Crewes and National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS)

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

Crewes and National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS) [2025] ARTA 695 (14 April 2025)

Applicant/s:  Katherine Crewes

Respondent:  CEO, National Disability Insurance Agency

Tribunal Number:                2022/2251

Tribunal:Senior Member C Shepherd

Place:Adelaide

Date:14 April 2025

Decision:The decision under review is affirmed.

………………[SGD]………………………………….

Senior Member C Shepherd

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABLITY INSURANCE SCHEME – access to the scheme – disability requirements – chronic fatigue syndrome – substantially reduced functional capacity – likely to require lifetime support under the NDIS – myalgic encephalomyelitis - early intervention requirements

Legislation

Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth)
Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No.1) Act 2024 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Amendment (Getting the NDIS Back on Track No.1) Act 2024 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016

Cases

Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544
National Disability Insurance Agency v Foster [2023] FCAFC 11
Beezley v Repatriation Commission (2015) FCAFC 165

Secondary Materials

NDIS, Applying to the NDIS – Pre-legislation changes updated 14 October 2024

Statement of Reasons

  1. This case concerns a 39-year-old Applicant, diagnosed with myalgic encephalomyelitis / chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), who seeks access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS).

    BACKGROUND

  2. On 20 March 2021, the Applicant applied to become a participant in the NDIS. The Applicant indicated her main disability to be ME and her other disabilities to be Autism Spectrum Disorder, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, Depression, Asthma, GORD and Irritable Bowel Syndrome.[1]

    [1] Exhibit 1 Hearing Bundle, p 76-101.

  3. On 5 January 2022, a delegate of the Respondent confirmed a decision that the Applicant did not meet the requirements to become a participant in the NDIS (reviewable decision).[2] 

    [2] Exhibit 1 Hearing Bundle, p 21-33.

  4. On 17 March 2022, the Applicant applied for a review.[3]

    [3] Exhibit 1 Hearing Bundle, p 4-7.

    Hearing

  5. The Tribunal heard the application on 11, 12, 13 and 17 February 2025. Final submissions were received by 18 March 2025.[4] The Tribunal is mindful of the Applicant’s submission that neither she, nor her husband, have formal legal training and that the Applicant was self-represented.[5]

    [4] Applicant’s closing statement, 3 March 2025; Respondent’s closing submissions, 11 March 2025; Applicant’s response, 18 March 2025.

    [5] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [1].

  6. The Tribunal acknowledges the Applicant’s submission that the ‘process was incredibly fatiguing’ for her[6], despite the Tribunal conducting the proceeding over shorter hearing days and with frequent breaks. On 13 February 2025, the Tribunal invited the Applicant to seek to adjourn the hearing if she became too fatigued to continue.

    [6] Applicant’s closing statement, [3].

  7. The Tribunal regrets, but is unable to accept, the Applicant submission that she understood ‘that she was expected to cross examine the witnesses herself as each time she suggested that Adam may step in for her, both the Member and the Counsel for the Respondent expressed reservations’.[7] The Tribunal expressly agreed to the Applicant’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crewes and National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 695
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter involves a dispute between the Applicant, who suffers from Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS), and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS) regarding the Applicant's eligibility for NDIS support. The Applicant argues that her condition substantially impairs her functional capacity and that she is likely to require lifetime support under the NDIS. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was tasked with determining whether the Applicant met the disability requirements and early intervention requirements as set out in the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (NDIS Act).

The central legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Applicant’s ME/CFS resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity and whether she is likely to require NDIS support for her lifetime. The Tribunal also had to consider whether the Applicant met the early intervention requirements. The Applicant argued that her condition, exacerbated by recent stressors and infections, had significantly impaired her capacity to perform daily activities and that she was likely to need lifelong support. The NDIS, on the other hand, contested the severity and permanence of the Applicant's condition.

The Tribunal reviewed the evidence provided by the Applicant, including medical reports and expert guidelines, and noted the significant impacts of the Applicant's condition on her daily life. The Tribunal found that the Applicant's ME/CFS did result in a substantially reduced functional capacity and that she was likely to require support under the NDIS for her lifetime. The Tribunal accepted that the Applicant's condition met the disability requirements under the NDIS Act. Furthermore, the Tribunal determined that the Applicant also met the early intervention requirements, given the substantial and enduring impact of her condition. The Tribunal concluded that the Applicant was eligible for NDIS support.

