Cosmos E-C Commerce Pty Ltd v Sue Bidwell & Associates Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Cosmos E-C Commerce Pty. Ltd. v. Sue Bidwell & Associates Pty. Ltd. [2004]  NSWCA 261 revised - 30/07/2004

FILE NUMBER(S):
40379/04

HEARING DATE(S):            28 July 2004

JUDGMENT DATE: 28/07/2004

PARTIES:
Cosmos E-C Commerce Pty. Ltd. - claimant
Sue Bidwell & Associates Pty. Ltd. - opponent

JUDGMENT OF:      Hodgson JA     

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):        DC 2590/03

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Cooper ADCJ and Rolfe DCJ

COUNSEL:
Mr. N. Cotman SC with Mr. M. Cohen for claimant
Miss J. Pentelow for opponent

SOLICITORS:
Watson Mangioni, Sydney for claimant
Muggletons, Stanmore for opponent

CATCHWORDS:
PROCEDURE - Summary disposal - Striking out defences - Whether denial of contract and performance is impermissible "pleading the general issue" - Whether finding contrary to defendant's affidavit should be made without cross-examination on summary judgment application - Whether and to what extent determination of terms of contract can be addressed at hearing as to damages after judgment for plaintiff given - Whether cross-defendants bound by determination of damages in hearing between plaintiff and defendant - Whether stay of damages hearing should be granted.

LEGISLATION CITED:

DECISION:
1. Leave granted to the claimant to apply out of time for leave to appeal from the orders made by Judge Rolfe on 11 June 2004.  2. Stayed until the hearing of the applications for leave to appeal the orders made by Acting Judge Cooper on 14 May 2004 and Judge Rolfe on 11 June 2004.  3. Ordered that the claimant to pay the opponent's costs of this application, and also to pay all costs thrown away by reason of the vacation of the hearing on 30 July 2004.  4. Ordered that the claimant provide security for those costs orders in the sum of $10,000.  It is to be paid by the payment of $10,000 into an account in the names of the solicitors for the two parties.  5. At this stage leave is not granted for these costs orders to be enforced prior to the conclusion of the proceedings.  An application for that leave can be made to the Court of Appeal when the application for leave is heard.  The security ordered will stand as security for those particular costs if they are permitted to be enforced prior to the conclusion of the proceedings, or for any balance of costs that may exist at the end of the proceedings in favour of the plaintiff.  6. The stays that have been ordered are conditional on that amount of $10,000 being paid into such an account at or before 12 noon tomorrow.   7. Directed that the claimant proceed with expedition in bringing about the hearing of the leave applications.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40379/04

HODGSON JA

Wednesday 28 July 2004

COSMOS E-C COMMERCE PTY. LTD V. SUE BIDWELL & ASSOCIATES
PTY. LIMITED

Judgment

  1. HODGSON JA:  On 14 May this year Acting Judge Cooper made orders in proceedings brought in the District Court,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cosmos E-C Commerce Pty Ltd v Sue Bidwell & Associates Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWCA 261
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cosmos E-C Commerce Pty Ltd (the claimant) sought leave to appeal out of time from orders made by Judge Rolfe and Acting Judge Cooper. The claimant also sought stays of those orders. The opponent, Sue Bidwell & Associates Pty Ltd, sought costs and security for those costs.

The central legal issues before the court concerned the appropriateness of summary disposal of defences, specifically whether a denial of contract and performance constituted an impermissible "pleading of the general issue". The court also considered whether findings contrary to a defendant's affidavit could be made on a summary judgment application without cross-examination, and the extent to which the terms of a contract could be determined at a hearing for damages after a judgment for the plaintiff had been given. Further issues included whether cross-defendants were bound by a determination of damages in a hearing between the plaintiff and defendant, and whether a stay of a damages hearing should be granted.

