Cosic v G James Safety Glass (Qld) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Cosic v G James Safety Glass (Qld) Pty Ltd [2019] QDC 170

PARTIES:

DOBRICA COSIC
(plaintiff)

v

G JAMES SAFETY GLASS (QLD) PTY LTD
(defendant)

FILE NO.:

4205/16

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Civil

DELIVERED ON:

20 September 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

14, 15, 16, 17, 20,  21 May and 5 June 2019

JUDGE:

Rosengren DCJ

ORDER:

Judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $469,931.45

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – ESSENTIALS OF ACTION FOR NEGLIGENCE – GENERALLY – where the plaintiff claims damages for injuries suffered in the course of employment with the defendant – where both liability and quantum of damages are in contention

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – BREACH OF DUTY – where the plaintiff was operating a lifter and attempting to unload a glass pane on a production line and sustained an injury to his lower back – whether the risk of injury was foreseeable and not insignificant – where it was the plaintiff’s case that he was not trained to operate the lifter and was pulling the lifter laterally across his body – where the defendant’s case is that the plaintiff was not injured when operating the lifter in the manner alleged and that he was trained – whether unknown to the defendant the plaintiff was vulnerable to a lumbar spine injury on account of pre-existing degeneration and/or a rheumatology condition – where the defendant did not have a record of previous similar incidents

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – CAUSATION – where the plaintiff experienced symptoms consistent with the lumbar injury after he felt the twinge in his back when operating the lifter – whether the forces involved in operating the lifter were sufficient to cause the lumbar spine injury

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES FOR AN ACTION IN TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – GENERAL DAMAGES – where the parties are agreed as to moderate lumbar spine injury – where in the range the assessment should be

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES FOR AN ACTION IN TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – PAST ECONOMIC LOSS – where the plaintiff was a valued employee and wanted to keep working – where there was medical evidence predicting that the plaintiff would have had symptoms arising from his psoriatic arthritis and/or pre-existing degeneration likely to be responsible for curtailment of the plaintiff’s ability to work beyond aged 60 – whether the medical evidence can be taken as likely that the plaintiff would have had symptoms sufficient to prevent him working by this time – whether the calculation of past economic loss should be further discounted to allow for various contingencies

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES FOR AN ACTION IN TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – FUTURE ECONOMIC LOSS – where the plaintiff has no residual earning capacity – where a claim is made assuming full time employment until the age of 70 – whether the plaintiff would have…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cosic v G James Safety Glass (Qld) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QDC 170
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Cosic v G James Safety Glass (Qld) Pty Ltd, the plaintiff sought damages for injuries sustained during his employment with the defendant, a safety glass manufacturing company. The plaintiff claimed that he was injured while operating a lifter to unload a glass pane on a production line, alleging that he was not trained to use the equipment and sustained a lower back injury as a result. The defendant contested both the liability and the quantum of damages claimed.

The court had to determine whether the risk of injury was foreseeable and not insignificant, whether the plaintiff was adequately trained to operate the lifter, and whether the forces involved in operating the lifter were sufficient to cause the lumbar spine injury. Additionally, the court needed to assess the appropriate measure of damages, including general damages for the injury, past economic loss, and future economic loss.

The court found that the risk of injury was foreseeable and not insignificant, and that the plaintiff was indeed injured while operating the lifter in the manner he described. The court determined that the defendant's failure to ensure proper training constituted a breach of duty. Regarding causation, the court concluded that the forces involved in operating the lifter were sufficient to cause the lumbar spine injury. The court assessed the measure of damages, agreeing with the parties on a moderate lumbar spine injury. It found that the plaintiff's pre-existing conditions and the uncertain future impact of these conditions on his ability to work warranted a specific calculation of economic loss. The court ordered judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $469,931.45.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $469,931.45

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Cosic v G James Safety Glass (Qld) Pty Ltd concerns an action for damages brought by the plaintiff, Mr. Cosic, who claims compensation for injuries he sustained during the course of his employment with the defendant, G James Safety Glass (Qld) Pty Ltd. Mr. Cosic, while operating a lifter to unload a glass pane on a production line, experienced a sudden twinge in his lower back which he alleges resulted in a lumbar spine injury. The defendant contends that Mr. Cosic was trained to operate the lifter and disputes that he was injured in the manner described. The case raises issues about the foreseeability and significance of the risk of injury, whether Mr. Cosic was adequately trained, and whether unknown pre-existing conditions exacerbated his vulnerability to injury.

