Crelin and Font

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CRELIN & FONT [2009] FamCA 618
FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN – With whom a child lives – With whom a child spends time
APPLICANT: Ms Crelin
RESPONDENT: Mr Font
FILE NUMBER: BRC 10280 of 2007
DATE DELIVERED: 8 July 2009
PLACE DELIVERED: Brisbane
PLACE HEARD: Brisbane
JUDGMENT OF: Bell J
HEARING DATE: 6 & 7 July 2009

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Ms V Martinovic
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Michael Heffernan, Solicitor
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Respondent appeared on his own behalf
COUNSEL FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: Mr G S Andrew
SOLICITOR FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: Legal Aid Queensland

Orders

IT IS ORDERED THAT

Where the child lives

  1. That the child …born ... August 2005 live with the Mother

Parental responsibility

  1. That the parents have equal shared parental responsibility for long term decisions with respect to the child

How the Father spends time and communicates with the child

  1. That the father spend time and communicate with the child as agreed between the parties and failing agreement as follows:-

    3.1.Until 31 December 2010 as follows:-

    3.1.1.Each fortnight from 3pm Friday to 5pm Sunday commencing 10 July 2009

    3.1.2.On the weekend on Father’s day from 3pm Friday to 5pm Sunday

    3.1.3.By telephone once per week each Tuesday with the Mother to assist the child to initiate the call to the Father between 6.00pm and 6.30pm

    3.2.From 31 December 2010:-

    3.2.1.Each alternate weekend with the Father to collect the child from the child’s school at the conclusion of school on Friday and return the child immediately before the commencement of school on Monday

    3.2.2.In each other week from after school Wednesday to before school Thursday with the Father to collect the child from the child’s school at the conclusion of school on Wednesday until before the commencement of school on Thursday 

    3.2.3.One half of all gazetted school holidays during the first half in odd years and the second half in even years.

    3.2.4.By telephone once per week each Tuesday with the Mother to assist the child to initiate the call to the Father between 6.00pm and 6.30pm

    3.3.For special days commencing 7 July 2009 as follows:-

    3.3.1.From 4.30pm Christmas Eve until 1pm Christmas Day in odd years and from 1pm Christmas Day to 4.30pm Boxing Day in even years;

    3.3.2.From 4.30pm Easter Saturday to 1pm Easter Sunday in even years and from 1pm Easter Sunday to 4.30pm Easter Monday in odd years;

    3.3.3.On the child’s birthday as follows:-

    3.3.3.1.From 9am to 12 noon on the child’s birthday in 2009 and 2010

    3.3.3.2.From 3pm until  6pm on the child’s birthday from 2011 onwards

    3.3.4.By telephone on the Father’s birthday with the Mother to assist the child to initiate the call.

  2. The father shall not exercise time with the child on the weekend of Mothers Day.

  3. The child shall have telephone communication with the Mother each Tuesday when the child is spending time with the Father, with the Father to assist the child to initiate the call to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crelin and Font and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FamCA 618
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bell J made orders concerning the living arrangements and parental responsibilities for a child born in August 2005. The dispute involved the father's time with the child, communication between parents and child, and the practicalities of changeovers.

The court was required to determine the specific arrangements for the child's residence, the extent of equal shared parental responsibility for long-term decisions, and the detailed schedule for the father's time with the child, including communication and special days. Further issues included the method and location of changeovers between parents, the use of a contact centre, and provisions for information sharing regarding the child's health and education. The court also addressed prohibitions concerning certain individuals and the disclosure of addresses.

Bell J ordered that the child live with the mother and that the parents have equal shared parental responsibility for long-term decisions. The father's time with the child was detailed, with specific arrangements for fortnightly weekends, mid-week time, school holidays, and special days, including telephone communication. The orders established a priority for changeover locations, commencing with the child's school, then a contact centre, and finally a police station, with strict protocols for each. The use of a contact centre for supervised changeovers was mandated, with detailed provisions for assessment, compliance, and payment of fees. The court also made orders for information sharing through a communication book and direct notification for serious matters, and prohibited the disclosure of the mother's address to specific individuals. The Independent Children's Lawyer was to be discharged upon completion of initial contact centre arrangements.

