EXPLANATORY STATEMENT
Issued by authority of the Judge Advocate General
Defence Force Discipline Act 1982
Court Martial and Defence Force Magistrate Rules 2020
The Defence Force Discipline Act 1982 (the Act) makes provision for a mechanism, by creating a discipline system, for the maintenance and enforcement of good order and discipline in the Defence Force.
Section 149A of the Act provides that the Judge Advocate General may make rules, to be known as the Court Martial and Defence Force Magistrate Rules, providing for the practice and procedure to be followed by a court martial or Defence Force Magistrate.
The purpose of the Court Martial and Defence Force Magistrate Rules 2020 (the Rules) is to prescribe the rules and processes that are to be undertaken by a court martial and Defence Force Magistrate proceeding under the Act. The Rules consist of 10 Parts that address preliminary matters, charging and summoning an accused person, general trial provisions for superior disciplinary tribunal proceedings, evidence before superior disciplinary tribunal proceedings, and procedure for recording of proceedings and dealing with exhibits. New Rules have been introduced to deal with tendency/coincidence evidence and procedure, as well as pre-trial hearings on the application of a party or on the direction of the Judge Advocate or Defence Force Magistrate. The new Rules change the requirement to swear or affirm a recorder as most proceedings are electronically recorded. The new Rules will also repeal the Court Martial and Defence Force Magistrate Rules 2013 before they sunset on 1 April 2020.
The Rules replace this sunsetting instrument in substantially the same format with some procedural and evidential changes, having regard to superior tribunal discipline reform which is intended to simplify and streamline proceedings. They also update the previous Rules with modernised language and drafting compliance.
Details of the Rules are set out in Attachment A.
The Act specifies no condition that must be met before the power to make the Rules may be exercised.
The Rules are a legislative instrument for the purposes of the Legislation Act 2003.
Commencement
The Rules commence on 1 April 2020.
Regulatory Impact Statement
The Office of Best Practice Regulation advised that no regulatory impact statement was required (OBPR ref ID 26361).
Human Rights Statement
Human rights statement is at Attachment B.
Consultation
Military Justice Steering Group, Australian Defence Force
Part One: preliminary
Rule 1 – Name of rules
This rule provides that the title of the instrument is the Court Martial and Defence Force Magistrate Rules 2020.
Rule 2 – Commencement
This rule provides for the commencement of the Rules on 1 April 2020.
Rule 3 – Authority
This rule provides that this instrument is made under section 149A of the Defence Force Discipline Act 1982.
Rule 4 – Interpretation
This rule provides interpretation of words and phrases used in the Rules.
Rule 5 – Cases not covered by the Act, these Rules or the Regulations
Where a case arises for which no provision is made in the Act or…
Overview
The Defence Force Discipline Act 1982 was enacted to establish a discipline system within the Australian Defence Force (ADF) to maintain good order and discipline. The Act provides a legal framework for disciplinary proceedings against ADF members. The Judge Advocate General has the authority under section 149A of the Act to make rules that govern the practice and procedure of court martials and Defence Force Magistrates, known as the Court Martial and Defence Force Magistrate Rules. The Court Martial and Defence Force Magistrate Rules 2020 were introduced to modernise and streamline disciplinary proceedings under the Act, with an emphasis on simplifying procedures and updating language. The Rules cover various aspects, including preliminary matters, charging and summoning an accused person, trial procedures, evidence, and recording of proceedings. A notable change includes the introduction of rules regarding tendency/coincidence evidence and pre-trial hearings, as well as the adjustment of the requirement to swear or affirm a recorder in light of the increased use of electronic recording. The Rules are designed to ensure that disciplinary proceedings are conducted fairly and efficiently, in line with human rights principles such as the right to a fair trial and the right to liberty and security of the person.
Scope and Application
The Defence Force Discipline Act 1982 (Act) and the Court Martial and Defence Force Magistrate Rules 2020 (Rules) apply to all members of the Australian Defence Force (ADF), including both commissioned and non-commissioned officers, as well as all persons who are subject to the Act, such as reservists and defence force cadets. The Act establishes a disciplinary system to ensure good order and discipline within the ADF, and the Rules prescribe the practice and procedure for court martial and Defence Force Magistrate proceedings under the Act. The Rules apply to all proceedings conducted under the Act, including those involving the charging and trial of ADF members for disciplinary offences. The Rules do not apply to civil proceedings or to criminal proceedings outside the scope of the Act. The Rules extend the application of the Act by providing detailed procedural guidance for court martial and Defence Force Magistrate proceedings, including new provisions for handling tendency/coincidence evidence and pre-trial hearings. The Rules also clarify certain procedures, such as the swearing of recorders where proceedings are electronically recorded. The Rules have a national jurisdictional reach, applying across all Australian states and territories, as they govern proceedings under the Commonwealth Act. The Rules were made under section 149A of the Act, which grants the Judge Advocate General the authority to create these rules. The Office of Best Practice Regulation advised that no regulatory impact statement was required for these Rules. The Rules are compatible with human rights, including the right to liberty and security of the person and the right to a fair trial and fair hearing, as they amplify the practice and procedure available to courts martial and Defence Force Magistrates to give effect to the rights and protections already afforded under the discipline framework.
Key Provisions
- The Court Martial and Defence Force Magistrate Rules 2020, which commenced on 1 April 2020, provide the framework for the practice and procedure of courts martial and Defence Force Magistrates under the Defence Force Discipline Act 1982 (the Act). The Rules cover a range of matters, including the form of charges (Rule 10), the disclosure obligations of the prosecution (Rule 15), the examination of witnesses (Rule 17), the functions of the judge advocate (Rule 28), and the recording of proceedings (Rule 52). The Rules also introduce new procedures for pre-trial hearings (Rule 33), the handling of tendency and coincidence evidence (Rule 35 and Rule 36), and changes to the swearing of recorders when proceedings are electronically recorded (Rule 37).
- The Rules impose various obligations on parties involved in court martial or Defence Force Magistrate proceedings. For instance, the Registrar of Military Justice must provide certain documents to each party (Rule 25), and the judge advocate must ensure that proceedings are conducted in accordance with the Act and the Rules (Rule 28). Additionally, the Rules detail the process for objecting to a member of a court martial (Rule 30) and the manner of voting by members of a court martial (Rule 29).
- Breaches of the Rules may lead to various consequences, though the Rules themselves do not explicitly state the penalties for non-compliance. However, given the overarching framework of the Act, non-compliance with the Rules or the Act could potentially result in disciplinary actions against Defence Force members, which may include fines, imprisonment, or other punitive measures as stipulated in the Act. Furthermore, failure to adhere to the Rules could also impact the fairness and validity of the proceedings, potentially leading to appeals or reviews under the Act.
- Area of Law
- Criminal Law
- Military Law
- Instrument
- Regulation
- Concepts
- Definitions & Interpretation
- Offence Provisions
- Civil Penalty Provisions
- Enforcement Powers