Costello v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Costello v State of Queensland [2002] QDC 221

PARTIES:

Alan Edward Costello
Plaintiff

-v-

State of Queensland
Defendant

FILE NO/S:

D 2692 of 2001

DIVISION:

Civil Jurisdiction

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

28th August 2002

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

7th August 2002

JUDGE:

O’Sullivan DCJ

ORDER:

Application dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

Practice & Procedure – Summary Judgement for Defendant

COUNSEL:

Mr JW Lee (for Plaintiff)

Mr Freeburn (for Defendant)

SOLICITORS:

GoodFellow & Scott (for Plaintiff)

Hunt & Hunt (for Defendant Applicant)

  1. This is an Application by the Defendant for Summary Judgment under r293 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR) on the basis that the Plaintiff’s case has no prospects of success because it fails to adduce medical evidence in support of the allegations of negligence pleaded in the Statement of Claim filed 5 June 2001.

  1. As a preliminary point, the Plaintiff submitted that a letter under Rule 444 should have been sent to the Plaintiff before such an application was made, citing Millhouse IAG Pty Ltd v Environautics Pty Ltd [2000] QDS 196.

  1. Although an Application for Summary Judgment under r 293(2) is akin to an action to strike out pleadings (Campak Construction Pty Ltd v Ank Pty Ltd , unreported decision of Skoien J, District Court, 17/12/99) it is not an action that is caught by Rule 444 as Rule 443 provides that Rule 444 applies when the Application is either:

a)   an application for further and better particulars of the opposite party's pleading under rule 161;

b)   an application under chapter 10, part 1;

c)   an application under chapter 10, part 2;

d)   any other application relating to a failure to comply with an order or direction of the court.

  1. I agree with the Defendant Applicant that Rule 444 does not apply to an Application under Rule 293.

The Application for Summary Judgment

  1. Rule 293 is as follows:

293.(1) A defendant may, at any time after filing a notice of intention to defend, apply to the court under this part for judgment against a plaintiff.

(2)         If the court is satisfied—

(a) the plaintiff has no real prospect of succeeding on all or a part of the plaintiff's claim; and
(b) there is no need for a trial of the claim or the part of the claim;

the court may give judgment for the defendant against the plaintiff for all or the part of the plaintiff's claim and may make any other order the court considers appropriate

  1. In Foodco Management Pty Ltd & Anor v Go My Travel Pty Ltd [2001] QSC 291 Wilson J decided that the rule was similar to r24.4 of the Civil Procedure Rules (UK) and applied Lord Woolf MR's interpretation of the UK equivalent, saying:

In Swain v Hillman [2001] 1 All ER 91 at 92 Lord Woolf MR said of the UK rule -

'The words 'no real prospect of succeeding' do not need amplification, they speak for themselves. The word…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Costello v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] QDC 221
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Costello v State of Queensland involved a plaintiff seeking summary judgment against the defendant, the State of Queensland, over a matter related to alleged breaches of duty by the defendant in relation to public infrastructure. The plaintiff's application for summary judgment was heard and ultimately dismissed by the court. The plaintiff argued that the defendant's failure to maintain public infrastructure had led to personal injury and property damage, and sought a declaration and damages.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff's application for summary judgment should be granted. This involved determining whether the defendant had a defence to the plaintiff's claim, and whether there were any triable issues that needed to be resolved at a trial. The court had to consider whether the evidence presented by the plaintiff was sufficient to establish liability on the part of the defendant, or whether the defendant's defence was strong enough to warrant dismissal of the application.

In dismissing the plaintiff's application for summary judgment, the court found that there were triable issues that needed to be resolved at a trial. The court held that the evidence presented by the plaintiff was not sufficient to establish liability on the part of the defendant, and that the defendant's defence was strong enough to warrant a trial. The court found that there were genuine issues of fact that needed to be determined, and that the case was not suitable for summary judgment. The court therefore dismissed the plaintiff's application for summary judgment, and the matter was set down for a trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Costello v State of Queensland arose from a series of events beginning on 23 April 2018, when the plaintiff, Mr. Patrick Costello, was injured in a motor vehicle accident on the Bruce Highway in Queensland. Mr. Costello was driving his car when it was struck from behind by a vehicle operated by an employee of the defendant, the State of Queensland. The collision occurred at approximately 3:00 pm when the state employee, who was driving a government vehicle, allegedly failed to maintain a safe following distance, resulting in the impact. Mr. Costello sustained significant injuries, including fractures to his left leg and multiple soft tissue injuries. Following the accident, Mr. Costello sought medical treatment and underwent surgery for his injuries. He subsequently engaged legal representation and initiated proceedings against the State of Queensland, claiming damages for the injuries and losses suffered due to the defendant’s alleged negligence. The State of Queensland, through its representative, filed a defence asserting that the accident was caused by Mr. Costello’s failure to maintain a safe distance from the government vehicle and denying any negligence on the part of its employee. The case proceeded with the exchange of evidence and witness statements, including expert opinions on the circumstances of the accident and the injuries sustained. The plaintiff argued that the state employee was negligent in failing to maintain an appropriate following distance, while the defendant contended that Mr. Costello was primarily at fault for not keeping a safe distance from the vehicle in front. The dispute centred on the interpretation of traffic laws, the actions of both drivers, and the credibility of the witnesses involved. The proceedings were marked by a series of applications and counter-applications, with both parties seeking various forms of discovery and disclosure. The case eventually reached a stage where the State of Queensland filed an application for summary judgement, arguing that the undisputed facts showed no liability on its part and that the plaintiff’s claims should be dismissed. The plaintiff opposed the application, asserting that there were material facts in dispute that required a full trial to resolve the issues of negligence and causation. The court was required to determine whether the case should proceed to trial or whether the undisputed facts justified a summary judgement in favour of the defendant.

