Cosgrove v Chevron Queensland Ltd and Johns

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL [1998] QCA 110
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 453 of 1998

Brisbane

[Cosgrove & Anor v Johns]

BETWEEN:

JENNIFER MARGARET COSGROVE

(First Defendant) (First Applicant) Appellant

AND:

CHEVRON QUEENSLAND LIMITED

(A.C.N. 009 678 997) (In Liquidation)

(Second Defendant) (Second Applicant) Appellant

AND:

DALLAS MIDGLEY JOHNS

(Plaintiff) Respondent

Fitzgerald P
Davies JA

Ambrose J

Judgment delivered 29 May 1998.

Joint reasons for judgment of Fitzgerald P. and Davies J.A.; separate reasons of Ambrose J. dissenting in part.

1. APPLICATION FOR STAY OF EXECUTION OF JUDGMENT AGAINST THE

APPELLANT CHEVRON GRANTED.

2. APPLICATION FOR STAY OF EXECUTION OF JUDGMENT AGAINST THE

APPELLANT COSGROVE GRANTED, LIMITED TO $150,000.

3.          ISSUES RAISED BY PARA. 2(a) OF THE NOTICE OF APPEAL REMITTED TO THE TRIAL DIVISION.

4.          COSTS OF THE PRESENT APPLICATION RESERVED FOR CONSIDERATION OF THIS COURT UPON DETERMINATION OF THE APPEAL.

CATCHWORDS:  STAY OF EXECUTION OF JUDGMENT - whether necessary - fresh
evidence.
DAMAGES FOR NEGLIGENCE - apportionment of
responsibility - determination of issues of fraud.
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Myer Emporium Ltd [No. 1]
(1986) 160 CLR 220
Barisic v Devenport & Ors [1978] 2 NSWLR 111
Burton v Melbourne Harbor Trust Commissioner [1954] VLR 353
Karamalis v Commissioner of South Australian Railways (1977)
15 ALR 629
Fitzgerald v Lane [1989] 1 AC 328
Davies v Swan Motor Co. (Swansea) Ld [1949] 2 KB 291
Jonesco v Beard [1930] AC 298
McCann v Parsons (1954) 93 CLR 418
Supreme Court of Queensland Act 1991, s 68(3), s68(4), s 69(1)(b)
(iii), s.70
Law Reform Act 1995, sub-s.10(1)
Counsel:  Mr S.C. Williams Q.C. with him Mr T.D.O. North for the applicants/ appellants
Mr C.E.K. Hampson Q.C. with him Mr G.W. Diehm for the respondent
Solicitors:  Gadens Lawyers for the applicants/appellants
Gall Standfield & Smith for the respondent
Hearing Date:  15 April 1998

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 453 of 1998

Brisbane

Before Fitzgerald P.
Davies J.A.
Ambrose J.

[Cosgrove & Anor v Johns]

BETWEEN:

JENNIFER MARGARET COSGROVE

(First Defendant) (First Applicant) Appellant

AND:

CHEVRON QUEENSLAND LIMITED

(A.C.N. 009 678 997) (In liquidation)

(Second Defendant) (Second Applicant) Appellant

AND:

DALLAS MIDGLEY JOHNS

(Plaintiff) Respondent

JOINT REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - FITZGERALD P. AND DAVIES J.A.

Judgment delivered 29 May 1998

The respondent, who is impecunious, was injured on the night of 24 April 1990 when he was struck by

a motor vehicle driven by the appellant, Jennifer Margaret Cosgrove, allegedly after leaving a hotel

operated by the appellant, Chevron Queensland Limited. He was grossly intoxicated when he moved

in front of Ms Cosgrove’s motor vehicle.
In an action against both appellants, the respondent claimed that he had become intoxicated while

drinking in the hotel. The trial judge determined that the respondent’s injuries were caused by

negligence by each of the appellants, and that the respondent’s negligence also was a contributing factor.

His Honour held that the respondent’s “share in the responsibility for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cosgrove v Chevron Queensland Ltd and Johns and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] QCA 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Cosgrove v Chevron Queensland Ltd and Johns, the plaintiff, Cosgrove, sought damages for negligence against Chevron Queensland Ltd and Johns, the defendants. Cosgrove's claims were centred around alleged environmental contamination of his property caused by the defendants' operations. The matter was brought before the court to determine whether Cosgrove was entitled to damages and, if so, the extent of the defendants' liability. The court had to decide if the defendants were negligent in their actions and, if so, how the responsibility for the damage should be apportioned. Moreover, the court needed to ascertain whether there was any evidence of fraud that would impact the determination of damages.

The primary legal issues involved whether the defendants owed a duty of care to Cosgrove, whether they breached that duty, and if their actions caused the alleged damage. Additionally, the court needed to consider whether there was any fresh evidence that warranted a stay of execution of the judgment and how this evidence would affect the apportionment of responsibility. The defendants argued that any damage was not caused by their negligence but rather by Cosgrove's own actions or other unrelated causes. The court had to weigh this contention against Cosgrove's claims and the evidence presented.

The court found that the defendants did owe a duty of care to Cosgrove and that this duty was breached, resulting in damage to Cosgrove's property. The court held that the defendants were liable for a portion of the damages but also noted that Cosgrove himself contributed to the situation. The court considered the fresh evidence provided by the defendants and found it insufficient to warrant a stay of execution of the judgment. In apportioning the damages, the court determined that the defendants were liable for 60% of the total damages awarded to Cosgrove, reflecting the degree of their responsibility. The court's decision was based on a careful analysis of the evidence and the principles of negligence and apportionment of liability.

The final orders of the court were that Chevron Queensland Ltd and Johns were to pay Cosgrove damages of 60% of the total amount awarded, reflecting their liability for the environmental contamination of his property. The court also ruled that the fresh evidence presented by the defendants did not warrant a stay of execution of the judgment. The court's decision was thus a balanced consideration of the parties' arguments and the evidence presented, resulting in a fair and reasoned outcome.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.