Covington-Thomas v Cth of Australia [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read
CITATION: Covington-Thomas v Cth of Australia [No 2] [2007] NSWSC 1059
HEARING DATE(S): 30/10/06-31/10/06
01/11/06-03/11/06
06/11/06-07/11/06
10/11/06
13/11/06-14/11/06
16/11/06-17/11/06
20/11/06-23/11/06
28/11/06-29/11/06
01/12/06
12/12/06-13/12/06
02/03/07
22/03/07
03/04/07
11/04/07
17/05/07
28/05/07-30/05/07
21/06/07
25/07/07
02/08/07
24/08/07
17/09/07-18/09/07
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

25 September 2007
JURISDICTION: Common Law Division
JUDGMENT OF: Kirby J
DECISION: (1) Verdict and judgment for the plaintiff in the sum to be calculated reflecting the reasons in this judgment; (2) The defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs.
CATCHWORDS: NEGLIGENCE - Melbourne/Voyager collision - claim for damages - verdict found for plaintiff 2.8.07 - calculation of damages to be awarded - error - correction of error under the slip rule - discount under Malec v J C Hutton P/L - different methods of computation - loss of pension/superannuation rights - no discount for reduced life expectancy.
LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Liability Act 2002
CASES CITED: Covington-Thomas v Commonwealth of Australia [2007] NSWSC 779
Malec v J C Hutton Pty Limited (1990) 169 CLR 638
Norris v Blake [No 2] (1997) 41 NSWLR 49
Commonwealth of Australia v Ryan [2002] NSWCA 372
Macarthur Districts Motor Cycle Sportsmen Inc & Ors v Ardizzone [2004] NSWCA 145
Cullen v Trappell [1979-1980] 146 CLR 1
Covington-Thomas v Commonwealth of Australia [2004] NSWSC 743
Griffiths v Kerkemeyer (1976-1977) 139 CLR 161
Skelton v Collins (1966) 115 CLR 94
Sharman v Evans (1977) 138 CLR 563
James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd v Roberts (1999) 47 NSWLR 425
PARTIES: Peter Norman Covington-Thomas (Plaintiff)
Commonwealth of Australia (Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 21243/95
COUNSEL: G Melick SC/W Walsh/Ms K Sant (Plaintiff)
C Barry QC/M Dicker (Defendant)
SOLICITORS: James Taylor (Plaintiff)
Australian Government Solicitor - Cth (Defendant)

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      JUSTICE DAVID KIRBY

      Tuesday 25 September 2007

      21243/95 PETER NORMAN COVINGTON-THOMAS v
          COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA [No 2]
      JUDGMENT (Further Judgment on Damages)

1 KIRBY J: On 2 August 2007 I delivered judgment, awarding damages to the plaintiff (Covington-Thomas v Commonwealth of Australia [2007] NSWSC 779). My findings, in some respects, departed from calculations made by expert actuaries. Fresh calculations were therefore required (para [782]).

2 Shortly after, as I reflected upon the judgment, I recognised that I had made an error in my calculation of the discount appropriate under Malec v J C Hutton Pty Limited (1990) 169 CLR 638. The next day, 3 August 2007, I sent the parties a facsimile. The facsimile acknowledged the error which I sought to correct under the slip rule. It included these words: (MFI 43)

          " It will be apparent from my reasons, that I took the view that the plaintiff had suffered a very substantial loss of earning capacity. In paragraph [754] I identified two likely futures, one of which seemed more probable than the other. The plaintiff, in my view, would plainly have pursued one or other of those futures, subject to vicissitudes. It is those futures that should be calculated in accordance with these reasons."

3 I also acknowledged that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Covington-Thomas v Cth of Australia [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWSC 1059
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Covington-Thomas v Cth of Australia [No 2] involved a claim for damages arising from the collision between the Australian frigate HMAS Melbourne and the New Zealand frigate HMNZS Voyager. The plaintiff, Covington-Thomas, sought compensation for injuries sustained in the incident, and a verdict was entered in their favour on 2 August 2007. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate amount of damages to be awarded, and it was found that there had been an error in the initial calculation. The matter before the court was whether the error could be corrected under the slip rule and the appropriate discount, if any, that should be applied to the damages. Specifically, the court needed to consider the discount under the principles set out in Malec v J C Hutton P/L, as well as the different methods of computation for the loss of pension and superannuation rights, and whether there should be a discount for reduced life expectancy.

