Crawford v Taylor

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

[2005] TASSC 77

CITATION:                 Crawford v Taylor [2005] TASSC 77

PARTIES:  CRAWFORD, Stephen Dean
  CRAWFORD, Maree Joy

v
  TAYLOR, Terence Street
  TAYLOR, Florence Ann

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:  ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S:  LDR 38/2005
DELIVERED ON:  16 August 2005
DELIVERED AT:  Launceston
HEARING DATE:  25 July 2005
JUDGMENT OF:  Slicer J

CATCHWORDS:

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Applicants/Plaintiffs:  Mr R W Pearce
             Respondents/Defendants:                Mr K J Stanton
Solicitors:
             Applicants/Plaintiffs:  Douglas & Collins
             Respondents/Defendants:                Shields Heritage

Judgment Number:  [2005] TASSC 77
Number of paragraphs:  15

Serial No 77/2005

File No LDR 38/2005

STEPHEN DEAN CRAWFORD and MAREE JOY CRAWFORD
v TERENCE STREET TAYLOR and FLORENCE ANN TAYLOR

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  SLICER J
  16 August 2005

  1. The applicants are plaintiffs in an action which seeks a declaration of validity of an agreement, an order for specific performance of that contract and an injunction restraining the respondents from taking or attempting to retake possession of land.  These proceedings involve their application for the grant of an interlocutory injunction pending the hearing of the action.  The respondents are the registered proprietors of land on Flinders Island which is the subject of an agreement and these proceedings. 

  1. On 13 April 2002 the parties entered into a lease over approximately 220 hectares of farming land.  A portion of the land, within the boundaries, was reserved by the owners for their own purpose.  That excised portion of the land which comprised the homestead was separately rented to different tenants.  The lease document included the terms of a separate but concurrent agreement affording the applicants an option to purchase all of the land including the homestead.  The terms of the option were:

"1        The Tenant:

(a)throughout the term of this lease shall be entitled to purchase the real estate described in the Item 1 of the Schedule (and including the house) in accordance with the provisions of this clause;

(b)the Tenant shall exercise the said entitlement by serving upon the Landlord a notice of their intention to purchase the said premises in accordance with the provisions of this covenant.

(c)the purchase shall be upon the following terms and conditions:

(i)the purchase price shall be the sum of three hundred thousand dollars ($300,000.00)

(ii)a deposit of 10% of the purchase price shall be paid upon the exercise of the option to purchase and the Tenant and Landlord shall sign a Contract for Sale of land in accordance with the standard form of Contract as annexed hereto and marked with the letter 'A'."

The value of comparable land, as of the date of the option was in the vicinity of $450 per acre.  The applicants agreed to pay the price of $600 per acre.  Concurrent with the lease and option agreements the applicants purchased stock on the property for about $100,000. 

  1. The lease provided for the circumstances which gave rise to the right of termination which states:

"(1)The landlord may end the lease in the manner set out below in the following circumstances:

(a)if the rent or any part of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crawford v Taylor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] TASSC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Crawford and Crawford have brought proceedings against Taylor and Taylor seeking a declaration of validity of an agreement, an order for specific performance of that contract and an injunction restraining the respondents from taking or attempting to retake possession of land. The applicants have applied for the grant of an interlocutory injunction pending the hearing of the action. The respondents are the registered proprietors of land on Flinders Island which is the subject of an agreement and these proceedings. The applicants have entered into a lease over approximately 220 hectares of farming land, reserving a portion for their own purpose. The lease document included the terms of a separate but concurrent agreement affording the applicants an option to purchase all of the land including the homestead. The applicants agreed to pay the price of $600 per acre. Concurrent with the lease and option agreements the applicants purchased stock on the property for about $100,000. The lease provided for the circumstances which gave rise to the right of termination, including if the rent or any part of it or any other moneys owing to the landlord under the lease is or are in arrears for 14 days after the issuing of a tax invoice or if and whenever there shall be a breach or non-performance or non-observance of the covenants and conditions herein contained and on the part of the tenant to be observed or performed and such breach continues for a period of fourteen (14) days after service of a notice on the tenant requiring it to remedy the same. On 30 April 2005 the respondents purported to exercise their rights of termination providing a notice in the following terms: "We the Landlords of the above Property are exercising our rights to terminate the Lease on said Property. On recent inspection of the Property, we were appalled to note the following:- 1 Dead sheep everywhere. On the land & also in the dams. ALL dead sheep to be picked up off the paddocks, & taken out of the dams, & disposed of. 2 We have had complaints from neighbours regarding the state of the property, & animals. 3 Fencing is non existent in comparison to when you took over the Lease (3 years ago), they (fences) are either lying on the ground, or in a tangled mess. – My brother & I made sure all fences were in top condition when you took over the lease. 4 Electric fences to be fully operational. Fences to be the same as when you took over the Lease. This includes gates, wire & posts. 5 Some shelterbelts are wrecked. Trees have not been replaced. – These have to be replanted, & fences around them made stock-proof. Also trees that are down, are to be cut off the fences. 6 Shearing shed to be cleaned up. Window to be replaced. 7 Sheep yards to be repaired, & rubbish removed. 8 The Windmill has been rendered unserviceable. Gearbox & pump to be reconditioned. 9 Driveway to Property has not been maintained. Needs to be graded & gravelled. 10 Guttering on A-frame Barn to be fixed. 11 Railing on bridge to be fixed 12 Culverts x2 to be cleaned out. (main ditch on S/W corner of Property.) 13 One fence on Cattle Yards to be replaced. 14 Insurance – As per lease." Pursuant to terms of the Lease, the respondents claim that the applicants are in breach of the same. The applicants have 14 days in which to comply with the obligations to repair, & maintain the Property. The obligations are as listed above. No further notice will be given. However, the respondents are prepared to give the applicants until the 30th June 2005, to remove all stock from the Property. The applicants contend that there has been no breach, or at least no significant breach, of the terms of the lease and the right of termination would not be upheld. They claim that the evidence to be led at trial demonstrates that they were not in breach of the lease and that they had validly exercised an option to purchase. Moreover, on their case, any claim on the part of the respondents could be properly met through the remedy of damages which in turn would be subsumed by the purchase of the land in accordance with the option. The claim that any act of possession by the respondents pending trial would cause significant harm in that the applicants would be required to find other property to agist their stock and that presently no such land is readily available on Flinders Island. The court found that interlocutory relief ought be granted, as the applicants are in possession of the land and have made all required payments to the respondents in accordance with the terms of the lease. The breaches claimed in the April notice and their effect will require determination at trial. The breaches of alterations to or non-maintenance of internal fencing reflect a policy of method of agricultural practice rather than neglect of the property. In any event the applicants are entitled to argue that failure to replace the generator with one sufficient to service the internal fencing shows that the respondents knew of the change of agricultural policy and were until April 2005 indifferent to change. The failure to place the windmill in a working condition is also a reflection of changed policy rather than neglect. The failure to include the respondents as parties to the insurance agreement especially since insurance was maintained, might at trial be shown to be insufficient to entitle forfeiture. Other matters such as failure to remove sheep, damage to windbreaks and the like, are matters of contention between the parties. Loss of use of the property will cause significant harm to the farming operations of the applicants. Potential harm to the respondents is not equivalent; they retain a right to compensation and the applicants are required to give undertakings as to damages. The applicants have purported to exercise the option to purchase in unconditional terms. If that exercise is held to be valid then any claim for damages on the part of the respondents would be diminished. If the validity of the option is upheld then any interim removal of the applicants' stock might prove irredeemable. The interlocutory injunction ought be granted in the terms sought.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.