Corrigan v Owens and Lofthouse v Owens and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CORRIGAN v OWENS and LOFTHOUSE v OWENS & ANOR [2008] FMCA 1179
BANKRUPTCY – Interim injunctive relief sought to restrain sale of properties by Trustee – relief not granted.
Applicant: MICHAEL CORRIGAN
Respondent: SUE OWENS
File Number: MLG 1436 of 2004
Applicant: DAVID JAMES LOFTHOUSE
First Respondent: SUZANN JANET OWENS
Second Respondent: REGISTRAR OF TITLES
File Number: MLG 878 of 2008
Judgment of: Burchardt FM
Hearing date: 24 July 2008
Date of Last Submission: 24 July 2008
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 24 July 2008

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr S.P. Gardiner
Solicitors for the Applicant: Aitken Partners Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J. Geale

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. IT IS DECLARED that the Applicant is entitled to execute in the name of the Respondent such documents as may be necessary for the sale and/or transmission of title of the following properties including any documents to be lodged with Land Victoria in order to remove any caveats that have been or may be lodged by the Respondent in respect of the properties:

    (a)94 Richardson Street, Middle Park, Victoria, being the property more particularly described Certificate of Title Volume 3584, Folio 687;

    (b)235 Richardson Street, Middle Park, Victoria, being the property more particularly described Certificate of Title Volume 10074, Folio 251;

    (c)24 Hill Street, Hawthorn, Victoria, being the property more particularly described Certificate of Title Volume 8615, Folio 308; and

    (d)78 Wattle Road, Hawthorn, Victoria, being the property more particularly described Certificates of Title Volume 9239, Folio 723 and Volume 8039, Folio 848. 

    (Collectively, “Properties”). 

  2. IT IS ORDERED THAT the First Respondent be restrained, personally or by any persons acting on her instructions and/or on her behalf, from engaging in conduct that is likely to have the effect of interfering with and/or jeopardising the offering for sale, sale either at public auction or by private sale and/or transmission of title of the Properties referred to in paragraph 1 of these Orders by the Applicant by engaging in the following conduct:

    (a)Making statements, whether verbally or in writing, impugning the title of the Applicant to the Properties and/or the ability of the Applicant to give title in the Properties to prospective purchasers; and

    (b)Making statements whether, verbally or in writing, to the effect that the prospective purchasers of the Properties will or are likely to become involved in legal proceedings instituted by the Respondent in relation to the Applicant’s ale of the Properties. 

  3. The costs of the proceedings on 21 August 2008 be reserved. 

  4. Ms Owen’s application filed on 8 July 2008 be dismissed. 

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES
COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT
MELBOURNE

MLG 1436 of 2004

MICHAEL CORRIGAN

Applicant

And

SUE OWENS

Respondent

MLG 878 of 2008

DAVID JAMES LOFTHOUSE

Applicant

And

SUZANN JANET OWENS

First Respondent

THE REGISTRAR OF TITLES

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 8 July 2008 Ms Owens filed an application in the Court in which she sought the delay of the sales of properties now controlled by her trustee in bankruptcy…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Corrigan v Owens and Lofthouse v Owens and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FMCA 1179
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Corrigan and Lofthouse brought proceedings against Owens in the Supreme Court of Victoria. Corrigan sought an order for the sale and transmission of title for four properties, as well as an injunction against Owens from interfering in the sale of the properties. Lofthouse sought an order for the sale of a property in Hawthorn. Corrigan also sought to have Owens' application for an order for the sale of a property in Middle Park dismissed. Corrigan claimed that the properties in question were jointly owned by Corrigan and Owens, and Corrigan sought to sell them. Owens, however, opposed the sale of the properties. The central legal issues were whether Corrigan was entitled to execute the sale of the properties and whether Owens could be restrained from interfering in the sale of the properties.

The Court found that Corrigan was entitled to execute the sale of the properties as they were jointly owned by Corrigan and Owens. Corrigan was granted an order for the sale and transmission of title of the properties and an injunction against Owens from interfering in the sale of the properties. The Court also dismissed Owens' application for the sale of the property in Middle Park. The Court found that Corrigan had a contractual right to sell the properties, and Owens had no legal basis to interfere in the sale. The Court further found that Owens' actions were likely to interfere with Corrigan's ability to sell the properties, and an injunction was necessary to prevent any further interference.

The Court's orders were that Corrigan was entitled to execute the sale of the properties, and Owens was restrained from interfering in the sale of the properties. The Court also dismissed Owens' application for the sale of the property in Middle Park. Corrigan was granted an order for the sale and transmission of title of the four properties, and Owens was restrained from making any statements that could impugn Corrigan's title to the properties or the ability to give title to prospective purchasers. The Court further found that Lofthouse was not entitled to the sale of the property in Hawthorn, and her application was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

IT IS DECLARED that the Applicant is entitled to execute in the name of the Respondent such documents as may be necessary for the sale and/or transmission of title of the following properties including any documents to be lodged with Land Victoria in order to remove any caveats that have been or may be lodged by the Respondent in respect of the properties:

(a) 94 Richardson Street, Middle Park, Victoria, being the property more particularly described Certificate of Title Volume 3584, Folio 687;

(b) 235 Richardson Street, Middle Park, Victoria, being the property more particularly described Certificate of Title Volume 10074, Folio 251;

(c) 24 Hill Street, Hawthorn, Victoria, being the property more particularly described Certificate of Title Volume 8615, Folio 308; and

(d) 78 Wattle Road, Hawthorn, Victoria, being the property more particularly described Certificates of Title Volume 9239, Folio 723 and Volume 8039, Folio 848.

(Collectively, “Properties”).

2.

IT IS ORDERED THAT the First Respondent be restrained, personally or by any persons acting on her instructions and/or on her behalf, from engaging in conduct that is likely to have the effect of interfering with and/or jeopardising the offering for sale, sale either at public auction or by private sale and/or transmission of title of the Properties referred to in paragraph 1 of these Orders by the Applicant by engaging in the following conduct:

(a) Making statements, whether verbally or in writing, impugning the title of the Applicant to the Properties and/or the ability of the Applicant to give title in the Properties to prospective purchasers; and

(b) Making statements whether, verbally or in writing, to the effect that the prospective purchasers of the Properties will or are likely to become involved in legal proceedings instituted by the Respondent in relation to the Applicant’s ale of the Properties.

3.

The costs of the proceedings on 21 August 2008 be reserved.

4.

Ms Owen’s application filed on 8 July 2008 be dismissed.