CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Crime and Corruption Commission (CCC) has applied for a review of the disciplinary sanction imposed on Constable Waller for misconduct. The CCC contends that the only appropriate sanction is dismissal, whereas Constable Waller and the Acting Deputy Commissioner contend that the existing sanction decision should be confirmed. The tribunal must conduct a fresh hearing on the merits, to produce the correct and preferable decision. The tribunal must bring a ‘public point of view’ to the decision-making process. After affording due respect to the views of the original decision-maker, the tribunal must reach its own decision on what constitutes the correct and preferable decision. The misconduct of Constable Waller involved sharing his QLITE device with other officers, giving a woman a lift home when on duty, engaging in sex with the woman while on duty, and failing to secure his firearm while on duty. The misconduct also involved not conducting a random breath test on the woman while on duty, when she was on her way to collect her children. The CCC argues that Constable Waller’s misconduct demonstrates that he is unfit to be a police officer. The CCC submits that the Acting Deputy Commissioner placed too much weight on factors pressed by Constable Waller as mitigating. The CCC argues that Constable Waller has displayed a ‘predilection for favouring his own interests over the interests of the public’. However, the misconduct was not a single, isolated act. It took various forms, over a period. Constable Waller’s misconduct demonstrates that he has acted improperly and unbecomingly. It reflects negatively on his character and integrity. His failure to perform his duties impartially on the occasion in question erodes the confidence that the community can place in him. He was willing to favour an associate on that occasion: might he do so again, or even turn a blind eye to criminal conduct committed by an associate? The other misconduct adds to the impression of untrustworthiness. The stain on his character detracts from his credibility as an authority figure or a witness. However, the evidence from referees and others suggests that ordinarily Constable Waller performs his duties diligently and impressively. Some of this evidence relates to conduct while the tribunal review proceedings have been on foot (since October 2019), and it should be borne in mind that Constable Waller will have had motivation to be on his best behaviour in an effort to save his career. However, the observations are similar to ones that were made about Constable Waller’s earlier behaviour, and so I do not regard his recent behaviour as unrepresentative of his usual conduct. Constable Waller’s misconduct involving the sharing of the QLITE device was well-intentioned but improper. The misconduct on the night in late 2016 was foolish and unbecoming. The more serious misconduct involved the random breath testing. That conduct was clearly improper, albeit momentary and not premeditated. It reflects negatively on Constable Waller’s character and integrity. I accept that the marital and workplace difficulties that Constable Waller experienced in 2016 and 2017 lowered his morale, and may have resulted in him engaging in conduct that he otherwise would have avoided. However, I do not regard those factors as particularly significant when assessing Constable Waller’s fitness to be a police officer. Police officers are rightly expected to act ethically and responsibly even if circumstances are challenging or suboptimal. Weight should, though, be placed on the indications that Constable Waller ordinarily engages in appropriate and even commendable conduct as a police officer. This is evidenced by the awards he has received and the very favourable comments, both solicited and unsolicited, from varied sources. Overall, the evidence does not lead me to the conclusion that Constable Waller has such a flawed character that he is incapable of acting ethically or is disinclined to do so. His motivation for ethical conduct must surely have been boosted considerably by the salutary experience of being investigated and disciplined. I consider it likely, if he remains a police officer, that he will act ethically and not corruptly. It is also relevant to bear in mind that Constable Waller was relatively young and inexperienced, and at a junior rank, at the time of the misconduct. I place weight on the view of the Acting Deputy Commissioner as to the appropriate disciplinary response. I must also bring a public perspective. That is not a straightforward task, because views within the community would differ on how much latitude, if any, should be shown to officers who have engaged in misconduct. Most members of the community would agree that there should be little tolerance for police conduct that displays favouritism or which could imperil safety. However, they would also agree that each case should be considered on its merits, taking into account factors such as the extent of wrongdoing, the reasons for it, and the officer’s other conduct. The predominant community view, I think, would be that misconduct of the type involved in the present case, by a relatively new officer with an otherwise good record, is not so serious as to render that person permanently unfit to serve as a police officer. Accordingly, I do not accept the CCC’s submission that the only appropriate sanction is dismissal. The sanction imposed by the Acting Deputy Commissioner does sufficiently and appropriately give effect to the statutory purposes of disciplinary action. It denounces the misconduct. It deters future misconduct both by that denunciation and by the financial impact. The investigatory and disciplinary process itself has had a salutary effect. The sanction involves guidance and supervision. It is sufficient to maintain public and collegial confidence in the police service because it shows that serious lapses from required standards will have significant consequences. Where the purposes of the disciplinary process are adequately met by a sanction less severe than dismissal, that sanction is preferable to dismissal. This is because of the impact of dismissal on the individual and the wasted investment by the police service in training and developing an officer. The correct and preferable decision on sanction is the decision that was made by the Acting Deputy Commissioner. Accordingly, I will confirm that decision. The tribunal may make a non-publication order only if it considers that such an order is necessary for certain reasons, such as to avoid the publication of confidential information or information whose publication would be contrary to the public interest, or for some other reason in the interests of justice. The CCC sought an order permanently prohibiting publication of the names of the civilians, and an order prohibiting publication of Constable Waller’s name while the review proceeding was before the tribunal. In its submissions dated 3 April 2020, the CCC said that the prohibition on publication of the identity of Constable Waller should be removed. The CCC advised that it did not wish to file further submissions on the matter. The Acting Deputy Commissioner advised that he did not oppose the continuation of the non-publication order, but he did not wish to file submissions. Mr McMillan for Constable Waller has submitted that the non-publication order should continue. He submits that publication of Constable Waller’s identity would be contrary to the public interest, and not in the interests of justice. He notes that if the CCC’s review of the sanction decision is unsuccessful, the Acting Deputy Commissioner’s decisions on substantiation and sanction will both have been confirmed. Constable Waller will be in the same position as he was before the review proceedings. Constable Waller did not bring the proceedings, and Mr McMillan submits it would not be in the public interest for Constable Waller’s identity to be published ‘where the applications for review have been entirely unsuccessful’. However, I do not accept Mr McMillan’s submissions. In