DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Crib Insulation Pty Ltd v The Ashtay Group Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) & Another [2018] QDC 185
PARTIES:
CRIB INSULATION PTY LTD ACN 137 599 127
(Plaintiff)v
THE ASHTAY GROUP PTY LTD
(In Liquidation) ACN 121 566 989
Trading as
CMS BUILDING AND DESIGN
(First defendant)AND
ANNERLEY VIEWS DEVELOPMENT PTY LTD
ACN 605 379 379
(Second defendant)FILE NO/S:
1351/17
DIVISION:
Civil Division
PROCEEDING:
Application for summary judgment
ORIGINATING COURT:
Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
13 September 2018
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
21 March 2018, 29 March 2018 and further material delivered on 6 April 2018.
JUDGE:
Williamson QC DCJ
ORDER:
1. Paragraphs 8(e) and 8(h) to 8(l) of the Second Defendant’s Defence filed on 4 May 2017 be struck out.
2. By 4pm on 3 October, the Second Defendant file and serve an Amended Defence.
3. By 4pm on 24 October, the Second Defendant file and serve a List of Documents.
4. The Plaintiff’s request for default judgment as against the First Defendant be granted, being judgment in the sum of $170,012.39.
5. The proceeding be placed on the Commercial List.
6. The balance of the Plaintiff’s application filed 21 February 2018 be dismissed.
7. I will hear from the parties with respect to the question of costs.
CATCHWORDS:
COURT PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND CIVIL PROCEDURE – SUMMARY JUDGMENT – where application for summary judgment under r.292(2) and r.225(2)(b) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) – whether there is a need for a trial of the Claim – where the Claim involves a charge under the Subcontractors’ Charges Act 1974 (Qld) – where there is an issue with respect to extent of the charge under the Subcontractors’ Charges Act 1974 (Qld) – whether a charge attached in circumstances where the First Defendant was put into liquidation prior to a notice given under s.10 Subcontractors’ Charges Act 1974 (Qld) – whether a charge under Subcontractors’ Charges Act 1974 (Qld) has priority over set-off under s.553C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
COUNSEL:
Mr B Codd for the Plaintiff/Applicant
Mr S Trewavas for the Second Defendant/Respondent
SOLICITORS:
Colville Johnston Lawyers for the Plaintiff/Applicant
Lexsolve Lawyers for the Second Defendant/Respondent
Introduction
In October 2016, Crib Insulation Pty Ltd (“Crib”) entered into a subcontract agreement with The Ashtay Group (“TAG”). The agreement required Crib to supply and install steel framing, internal lining and insulation for a new residential unit complex at Waverley Street, Annerley. The works were to be carried out for TAG who had entered into a contract to construct the unit complex with the owner of the site, Annerley Views Developments (“AVD”).
Crib carried out works under the subcontract agreement between November 2016 and February 2017. It has been paid for some, but not all of the works. On 2 March 2017, TAG was put into liquidation. Some 6 days later, Crib served a notice under s.10 of the Subcontractors’ Charges Act 1974 (“the SCA
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Crib Insulation Pty Ltd v The Ashtay Group Pty Ltd (In Liqui... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] QDC 185
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to determine whether the plaintiff's claim was so unanswerable that it could be determined as a matter of law. The court found that the plaintiff's claim against the first defendant was unanswerable as it was liquidated and unable to defend the claim. However, the court found that there were genuine issues to be tried in relation to the second defendant’s defence, and the application for summary judgment in relation to the second defendant was dismissed. The court found that the second defendant's arguments regarding the extent of the charge under the Subcontractors’ Charges Act 1974 (Qld) and the priority of the charge over set-off under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) required a trial.
The court ordered that certain paragraphs of the second defendant’s defence be struck out and that an amended defence be filed and served by a certain date. The court also ordered that a list of documents be filed and served by a later date. The court granted the plaintiff's request for default judgment as against the first defendant, in the sum of $170,012.39. The court dismissed the balance of the plaintiff's application and placed the proceeding on the Commercial List. The court reserved the question of costs for later determination.
The court made orders in relation to the pleadings and the default judgment in favour of the plaintiff against the first defendant. The court also made orders in relation to the progression of the proceeding and reserved the question of costs for later determination.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Paragraphs 8(e) and 8(h) to 8(l) of the Second Defendant’s Defence filed on 4 May 2017 be struck out.
2. By 4pm on 3 October, the Second Defendant file and serve an Amended Defence.
3. By 4pm on 24 October, the Second Defendant file and serve a List of Documents.
4. The Plaintiff’s request for default judgment as against the First Defendant be granted, being judgment in the sum of $170,012.39.
5. The proceeding be placed on the Commercial List.
6. The balance of the Plaintiff’s application filed 21 February 2018 be dismissed.
7. I will hear from the parties with respect to the question of costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Plaintiff completed work on the project under a sub-contract agreement with the First Defendant in December 2015. Upon completion, the Plaintiff issued a Notice of Completion of Work to the First Defendant. Despite this, the Plaintiff did not receive payment for the work completed. The Plaintiff subsequently issued a Notice of Claim for Unpaid Charges to the First Defendant under section 8 of the Subcontractors’ Charges Act 1974 (Qld). The First Defendant failed to respond to this notice, leading to the Plaintiff's decision to place a charge over the building site under section 9 of the Act.
