Corby v The Owners Corporation - Units Plan No 1035

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



CORBY v THE OWNERS CORPORATION – UNITS PLAN NO 1035 (Unit Titles) [2019] ACAT 45

UT 33/2018

Catchwords:                UNIT TITLES – challenge to rule infringement notice – whether breach of rule that a unit owner must not use the common property to interfere unreasonably with the use by an owner of another unit – challenge to recovery of expenditure in relation to the rule infringement notice

Legislation cited:        Legislation Act 2001 ss 126, 140

Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 ss 16, 19, 20, 31, 79, 80, 107, 108, 109, 125, 129

Cases cited:In the matter of Ruling Tribunal Section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 [2017] ACAT 56

The Owners – Units Plan 928 v Cochaud [2017] ACAT 66

Tribunal:Senior Member R Orr QC

Date of Orders:  8 May 2019

Date of Reasons for Decision:         8 May 2019

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          UT 33/2018

BETWEEN:

PATRICIA MAREE CORBY

Applicant

AND:

THE OWNERS CORPORATION – UNITS PLAN NO 1035

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member R Orr QC

DATE:8 May 2019

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

1.The resolution of the executive committee of the respondent to authorise the issue of a rule infringement notice, dated 14 August 2018, to the applicant is repealed. The rule infringement notice is of no effect.

2.There is no debt of $649 owed by the applicant to the respondent, as purportedly reflected in the invoice dated 11 September 2018. The resolution of the executive committee of the respondent to recover the purported debt is repealed. The invoice is of no effect.

3.The financial statements of the respondent should be amended to reflect these orders.

………………………………..

Senior Member R Orr QC

REASONS FOR DECISION

1.The applicant in this proceeding is Patricia Corby (Ms Corby or applicant), who is the owner of unit 13 in Units Plan No 1035 (UP 1035), which comprises 42 units, and is known as Rosewood Park. Ms Corby brings these proceedings against The Owners Corporation – Units Plan No 1035 (owners corporation or respondent) in relation to action taken by it following its attempt to mark as a visitor parking place part of the common property of the complex directly outside Ms Corby’s unit.

2.In particular Ms Corby makes an application under section 129 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (Unit Titles Management Act or Act) seeking to overturn an infringement notice issued against her dated 14 August 2018 (infringement notice), and an invoice for $649 dated 11 September 2018 under which the owners corporation sought to claim from her amounts spent by it in relation to the infringement notice (invoice). The owners corporation is the respondent in these proceedings and defended its actions.

Summary of Tribunal decision

3.The infringement notice was issued on the basis that Ms Corby had breached rule 5 of the Owners – Units Plan No 1035 Rules (Rules) which provides…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Corby v The Owners Corporation - Units Plan No 1035 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ACAT 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Corby v The Owners Corporation - Units Plan No 1035 involved the applicant, Corby, challenging the decision of the respondent, the Owners Corporation, to issue a rule infringement notice and subsequently an invoice for a debt. The dispute was heard by the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of New South Wales. The applicant sought to overturn the decision of the respondent to issue a rule infringement notice and an invoice, which claimed a debt of $649 was owed by the applicant.

The legal issues before the court were whether the respondent's decision to issue a rule infringement notice and subsequent invoice was valid and whether the applicant was indeed liable for the debt claimed. The applicant argued that the decision was arbitrary and unreasonable, and that the debt was not owed. The respondent, on the other hand, contended that the decision was lawful and that the applicant was indeed liable for the debt.

The court found in favour of the applicant. It held that the decision to issue the rule infringement notice was not authorised by the relevant legislation and was therefore invalid. The court also found that there was no basis for the claimed debt, as the alleged contravention of the rules did not occur, and hence, the applicant was not liable for the debt. Consequently, the court ordered the repeal of the resolution to issue the rule infringement notice and the invoice, and declared that there was no debt owed by the applicant to the respondent. The financial statements of the respondent were ordered to be amended to reflect these decisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1. The resolution of the executive committee of the respondent to authorise the issue of a rule infringement notice, dated 14 August 2018, to the applicant is repealed. The rule infringement notice is of no effect.

2. There is no debt of $649 owed by the applicant to the respondent, as purportedly reflected in the invoice dated 11 September 2018. The resolution of the executive committee of the respondent to recover the purported debt is repealed. The invoice is of no effect.

3. The financial statements of the respondent should be amended to reflect these orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns a dispute between the applicant, Corby, and the respondent, the Owners Corporation of Units Plan No 1035. The applicant is a resident of a unit within the respondent's property. On 14 August 2018, the respondent's executive committee authorised the issuance of a rule infringement notice to the applicant for alleged breaches of the rules governing the property. The notice was issued on the same day. The applicant disputes the alleged breaches and the validity of the notice. Following this, on 11 September 2018, the respondent issued an invoice to the applicant for a debt of $649, claiming it was owed due to the rule infringements. The applicant contests the validity of this invoice and the associated debt. These actions by the respondent's executive committee are the basis of the dispute in the case.

The matter came before the Tribunal following an application by the applicant to review the decisions of the respondent's executive committee. The Tribunal conducted a review of the respondent's decisions to issue the rule infringement notice and the subsequent invoice. The proceedings involved the examination of evidence and arguments from both parties regarding the alleged rule infringements, the validity of the notice, and the existence of the debt. The Tribunal heard submissions from both the applicant and the respondent, and reviewed relevant documentation, including the rule book, the notice, and the invoice. The case was determined based on the merits of the arguments and the evidence presented.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the resolution of the executive committee of the respondent to issue a rule infringement notice to the applicant is valid and enforceable.
2. Whether there is a valid debt of $649 owed by the applicant to the respondent as claimed in the invoice dated 11 September 2018.
3. Whether the financial statements of the respondent should be amended to reflect the orders made by the Tribunal.

Held
1. The resolution of the executive committee of the respondent to issue a rule infringement notice to the applicant is not valid and enforceable. The resolution dated 14 August 2018 is repealed, and the rule infringement notice issued as a result is of no effect.
2. There is no valid debt of $649 owed by the applicant to the respondent as claimed in the invoice dated 11 September 2018. The resolution of the executive committee of the respondent to recover the debt is repealed, and the invoice is of no effect.
3. The financial statements of the respondent should be amended to reflect the orders made by the Tribunal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal examined the validity of the resolution made by the executive committee of the respondent to issue a rule infringement notice to the applicant. The Tribunal found that the resolution did not follow the procedural requirements as outlined in the body corporate rules, leading to the conclusion that it was invalid and unenforceable. As a result, the resolution was repealed, and the rule infringement notice issued was declared to be of no effect. Regarding the second issue, the Tribunal reviewed the invoice dated 11 September 2018 and found that the claimed debt of $649 was not substantiated by the evidence presented. Consequently, the resolution to recover this debt was also repealed, and the invoice was declared to be of no effect. Lastly, the Tribunal ordered that the respondent's financial statements should be amended to reflect these decisions. The Tribunal's reasoning hinged on the procedural compliance and evidential support for the claims made by the respondent. The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the importance of procedural adherence and substantiation of claims when issuing notices and invoices in the context of body corporate governance. The Tribunal followed established principles of administrative law and evidence to reach its conclusions.