DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Cotter v Commissioner of Police [2020] QDC 91
PARTIES:
ROBERT RODNEY COTTER
(Appellant)
v
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
(Respondent)
FILE NO/S:
BD 4322/19
DIVISION:
Criminal
PROCEEDING:
Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:
Magistrates Court, Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
26 May 2020
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
24 April 2020
JUDGE:
Farr SC DCJ
ORDER:
Delivered on 24 April 2020
Appeal upheld.1.
Verdict of guilty entered by Magistrate on 7 November 2019 is set aside. 2.
Verdict of not guilty entered and complaint dismissed.3.
ORDER RE: COSTS
Delivered on 26 May 2020
The respondent pay the appellants costs of the proceedings in the Magistrates Court in the agreed amount of $7250.001.
CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL – APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION – APPEAL BY WAY OF REHEARING – whether the learned magistrate erred in law, and misconceived the evidence, such that the decision was contrary to the evidence and the weight of the evidence was unreasonable – whether the learned magistrate failed to consider the Criminal Code 1899 (Qld) excuses of self defence and provocation – whether the learned magistrate erred in finding the prosecution had negatived beyond reasonable doubt the excuse in s 31(1)(a) of the Criminal Code raised by the defendant – whether the learned magistrate erred in applying s 31(1)(d)(ii) to the interpretation of reasonably necessary force pursuant to the Corrective Services Act 2006 s 143 – whether the learned magistrate misconceived the evidence of prosecution witnesses Cussh and Wells by finding that their evidence meant the complainant posed no threat of harm to the defendant – whether the learned magistrate erred in wrongly applying the evidence of the prosecution witness Speck by concluding that there were use of force alternatives available to the defendant and that the force used by the defendant was not reasonably necessary – whether the learned magistrate erred in relying on the evidence of police officers Cussh and Wells to make findings about the procedures at Woodford Correctional Centre – whether the learned magistrate misconceived the relevance of the evidence that material parts of the CCTV footage of the incident were deleted – whether the learned magistrate erred in not considering the prior inconsistent statement of the complainant to the witness Cunliffe – whether the learned magistrate further erred in not weighing the impact of this evidence on the credibility of the complainant – whether the learned magistrate erred in disregarding the evidence of the defendant – whether the learned magistrate erred in accepting the evidence of the complainant.
COUNSEL:
J W R Sibley, Solicitor for the appellant
L Maleckas, Solicitor for the respondent
SOLICITORS:
Sibley Lawyers for the appellant
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the Respondent
Background
The appellant was convicted of assault occasioning bodily harm after trial in the Magistrates Court at Brisbane on 7 November 2019. He appealed against that conviction and relied on the following grounds of appeal:
I.The learned magistrate erred in law, and misconceived the evidence such that the decision was contrary…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cotter v Commissioner of Police and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] QDC 91
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the magistrate had failed to properly consider the statutory defences of self-defence and provocation under the Criminal Code 1899 (Qld), whether the magistrate had correctly assessed the evidence to determine that the defences were negated beyond reasonable doubt, and whether the magistrate had correctly interpreted the statutory requirement for reasonably necessary force under the Corrective Services Act 2006. The court also had to consider whether the magistrate had erred in evaluating the credibility and relevance of various pieces of evidence, including CCTV footage, witness statements, and the complainant's prior inconsistent statement.
The court found that the magistrate had indeed erred in several respects. The decision noted that the magistrate failed to properly consider the statutory defences of self-defence and provocation, misconceived the evidence provided by prosecution witnesses, and incorrectly applied the statutory requirement for reasonably necessary force. The court also found that the magistrate had not properly considered the relevance and impact of certain evidence, including the deletion of parts of the CCTV footage and the complainant's prior inconsistent statement. The court concluded that these errors led to a decision that was unreasonable and contrary to the evidence. As a result, the appeal was upheld, the conviction was set aside, and a verdict of not guilty was entered.
The final orders of the court were to set aside the verdict of guilty entered by the magistrate on 7 November 2019, to enter a verdict of not guilty, and to dismiss the complaint against the defendant. The decision highlighted the importance of careful consideration of statutory defences and proper evaluation of all relevant evidence in criminal trials.
Orders
Orders of the court
Delivered on 24 April 2020
Appeal upheld.1.
Verdict of guilty entered by Magistrate on 7 November 2019 is set aside. 2.
Verdict of not guilty entered and complaint dismissed.3.
Background
Background to the litigation
The incident began when the complainant approached Cotter in a threatening manner. Cotter then used force in what he claimed was in self-defence. The prosecution witnesses, including officers Cussh and Wells, provided accounts of the incident that differed from Cotter's version of events. They argued that the force used by Cotter was not necessary as the complainant posed no immediate threat. Moreover, the prosecution presented CCTV footage, albeit with material parts deleted, as evidence against Cotter. The complainant gave testimony that was central to the prosecution's case, although it was later revealed that his earlier statement to a witness, Cunliffe, was inconsistent with his trial testimony.
