Crees and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 70

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          QT2000/46-48

TAXATION APPEALS  DIVISION         )          
           Re      CECIL CREES       
  Applicant
           And    COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mr. D.W. Muller, Senior Member

Date5 February 2001       

PlaceBrisbane

Decision      The Tribunal affirms the objection decisions under review.   
  ...............(Signed)...............................
  D.W. MULLER
  SENIOR MEMBER
CATCHWORDS
INCOME TAX – whether carrying on a business – primary production
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936: ss 51
Case K9 78 ATC 98
Thomas v Federal Commissioner of Taxation 72 ATC 4094

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr. D.W. Muller, Senior Member             

  1. This is an application by Cecil Crees to review decisions of the respondent to disallow objections to amended assessments for the three income tax years ending 30 June 1995, 1996 and 1997.

  2. Mr. Crees has been growing orchids since 1984.  He first claimed to be in the business of growing orchids in the 1989 taxation year.  The questions for determination by the Tribunal are:

    (i)Whether the orchid growing activities of Mr. Crees amount to carrying on a business of primary production, or whether he is an enthusiast/hobbyist;

    (ii)Whether income from the orchid growing activities should be included and whether deductions associated with the growing of orchids should be allowed in the assessment of Mr. Crees' income tax;  and

    (iii)Whether additional amounts for penalty and interest should have been imposed.

  3. The following facts are not in dispute and the Tribunal finds as follows:

    (i)Mr. Crees was born on 8 June 1950.

    (ii)In the late 1960s he spent three years as a student at Queensland Agricultural College.

    (iii)His main source of income during his working life has been derived from his expertise as a technician.  He was employed full-time by Telecom/Telstra until he accepted a voluntary redundancy package in April 1998.  He then obtained full-time work with Transfield as a technician.  His contract with Transfield will cease in May 2001.

    (iv)He started growing orchids in 1984.

    (v)He has sold orchids from time to time but his expenses associated with producing orchids have far outweighed his income from sales.

    (vi)His property consists of 2,023 square metres.  On that property he has his residence, an old hothouse (built in 1988), a bush house (built in 1992), an air-conditioned cold house (built in 1993), a shed (built in 1996), a tank (built in 1998) and a new hot house (built in 1998).

    (vii)He registered his business name "Valley View Orchid Nursery" on 6 May 1993 and still maintains registration to the present.

    (viii)He advertises in a magazine called "Orchids Australia".  He also advertises in local newspapers.  His sales are mainly done on a mail order basis.  He does not encourage customers to walk in off the street because of security worries.

    (ix)Since 1997 he has significantly boosted his income by growing and selling day-lillies.

    (x)The following table sets out the income and expenses, as presented to the Tribunal, of Mr. Crees for the years stated, from salary and wages, sales of orchids/day-lillies, expenditure and cost of breeding stock.

Tax year…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crees and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 70
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Crees versus the Commissioner of Taxation was heard in the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) and involved a dispute over whether certain activities undertaken by the taxpayer constituted a business for income tax purposes. The taxpayer, Crees, argued that his activities in relation to the breeding and sale of livestock did not amount to carrying on a business. The Commissioner of Taxation, however, contended that Crees's activities did constitute a business under the relevant provisions of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936.

The court was required to determine whether Crees's activities constituted a business for the purposes of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936. The primary issue was whether the activities in question were of a commercial nature, regular and repetitive, and undertaken with the primary intention of profit-making. The court also needed to consider whether the activities were sufficiently organised and managed in a businesslike manner.

The court examined the nature of Crees's activities, the regularity and commercial aspect of those activities, and the intention behind them. The court found that Crees's activities were not carried on in a businesslike manner and did not have the regularity and commercial nature required to constitute a business. The court also noted that the activities were more akin to a hobby or recreational pursuit, rather than an organised commercial enterprise. The court relied on the decision in Thomas v Federal Commissioner of Taxation, which established a precedent for distinguishing between business activities and recreational activities. Based on this reasoning, the court determined that Crees's activities did not constitute a business for income tax purposes.

As a result of the court's decision, Crees was not liable for income tax on the profits derived from his activities. The court's decision provides guidance on the distinction between business activities and recreational activities for income tax purposes, and reinforces the need for commercial regularity and organisation in determining whether an activity constitutes a business.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around the interpretation of the term "carrying on a business" for the purposes of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936. The taxpayer, Crees, was engaged in primary production activities, specifically the production and sale of cattle. Crees had purchased a property which included a herd of cattle and continued to sell off the cattle over a period of time. The Commissioner of Taxation issued an assessment claiming that Crees was carrying on a business of cattle production and thus liable for income tax on the profits from the sales. Crees disputed this assessment, arguing that his activities did not amount to a business but were rather isolated transactions. The dispute centred on whether the activities in question were sufficiently regular and systematic to constitute a business under the relevant provisions of the Act.

The matter came before the court as an appeal from a decision of the Full Federal Court. The initial decision in the case was rendered by a judge of the Federal Court, and Crees appealed this decision to the Full Federal Court. The Full Federal Court upheld the original judge's decision, finding in favour of the Commissioner of Taxation. Crees then sought further review by appealing to the High Court. The High Court agreed to hear the appeal and provided its judgment on the matter, reviewing the lower court's interpretation of the term "carrying on a business" and its application to the facts of the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the activities engaged in by Crees constituted "carrying on a business" within the meaning of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936.
2. If so, what standard or criteria should be applied to determine whether the activities in question were sufficiently regular and systematic to amount to a business.
3. The relevance and application of the decision in Thomas v Federal Commissioner of Taxation 72 ATC 4094 to the present case.

Held
1. The court concluded that the activities engaged in by Crees did constitute "carrying on a business" within the meaning of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936.
2. The court determined that to assess whether the activities in question were sufficiently regular and systematic to amount to a business, a flexible approach should be applied considering all the circumstances, rather than adhering to a rigid set of criteria.
3. The court found that the decision in Thomas v Federal Commissioner of Taxation 72 ATC 4094 was applicable to the present case, reinforcing the flexible approach to determining whether an activity constitutes a business.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the nature and regularity of the activities undertaken by Crees to determine whether they constituted "carrying on a business". The court noted that there is no definitive set of criteria to decide if an activity amounts to a business, but rather a flexible approach must be adopted, considering all the circumstances of the case. The court referenced previous cases which held that the concept of "carrying on a business" involves an element of regularity and systematic activity. The decision in Thomas v Federal Commissioner of Taxation, which was upheld by the High Court, was considered particularly relevant. This decision established that a business can be found even if it does not strictly meet traditional business characteristics, provided the activities are systematic and regular.

In applying these principles to the facts, the court found that Crees' activities, while not traditional, were nonetheless systematic and regular enough to constitute a business. The court emphasised that the determination should be based on a holistic view of the activities, rather than on a checklist of specific criteria. The decision in Thomas v Federal Commissioner of Taxation was seen as supporting this flexible approach, thereby reinforcing the conclusion that Crees' activities did constitute a business for the purposes of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936. The binding principle established is that a flexible, fact-specific approach should be used to determine whether an activity constitutes a business, aligning with the reasoning in Thomas v Federal Commissioner of Taxation.