Crime and Corruption Commission v Deputy Commissioner Barnett

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Crime and Corruption Commission v Deputy Commissioner Barnett & Anor [2017] QCA 320

PARTIES:

CRIME AND CORRUPTION COMMISSION
(appellant)
v
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF POLICE, ROSS BARNETT
(first respondent)
CRAIG HOPKINS
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 4008 of 2017
QCAT No 231 of 2015

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Reference under s 118(1) Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act

ORIGINATING COURT:


Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal

DELIVERED ON:

22 December 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

29 September 2017

JUDGES:

Gotterson and McMurdo JJA and Bond J

ORDERS:

1.   The question referred by the President of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal to this Court for its determination, namely:

Upon the proper construction of section 7.4(3) of the Police Service Administration Act 1990 and regulation 5 of the Police Service (Discipline) Regulations 1990, was it within the First Respondent’s power to suspend a sanction of dismissal imposed on the Second Respondent subject to the conditions specified in the First Respondent’s order made on 21 December 2015?

is answered: Yes.

2.   The appellant is to pay the second respondent’s costs of and incidental to the reference on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

STATUTES – SUBORDINATE LEGISLATION – CONSTRUCTION – GENERALLY – where the first respondent imposed a sanction of dismissal upon the second respondent for misconduct pursuant to the Police Service (Discipline) Regulations 1990 (Qld) (“the Regulations”) – where the first respondent further ordered the sanction of dismissal be suspended provided that some four conditions were thereafter met – where reg 12 grants a power to a prescribed officer to suspend a disciplinary sanction made under the Regulations subject to the disciplined officer agreeing to undertake certain conditions – where compliance with the conditions of suspension under reg 12 rescinds the disciplinary sanction from the officer’s record – where the conditions imposed by the first respondent were inconsistent with reg 12 – where the first respondent relied on the power under reg 5 to discipline in a manner that “appears to… be warranted” – whether reg 5 authorises the commissioner or a deputy commissioner to conditionally suspend an officer’s dismissal without regard to reg 12

Police Service Administration Act 1990 (Qld), s 7.4
Police Service (Discipline) Regulations 1990 (Qld), reg 5, reg 6, reg 7, reg 8, reg 10, reg 12

Anthony Hordern & Sons Ltd v Amalgamated Clothing and Allied Trades Union of Australia (1932) 47 CLR 1; [1932] HCA 9, cited
Crime and Misconduct Commission v McLennan & Ors
[2008] QSC 23, approved
Francis v Crime and Corruption Commission & Anor[2015] QCA 218, cited
Irwin v Stewart(Commissioner of Police) & Anor [2015] QSC 350, cited
Lee v Crime and Corruption Commission& Anor [2014] QCATA 326, not applied
Leon Fink Holdings Pty Ltd v Australian Film Commission (1979) 141 CLR 672; [1979] HCA 26, cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Nystrom (2006) 228 CLR 566; [2006] HCA 50, cited

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crime and Corruption Commission v Deputy Commissioner Barnet... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QCA 320
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Crime and Corruption Commission v Deputy Commissioner Barnett involved the Deputy Commissioner of the Queensland Police Service imposing a sanction of dismissal upon an officer for misconduct, as per the Police Service (Discipline) Regulations 1990 (Qld). The Deputy Commissioner also imposed conditions that, if met, would suspend the dismissal. The Court was asked to determine whether the Deputy Commissioner had the power to conditionally suspend the dismissal, particularly in light of the terms of regulation 12 of the Regulations, which provides for the suspension of a disciplinary sanction subject to the officer agreeing to certain conditions. The core legal issue was whether regulation 5, which grants the power to discipline in a manner that appears to be warranted, allowed for the conditional suspension of a dismissal without adhering to the specific conditions outlined in regulation 12.

The Court concluded that the power to suspend the dismissal was indeed derived from, and constrained by, regulation 12 of the Regulations. The conditions specified by the Deputy Commissioner were inconsistent with regulation 12, thus beyond his power. The Court emphasised that the disciplinary powers of a prescribed officer, including the Deputy Commissioner, derive from both the Act and the Regulations. The conditions imposed by the Deputy Commissioner were not aligned with the requirements set forth in regulation 12, which meant they were invalid. Therefore, the Deputy Commissioner overstepped his authority by imposing conditions that were not in accordance with the prescribed regulations.

The Court answered the referred question in the negative, ruling that the Deputy Commissioner did not have the power to impose the conditions as he did. The Court also ordered that the appellant pay the second respondent’s costs of and incidental to the reference on the standard basis. This decision underscores the importance of adhering to the specific provisions of the Regulations when imposing disciplinary sanctions, highlighting that even the Deputy Commissioner is bound by these regulatory constraints.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The question referred by the President of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal to this Court for its determination, namely:

Upon the proper construction of section 7.4(3) of the Police Service Administration Act 1990 and regulation 5 of the Police Service (Discipline) Regulations 1990, was it within the First Respondent’s power to suspend a sanction of dismissal imposed on the Second Respondent subject to the conditions specified in the First Respondent’s order made on 21 December 2015?

is answered: Yes.