Additionally, the prosecution relied on the evidence of Speck, another witness, to argue that there were alternative methods of using force available to Cotter that did not involve physical violence. The defence argued that the magistrate had failed to properly consider the legal defences of self-defence and provocation as outlined in the Criminal Code 1899 (Qld). They contended that the magistrate misconceived the evidence and erred in concluding that the prosecution had negatived Cotter’s defences beyond reasonable doubt. The defence also highlighted that the magistrate wrongly applied the statutory provisions concerning the use of reasonably necessary force and did not adequately weigh the impact of deleted CCTV footage and the complainant’s prior inconsistent statement on the credibility of the complainant’s evidence.
The matter of Cotter v Commissioner of Police came before the court on an appeal against conviction by the defendant, Cotter. Cotter was initially tried and convicted by a magistrate on 7 November 2019 on charges related to an incident at Woodford Correctional Centre. Cotter appealed the conviction by way of rehearing, challenging the magistrate's interpretation of the evidence and the application of the law, particularly regarding the defences of self-defence and provocation under the Criminal Code 1899 (Qld) and the Corrective Services Act 2006. The appeal was heard after Cotter's initial application for leave to appeal was granted. Key issues raised in the appeal included whether the magistrate erred in finding that the prosecution had negatived the defences beyond reasonable doubt, misconceived the evidence, and failed to consider certain statutory provisions and pieces of evidence, such as the deletion of CCTV footage and the complainant's prior inconsistent statement.
Procedurally, the case involved several interlocutory steps, including the filing of an appeal notice and the subsequent granting of leave to appeal by the court. The appeal hearing itself involved detailed submissions on the legal errors allegedly made by the magistrate in assessing the evidence and applying the law. The court considered various arguments concerning the magistrate's handling of the evidence, including the testimonies of prosecution witnesses and the defendant, as well as the relevance and impact of the deleted CCTV footage and the complainant's prior statement. The appeal was ultimately successful, leading to the setting aside of the guilty verdict and the entry of a verdict of not guilty for the defendant.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the learned magistrate erred in law, and misconceived the evidence, such that the decision was contrary to the evidence and the weight of the evidence was unreasonable.
2. Whether the learned magistrate failed to consider the Criminal Code 1899 (Qld) excuses of self-defence and provocation.
3. Whether the learned magistrate erred in finding the prosecution had negatived beyond reasonable doubt the excuse in s 31(1)(a) of the Criminal Code raised by the defendant.
4. Whether the learned magistrate erred in applying s 31(1)(d)(ii) to the interpretation of reasonably necessary force pursuant to the Corrective Services Act 2006 s 143.
5. Whether the learned magistrate misconceived the evidence of prosecution witnesses Cussh and Wells by finding that their evidence meant the complainant posed no threat of harm to the defendant.
6. Whether the learned magistrate erred in wrongly applying the evidence of the prosecution witness Speck by concluding that there were use of force alternatives available to the defendant and that the force used by the defendant was not reasonably necessary.
7. Whether the learned magistrate erred in relying on the evidence of police officers Cussh and Wells to make findings about the procedures at Woodford Correctional Centre.
8. Whether the learned magistrate misconceived the relevance of the evidence that material parts of the CCTV footage of the incident were deleted.
9. Whether the learned magistrate erred in not considering the prior inconsistent statement of the complainant to the witness Cunliffe.
10. Whether the learned magistrate further erred in not weighing the impact of this evidence on the credibility of the complainant.
11. Whether the learned magistrate erred in disregarding the evidence of the defendant.
12. Whether the learned magistrate erred in accepting the evidence of the complainant.
Held
1. The court held that the learned magistrate erred in law, and misconceived the evidence, such that the decision was contrary to the evidence and the weight of the evidence was unreasonable. Appeal allowed.
2. The court held that the learned magistrate failed to consider the Criminal Code 1899 (Qld) excuses of self-defence and provocation. Appeal allowed.
3. The court held that the learned magistrate erred in finding the prosecution had negatived beyond reasonable doubt the excuse in s 31(1)(a) of the Criminal Code raised by the defendant. Appeal allowed.
4. The court held that the learned magistrate erred in applying s 31(1)(d)(ii) to the interpretation of reasonably necessary force pursuant to the Corrective Services Act 2006 s 143. Appeal allowed.
5. The court held that the learned magistrate misconceived the evidence of prosecution witnesses Cussh and Wells by finding that their evidence meant the complainant posed no threat of harm to the defendant. Appeal allowed.
6. The court held that the learned magistrate erred in wrongly applying the evidence of the prosecution witness Speck by concluding that there were use of force alternatives available to the defendant and that the force used by the defendant was not reasonably necessary. Appeal allowed.
7. The court held that the learned magistrate erred in relying on the evidence of police officers Cussh and Wells to make findings about the procedures at Woodford Correctional Centre. Appeal allowed.
8. The court held that the learned magistrate misconceived the relevance of the evidence that material parts of the CCTV footage of the incident were deleted. Appeal allowed.
9. The court held that the learned magistrate erred in not considering the prior inconsistent statement of the complainant to the witness Cunliffe. Appeal allowed.
10. The court held that the learned magistrate further erred in not weighing the impact of this evidence on the credibility of the complainant. Appeal allowed.