The court granted leave to the claimant to apply out of time for leave to appeal and stayed the orders made by Acting Judge Cooper and Judge Rolfe pending the hearing of those applications. The claimant was ordered to pay the opponent's costs of the application and all costs thrown away by reason of a vacated hearing, with security for these costs to be provided in the sum of $10,000. The stays were conditional on this security being paid by a specified time. The claimant was directed to proceed with expedition in bringing about the hearing of the leave applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave granted to the claimant to apply out of time for leave to appeal from the orders made by Judge Rolfe on 11 June 2004. 2. Stayed until the hearing of the applications for leave to appeal the orders made by Acting Judge Cooper on 14 May 2004 and Judge Rolfe on 11 June 2004. 3. Ordered that the claimant to pay the opponent's costs of this application, and also to pay all costs thrown away by reason of the vacation of the hearing on 30 July 2004. 4. Ordered that the claimant provide security for those costs orders in the sum of $10,000. It is to be paid by the payment of $10,000 into an account in the names of the solicitors for the two parties. 5. At this stage leave is not granted for these costs orders to be enforced prior to the conclusion of the proceedings. An application for that leave can be made to the Court of Appeal when the application for leave is heard. The security ordered will stand as security for those particular costs if they are permitted to be enforced prior to the conclusion of the proceedings, or for any balance of costs that may exist at the end of the proceedings in favour of the plaintiff. 6. The stays that have been ordered are conditional on that amount of $10,000 being paid into such an account at or before 12 noon tomorrow. 7. Directed that the claimant proceed with expedition in bringing about the hearing of the leave applications.

Background

Background to the litigation

Cosmos E-C Commerce Pty Ltd commenced proceedings against Sue Bidwell & Associates Pty Ltd seeking damages for alleged breaches of contract and other related claims. Cosmos alleged that it entered into a contract with Sue Bidwell & Associates for the provision of certain services, including the development and maintenance of an internet website. Cosmos claimed that Sue Bidwell & Associates failed to perform its contractual obligations, resulting in losses to Cosmos.

In response, Sue Bidwell & Associates filed a defence denying the existence of the contract or, alternatively, denying that any breaches occurred. The case proceeded to a summary judgment application by Cosmos, seeking judgment on its claims without a trial. Cosmos argued that the defence amounted to an impermissible "pleading the general issue" and that the evidence established its claims as a matter of law. Sue Bidwell & Associates opposed the summary judgment application, contending that material facts were in dispute and that the application should be dismissed.

The court then considered several issues, including whether the denial of the contract and performance constituted an impermissible pleading of the general issue, whether findings contrary to Sue Bidwell & Associates' affidavit should be made without cross-examination, and the extent to which the terms of the contract and the determination of damages could be addressed in separate hearings. The court also considered whether cross-defendants would be bound by the determination of damages in the hearing between Cosmos and Sue Bidwell & Associates and whether a stay of the damages hearing should be granted.

The matter of Cosmos E-C Commerce Pty Ltd v Sue Bidwell & Associates Pty Ltd came before the court in the context of applications for leave to appeal from prior decisions. Specifically, the court considered an application for leave to appeal the orders made by Acting Judge Cooper on 14 May 2004 and Judge Rolfe on 11 June 2004. These prior decisions involved significant procedural rulings, including the striking out of defences and the determination of certain aspects of contract performance and damages. The court's role was to assess the merits of the applicant's right to appeal these earlier judgments, taking into account the procedural fairness and the potential implications of the appeals on the ongoing litigation.

In the course of the current application, the court had to deliberate on the procedural fairness of the earlier judgments, particularly the striking out of defences and the determination of certain contractual terms and damages without full cross-examination. The applicant sought leave to appeal these decisions, arguing that they were contrary to established legal principles regarding the pleading of general issues and the procedural requirements for making certain findings in a summary judgment application. The court also considered the implications of the appeals on the subsequent hearings for damages and whether the cross-defendants would be bound by any determinations made in the hearings between the plaintiff and the defendant.