Orders

Orders of the court

IT IS ORDERED THAT

Where the child lives

1.

That the child …born ... August 2005 live with the Mother

Parental responsibility

2.

That the parents have equal shared parental responsibility for long term decisions with respect to the child

How the Father spends time and communicates with the child

3.

That the father spend time and communicate with the child as agreed between the parties and failing agreement as follows:-

3.1. Until 31 December 2010 as follows:-

3.1.1. Each fortnight from 3pm Friday to 5pm Sunday commencing 10 July 2009

3.1.2. On the weekend on Father’s day from 3pm Friday to 5pm Sunday

3.1.3. By telephone once per week each Tuesday with the Mother to assist the child to initiate the call to the Father between 6.00pm and 6.30pm

3.2. From 31 December 2010:-

3.2.1. Each alternate weekend with the Father to collect the child from the child’s school at the conclusion of school on Friday and return the child immediately before the commencement of school on Monday

3.2.2. In each other week from after school Wednesday to before school Thursday with the Father to collect the child from the child’s school at the conclusion of school on Wednesday until before the commencement of school on Thursday

3.2.3. One half of all gazetted school holidays during the first half in odd years and the second half in even years.

3.2.4. By telephone once per week each Tuesday with the Mother to assist the child to initiate the call to the Father between 6.00pm and 6.30pm

3.3. For special days commencing 7 July 2009 as follows:-

3.3.1. From 4.30pm Christmas Eve until 1pm Christmas Day in odd years and from 1pm Christmas Day to 4.30pm Boxing Day in even years;

3.3.2. From 4.30pm Easter Saturday to 1pm Easter Sunday in even years and from 1pm Easter Sunday to 4.30pm Easter Monday in odd years;

3.3.3. On the child’s birthday as follows:-

3.3.3.1. From 9am to 12 noon on the child’s birthday in 2009 and 2010

3.3.3.2. From 3pm until 6pm on the child’s birthday from 2011 onwards

3.3.4. By telephone on the Father’s birthday with the Mother to assist the child to initiate the call.

4.

The father shall not exercise time with the child on the weekend of Mothers Day.

5.

The child shall have telephone communication with the Mother each Tuesday when the child is spending time with the Father, with the Father to assist the child to initiate the call to the Mother between 6.00pm and 6.30pm.

Calculation of school holidays

6.

For the purposes of these orders the following shall apply:-

6.1. For the purposes of calculations school holidays shall commence at the conclusion of school time hours on the last scheduled day of school term and end on the Sunday immediately prior to the start of the school term;

6.2. The first half of gazetted school holiday period is deemed to commence at the conclusion of school time hours on the last day of the school term and conclude on the day calculated to be half of the school holiday period using the number of nights in each school holiday period and if there is an uneven number, then the child will stay with the Father for the additional night regardless of whether he is spending time with the child in the first or second half.

Changeovers

7.

The changeover location shall be, in order of priority, as follows:-

7.1. The Child’s school on days the child is attending school;

7.2. The Y contact centre where their services are available; and

7.3. The police station closest to the mother’s residence.

8.

That the Mother shall not be present at the school when the father is collecting or delivering the child.

9.

The father shall not be present at the school at the times the mother is collecting or delivering the child.

Contact centre

10.

The parties shall;

10.1. contact the Y Contact Centre (“the Contact Centre”) within 48 hours and arrange an appointment for assessment for suitability for supervision of changeovers;

10.2. attend the assessment;

10.3. comply with any appointments made by the Contact Centre for supervised changeovers;

10.4. comply with all reasonable rules of the Contact Centre; and

10.5. comply with all reasonable requests or directions of the staff of the Contact Centre.

11.

The Contact Centre may recommend the parties or either of them to participate in a program or programs, and in that event the parties shall attend the next available program or programs as recommended by the Contact Centre.

12.

If after assessment the parties are accepted by the Contact Centre as suitable for supervised changeovers the Father is to have contact with the child as outlined in Order 3 and such changeovers are to occur at the Contact Centre.

13.

