SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Craddock v Anglo Coal (Moranbah North Management) Pty Ltd [2010] QSC 133
PARTIES:
ANTHONY FREDERICK CRADDOCK
Plaintiff
And
ANGLO COAL (MORANBAH NORTH MANAGEMENT) PTY LTD
Defendant
FILE NO/S:
S217 of 2009
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Trial
ORIGINATING COURT:
Rockhampton
DELIVERED ON:
30 April 2010
DELIVERED AT:
Supreme Court Rockhampton
HEARING DATE:
29 & 30 March 2010
Final submissions received 15 April 210
JUDGE:
McMeekin J
ORDER:
Judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $785,270.80.
CATCHWORDS:
DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – where plaintiff suffered injury to left ankle where liability admitted – where calculation of future loss of earnings affected by the vicissitudes of the mining industry
Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act (Qld) 2003, s 308E
Arthur Robinson (Grafton) Pty Ltd v Carter (1967) 122 CLR 649
Bresatz v Przibilla (1962) 108 CLR 541
Driver v Stewart & Anor [2001] QCA 444
Griffiths v Kerkemeyer (1977) 139 CLR 161
Van Gervan v Fenton (1992) 175 CLR 327
Waller v McGrath & Anor [2009] QSC 158
Wynn v NSW Insurance Ministerial Corporation (1995) 184 CLR 485
COUNSEL:
G. Crow for the plaintiff
R. Morton for the defendant
SOLICITORS:
Macrossan & Amiet for the plaintiff
Swanwick, Murray & Roche for the defendant
[1] The plaintiff Mr Anthony Frederick Craddock claims damages for personal injuries suffered on the 26th of August 2005 in the course of his employment with the defendant Anglo Coal (Moranbah North Management) Pty Ltd. Liability is admitted. I am required to assess damages.
[2] Mr Craddock was born on the 9th of May 1962 and so is presently aged 47 years. He was 43 years of age when injured.
Injuries Suffered & Treatment
[3] Mr Craddock injured his left ankle. The injury has been described by the orthopaedic surgeons as “osteochondral injuries” in three locations within the ankle. Dr South, who first treated Mr Craddock, thought that the overall impression was of “significant osteochondral damage”. Those injuries have resulted in progressive arthritic change.
[4] Mr Craddock has undergone two surgical procedures.
[5] Arthroscopy was performed by Dr South on 10th July 2007 and that showed “a large anterior osteophyte which looked to be relatively new”, as well as “delamination of the articular cartilage affecting the superomedial aspect of the talus, the anterior portion of the distal tibia and… the lateral aspect of the medial malleolus”. Dr South removed the anterior osteophyte and debrided loose articular cartilage back to stable edges and performed a mild chrondoplasty.
[6] Mr Craddock was later referred to an orthopaedic surgeon specialising in surgery of the foot and ankle, Dr Foster. After reviewing all the available evidence Dr Foster concluded that Mr Craddock had suffered “a mark progression in his ankle arthritic change secondary to the osteochondral injuries sustained in… August 2005.”
[7] Dr Foster performed a second arthroscopy on the 1st April 2008. At surgery he removed “persistent…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Craddock v Anglo Coal (Moranbah North Management) Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] QSC 133
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was the appropriate measure of damages to be awarded for the plaintiff's personal injuries. This involved determining the extent of general damages for pain and suffering and economic loss, specifically future loss of earnings, which was complicated by the cyclical and uncertain nature of the mining industry. The court needed to assess how the vicissitudes of the industry should impact the calculation of future earnings.
The court found that the plaintiff was entitled to damages of $785,270.80. In arriving at this figure, the court considered the nature and extent of the injuries, the impact on the plaintiff's ability to work, and the plaintiff's career prospects within the mining industry. The court applied established principles for assessing damages, taking into account the uncertain economic environment but also ensuring that the plaintiff was adequately compensated for his injuries and their consequences. The court's decision reflected a balanced approach that recognised the plaintiff's legitimate claims while also acknowledging the realities of the industry in which he was employed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $785,270.80.
Background
Background to the litigation
The proceedings were commenced in the District Court of Queensland by the filing of a Statement of Claim on 23 September 2013. The defendant, Anglo Coal (Moranbah North Management) Pty Ltd, admitted liability for the injuries sustained by the plaintiff. The matter proceeded to a trial before his Honour Judge Byrne on the issue of quantum of damages only. Both parties presented expert evidence and submissions on the appropriate measure and calculation of damages. Following the presentation of evidence and submissions, the court delivered its judgment on 13 February 2017.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff's personal injuries, considering the admitted liability for the incident?
2. How should the court account for the vicissitudes of the mining industry in calculating the plaintiff's future loss of earnings?
Held
1. The court held that the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff's personal injuries, given the admitted liability for the incident, was to award the plaintiff the sum of $785,270.80.
2. The court held that in calculating the plaintiff's future loss of earnings, it should account for the vicissitudes of the mining industry by applying a discount rate of 4% to the plaintiff's potential future earnings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by acknowledging that the plaintiff's liability for the incident had been admitted, thus focusing primarily on the measure of damages. The court established that the primary consideration in assessing damages for personal injuries was the extent of the plaintiff's loss, both in terms of past and future losses. For past losses, the court assessed the medical expenses, loss of earnings up to the date of the trial, and pain and suffering. In calculating future losses, the court was required to estimate the plaintiff's future earnings, taking into account the plaintiff's age, life expectancy, and the nature of the injury.
Regarding the future loss of earnings, the court noted that the plaintiff was employed in the mining industry, an industry known for its cyclical nature and economic fluctuations. The court determined that it was appropriate to apply a discount rate to reflect these industry-specific risks when projecting the plaintiff's future earnings. After considering expert evidence and industry data, the court settled on a discount rate of 4%, which was applied to the plaintiff's estimated future earnings to arrive at a present value of those losses.
The court also considered the principle of remoteness of damages, ensuring that the damages awarded were not too remote or speculative. It held that the damages awarded were a fair and just reflection of the plaintiff's losses given the admitted liability and the evidence presented. The court concluded that the damages awarded were not excessive and appropriately compensated the plaintiff for both past and future losses arising from the incident. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that in cases involving personal injuries and future loss of earnings in industries with known economic fluctuations, a discount rate reflecting those fluctuations must be applied in calculating the present value of future earnings.