2. The appellant is to pay the second respondent’s costs of and incidental to the reference on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around the disciplinary proceedings against the second respondent, who was dismissed from the police service by the first respondent, a Deputy Commissioner, for misconduct. Pursuant to the Police Service (Discipline) Regulations 1990 (Qld) (the "Regulations"), the first respondent imposed the sanction of dismissal on the second respondent. However, the first respondent also ordered that the dismissal be suspended contingent upon the second respondent meeting certain specified conditions. Regulation 12 of the Regulations provides a power to a prescribed officer to suspend a disciplinary sanction made under the Regulations, subject to the disciplined officer agreeing to undertake certain conditions. Compliance with the conditions of suspension under regulation 12 rescinds the disciplinary sanction from the officer’s record. The conditions imposed by the first respondent were inconsistent with regulation 12. The first respondent relied on the power under regulation 5 to discipline in a manner that "appears to... be warranted".

The matter was referred to the Court by the President of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The Tribunal had to determine whether the power of the Deputy Commissioner to suspend the dismissal of the second respondent derived from, and was subject to the limitations of, regulation 12 of the Police Service (Discipline) Regulations 1990 (Qld). The Tribunal found that the conditions specified in the first respondent's order, which purported to suspend the dismissal of the second respondent, were inconsistent with regulation 12 and were thereby beyond power. The Deputy Commissioner appealed this decision to the court, which then addressed the issue of whether regulation 5 authorises the commissioner or a deputy commissioner to conditionally suspend an officer’s dismissal without regard to regulation 12.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusion: For these reasons, I would answer the referred question “Yes”. The second respondent has asked for an order for costs in his favour. I think it appropriate that the appellant pay his costs on the standard basis. I would propose the following orders: McMURDO JA: In my opinion, the question of law which has been referred to this Court should be answered in the negative. The power of the Deputy Commissioner to suspend the dismissal of the second respondent derived from, and was subject to the limitations of, regulation 12 of the Police Service (Discipline) Regulations 1990 (Qld) (“the Regulations”). The conditions specified in the first respondent’s order, which purported to suspend the dismissal of the second respondent, were inconsistent with regulation 12 and were thereby beyond power. The internal command and discipline of serving police officers in Queensland is governed by Part 7 of the Police Service Administration Act 1990 (Qld) (“the Act”). In particular, s 7.4 provides as follows: Two things should be noted about s 7.4. The first is that it speaks of disciplinary action being taken by a “prescribed officer”, a term which is not limited to the commissioner of police or a deputy commissioner. The second is that the section is not a self-contained source of power to take disciplinary action. It refers to a range of disciplines that may be imposed by a prescribed officer by way of disciplinary action,[21] but leaves it to “the regulations” to prescribe the grounds for that action.[22] Necessarily, the disciplinary powers of a prescribed officer, including the commissioner or a deputy commissioner, derive, at least in part, from the Regulations.[21]s 7.4(3).[22]s 7.4(2). Those grounds for disciplinary action are prescribed by regulation 9(1) of the Regulations as follows: The disciplinary powers of the commissioner or a deputy commissioner are expressed in regulation 5 as follows: There is no reference to regulation 9 in regulation 5, whereas regulations 6, 7 and 8(1) refer to an officer being disciplined “on any ground referred to in regulation 9”. However, as I have said, according to s 7.4 the grounds for disciplinary action, whether taken by the commissioner, a deputy commissioner or another prescribed officer, are those as prescribed by a regulation, and regulation 9 is the only provision of that kind. Regulation 10 provides for disciplinary sanctions which may be imposed. Regulation 10 is as follows: Not every disciplinary sanction which is listed in regulation 10 may be imposed by every prescribed officer. For example, an assistant commissioner may not impose the disciplinary sanction of dismissal. That limitation comes from regulation 6 which is as follows: Similarly, regulation 7 provides that a commissioned officer may not impose the sanctions referred to in sub-regulations 10(c) to 10(f) and regulation 8(1) provides that a non-commissioned officer may impose only the sanction of a caution or reprimand, under regulation 10(a).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The internal command and discipline of serving police officers in Queensland is governed by Part 7 of the Police Service Administration Act 1990, with disciplinary actions taken by a "prescribed officer". The disciplinary powers of a prescribed officer, including the commissioner or a deputy commissioner, derive from both the Act and the Police Service (Discipline) Regulations 1990. Section 7.4(3) of the Act refers to the regulations to prescribe the grounds for disciplinary action, with regulation 9 of the Regulations listing those grounds. Regulation 5 outlines the disciplinary powers of the commissioner or a deputy commissioner, which includes the power to discipline in a manner that "appears to... be warranted". However, regulation 12 grants a power to a prescribed officer to suspend a disciplinary sanction made under the Regulations subject to the disciplined officer agreeing to undertake certain conditions.

The court examined whether regulation 5 authorised the First Respondent to conditionally suspend the Second Respondent’s dismissal without regard to regulation 12. The conditions imposed by the First Respondent were inconsistent with regulation 12. The court concluded that the First Respondent’s power to suspend the dismissal derived from and was subject to the limitations of regulation 12. As the conditions specified in the First Respondent’s order were inconsistent with regulation 12, they were beyond the First Respondent's power.

The court then addressed the issue of costs. It found it appropriate for the appellant to pay the second respondent’s costs on the standard basis, given the circumstances of the case and the outcome of the appeal. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the disciplinary powers of a deputy commissioner are constrained by the specific provisions of the Police Service (Discipline) Regulations 1990, and any conditions imposed for the suspension of a disciplinary sanction must comply with those provisions.