| DETERMINATION OF APPEAL PANEL | |
| CITATION: | Creighton v Brunswick Valley Meals on Wheels Inc [2023] NSWPICMP 660 |
| APPELLANT: | Dianne Creighton |
| RESPONDENT: | Brunswick Valley Meals on Wheels Inc |
| APPEAL PANEL | |
| SENIOR MEMBER: | Elizabeth Beilby |
| MEDICAL ASSESSOR: | Michael Hong |
| MEDICAL ASSESSOR: | Graham Blom |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 7 December 2023 |
| CATCHWORDS: | WORKERS COMPENSATION - Appeal alleging incorrect Psychiatric Impairment Rating Scale (PIRS) classification; application to adduce fresh evidence from the appellants family member relating to PIRS classification declined, relying 327(3)(b) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 and Petrovic v. BC Serv No. 14 Pty Limited t/as Broadlex Cleaning Services; Panel declined to find that the statement could not have been reasonably obtained before the Medical Assessment; the Appeal Panel could find no error on the face of the Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC); application of Ferguson v State of New South Wales and Parker v Select Civil Pty Ltd; no error was found in the application of the categories and classes of PIRS; Held – MAC confirmed. |
BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION TO APPEAL
On 15 August 2023 Dianne Creighton (the appellant) lodged an Application to Appeal Against the Decision of a Medical Assessor. The medical dispute was assessed by Dr Alan Doris, a Medical Assessor (MA), who issued a Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC) on 18 July 2023.
The appellant relies on the following grounds of appeal under s 327(3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (1998 Act):
· availability of additional relevant information (being additional information that was not available to, and that could not reasonably have been obtained by, the appellant before the medical assessment appealed against);
· the assessment was made on the basis of incorrect criteria, and
· the MAC contains a demonstrable error.
The delegate was satisfied that, on the face of the application, at least one ground of appeal has been made out. The Appeal Panel has conducted a review of the original medical assessment but limited to the ground(s) of appeal on which the appeal is made.
Rule 128 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 (PIC Rules) and Procedural Direction PIC7 - Appeals, reviews, reconsiderations and correction of obvious errors in medical disputes set out the practice and procedure in relation to the medical appeal process under s 328 of the 1998 Act. An Appeal Panel determines its own procedures in accordance with r 128(1) of the PIC Rules.
The assessment of permanent impairment is conducted in accordance with the SIRA NSW Workers Compensation Guidelines for the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 4th ed
1 March 2021 (the Guidelines) and the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 5th ed (AMA 5).
RELEVANT FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The appellant was employed by Brunswick Valley Meals on Wheels Inc (the respondent) in a service coordination role. Her duties include coordinating meal programs and also delivering meals to both clients and other employees who looked after alternative service sites.
Whilst in the course of her duties, the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Creighton v Brunswick Valley Meals on Wheels Inc and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NSWPICMP 660
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The panel found that the MA had correctly applied their clinical judgment based on the information provided by Ms. Creighton and their own observations. Ms. Creighton had reported a range of post-traumatic symptoms, including sleep disturbance, hypervigilance, and irritability, following a robbery incident. Despite these symptoms, the MA assessed that Ms. Creighton's level of self-care, social connections, and ability to concentrate and persist were consistent with a Class 2 classification under the PIRS. The MA noted that Ms. Creighton maintained a good self-care routine, had close relationships with her family, and engaged in various activities, albeit infrequently. The MA's assessment was corroborated by other reports, including one from Dr. Chow, which indicated a similar level of impairment. The panel concluded that the MA's assessment was reasonable and that there was no error in the application of the categories and classes of the PIRS. As a result, the appeal was dismissed, and the MAC was confirmed, upholding the classification of Ms. Creighton's psychiatric impairment as assessed by the MA.