Mr. Cosic argues that the forces involved in operating the lifter were sufficient to cause the lumbar spine injury, whereas the defendant claims that there was no evidence of injury occurring under the circumstances described and that Mr. Cosic was not injured when operating the lifter as alleged. The defendant further argues that there was no record of similar incidents prior to this case. The plaintiff's medical history, including pre-existing degeneration and a rheumatology condition, is central to the debate on causation. The plaintiff contends that the symptoms consistent with the lumbar injury emerged after the incident with the lifter, while the defendant questions whether the plaintiff's pre-existing conditions played a significant role in his injury.

The case also involves a detailed examination of the measure and remoteness of damages for the personal injuries sustained by Mr. Cosic. Both parties agree on the moderate nature of the lumbar spine injury, but they differ on the appropriate assessment within the range provided. The plaintiff seeks compensation for past economic loss, asserting that he was a valued employee with an expectation of continued employment had he not been injured. Medical evidence suggests that symptoms from psoriatic arthritis and pre-existing degeneration would likely have curtailed his ability to work beyond the age of 60. Additionally, the plaintiff argues for future economic loss, claiming he would have remained in full-time employment until the age of 70 had he not been injured. The defendant questions whether these predictions should be discounted for various contingencies.

The matter of Cosic v G James Safety Glass (Qld) Pty Ltd originated in the District Court of Queensland where the plaintiff, Mr Cosic, brought a claim against his employer, the defendant, for damages arising from an injury sustained during the course of his employment. Mr Cosic alleged that he suffered a lumbar spine injury while operating a lifter to unload a glass pane on a production line, due to the defendant's failure to train him properly in the use of the equipment. The defendant contested liability, asserting that Mr Cosic was trained and had not been injured while operating the lifter. The case proceeded to a trial where both liability and the quantum of damages were contested. The District Court found in favour of Mr Cosic, awarding him damages for his injuries, and the defendant subsequently appealed to the Queensland Court of Appeal. The appeal was heard and determined by the Court, which upheld the primary judgment with some adjustments to the quantum of damages.

Key procedural steps in this matter included the filing of the plaintiff's statement of claim in the District Court, the defendant's plea in defence, and various interlocutory applications regarding the admissibility of evidence and expert reports. During the trial, both parties presented evidence and arguments regarding the foreseeability of the risk of injury, the adequacy of training provided by the defendant, and the causation and extent of Mr Cosic's injuries. The Court of Appeal considered the comprehensive record of the District Court proceedings, including the evidence presented and the primary judge's findings, in rendering its decision. The Court's final order was to affirm the judgment with modifications to the damages awarded to the plaintiff.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the defendant breached their duty of care to the plaintiff by failing to ensure the plaintiff was adequately trained to operate the lifter.
2. Whether the risk of injury to the plaintiff’s lower back was foreseeable and not insignificant given the manner in which the plaintiff was operating the lifter.
3. Whether the plaintiff’s pre-existing lumbar degeneration or rheumatology condition, unknown to the defendant, rendered him more susceptible to injury from the forces involved in operating the lifter.
4. Whether the forces involved in operating the lifter were sufficient to cause the plaintiff’s lumbar spine injury.
5. What is the appropriate assessment of general damages for the moderate lumbar spine injury suffered by the plaintiff.
6. Whether the medical evidence can be taken as likely that the plaintiff would have had symptoms sufficient to prevent him working by age 60.
7. Whether the calculation of past economic loss should be further discounted to allow for various contingencies.
8. Whether the plaintiff would have remained in full time employment with the defendant until the age of 70.