The mother must personally deliver and/or cause some other responsible adult known to the child and nominated beforehand in writing to the Contact Centre to deliver the child to and collect the child from the Contact Centre at the times specified by the Contact Centre and on each occasion promptly leave the building and the vicinity.

14.

In the event that the Contact Centre offers supervised changeovers at different times on the days specified in Order 3 then contact shall occur at the times that are offered by the Contact Centre.

15.

Each of the parents must pay one half of any reasonable fees for each supervised changeover and shall be solely responsible for any other fees levied against them by the contact centre.

16.

The father must not attend the Contact Centre or its vicinity before the time with the child is to start and must promptly leave the Contact Centre and the vicinity at the time the time with the child is to end.

17.

The period of contact provided in these orders may vary by reason of the closure of the Contact Centre’s services during school and public holiday periods, and in such event, contact shall occur at times when the services can be provided by the Contact Centre.

18.

Where changeovers occur at a police station the following shall apply:-

18.1. The party collecting the child shall enter the police station 5 minutes before the changeover time and wait in the police station foyer

18.2. The party delivering the child shall adopt the following process :-

· The parent shall say their final goodbyes to the child at their vehicle;

· The parent shall accompany the child to the door to the police station foyer

· The parent shall open the door for the child to enter the foyer

· The parent shall have the child enter the foyer ensuring the other parent is present; and

· The delivering parent shall leave the vicinity of the police station immediately.

18.3. Neither party shall be accompanied by another person at the time of the handovers;

18.4. Neither party shall by word or facial expression or other similar action engage the other party or seek to provoke the other party;

18.5. The parties shall not exchange insults or other harassing comments to the other; and

18.6. Neither party shall approach the other.

Information sharing

19.

Both parties shall as soon as practicable notify the other of any serious injury or illness suffered by the child whilst in their care by telephone.

20.

Save for emergencies, the parties shall communicate issues in relation to the child by using a communication book which shall travel with the child in a sealed envelope. The entries in that book shall be legible and courteous and relate only to the child. The father shall purchase the first book and thereafter the parties shall alternate the purchase of the books.

21.

That should the parties change address they shall provide notice to the other that there is an intended relocation and shall provide to the other the name of the suburb in which they intend to reside.

22.

That the parties shall keep the other informed of their telephone number and shall advise the other of any change to that number within 24 hours of the change.

23.

That the parties be entitled to liaise with the child’s schools, day care, extra curricular activity providers, medical or health professionals about the child’s ongoing education and health needs and this order authorises the child’s schools, day care, extra curricular activity providers, medical or health professionals to speak to each of the parties regarding the child’s progress and this order is authority to obtain documents in relation to the child that a parent is entitled to receive including but not limited to school reports, order forms for school photos, school newsletters, medical reports and parent teacher interview notifications. The requesting party shall be responsible for any costs involved. This authority strictly prohibits the provision of the Mother’s address to any person.

24.

The parties shall provide to the other within seven days a list of the child’s current schools, day care extra curricular activity providers, medical or health professionals and shall keep the other informed if there is an addition to the list within seven days.

General

25.

Neither party shall whilst the child is in their care be under the influence of or consume illicit drugs and shall not allow the child to be exposed to other persons under the influence of or consuming illicit drugs.

26.

That the Mother and Father shall not allow the child to come into contact with Mr T (also known as …) whatsoever either directly or indirectly.

27.

The mother is prohibited from uttering or publishing her address, unless permitted by further order, to Mr T.

28.

That should the Father know the whereabouts of the Mother’s address he is, unless permitted by further order, prohibited from uttering or publishing that address to any person and are further prohibited from causing any other person to utter or publish that information to any person.

29.

The father shall not attempt to locate the Mother’s residential address.

30.

That the Independent Children’s Lawyer be discharged after the parties have attended to intake with the contact centre and the child’s first visit with the father with changeover at the contact centre is complete.

31.

That should the Independent Children’s Lawyer remain undischarged she may restore this matter to the list on the giving of two days notice to the parties.

32.

That pursuant to s 65DA(2) and s 62B, the particulars of the obligations these orders create and the particulars of the consequences that may follow if a person contravenes these orders and details of who can assist parties adjust to and comply with an order are set out in the Fact Sheet attached hereto and these particulars are included in these orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.