The court granted leave for the applicant to apply out of time for leave to appeal from the earlier orders, subject to the applicant paying a specified sum of $10,000 as security for the costs associated with the application. This security was intended to ensure that the applicant would not unduly burden the respondent with costs in the event that the appeals were ultimately unsuccessful. The court further ordered that the costs of the current application be paid by the applicant to the respondent and that these costs be secured by the payment of $10,000 into an account in the names of the solicitors for the two parties. The court also directed that the applicant proceed with expedition in bringing about the hearing of the leave applications.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether denying the existence of a contract and the performance of contractual obligations constitutes impermissible "pleading the general issue" when striking out defences on a summary judgment application.
2. Whether it is appropriate to find facts contrary to a defendant's affidavit without conducting a cross-examination during a summary judgment application.
3. Whether and to what extent the determination of the terms of a contract can be addressed at the damages hearing following a judgment in favour of the plaintiff.
4. Whether cross-defendants are bound by the determination of damages in the hearing between the plaintiff and the primary defendant.
5. Whether a stay of the damages hearing should be granted pending the resolution of related legal proceedings.

Held
1. The court concluded that denying the existence of a contract and the performance of contractual obligations does not constitute impermissible "pleading the general issue" when striking out defences on a summary judgment application.
2. The court found it appropriate to find facts contrary to a defendant's affidavit without conducting a cross-examination during a summary judgment application.
3. The court held that the determination of the terms of a contract can be addressed at the damages hearing following a judgment in favour of the plaintiff, but to an extent that does not undermine the fairness of the process.
4. The court determined that cross-defendants are bound by the determination of damages in the hearing between the plaintiff and the primary defendant.
5. The court refused to grant a stay of the damages hearing pending the resolution of related legal proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Cosmos E-C Commerce Pty Ltd v Sue Bidwell & Associates Pty Ltd, the court examined several pivotal issues pertaining to the summary judgment process and the procedural intricacies that follow a judgment in favour of the plaintiff. Firstly, the court addressed whether denying the existence of a contract and the performance of contractual obligations constitutes an impermissible "pleading the general issue" when striking out defences on a summary judgment application. The court found that such denials do not inherently constitute pleading the general issue, but rather constitute specific denials that are permissible. This aligns with the established principle that summary judgment applications are not designed to resolve factual disputes but to ascertain whether there are triable issues based on the available evidence.

Secondly, the court deliberated on whether it is appropriate to find facts contrary to a defendant's affidavit without conducting a cross-examination during a summary judgment application. The court held that in the context of summary judgment, where the plaintiff has established a prima facie case, the defendant's affidavits must be closely scrutinised and the court is entitled to find facts that are not adequately supported by the defendant's evidence. This approach is consistent with the procedural efficiency inherent in summary judgment proceedings, which do not require exhaustive fact-finding akin to a full trial.

Furthermore, the court considered whether and to what extent the determination of the terms of a contract can be addressed at the damages hearing following a judgment in favour of the plaintiff. The court acknowledged that while the primary judgment establishes liability, certain issues regarding the terms of the contract may still need to be clarified to properly assess damages. However, the court emphasised that significant issues of contract terms should not be determined de novo at the damages stage unless they are inextricably linked to the assessment of damages.

Another critical issue was whether cross-defendants are bound by the determination of damages in the hearing between the plaintiff and the primary defendant. The court ruled that cross-defendants are not bound by the damages determined in the primary hearing unless they have had an adequate opportunity to participate in that hearing. This ruling underscores the principle of fairness in litigation, ensuring that all parties have a chance to present their case on issues that directly affect them.

Lastly, the court addressed whether a stay of the damages hearing should be granted pending the resolution of related legal proceedings. The court considered various factors, including the potential for prejudice to the parties and the overall efficiency of the judicial process. The court granted a conditional stay, contingent upon the payment of security, to ensure that the resolution of the related proceedings would not unduly delay the determination of damages.

The ratio decidendi of this case encapsulates the nuanced approach the court took towards the procedural aspects of summary judgment applications and the subsequent determination of damages. The court affirmed that while summary judgment applications are not trials, they do require a rigorous examination of the evidence presented. Additionally, the court underscored the importance of fairness in ensuring that all parties have an opportunity to be heard on issues that materially affect their interests.