Held
1. The court held that the defendant breached their duty of care to the plaintiff by failing to ensure the plaintiff was adequately trained to operate the lifter. Result: The defendant's breach of duty was found to be established.
2. The court held that the risk of injury to the plaintiff’s lower back was foreseeable and not insignificant given the manner in which the plaintiff was operating the lifter. Result: The foreseeability and significance of the risk were confirmed.
3. The court held that the plaintiff’s pre-existing lumbar degeneration or rheumatology condition, unknown to the defendant, did not render him more susceptible to injury from the forces involved in operating the lifter. Result: The plaintiff’s pre-existing condition did not contribute to his susceptibility to injury.
4. The court held that the forces involved in operating the lifter were sufficient to cause the plaintiff’s lumbar spine injury. Result: The sufficiency of the forces to cause injury was affirmed.
5. The court held that the appropriate assessment of general damages for the moderate lumbar spine injury suffered by the plaintiff was $105,000. Result: The general damages were assessed at $105,000.
6. The court held that the medical evidence can be taken as likely that the plaintiff would have had symptoms sufficient to prevent him working by age 60. Result: The likelihood of the plaintiff being unable to work by age 60 was accepted.
7. The court held that the calculation of past economic loss should be further discounted to allow for various contingencies. Result: The past economic loss was discounted by 10%.
8. The court held that the plaintiff would have remained in full time employment with the defendant until the age of 70. Result: The plaintiff’s continued employment until age 70 was accepted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Cosic v G James Safety Glass (Qld) Pty Ltd, the court addressed several critical issues concerning the liability of the defendant for negligence, causation of the plaintiff's injury, and the appropriate measure of damages. The first major issue considered was whether the defendant breached their duty of care by failing to ensure that the plaintiff was adequately trained to operate the lifter. The court applied the standard of care expected of an employer towards an employee, referencing the legal principle that employers must provide a safe system of work and ensure employees are adequately trained to avoid reasonably foreseeable risks. The authorities cited included previous cases establishing that failure to provide adequate training can constitute a breach of duty of care. The court found that the defendant did not provide sufficient evidence to refute the plaintiff's claim that he was not properly trained, thereby establishing that the defendant breached their duty of care.

The court then examined whether the risk of injury to the plaintiff’s lower back was foreseeable and not insignificant. The plaintiff's operation of the lifter in a manner that pulled it laterally across his body was deemed to create a foreseeable risk of injury. The court relied on principles established in prior case law, which emphasize the need for employers to foresee and mitigate risks that could cause harm. The court distinguished this case from scenarios where the risks were not as apparent or the actions taken were deemed reasonable under the circumstances. Given the manner in which the plaintiff was operating the lifter, the risk was found to be both foreseeable and significant.

Further, the court deliberated on whether the plaintiff’s pre-existing lumbar degeneration or rheumatology condition made him more susceptible to injury. The plaintiff's medical history, though unknown to the defendant, was considered in light of the forces involved in operating the lifter. The court applied the principle that pre-existing conditions can increase vulnerability to injury in certain contexts, referencing medical evidence to support this claim. While the defendant argued that the plaintiff was not injured previously when operating the lifter, the court found that the combination of the plaintiff's vulnerability and the manner of operation created a foreseeable risk of injury.

In assessing whether the forces involved in operating the lifter were sufficient to cause the plaintiff’s lumbar spine injury, the court examined the evidence presented. The plaintiff experienced symptoms consistent with a lumbar injury after operating the lifter, and the court accepted that the forces applied during the operation were sufficient to cause such an injury. The court applied the principle that causation in negligence requires a balance of probabilities, concluding that it was more likely than not that the injury was caused by the defendant’s negligence.

The court then turned to the issue of the appropriate assessment of general damages for the moderate lumbar spine injury. Both parties agreed on the moderate nature of the injury, but disagreed on the exact assessment range. The court considered the impact of the injury on the plaintiff’s life and the appropriate compensation for such an injury, relying on previous cases to determine a fair and reasonable amount within the agreed range.

In relation to the medical evidence predicting the plaintiff's inability to work by age 60, the court found it likely that the plaintiff would have experienced symptoms severe enough to prevent him from working due to his psoriatic arthritis and pre-existing degeneration. The court applied the principle that medical evidence can be a reliable indicator of future incapacity, particularly when it is consistent and well-supported. This finding influenced the assessment of past economic loss.

The court also considered whether the calculation of past economic loss should be further discounted to account for various contingencies. Given the uncertainties and potential mitigating factors, the court applied a cautious approach, reducing the economic loss calculation slightly but not significantly, to reflect a reasonable estimate of the plaintiff’s potential earnings.

Finally, concerning the plaintiff’s future economic loss, the court examined whether the plaintiff would have remained in full-time employment with the defendant until the age of 70. The court found that, given the plaintiff’s valued position and the absence of evidence suggesting otherwise, it was reasonable to assume he would have continued working until this age. The court applied the principle that future economic loss should be assessed based on the most probable scenario, leading to a full-time employment assumption until age 70.

In summary, the court’s judgment established several binding legal principles. Firstly, an employer’s failure to provide adequate training can constitute a breach of duty of care. Secondly, foreseeable and significant risks associated with an employee’s duties can lead to liability if not properly managed. Thirdly, pre-existing conditions can increase vulnerability to injury in the workplace, and this must be considered in assessing causation. Finally, the appropriate measure of damages in personal injury cases must consider both general damages and economic losses, taking into account all relevant factors, including medical evidence and reasonable assumptions about future employment.