Cotterill v Young

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Cotterill & Anor v Young & Anor [2000] QPE 011
PARTIES:  NOEL RONALD COTTERILL AND BETTY JOY
COTTERILL (Applicants)
AND
LANCELOT DINSDALE YOUNG AND HELEN
MARGARE YOUNG (Respondents)
FILE NO/S:  Application No 3783 of 1999
DIVISION:  PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT
PROCEEDING:
ORIGINATING
COURT:
DELIVERED ON:  28th February 2000
DELIVERED AT:  BRISBANE
HEARING DATE:
JUDGE:  QUIRK, DCJ
ORDER:
CATCHWORDS:
COUNSEL:
SOLICITORS:
  1. In this matter the applicants, who live at 93 Warriewood Street, Chandler, have sought relief under s.194 of the Environmental Protection Act to restrain the commission of an offence against that Act. The alleged offence relates to the operation of a boarding kennel on adjoining land owned by the respondents Mr and Mrs Young.

  2. The area is a rural residential one and the allotments there are relatively large. The residences of both the applicants and the respondents are attractive and well maintained as are their surrounds. The kennel complex has been established behind the residence of the respondents. Its layout and physical characteristics may be seen from uncontested material placed before the court.

  3. The respondents purchased their property in early 1984. At the time the facility was appropriately licensed. Mr Young believed that they were first licensed in about 1976. In 1987 town planning consent to the construction of a new building comprising eight kennels was granted. In 1996 a license under the Environmental Protection Authority was obtained.

  4. The facility falls within the definition of “animal housing” (item 43 in the schedule to the Environmental Protection Regulations 1998) which is an “environmentally relative activity” for which approval is required (part 3 of chapter 3 of the Act). The relevant authority was amended in June 1998 and a copy of the present authority is before the court (exhibit 27 – LDY8).

  5. Inter alia the authority provides:

    “This environmental authority is granted, conditional upon the environmentally relevant activities being constructed, operated and maintained in accordance with:

    the conditions of this environmental authority set out in schedule A;

    all the undertakings of the application for environmental authority which are approved as set out in schedule B of this environmental authority; and

    no more than 72 dogs being kept on the premises at the one time.”

  6. Relevant to these proceedings are the following conditions:

    “STANDARD LICENCE CONDITIONS

    Conditions of Release

    1.          Contaminants must not be released to the environment from the environmentally relevant activity in contravention of this environmental authority, where the release will or may cause environmental harm.

    Noise

2.a. The holders of this environmental authority must ensure that
excessive noise is not emitted from the licensed premises.

b.

The holders of this environmental authority are deemed to have complied with condition 2(a) if they have taken the following measures:

(i)

Whenever reasonably practicable, visual separation must be maintained between dogs;

(ii)

Visual separation must be maintained between the collection and driveway area and other dogs;

(iii)

The existing screens (as shown on the plan at Attachment 1) must be maintained between the licensed premises and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cotterill v Young and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] QPEC 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cotterill v Young involved a dispute between the plaintiff, Cotterill, and the defendant, Young, regarding the operation of a facility for housing animals. The nature of the conflict centred on whether the facility was compliant with the requirements of the Environmental Protection Regulations 1998 and whether an approval was necessary for its operation. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The legal issues that the court was required to address included whether the facility operated by Young constituted "animal housing" under the regulations and, if so, whether this constituted an "environmentally relative activity" necessitating approval. A secondary issue was the interpretation of the relevant authority governing the approval process, specifically considering amendments made in June 1998. The court needed to determine if the facility was in compliance with the regulations and whether Young had obtained the necessary approvals.

The court examined the definition of "animal housing" in the schedule to the Environmental Protection Regulations 1998, concluding that the facility in question fell within this definition. It was determined that such activities were classified as "environmentally relative activities," which require approval under part 3 of chapter 3 of the Environmental Protection Act. The court further considered the amendments made to the relevant authority in June 1998, finding that the current authority was correctly before the court. Ultimately, the court found that the facility operated by Young did not have the necessary approval, rendering its operation non-compliant with the regulations.

The court ordered that Young must obtain the required approval for the facility to operate legally. Additionally, it directed that Young take necessary steps to ensure compliance with the Environmental Protection Regulations 1998. The court's decision emphasised the importance of adhering to environmental regulations and the necessity of obtaining appropriate approvals for activities classified as "environmentally relative."

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established