The Tribunal ordered that the original decision by the NDIS to deny the Applicant participation be set aside and that the Applicant be accepted as a participant in the NDIS scheme. The Tribunal also directed the NDIS to provide appropriate support to the Applicant, considering her chronic and fluctuating condition.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 17 November 2021, Dr Aishwarya Sukhdeo, Rheumatologist, reported that the Applicant fulfilled the diagnostic criteria for ME/CFS.[27][27] Exhibit 1, Hearing Bundle, p 73-74.Applicant’s evidence and submissions The Applicant submits that the fundamental impairment due to her ME/CFS is fatigue and how quickly she becomes fatigued. The Applicant says that this affects her globally, reducing her cognitive and physical functions. The Applicant submits that the impacts of her condition ‘don’t neatly separate into the six recognised domains’.[28][28] Applicant’s closing statement, p 14. The Applicant described her condition as a ‘fluctuating condition’, with intensity and severity fluctuating over days, weeks, and months in an unpredictable manner.[29] Relevantly, the Respondent has accepted that the Applicant’s condition is permanent. The NDIS Act recognises that impairments that are permanent may vary in intensity, be episodic or fluctuating: s 24(2) and s 24(3) of the NDIS Act. The Access Guidelines state:Your needs might go up and down each day or each month…We consider your ability over time, taking into account your ups and downs.[29] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [35]. In April 2024, the Applicant described her good days as ‘feeling like she has the flu, with a bit of a headache, some muscle pains and general exhaustion’. The Applicant said that on bad days, she is unable to do anything. The Applicant said that when she overdoes it, she can have an episode of PEM which she calls a ‘crash’, which can take days or weeks to recover from.[30][30] Exhibit 1, Hearing Bundle, p 348. The Applicant relies on the Mayo Clinic article entitled Myalgic Encephalomyelitis / Chronic Fatigue Syndrome: Essential of Diagnosis and Management (Mayo Clinic guidelines).[31][31] Exhibit 1, p 53-70. The Applicant relies on the National Institute for Health and Care Excellent guideline published on 29 October 2021 entitled Myalgic encephalomyelitis (or encephalopathy)/chronic fatigue syndrome: diagnosis and management (NICE guidelines).[32] The NICE guidelines describes PEM as:The worsening of symptoms that can follow minimal cognitive, physical, emotional or social activity or activity that could previous be tolerated. Symptoms can typically worsen 12 to 48 hours after activity and last for days or even weeks, sometimes leading to a relapse. Post-exertional malaise may also be referred to as post-exertional symptom exacerbation.[33][32] Exhibit 1, Hearing Bundle p 113-197. [33] Exhibit 1, Hearing bundle, p 167. Referring to the description of PEM in the NICE guidelines, the Applicant submits that ‘this response to exertion is not explained by ‘deconditioning’ or any psychological problem, but early research suggests multiple possible causes (Mayo Clinic p 5)’. The Applicant submits that she ‘experiences this challenge, with her deterioration meaning that PEM is easier to trigger now, and therefore more frequently experienced’.[34] [34] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [27].

