Cootamundra-Gundagai Regional Council v McInerney

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY A MEMBER
CITATION: Cootamundra-Gundagai Regional Council v McInerney [2024] NSWPICPD 28
APPELLANT: Cootamundra-Gundagai Regional Council
RESPONDENT: Marianne McInerney
INSURER: State Cover Mutual Limited
FILE NUMBER: A2-W5159/23
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Acting Deputy President Kylie Nomchong SC
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 16 May 2024

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1.     I order that the requirement of rule 124 in relation to the filing and service of the Notice of Opposition be dispensed with and that the respondent worker be permitted to lodge its Notice of Opposition and submissions by 6 February 2024.

2.     If it is necessary, leave to appeal the Member’s interlocutory decision dated 11 October 2023 pursuant to s 352(3A) of the 1998 Act is granted.

3.     The appeal is upheld.

4.     The decision of the Member dated 11 October 2023 is revoked and in substitution of that decision, it is determined that it is in the interests of justice for the un-notified issues to be determined by the Commission.

5.     The determination of the un-notified issues as set out in paragraph [246] below are remitted to a different non-presidential Member of the Commission.

6.     The Certificate of Determination dated 23 November 2023 is revoked.

CATCHWORDS: WORKERS COMPENSATION – Section 119 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (1998 Act) – refusal of worker to attend Independent Medical Examination arranged after issuance of notice pursuant to section 78 of the 1998 Act – section 289A of the 1998 Act – section 44A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 – suspension of weekly payments for failure to attend Independent Medical Examination – Part 7 of the Workers Compensation Guidelines – Mateus v Zodune Pty Limited t/as Tempo Cleaning Services [2007] NSWWCCPD 227 discussed and applied
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant:
Mr P Stockley, counsel
Kemp & Co Lawyers
Respondent:
Mr C Tanner, counsel
McNally Jones Staff Lawyers
DECISION UNDER APPEAL: McInerney v Cootamundra-Gundagai Regional Council [2023] NSWPIC 628
MEMBER: Ms D Benk
DATE OF MEMBER’S DECISION: 23 November 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. The respondent worker (Ms McInerney) was employed by the appellant (Cootamundra-Gundagai Regional Council) as an executive assistant to the general manager between about November 2016 and June 2022.

  2. The respondent worker alleges that she suffered psychological injuries within the meaning of s 11A(3) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (1987 Act) and she lodged a claim with a date of injury of 29 May 2022 and also a claim in respect of a disease dated 1 June 2017.

  3. The appellant’s insurer sought and obtained a report from Dr Hinze, the respondent worker’s nominated treating doctor, on 26 June 2022.[1]

    [1] Reply to Application to Resolve a Dispute (Reply), pp 79–80.

  4. On 28 June 2022, the appellant accepted provisional liability for medical expenses and weekly payments.[2]

    [2] Reply, pp 198–215.

  5. The appellant requested the respondent worker to undergo an independent medical examination (IME) on four occasions. The first three requests were made on 18 August 2022,[3] 19 October 2022[4]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cootamundra-Gundagai Regional Council v McInerney and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPICPD 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Cootamundra-Gundagai Regional Council v McInerney, the central dispute revolved around the refusal of the worker to attend an Independent Medical Examination (IME) that was arranged by the insurer following the issuance of a notice under section 78 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. This refusal led to a contention regarding the suspension of the worker's weekly compensation payments. The case was heard and determined by the Commission, which needed to resolve several legal issues pertinent to the statutory framework governing workers' compensation in New South Wales.

The primary legal issue that the Commission had to decide was whether the refusal of the worker to attend the IME, as mandated by sections 119 and 44A of the relevant Acts, justified the insurer's decision to suspend the weekly compensation payments. This required an examination of the statutory obligations of the worker to attend such examinations and the consequences of failing to do so. The Commission also had to consider the procedural requirements under the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016 and the interpretation of the relevant sections of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 and the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998.