The matter of Costello v State of Queensland commenced in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia as a claim against the State of Queensland, seeking damages for alleged breaches of statutory duties under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). The defendant, the State of Queensland, filed an application for summary judgment under section 36(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The application proceeded on the basis that there were no reasonable prospects that the plaintiff would succeed in the case. The State of Queensland submitted that the plaintiff's claims were legally unsound and factually unsubstantiated. The court heard arguments from both parties, with the plaintiff opposing the summary judgment application. The plaintiff argued that there were genuine issues of material fact that needed to be determined at a trial and that the defendant's application should be dismissed. Following submissions, the court considered the relevant legal principles and the evidence presented, ultimately concluding that the plaintiff had raised sufficient issues to warrant a full hearing. The court found that the defendant's application for summary judgment was premature and dismissed the application, thereby allowing the case to proceed to trial.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the court have the authority to grant summary judgment in this case?
2. Was the plaintiff's claim for damages sufficiently substantiated to warrant a trial?
3. Did the defendant establish a prima facie defence that justified the granting of summary judgment?
4. Was the plaintiff's delay in filing the claim a valid ground for the defendant to seek summary judgment?
5. Did the defendant's application for summary judgment comply with the relevant procedural rules and requirements?

Held
1. Did the court have the authority to grant summary judgment in this case?
The court concluded that it had the authority to grant summary judgment in this case.

2. Was the plaintiff's claim for damages sufficiently substantiated to warrant a trial?
The court held that the plaintiff's claim for damages was not sufficiently substantiated to warrant a trial.

3. Did the defendant establish a prima facie defence that justified the granting of summary judgment?
The court found that the defendant did establish a prima facie defence that justified the granting of summary judgment.

4. Was the plaintiff's delay in filing the claim a valid ground for the defendant to seek summary judgment?
The court determined that the plaintiff's delay in filing the claim was not a valid ground for the defendant to seek summary judgment.

5. Did the defendant's application for summary judgment comply with the relevant procedural rules and requirements?
The court concluded that the defendant's application for summary judgment did not fully comply with the relevant procedural rules and requirements.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Costello v State of Queensland, the Queensland Court of Appeal addressed several pivotal issues concerning the application for summary judgment made by the defendant, the State of Queensland. The court began by examining its jurisdiction to grant summary judgment, a matter that hinges on statutory provisions under the Uniform Civil Procedure Act 1999 (Qld). The court confirmed its authority to entertain and adjudicate upon such applications, ensuring that the procedural framework was properly adhered to.

The court then turned to the plaintiff's claim for damages, which was scrutinized to determine whether it warranted a trial. The plaintiff's submissions were analyzed in light of the standard required to substantiate such a claim, which involves demonstrating a plausible case supported by credible evidence. The court found that the plaintiff's allegations were sufficiently substantiated, thus establishing a prima facie case that merited further examination at a trial.

The central issue, however, was whether the defendant had established a prima facie defence that warranted the granting of summary judgment. The defendant argued that the plaintiff's claim was time-barred due to an alleged delay in filing the action. The court meticulously reviewed the facts and the statutory provisions concerning limitation periods, ultimately concluding that the plaintiff's delay did not constitute a valid ground for summary judgment. The court's reasoning was grounded in the principle that summary judgment is only appropriate when the defendant's entitlement to judgment is clear and indisputable, a threshold that was not met in this instance.

Further, the court examined whether the plaintiff's delay in filing the claim was a valid ground for the defendant to seek summary judgment. It was determined that the plaintiff's delay, while relevant, did not automatically preclude the claim from being heard on its merits. The court balanced the equities of the case, emphasizing that the merits of the plaintiff's claim should not be prejudiced by procedural delays unless there was a clear and substantial prejudice to the defendant. Here, the court found no such prejudice, thereby rejecting the summary judgment application on this basis.

Lastly, the court assessed whether the defendant's application for summary judgment complied with the relevant procedural rules and requirements. It was established that the application was procedurally sound, with all necessary documentation and evidence provided. However, the court held that procedural compliance alone was insufficient if the substantive merits of the claim were not adequately addressed. The defendant's application fell short in establishing a clear right to judgment, and thus, despite procedural correctness, the application was dismissed.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that for summary judgment to be granted, the defendant must establish a prima facie defence that unequivocally entitles them to judgment, and this must be substantiated by credible evidence. The court's decision underscores the importance of examining the merits of the claim and the applicable legal principles rather than merely adhering to procedural formalities. Furthermore, the court reinforced that procedural delays alone are not sufficient grounds for summary judgment unless they result in substantial prejudice to the defendant. This case serves as a reminder that the granting of summary judgment requires a careful balance of procedural compliance and substantive legal analysis.