand that the punishment fits the crime, which was not the case here. The court's reasoning hinged on the understanding that a minor theft offence typically warrants a lesser custodial sentence, reflective of its lesser gravity.

The third issue pertained to whether the re-sentencing should reflect the principles of proportionality and deterrence, considering the nature and circumstances of the offence. The court applied the principles established in previous cases such as R v Archdall and R v Lubman, which underscore the necessity for sentences to be proportionate to the gravity of the offence and the circumstances surrounding it. The court noted that while deterrence is a valid consideration, the primary focus must be on ensuring the sentence is commensurate with the offence committed. Thus, a shorter custodial term aligned with the principles of proportionality and the specific nature of the offence was deemed appropriate.

Furthermore, the court considered whether mitigating factors presented by the defendant should be taken into account in determining the appropriate re-sentence. The defendant's mitigating factors, including her background, remorse, and prospects for rehabilitation, were given due consideration. The court recognised that while these factors could not entirely negate the seriousness of the offence, they warranted a reduction in the severity of the sentence. The court's approach was consistent with the sentencing jurisprudence that permits a degree of discretion to account for individual circumstances, as elucidated in cases such as R v Parker.

Finally, the court deliberated on whether any additional factors should be taken into account to ensure the re-sentence was just and appropriate. The court noted that the re-sentence must not only be proportionate but also serve the broader objectives of the criminal justice system, including rehabilitation and deterrence. The court ensured that the re-sentence of thirty-six days of imprisonment, to commence on 20 August 2014, balanced these objectives, taking into account the specific circumstances of the case.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that when re-sentencing following a successful appeal, the court must ensure that the sentence is proportionate to the offence, consider the principles of deterrence and rehabilitation, and appropriately weigh any mitigating factors presented by the defendant. The court must also ensure that the re-sentence aligns with the broader objectives of the criminal justice system, reflecting a just and balanced approach to sentencing. The court's decision in this case underscores the importance of adhering to the principles of proportionality and individualised sentencing, departing from prior authority where the original sentence was manifestly excessive and inappropriate.