Corella Valley Corporation Pty Ltd v Campbell

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Corella Valley Corporation Pty Ltd v Campbell [2024] QLC 2
PARTIES: Corella Valley Corporation Pty Ltd
(applicant)
v
Ian Charles Campbell
(respondent)
FILE NO: MRA226-23
DIVISION:  General Division
PROCEEDING: Determination of compensation payable for renewal of mining leases
DELIVERED ON: 19 January 2024
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARD ON: Submissions closed on 22 December 2023
HEARD AT: On the papers
MEMBER: JR McNamara
ORDERS:

1.   In respect of the application for renewal of ML 2701, compensation for access through Lot 554 on SP177589 is determined at nil ($0).

2.   In respect of the application for renewal of ML 90106, compensation for access through Lot 554 on SP177589 is determined at nil ($0).

CATCHWORDS:

ENERGY AND RESOURCES – MINERALS – MINING FOR MINERALS – COMPENSATION – where the applicant applied for the renewal of two mining leases – where part of the access track to the mining leases is located on land held by the respondent – where part of the access track is gazetted road –where the respondent claims for diminution of use made or which may be made of the land caused by the applicant’s use of the part of the access track on the respondent’s land – where the respondent claims “loss or expense” of a valuer’s report and legal fees pursuant to s 281(3)(a)(vi) Mineral Resources Act 1989 (Qld)

Land Court Act 2000 s 27A
Mineral and Energy Resources (Common Provisions) Act 2014 s 91
Mineral Resources Act 1989 s 279, s 281

Corella Valley Corporation Pty Ltd v Campbell [2019] QLC 44
Corella Valley Corporation Pty Ltd v Campbell [2021] QLC 26

Lonergan & Anor v Friese [2020] QLAC 3

Moreton Bay Regional Council v Mekpine Pty Ltd & Anor (No 2) (2014) 35 QLCR 273; [2014] QLAC 5

APPEARANCES: Not applicable

Background

  1. Pursuant to s 279(1) of the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (MRA), a mining lease shall not be granted, or in this case renewed, unless compensation has been agreed between the mining lessee and landowner or otherwise determined by the Land Court. The MRA promotes a cooperative approach between landowners and mining lessees.[1]

  1. Twice before these same mining leases (ML 2701 and ML 90106), these same parties, and the same issue of unresolved compensation have been brought to this Court.[2] On both those occasions, compensation for the renewal of ML 2701 and ML 90106 (first for a 2-year term, and second, for the remaining 3 years of a 5-year term), was determined to be nil. I will refer to these as the 2019 decision and the 2021 decision throughout these reasons.

  2. Compensation in this matter is for “access only” through Mr Campbell’s property, Rosebud.  The mining leases are actually located on another property, Brightlands, to the south of Rosebud, where it appears compensation for access and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Corella Valley Corporation Pty Ltd v Campbell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QLC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Corella Valley Corporation Pty Ltd sought to renew two mining leases, ML 2701 and ML 90106, located on Brightlands, a property south of Rosebud, held by the respondent, Mr Campbell. The dispute centred on compensation for the use of an access track that traverses Rosebud, which is also owned by Mr Campbell. Mr Campbell claimed compensation for the diminution of use of his land caused by the applicant's use of the access track, as well as for the cost of a valuer's report and legal fees under s 281(3)(a)(vi) of the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (Qld). The primary legal issue was whether the applicant was liable for compensation for the impact of its mining activities on Mr Campbell's land. Given the previous decisions in 2019 and 2021, where the Court had determined compensation to be nil due to insufficient evidence, the Court had to assess if the new valuer's report provided sufficient evidence to support Mr Campbell's claims.

The Court assessed the evidence presented by Mr Campbell, noting that the 2019 decision highlighted inadequacies in the evidence supporting the extent of disturbance. In the 2021 decision, the Court again found no basis for compensation due to a lack of valuation evidence. This time, Mr Campbell had engaged a solicitor and commissioned a valuer's report. However, the Court found that the report did not provide sufficient information to determine the extent of the diminution of use. The Court also considered the use of the access track by other miners and the public, and concluded that the applicant should only be liable for the proportion of the loss attributable to its own operations. As there was another miner using the access track, the Court found that the applicant should not bear the full amount of Mr Campbell's loss.

The Court determined that the applicant was not liable for compensation for access through Lot 554 on SP177589 for either mining lease renewal. The Court found that the valuer's report did not provide sufficient information to determine the extent of the diminution of use, and that the applicant should only be liable for the proportion of the loss attributable to its own operations. The Court also noted that the use of the access track by other miners and the public meant that the applicant should not bear the full amount of Mr Campbell's loss. Consequently, the Court determined compensation for access through Lot 554 on SP177589 to be nil ($0) for both mining leases.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In respect of the application for renewal of ML 2701, compensation for access through Lot 554 on SP177589 is determined at nil ($0).

2. In respect of the application for renewal of ML 90106, compensation for access through Lot 554 on SP177589 is determined at nil ($0).