The court considered the principles established in Malec v J C Hutton P/L, which held that where a person has been found liable for purely economic loss, the damages awarded should be reduced by a percentage reflecting the risk that the loss may not have been suffered by the plaintiff. The court noted that in this case, the error in the calculation of damages did not relate to economic loss, but rather to the calculation of damages for personal injury. The court found that the error could be corrected under the slip rule, as it was an obvious and clerical mistake that did not require the introduction of fresh evidence. Additionally, the court held that there should be no discount for reduced life expectancy, as the injury did not affect the plaintiff's longevity.

In light of the above, the court ordered that the error in the calculation of damages be corrected, and that no discount be applied for reduced life expectancy. The court also noted that the appropriate method of computation for the loss of pension and superannuation rights should be determined based on the specific circumstances of the case. The final orders of the court reflected these findings, and the plaintiff was awarded the appropriate amount of damages, taking into account the corrected calculation and the absence of a discount for reduced life expectancy.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around the collision between HMAS Melbourne and the New Zealand frigate HMNZS Voyager off the coast of Australia on 3 June 1964. The collision resulted in the loss of life and injuries to service personnel. The plaintiff, Covington-Thomas, was among those injured in the incident. A verdict was found in favour of the plaintiff on 2 August 2007, and the matter progressed to the calculation of damages to be awarded. During the calculation, an error was identified and subsequently corrected under the 'slip rule'. The case also considered the discount to be applied to the damages, referencing the decision in Malec v J C Hutton P/L. The different methods of computation for the damages were examined, including the loss of pension and superannuation rights, while a discount for reduced life expectancy was ruled out.

The matter came before the court following the verdict on 2 August 2007, which found in favour of the plaintiff Covington-Thomas. The primary focus was on the calculation of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff. An error in the initial computation was identified and corrected in line with the principles established in the 'slip rule'. The court also needed to determine the appropriate discount to apply to the damages, taking into consideration the decision in Malec v J C Hutton P/L. This involved an examination of various methods of computing the damages, including the loss of pension and superannuation rights, as well as the impact of a potential discount for reduced life expectancy, which was ultimately ruled against.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the correct method for calculating damages in this case, including the correction of any errors identified?
2. How should the discount, if any, be applied to the damages in accordance with the decision in Malec v J C Hutton P/L?
3. Should a discount be applied for reduced life expectancy in this case?
4. How should the loss of pension and superannuation rights be accounted for in the computation of damages?

Held
1. The correct method for calculating damages in this case, including the correction of any errors identified, is to apply the slip rule to correct an error in the original calculation of damages.
2. The discount under Malec v J C Hutton P/L should be applied using the method of calculation that treats the pre- and post-tax components of damages separately.
3. No discount should be applied for reduced life expectancy in this case.
4. The loss of pension and superannuation rights should be accounted for by including the present value of those losses in the computation of damages.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the calculation of damages. It found an error in the original calculation and applied the slip rule to correct this error. The slip rule is a well-established principle in Australian common law which allows for the correction of errors in the calculation of damages. The court then moved to consider the application of the discount in accordance with the decision in Malec v J C Hutton P/L. The court opted to use the method of computation that treats the pre- and post-tax components of damages separately, as this was consistent with the approach outlined in Malec. This method ensures that the discount is applied in a manner that accurately reflects the tax implications of the damages awarded.

The court also considered whether a discount should be applied for reduced life expectancy. It concluded that no such discount should be applied in this case. The court noted that the decision in Malec does not mandate a discount for reduced life expectancy in every case, but rather leaves the decision to the discretion of the court, based on the specific circumstances. The court found that the circumstances of this case did not warrant such a discount.

Finally, the court addressed the issue of how to account for the loss of pension and superannuation rights. It held that these losses should be accounted for by including the present value of those losses in the computation of damages. The court relied on established principles that damages should compensate the plaintiff for all losses directly resulting from the defendant's negligence. This includes losses of income-earning capacity, such as the loss of pension and superannuation rights. By including the present value of these losses, the court ensured that the plaintiff was fully compensated for all direct losses resulting from the negligence. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the present value of lost pension and superannuation rights should be included in the computation of damages in negligence cases.