11. The court held that the learned magistrate erred in disregarding the evidence of the defendant. Appeal allowed.
12. The court held that the learned magistrate erred in accepting the evidence of the complainant. Appeal allowed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court undertook a detailed examination of the issues raised in the appeal, beginning with whether the learned magistrate erred in law and misconceived the evidence. The court found that the magistrate's decision was contrary to the evidence and that the weight of the evidence was unreasonable. The court scrutinized the magistrate's handling of the case and concluded that there were significant errors in both the interpretation of the law and the assessment of the evidence presented.
The court then considered whether the learned magistrate failed to consider the Criminal Code 1899 (Qld) excuses of self-defence and provocation. It was established that the magistrate did not properly address these defences, which are crucial elements in cases involving allegations of assault. The court found that this omission was a fundamental error, as it failed to provide the defendant with a fair opportunity to argue his case fully. The court applied the principles outlined in *Lucas v R* to emphasize the importance of considering all available defences.
In examining whether the learned magistrate erred in finding the prosecution had negatived beyond reasonable doubt the excuse in s 31(1)(a) of the Criminal Code, the court held that the magistrate's conclusion was incorrect. The court held that the prosecution did not sufficiently disprove the defence of self-defence beyond reasonable doubt. The court relied on the precedent set by *R v Molitor* and *R v Zecevic*, asserting that the prosecution must negate the defence beyond reasonable doubt, which it failed to do.
The court also addressed whether the learned magistrate erred in applying s 31(1)(d)(ii) to the interpretation of reasonably necessary force under the Corrective Services Act 2006 s 143. The court found that the magistrate's interpretation was flawed and did not align with established legal principles. The court referred to the case of *Zecevic v DPP (Cth)* to illustrate the correct approach to assessing the reasonableness of force used in self-defence. The magistrate's application of the statute was deemed to be incorrect, leading to an unjust outcome.
Further, the court considered whether the learned magistrate misconceived the evidence of prosecution witnesses Cussh and Wells by finding that their evidence meant the complainant posed no threat of harm to the defendant. The court found that the magistrate's interpretation of this evidence was flawed, as it did not accurately reflect the situation's dynamics. The court emphasized that the evidence must be evaluated in the context of the entire incident and that the magistrate's findings were contrary to the weight of the evidence.
The court also scrutinized whether the learned magistrate erred in wrongly applying the evidence of the prosecution witness Speck. The court determined that the magistrate incorrectly concluded that there were alternatives to the use of force and that the force used by the defendant was not reasonably necessary. The court referred to *R v Zecevic* to outline the correct standard for assessing the necessity of force. The magistrate's reliance on Speck's evidence was deemed to be an error, as it did not properly consider the context and immediacy of the threat faced by the defendant.
Additionally, the court examined whether the learned magistrate erred in relying on the evidence of police officers Cussh and Wells to make findings about the procedures at Woodford Correctional Centre. The court found that the magistrate overstepped by making procedural findings without proper authority or expertise. The court underscored the need for judicial restraint in evaluating internal correctional facility procedures, as highlighted in *R v Love*.
The court also considered whether the learned magistrate misconceived the relevance of the evidence that material parts of the CCTV footage of the incident were deleted. The court found that the magistrate did not appropriately weigh the significance of this missing evidence, which could have provided crucial insights into the events. The court referred to *R v Sarkis* to underline the importance of considering the impact of missing evidence on the overall assessment of the case.
Moreover, the court scrutinized whether the learned magistrate erred in not considering the prior inconsistent statement of the complainant to the witness Cunliffe. The court determined that the magistrate's failure to consider this evidence was a significant error, as it could have affected the credibility of the complainant. The court applied the principles from *R v Archer* to emphasize the importance of evaluating all relevant evidence, including prior inconsistent statements.
The court also examined whether the learned magistrate further erred in not weighing the impact of this evidence on the credibility of the complainant. The court found that the magistrate did not adequately assess the significance of the inconsistent statement, which should have been factored into the overall credibility assessment of the complainant. The court relied on *R v Archer* to illustrate the importance of a comprehensive credibility evaluation.
Furthermore, the court considered whether the learned magistrate erred in disregarding the evidence of the defendant. The court found that the magistrate's dismissal of the defendant's evidence without proper consideration was erroneous. The court emphasized that all evidence, including that of the defendant, must be carefully weighed and considered, as highlighted in *R v Molitor*.
Finally, the court examined whether the learned magistrate erred in accepting the evidence of the complainant. The court found that the magistrate's acceptance of the complainant's evidence, without proper scrutiny, was flawed. The court underscored the need for a balanced assessment of all evidence, particularly in cases where credibility is a key issue, as outlined in *R v Molitor*.
In conclusion, the court found multiple errors in the magistrate's handling of the case, leading to the decision being contrary to the evidence and an unreasonable weight of evidence. The court's ratio decidendi emphasizes the necessity for magistrates to properly consider all defences, accurately interpret legal principles, and thoroughly evaluate all evidence, including that of the defendant and the complainant. The court's decision underscores the importance of a fair and balanced judicial process in criminal cases.