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In the 2019 decision it would appear that the same, or a similar photograph was provided to the Court. The following was said at [18]-[21]:“The access track is used by at least one other miner. It is available to the public as part of a mining heritage trail.Corella is, therefore, not the only user of the access track. I agree with Corella’s submission that it should only be liable to compensate Mr Campbell for the proportion of loss attributable to its own operations.I have no information about how often travellers access the mining heritage trail. I suspect it is not a major attraction given the condition of the road and the warnings posted at the entrance; nonetheless, there will be some hardy souls who undertake that trail each year. Given the lack of information about the public use of the track for the heritage tail, I decline to discount the amount payable by Corella for that use.As there is another miner using the access track, and that miner’s use must contribute to the diminution of Mr Campbell’s use of the access track land, I cannot accept that Corella should bear the full amount of Mr Campbell’s loss. Indeed, in similar cases, where the track was used by “any number of persons who have leases, claims or prospecting” the Land and Resources Tribunal had declined to make any award for access. As it appears that Corella’s use of the track is comparable to the other miner’s use, Corella’s contribution to any loss should be no more than 50%.”[8] [8]Corella Valley Corporation Pty Ltd v Campbell [2019] QLC 44.Evidence of use Despite the clear statement in the 2019 decision concerning the relevance of information about the use of the track by other miners and tourists, surprisingly the applicant provides no further information or evidence of that kind in their submissions in this matter. Neither the applicant nor the respondent say whether the track is used for the Rosebud grazing enterprise, or by persons wanting or needing to access Brightlands. I have already discussed the status of a road or track in the context of alignment, mapping, construction, gazettal, survey, maintenance and use. The process to correct or regularise an off-alignment road is generally not a high priority, until it is. In this matter, it appears to be the case that the access track is commonly known as Fountain Springs Road, although technically it is not. The denotation on the Mines Online map suggests this. That difference (its status as private land as opposed to a public road) does give rise under the MRA to an entitlement of the landowner to pursue compensation for the impact that the applicant’s activities might have on land which forms part of the landholding. A title search for Lot 554 SP177589 (Rosebud) included in the respondent’s valuer’s report describes the holding as (about) 35,900 ha. The encumbrances identified in the title search include the catch all “Rights and interests reserved to the Crown”, two easements to the Commonwealth and one to the North Queensland Electricity Corporation, and some Administrative Advices under the Mineral and Energy Resources (Common Provisions) Act 2014 (MERCPA).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Twice before these same mining leases (ML 2701 and ML 90106), these same parties, and the same issue of unresolved compensation have been brought to this Court.[2] On both those occasions, compensation for the renewal of ML 2701 and ML 90106 (first for a 2-year term, and second, for the remaining 3 years of a 5-year term), was determined to be nil. I will refer to these as the 2019 decision and the 2021 decision throughout these reasons. [2]Corella Valley Corporation Pty Ltd v Campbell [2019] QLC 44; Corella Valley Corporation Pty Ltd v Campbell [2021] QLC 26. Compensation in this matter is for “access only” through Mr Campbell’s property, Rosebud. The mining leases are actually located on another property, Brightlands, to the south of Rosebud, where it appears compensation for access and the impact of the mining leases has been agreed.[3][3]Resource Authority Public Report (ML 2701 and ML 90106) Lot 2547 SP 255326 Compensation finalised 27 April 2023. The parties to this application have been unable to constructively engage and reach agreement in relation to compensation. As far as I am aware, the parties have not engaged in mediation. If the same issues come before the Court again, I would recommend that mediation be ordered. The Court maintains a panel of mediators well qualified to assist parties in these circumstances. The 2019 decision highlighted inadequacies in evidence to support submissions concerning the extent of disturbance claimed by the respondent relevant to the compensation sought. In the 2021 decision, referring to the 2019 decision, I said at [4]:“Member Stilgoe made certain findings of fact and conclusions in the earlier decision. In particular she concluded that there was no basis for a finding that Mr Campbell has been deprived of possession of the surface of the land over which the ungazetted 12.8 ha access track passes because there was no valuation evidence to support his claim. Her Honour concluded at [14]:‘The Court has previously accepted that the presence of miners on grazing country does impose some additional burden on the landowner. It is possible that Mr Campbell has suffered a loss because of this access track but he has provided me with no information that I can use to assess that loss. As I will not determine that Mr Campbell is entitled to payment for the mere presence of the access track, I determine the amount of compensation at nil.’” This time around, the respondent, Mr Campbell engaged a solicitor, and commissioned and furnished a valuer’s report. The report (the valuer’s report) completed by Acumentis and dated 10 October 2023 was attached to the respondent’s written submissions.[4] [4]Respondent’s response statement filed 8 December 2023, 10. The current and proposed continuing access through Rosebud Fountain Springs Road, as depicted by double lines on the Mines Online map provided by the applicant, traverses Rosebud from the Barkly Highway (about midway between Mt Isa and Cloncurry) in a roughly north to south direction before it leaves Rosebud and enters Brightlands.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.