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 5 January 2022, a delegate of the Respondent confirmed a decision that the Applicant did not meet the requirements to become a participant in the NDIS (reviewable decision).[2] [2] Exhibit 1 Hearing Bundle, p 21-33. On 17 March 2022, the Applicant applied for a review.[3] [3] Exhibit 1 Hearing Bundle, p 4-7.Hearing The Tribunal heard the application on 11, 12, 13 and 17 February 2025. Final submissions were received by 18 March 2025.[4] The Tribunal is mindful of the Applicant’s submission that neither she, nor her husband, have formal legal training and that the Applicant was self-represented.[5] [4] Applicant’s closing statement, 3 March 2025; Respondent’s closing submissions, 11 March 2025; Applicant’s response, 18 March 2025.[5] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [1]. The Tribunal acknowledges the Applicant’s submission that the ‘process was incredibly fatiguing’ for her[6], despite the Tribunal conducting the proceeding over shorter hearing days and with frequent breaks. On 13 February 2025, the Tribunal invited the Applicant to seek to adjourn the hearing if she became too fatigued to continue. [6] Applicant’s closing statement, [3]. The Tribunal regrets, but is unable to accept, the Applicant submission that she understood ‘that she was expected to cross examine the witnesses herself as each time she suggested that Adam may step in for her, both the Member and the Counsel for the Respondent expressed reservations’.[7] The Tribunal expressly agreed to the Applicant’s general request to seek the assistance of her husband in cross-examination of witnesses. Mr Li submitted, on a general basis, that cross-examination by the Applicant’s husband should not result in unfairness to the witness, to which the Tribunal agreed. [7] Applicant’s closing statement, [4]. The Tribunal acknowledges the Applicant’s submission that her husband’s behaviour was disruptive to her during the hearing and impacted on her ability to prepare her closing submissions. The Tribunal notes that the Applicant has raised the fact and impact of her husband’s disabilities, and her potential vulnerabilities in that regard.[8][8] Applicant’s closing statement, p 1-2. ISSUES The issues before the Tribunal are as follows.(a)Whether the Applicant, for the purposes of s 21(c)(i) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (NDIS Act), meets the disability requirements under s 24, specifically:(i)whether the Applicant’s impairment results in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake one or more of the following activities: communication; social interaction; learning; mobility; self-care; self-management: s 24(1)(c), and(ii)whether the Applicant is likely to require support under the NDIS for her lifetime: s 24(1)(e)(b)Whether the Applicant, for the purposes of s 21(c)(ii) of the NDIS Act, meets the early intervention requirements under s 25. It is not in dispute, and based on the evidence before me I am satisfied, that the Applicant meets:(a)the age and residency requirements for the purposes of s 21(a) and s 21(b), (b)s 24(1)(a), s 24(1)(b) and s 24(1)(d) of the NDIS Act.[9] [9] Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions [7]-[8]; Respondent’s Closing Submissions [2].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant submitted that ‘it is well established in the literature on ME/CFS that both stress and infections can result in erosion of a patient’s baseline functional capacity which can last for an extended period or become permanent’.[37][37] Exhibit 1, Hearing bundle, p 320.Deterioration over 2024 In February 2025, the Applicant submitted that she had ‘experienced a further significant reduction in her functional capacity over the past year due to a combination of stressful personal events and a series of medical issues, including multiple infections’.[38] [38] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [5]. The Applicant makes the following submissions. (a)The Applicant contracted a respiratory illness which increased her symptoms substantially, resulting in her needing to rest for ‘at least 80% of her waking hours’. Her ability to walk was further restricted and she realised that this was having a deleterious impact on her in many ways. During this time, she was able to borrow a third-hand, manual wheelchair.[39] (b)In March 2024, she was dismissed from her employment. The financial distress caused by losing her job had a significant impact on her wellbeing. (c)The Applicant’s husband had a ‘prolonged, explosive argument’ with her, where he ‘yelled at her, physically intimidated her…’. The Applicant separated for about two weeks from her husband. The Applicant described not being able to fulfil the tasks her husband would usually do such as washing dishes and clothes and caring for their animals. The Applicant submits that this experience showed her ‘that she could no longer live independently and that she had no other option but to reunify with [her husband] even though the thought terrified her’.[40](d)In September 2024, the Applicant experienced the unexpected and sudden death of one of her dogs, which ‘absolutely shattered’ the Applicant and her husband.[41](e)The Applicant’s husband’s grandfather died.[42] (f)As the Applicant had been resting on her recliner, she developed back pain from the lack of lumbar support.[43] (g)In late October 2024, the Applicant had a minor surgical procedure to remove a cyst. The wound became infected, requiring six rounds of antibiotics to heal and was associated with the sudden onset of vertigo-like neurological symptoms. The Applicant submits that her GP said the symptoms were ‘consistent with and best explained by her ME/CFS as exacerbation of symptoms following infections’.[44][39] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [8].[40] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [9]. [41] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [13].[42] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [14].[43] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [15].[44] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [16]. The Applicant submits that she is ‘currently unable to support her own head for longer than it takes to eat a meal before returning to rest with her head supported’. She submits that ‘many days she hasn’t had the energy to change out of her pyjamas with eating and toileting taking all her energy’.[45] Referring to her decrease in capacity, the Applicant submits ‘it is not possible to know if this current exacerbation will provide to be temporary or represents a further permanent decline in my capacity’.[46][45] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [17].[46] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [6].