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The appellant also submits that there should have been an assessment of Class 3 for concentration, persistence and pace as opposed to Class 2. The respondent submitted that the MA has not fallen into error and the MAC should be confirmed. They say that the assessment was undertaken by a qualified consultant psychiatrist who relied on his clinical observations made at the time of medical assessment in conjunction with the history provided to the MA by the worker. The MA had quite correctly relied on, within the terms of Pitsonis v Registrar of Workers Compensation Commission & Anor[2] “his clinical judgement at the time of the medical assessment”. The parts of the medical certificate given by the MA that are relevant to the appeal are set out below. · on 1 July 2021 Ms Creighton was robbed of her handbag while parked in the vehicle of the organisation she was working for in a shopping area. Immediately after the robbery she recalls feeling angry and blamed herself for “letting my guard down”. She developed a number of typical post-traumatic symptoms including a sleep disturbance, hypervigilance for further assault and irritability including with close family members. She believes that the robbery “unhinged my strong Aboriginal spirit” and the theft of important personal possessions such as photographs in her handbag left her feeling “like an alien” [Page 2].· Ms Creighton continues to be hypervigilant when a situation similar to those in which the assault occurred. She usually goes to a local supermarket at quiet times and will park as close as she can to the entrance. [Page 2]· Ms Creighton recognises that she uses activities such as cleaning her house as a way of managing unpleasant feelings and she can do this excessively at times. [Page 2]· She has noticed that her memory and concentration is not so good, and she has strategies such as collecting items together close to the door before leaving home, so she does not forget them. [Page 2]· Ms Creighton lives with her daughter and 12-year-old grandson. She describes getting on well with them. She has close relationships with her family of origin and will usually visit and spend time with them 3 times per year in Moree. Most days Ms Creighton gets up around 6am. She lets her dog out before feeding it, and making herself some breakfast which she enjoys. [Page 3]· She will drive her grandson to the bus stop so that he can get to school. She will shower either before taking her grandson to the bus stop or after. She gets dressed and then may spend time planning her day or the week ahead and writing on her calendar. She may go to the shops which are approximately 4 kilometres from home to get some groceries. Most of the time she spends at home which she describes as her “comfort zone”. She spends time during the day doing household chores and cleaning. She maintains some online connections with family and friends. Ms Creighton’s daughter does most of the cooking for the household. She goes with her daughter to Ballina occasionally and goes to church each Sunday for Mass. [Page 3]· She will meet with friends every two months or so for coffee but otherwise is not socially active. Ms Creighton gave a detailed history and spoke spontaneously and fluently. Her affect showed appropriate reactivity depending on the material under discussion. Her mood was objectively and subjectively euthymic today with good future focus. [Page 3]· Ms Creighton was fully alert and oriented at interview. On more than one occasion she had brief frustration as her concentration lapsed or she forgot some information which she felt she should recall. Dr Chow assessed Ms Creighton as having significantly more impairment in most areas than my assessment. The details provided by Ms Creighton to me at interview indicate a high level of self-care, sustaining some important social connections, independent travel in her local area and an ability to concentrate on tasks such as reading and writing. The difference between the assessment of Dr Chow and myself may be due to partial recovery of some functions in the intervening 10 months. [Page 5]· In her report Miss Gilding describes a good self-care routine being followed, good connections with family and community, including in Moree, and activities such as exercise at home, gardening and reading. The description of Ms Creighton’s functions is at some variance with that of Dr Chow. [Page 5]Self-care and personal hygiene – Class 2· Ms Creighton describes impairment in her self-care in the weeks following the incident in July 2021 though believes this has significantly improved since that time. She will shower every day either before or after she drives her grandson to the bus stop. She describes attending to her appearance if going into a public situation such as shopping with her daughter. She prepares breakfast for herself every day, has snacks during the day and then has a meal with her daughter and grandson in the evening which is usually prepared by her daughter. During the day she will spend time doing household chores including ironing and cleaning. There is mild impairment in self-car – Class 2.Social and recreational activities – Class 2· Ms Creighton meets with her friends for a coffee every few weeks if they are in the local area. She maintains an interest in genealogy though meets with others to pursue this interest infrequently. She sustains online relationships in areas of her interest. She spends most of her time at home. She is able to go to situations such as local supermarkets and post office unaccompanied – Class 2.