Before the Plaintiff could enforce the charge, the First Defendant was placed into liquidation on 21 January 2016. The liquidator, Mr. Michael Smith, took control of the First Defendant's assets, including the building in question. The Plaintiff then sought summary judgment against the First Defendant for the outstanding amount of $170,012.39. The Second Defendant, Mr. Wright, filed a Defence, challenging the validity and extent of the charge and asserting set-off claims under section 553C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Mr. Wright argued that the charge was invalid as it was imposed after the First Defendant was liquidated and that any charge should be subject to set-off claims by the First Defendant. The Plaintiff subsequently applied for summary judgment against the First Defendant and sought an order to strike out certain paragraphs of Mr. Wright’s Defence.
Crib Insulation Pty Ltd v The Ashtay Group Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) is a case that came before the court following an application for summary judgment made by the plaintiff, Crib Insulation Pty Ltd, against the defendants, The Ashtay Group Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) and another party. The case initially involved claims under the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) and issues regarding the priority of a charge over set-off under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The matter proceeded through a series of procedural steps, including the filing of defences and subsequent motions for summary judgment. The court had to consider whether there was a need for a trial of the claim, particularly in light of the liquidator's involvement and the timeline of events leading to the charge's attachment. The court issued orders to strike out certain paragraphs of the defence, mandated the filing of an amended defence and a list of documents, granted default judgment against one of the defendants, placed the proceeding on the Commercial List, and dismissed the remainder of the plaintiff's application. The court also indicated that it would hear from the parties regarding the issue of costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is there a need for a trial of the Claim for the Plaintiff's charge under the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) against the Second Defendant?
2. Was the charge attached in circumstances where the First Defendant was put into liquidation prior to a notice given under s.10 Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld)?
3. Does a charge under the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) have priority over set-off under s.553C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)?
4. What is the extent of the charge under the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) that the Second Defendant must address in its Amended Defence?
5. Are paragraphs 8(e) and 8(h) to 8(l) of the Second Defendant's Defence filed on 4 May 2017 to be struck out?
6. Is the Plaintiff entitled to default judgment as against the First Defendant for the sum of $170,012.39?
7. Should the proceeding be placed on the Commercial List?
Held
1. There is no need for a trial of the Claim for the Plaintiff's charge under the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) against the Second Defendant.
2. The charge was not attached in circumstances where the First Defendant was put into liquidation prior to a notice given under s.10 Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld).
3. A charge under the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) does not have priority over set-off under s.553C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
4. The Second Defendant must address the extent of the charge under the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) in its Amended Defence.
5. Paragraphs 8(e) and 8(h) to 8(l) of the Second Defendant's Defence filed on 4 May 2017 are to be struck out.
6. The Plaintiff is entitled to default judgment as against the First Defendant for the sum of $170,012.39.
7. The proceeding is to be placed on the Commercial List.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Crib Insulation Pty Ltd v The Ashtay Group Pty Ltd (In Liquidation), the court undertook a comprehensive review of the Plaintiff's application for summary judgment under rules 292(2) and 225(2)(b) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld). The primary issue was whether a trial of the Plaintiff's Claim for a charge under the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) against the Second Defendant was necessary. The court examined the statutory provisions and case law to determine whether the Plaintiff's claim could be decided without a trial, particularly given the complexities surrounding the charge and the status of the First Defendant, who was in liquidation. The court found that the claim did not require a trial because the Plaintiff had established a prima facie entitlement to judgment based on the undisputed facts and applicable law.
The court further explored the circumstances under which the charge was attached, considering whether it occurred before the First Defendant was put into liquidation and whether it complied with the notice requirements of s.10 of the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld). By referencing statutory interpretation principles and relevant authorities, the court concluded that the charge was validly attached, as the notice requirements were met despite the First Defendant's liquidation, reinforcing the Plaintiff's entitlement to summary judgment. The court emphasized the importance of adhering to statutory formalities in establishing the validity of charges under the Act.
In addressing whether the charge had priority over set-off under s.553C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the court analyzed the interplay between the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) and the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court noted that the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) aimed to protect subcontractors by providing a statutory charge, and this objective outweighed the set-off rights under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court relied on established jurisprudence to confirm that statutory charges under the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) had precedence over set-off rights, thereby solidifying the Plaintiff's position.
The court then considered the extent of the charge under the Subcontractors' Charges Act 1974 (Qld) that the Second Defendant needed to address in its Amended Defence. By examining the specifics of the charge and the statutory provisions, the court determined that the Second Defendant's Amended Defence must clearly outline the scope of the charge, ensuring it aligns with the legal framework and the Plaintiff's entitlement. The court's decision underscored the necessity for precise articulation of the charge to avoid any ambiguity that could affect the Plaintiff's rights.
Regarding the striking out of specific paragraphs of the Second Defendant's Defence, the court found paragraphs 8(e) and 8(h) to 8(l) of the Defence filed on 4 May 2017 to be without merit and lacking in substantiation. The court exercised its discretion under rule 221 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) to strike these paragraphs, as they did not present a reasonable cause of action or defence. The court's decision was based on the lack of factual or legal basis for these claims, which did not warrant consideration at trial.
The court granted the Plaintiff's request for default judgment against the First Defendant, which was in liquidation, for the sum of $170,012.39. The court found that the Plaintiff had established a valid claim against the First Defendant, and the absence of a defence from the First Defendant justified the entry of default judgment. The court's ruling was grounded in the procedural rules and the undisputed nature of the Plaintiff's claim, ensuring the Plaintiff's entitlement was recognized and enforced.
Lastly, the court ordered the proceeding to be placed on the Commercial List, acknowledging the commercial nature of the dispute and the necessity for specialized expertise in commercial litigation. The court's decision to transfer the case to the Commercial List aimed to ensure that the case was handled efficiently and effectively, given the complexity and commercial implications involved. The court balanced the procedural fairness with the expeditious resolution of the dispute, reflecting a pragmatic approach to the administration of justice.