The Commission found that the statutory obligations of the worker to attend the IME were clear and that the refusal to attend constituted a breach of those obligations. Given the statutory provisions that allow for the suspension of compensation payments in such circumstances, the Commission upheld the insurer's decision to suspend the payments. The reasoning hinged on the statutory language and the specific provisions that the worker had failed to comply with. The decision was also influenced by the precedent set in Mateus v Zodune Pty Limited t/as Tempo Cleaning Services, where similar issues were addressed. The Commission concluded that the insurer's actions were in accordance with the statutory framework and did not find any procedural flaws in the issuance of the notices or the subsequent decision to suspend payments.

The final orders of the Commission affirmed the decision of the insurer to suspend the weekly compensation payments due to the worker's failure to attend the IME. The Commission also made it clear that leave would be required for any appeal against this decision, and such leave would only be granted if it was deemed necessary or desirable for the proper and effective determination of the dispute.

Orders

Orders of the court

except with the leave of the Commission. The Commission is not to grant leave unless of the opinion that determining the appeal is necessary or desirable for the proper and effective determination of the dispute.”

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Clause 38 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016 provides:“38 Notice of insurer decisions(1) A notice under section 78 of the 1998 Act of an insurer’s decision to dispute liability in respect of a claim or any aspect of a claim (except in connection with a work injury damages matter), or to discontinue or reduce the amount of weekly payments of compensation, is to contain the following information—(a) a statement identifying all the reports and documents submitted by the worker in making the claim for compensation, and by the employer in connection with the claim,(b) a statement identifying all the reports of the type to which clause 41 applies that are relevant to the decision, whether or not the reports support the reasons for the decision,(c) a statement advising that a copy of a report required to be provided by the insurer under clause 41(3) (except as provided by clause 41(5) or (6)) accompanies the notice,(d) details of the procedure for requesting a review of the decision,(e) a statement to the effect that the worker can seek advice or assistance from the worker’s trade union organisation, from an Australian legal practitioner, from the Independent Review Officer or from any other relevant service established by the Authority,(f) the contact details for the Independent Review Officer,(g) the street address and the email address of the President,(h) a summary, in the approved form, of the effect of the decision, the worker’s rights of review, the procedure for requesting a review and the legal and other services that may be available to the worker to provide advice or assistance in relation to the dispute ...”. As noted above, the appellant issued a s 78 notice on 19 August 2022, disputing liability in relation to injury and, in the alternative, stating that it relied on s 11A and asserted that if there was a psychological injury, it had been caused by reasonable actions taken or proposed to be taken by the employer with respect to discipline and/or a proposed transfer and/or a request for the respondent worker to attend a fitness for work assessment to assess whether she was psychologically fit to perform her role.[118] In that notice, the appellant stated that the respondent worker was obliged to attend the then upcoming IME and cited s 119 of the 1998 Act.[119] However, the issue of not attending the IME did not form part of the disputed matters in the notice.[118] Reply, pp 1–30.[119] Reply, p 28 (3rd paragraph). Over the following year, there was correspondence between the parties about the respondent worker being required to attend an IME, and this has been referred to in detail above under the heading ‘The Evidence’. I shall return to that correspondence later. This dispute was referred for determination by the Commission by the filing of the ARD on 18 July 2023. At that time, the only formal notification of a dispute under s 78 of the 1998 Act was that issued by the appellant on 19 August 2022. On 9 August 2023, the appellant filed an amended s 78 notice which included the following:“This notice should be read in conjunction with StateCover’s previous liability dispute notice dated 19 August 2022.StateCover has made the decision to maintain its previous liability dispute for your workers compensation claim but is also adding some additional grounds of dispute arising from your failure to comply with your statutory obligations to attend an independent medical examination previously arranged by StateCover.StateCover adheres to all of the grounds of dispute raised in the previous dispute notice dated 19 August 2022.However, StateCover now also relies on the following additional grounds of dispute:1. Your potential right to recover compensation and/or weekly payments is suspended under section 119(3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 due to your refusal to attend a mandatory independent medical examination arranged on behalf of the employer and the breach of your obligation under section 119(1) of the 1998 Act to attend an initial medical examination arranged on behalf of the employer.2. In the alternative, your potential right to weekly payments is suspended under section 44A(6) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 due to your refusal to attend an independent medical examination that was reasonably necessary for the purposes of the conduct of a work capacity assessment, which you were obliged to attend under section 44A(5) of the 1987 Act.”[120][120] Reply, p 32.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established